Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Please note bolded text.

Come on Kevin, that's a bit disengenous.

Something to do with what is moral is not the equivelant of X is natural therefore it is moral.

Okay, I think I'm about done banging my head on this particular brick wall.

You're gripped by this conviction that instincts are in some way relevant to morality. You don't have any argument for why this should be except that you can't conceive of anything different, nor do you have any response whatsoever to the real elephant in the room: the fact that many of our instincts are counterproductive, selfish, stupid or evil.

Validity means a logically valid argument

In that case, yes, that too is necessary (but not sufficient). If your argument relies on fallacies to get off the ground it's a bad argument and it too goes out with window without any further discussion.

I'm not trying to appeal to emotion. I'm trying to get you to see the role emotions play in morality. Without feelings or emotion there is no morality.

Nope. That's just your assertion.

Ok, fine, make a compelling moral argument stripped of any and all emotion. BTW, "suffering" involves emotions so don't use that term. And don't use the term "care". Caring is an emotion.

Golden rule? What does that mean? I want to be treated with kindness, dignity and respect. I don't want anyone to cause me unnecassary suffering. All these things are emotions. I don't think the golden rule is going to work here.

Since when are these emotions? Now it looks like you're trying to redefine "emotions" incredibly broadly so as to make your original dumb claim into a tautology. Your argument was that moral instincts are important, but now you seem bent on moving and stretching those goalposts.

You're also engaging in a significant bit of sleight of hand by trying to reframe suffering as an instinctive moral intuition, probably because you have some fuzzy awareness that utilitarian moral philosophy exists and you think you're trying to head me off from bringing it up.

The problem is, in utilitarian moral philosophy everyone's suffering counts as morally bad regardless of how any individual feels about it. Utilitarianism doesn't start from the premise that suffering is wrong because your mirror neurons make you feel bad when you perceive others suffering, or anything resembling that kind of appeal to the naturalistic fallacy. It starts from the premise that suffering is undesirable and should be minimised everywhere and at all times, and that happiness (or preference satisfaction, or welfare, or whatever) should be maximised in the same way. If you happen to feel good when someone's suffering is relieved that's just a bonus bit of utility.

You don't need to wrap yourself in a flag, jump on a soapbox and give an Oscar-hound speech to get to the basic premise that suffering is bad, you just have to observe that you personally prefer to avoid it and that other living creatures count morally too and are overwhelmingly likely to share that preference.

Well, go ahead. Give it to us.

I NEVER said emotions, in and of themselves were!

This is somewhat disengenous of you Kevin as I have taken pains to note that feelings alone are not reliable guids.

Yet you keep trying to drag them back in as both necessary and semi-reliable, which is why I have to keep calling you on it in post after post. Your feelings about what is moral are neither necessary nor semi-reliable, they are irrelevant.

Your feelings in general (as opposed to your feelings about what is moral, and damn right I'm going to keep that distinction clear if you try to blur it some more) are relevant from a utilitarian perspective only as one, non-determinative factor in the overall utilitarian calculation.
 
Jimmy Fallon's bit on Obama swatting the fly was almost as awesome as my steak. PETA complained in either case.
 
You're gripped by this conviction that instincts are in some way relevant to morality.
Because they are.

Read The Selfish Gene and The Moral Animal.

...the fact that many of our instincts are counterproductive, selfish, stupid or evil.
And I've explained that humans are capable of reason and we can choose the good instincts from the bad ones. You are making a false dichotamy. You are in effect arguing that we either strip away all emotion or we must be slaves to all of our emotions.

Kevin, BS.

It starts from the premise that suffering is undesirable and should be minimised everywhere and at all times, and that happiness (or preference satisfaction, or welfare, or whatever) should be maximised in the same way.
WHY?

Isn't it that you "care" about these things? "Suffering is undesirable". Oh boo hoo. If you are in pain why should anyone give a damn about you? Who cares that suffering is "undersirable"? What the hell does that even mean if we strip away all emotion?

I don't believe you are even being honest with yourself.

Otherwise, why do you even give a damn at all? So what if we all sit around the fire killing & eating animals. So there is suffering? What's it to you?
 
Last edited:
My condolences. I hate losing pets. I'm overly emotional.

Thanks. She wasn't really mine she was more the rescue site's dog. (Like I said her job was to protect the 300 cats here. Shoulda expanded on that.) But we bonded over a mutual love of BBQ.

ETA: If someone tries to get you to volunteer at a animal rescue don't. If you really are overly emotional you'll be on a prozac I V in a week.
 
Last edited:
Dawkins on morality.

"I think there is kindness, charity and generosity in human nature and I think there is a Darwinian explanation for this"



Kevin,

Don't give me the BS that I never made an argument for my position. I gave you Dawkin's argument from the start. We are moral animals because we evolved to be moral animals. You don't have to agree but don't tell me it isn't an argument. You can even accuse me of an appeal to authority but I DID MAKE AN ARGUMENT!

Oh, and it's a damn good appeal so before you fall back on ad hominem and attack Dawkins why don't you watch the video and attack his arguments?
 
Last edited:
In addition to Dawkins, altruism and/or other moral sentiments are posited to have a Darwinian explanations by:

Steven Pinker (article The Moral Instinct)
Robert Wright (book The Moral Animal)
Amotz and Avishag (book The Handicap Principle: A Missing Piece of Darwin's Puzzle)
E.O. Wilson (book On Human Nature)
Michael Shermer (book The Science of Good and Evil: Why People Cheat, Gossip, Care, Share, and Follow the Golden Rule)
Laurence Tancredi (Hardwired Behavior: What Neuroscience Reveals about Morality )

Some points.

  • I never confused "ought" with "is" in our discussion.
  • I argued that humans evolved moral sentiment.
  • I argued that empathy and compassion play a significant role in our morality.
I really do resent your attitude and dogmatic closedmindeness. I don't care if you don't agree with me. You needn't treat me as though I just made it all up and had no basis for my claims though. Demanding that any mention of evolution, adaptive behavior, empathy, emotion etc., automatically equated with the Naturalistic Fallacy was rather boorish. And the personal attacks were uncalled for.
 
Last edited:
Has anyone else here ever actually butchered a cow?

At the farm of my parents, I butchered many things, up to a (small) pig, but never a cow or a horse. Mostly due to regulation it had to be done at the next slaughter house. We always tried to do it without stress for the animals, mostly out of consideration for those who would eat the meat (whether true or not, the thought/myth being that stressed meat taste less than unstressed one).

So far as I can see Cain and the other have failed to put forward an argument on their moral being the correct one, or even a good argument on vegetarianism being optimal.
 
Cows, deer, pigs, sheep...

I grilled some cowboy (bone in) rib eyes This past Sunday. One was extra rare as it was the last meal for the farm dog here. [qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_12044499cf0a10f4a6.jpg[/qimg]

18 years of protecting cats from coyotes. RIP Sheena.

I'm sorry for your loss, Redtail.
 
Because they are.

Read The Selfish Gene and The Moral Animal.

...okay, you just don't get it. I officially give up.

And I've explained that humans are capable of reason and we can choose the good instincts from the bad ones. You are making a false dichotamy. You are in effect arguing that we either strip away all emotion or we must be slaves to all of our emotions.

This is exactly the same as the quasi-Christians who argue "a lot of moral wisdom comes from the Bible, you just need to pick and choose the moral bits and ignore the immoral bits". If you are picking and choosing, whichever mechanism you are using to pick and choose trumps the source you are picking and choosing from.

In the case of the quasi-Christians, the real moral decision-making is their own, because they use it to overrule the Bible whenever they feel like it. You're doing the same thing - you're trying to put instinct up on a pedestal as a source of moral wisdom, but you're simultaneously overruling it with reason every time you don't like what instinct says.

Why not skip the pointless indulgence in the naturalistic fallacy, and just say that reason is the source of moral guidance?

Kevin, BS.

WHY?

Isn't it that you "care" about these things? "Suffering is undesirable". Oh boo hoo. If you are in pain why should anyone give a damn about you? Who cares that suffering is "undersirable"? What the hell does that even mean if we strip away all emotion?

I don't believe you are even being honest with yourself.

Otherwise, why do you even give a damn at all? So what if we all sit around the fire killing & eating animals. So there is suffering? What's it to you?

Didn't I just say that whoever loses it and starts posting semantically empty appeals to emotion probably doesn't have an argument that stands up to scrutiny?

You started out talking about emotion, then you moved the goalposts to "involved with emotion" which covers far more ground, and now you've blurred the definition of "involved with emotion" to such a ridiculous extent that now everything anybody ever cared about, for any reason, is now "involved with emotion". Since morality inherently concerns matters people care about your thesis has just degenerated into tautological meaninglessness.

Don't give me the BS that I never made an argument for my position. I gave you Dawkin's argument from the start. We are moral animals because we evolved to be moral animals. You don't have to agree but don't tell me it isn't an argument. You can even accuse me of an appeal to authority but I DID MAKE AN ARGUMENT!

No, you just posted a lot of stuff that was utterly beside the point.

Do you remember me saying something like "You can noodle on at any length you like about our moral instincts and how moral instincts evolved, and it's completely irrelevant"? That's all you've been doing. You've just been saying "I'm not indulging in the naturalistic fallacy, honest!" and then diving back in for yet another helping of it, time and time again.

The question you needed to answer is "Why should be pay any attention to these instincts?". You haven't posted that vital link in the chain, and I think it's because there is no satisfactory answer. It can't be because they are adaptive to our current situation, because many of them are not. It can't be because they are reliable guides to moral behaviour, because many of them are not. You admit yourself that if you don't like the conclusions of any given appeal to instinct you just trump it by saying "Oh, reason says that's wrong, so I can ignore it". So why are they relevant in the first place, if reason trumps them?

I think it's just because you've gotten so exited with your own cleverness at reading Dawkins and Pinker, and so caught up in your exposition of your inchoate and self-contradictory moral philosophy, that you can't slow down, think, and realise you've made some fundamental errors in your thinking.

Appeals to nature and emotion are fallacies. Whereas you can develop a perfectly useful and consistent moral philosophy out of, among other things, dispassionately determined preferences and utilitarian maximisation. That's not the only coherent moral philosophy, but it's one, and it doesn't rely on appealing to emotions to make it work. You can weasel around and say it "involves emotions" as soon as anyone cares about anything, and claim that means you were right all along, but nobody who's kept their eye on the ball will buy that.
 
Cows, deer, pigs, sheep...

I grilled some cowboy (bone in) rib eyes This past Sunday. One was extra rare as it was the last meal for the farm dog here. [qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_12044499cf0a10f4a6.jpg[/qimg]

18 years of protecting cats from coyotes. RIP Sheena.

Well, that is just scary. There is a dog that looks pretty much *exactly* like that not five feet from me.

It is only 14 though, and doesn't look like it'll make 15...
 
You know what... screw all this, I'm going back to what I said earlier.

Animals rights nuts, you're outmanned and outgunned. Your talent for arson and anonymous threats tied to bricks are amusing, occasionally mildly impressive, but tactically and strategically useless. That $#!+ will never get you anywhere in a real fight. Whine if you must (we find it amusing), but drop the minor league terrorism and keep your hands to yourselves.
 
:)

Damn, I was beginning to wonder.

Thank you very much for the response.
Hey, yeah, sorry, these days I haven't been able to make much time to get on here. It's frustrating, particularly when I start to get involved in an interesting discussion.

BTW: The long post was not really necessary. I've posted many, many thousands of posts on this subject and nothing you've posted is new to me and nothing you've posted is anything that I haven't said myself many hundreds of times. But that's fine.
Yeah, I sort of figured that, I've seen you post on this subject quite a bit, and I think we've even engaged each other here before as well. I admit it is tricky territory and my own thoughts aren't entirely clear. Just muddling my way through as best I can. I hope that a year from now I'll have some sort of fresh insight, because at the moment...

Ok, so:
  • Suffering is by definition bad (we evolved to experience certain things as painful or causing discomfort).
  • I assume that you would also agree that when others suffer, observers can also suffer because they experience the suffering of others (see mirror neurons) also an evolved sense.
Why?

Isn't it because this evolved sense helps to protect our genes and aid in social cohesion (see The Selfish Gene)?
To the above two points, agreed. That those things exist because they evolved, again, I agree.
That they evolved specifically to protect our genes, not agreed: more to spread those genes (and note, "to" is not the correct term, rather, because they are associated with traits that tended, in our past, to help genes spread, these genes have become predominant). I think you agree to that.
The social cohesion part, unless I misunderstand you, I don't agree. At least, that may be one selective pressure, but then again, it may not.
I think this is a side point, however.

In this interview with Pinker. Dawkins notes, and Pinker agrees, that morality is an evolved sense (a lust as Dawkins states).
I think this is generally the case. However, I think this applies to our feelings of what is right and wrong. It is a good reason to doubt those feelings. And when we are basing our morality upon a feeling that "things that are gross are bad", then I think there is no objective foundation.

But I think when we are using a reasoned moral framework, one founded, for instance, on the idea that suffering is bad, this is not a moral system which relies on being "natural" to be right. That is, just because something feels wrong, doesn't make it wrong.

So, so far we have A.) personal suffering and our ability to experience the suffering of others (empathy) as a negative experience (bad) and this feeling of pain or discomfort exists to facilitate genes and B.) Our sense of morality exists for the self same reason.
Well, again, I think that "ordinary" suffering, and suffering caused by empathising with the suffering of others can just be collapsed into suffering. Both are bad for the same reason.

Second, yes, suffering itself evolved, but it doesn't matter why it exists, it wouldn't matter if it had been created by some supernatural being or programmed into us by aliens, it is a bad thing in and of itself.

Third, our sense of morality may have evolved, but as I don't think that evolved sense is correct, I don't see how that bears on the question.

Ok, so here is the clincher, if I sense that any behavior is bad why is that, or would that sense be wrong? (FTR: There is an answer as to why it could be wrong, I believe it could be wrong, but I'll let you respond. The point is that the issue is a bit more nuanced than many would like to consider or perhaps even admit).
I would say that it isn't wrong because you feel it is wrong, and even that your feeling that it's wrong tells us little if anything about whether or not it is actually wrong.


Robo, I'm happy to get back to the rest of your post but we need to resolve this issue first.
Agreed.

Ok,
  1. I'm stranded on a dessert island with my family and some strangers.
  2. After a few months it becomes clear that water and other resources, while sufficient for my family to survive, are currently diminishing and will not hold out for everyone.
  3. My moral sense is to protect my family.
  4. This moral sense will likely lead me to conflict and even bloodshed in order for my family to survive.
  5. That moral sense exists because it is natural.
Question: Are any of my sensed (evolved) rules of behavior (such as, it is moral to put the needs of my family above others) wrong simply because they are natural (please note: I'm not arguing that these rules are right because they are natural. I'm asking you if the argument X is wrong because it is natural is valid?

No, they are not wrong simply because they are natural. I think they are wrong, but practically, there isn't much that we can do about that. I would say we should try to care more about strangers than we do, but that's difficult.

I'm not advocating that people be perfect, just that they try to be better. For instance, I'm here in this thread talking about animal rights, but I had pork for lunch today.

My point is that from a practical standpoint I don't think you'll be able to avoid caring more about family than strangers. Moreover, because we all care about family, everyone (generally) has people who care about them, and this system works out, if not perfectly, quite well. It's probably the best we can do at present with our imperfect nature.

But, again to answer your question, while I think those feelings are wrong, it's not because they are natural. They could have come from Allah, and still they would be wrong. There is simply no connection between whether something is natural, and whether it is good.
好不好,自然不自然没有什么关系。
 
Humans are omnivores, that is how we developed. Unless our digestive system changes, our diet needs will still consist of meats, nuts, and vegetables.

And yet some people exclude one or the other from their diets and seem to live fine. I'm more of a meat-eater, myself, but I have nothing against people who eat vegetables only.

Hell, some vegans feed their cats vegetable meals. Imagine that.
 
And yet some people exclude one or the other from their diets and seem to live fine. I'm more of a meat-eater, myself, but I have nothing against people who eat vegetables only.


I couldn't agree more. Don't judge me for what's on the end of my fork and I PROMISE to return the favor. :)


Hell, some vegans feed their cats vegetable meals. Imagine that.


I will admit that annoys me. Your cat doesn't give a rat's ass about your stances on social issues, leave them out of it.

ETA: My cat responds "Mmmmmm, rat's ass." :drool:
 
Cows, deer, pigs, sheep...

I grilled some cowboy (bone in) rib eyes This past Sunday. One was extra rare as it was the last meal for the farm dog here.[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_12044499cf0a10f4a6.jpg[/qimg]

18 years of protecting cats from coyotes. RIP Sheena.

That brings a tear to my eyes. Good dog. RIP.
 
I see what you are saying and in some cases the mentally handicapped/retarded still have cognitive ability and understanding above that of an animal. However, there are also cases in which people are mentally handicapped/retarded to the extent that for all intents and purposes they have the intelligence/decision making abilities of animals such as Apes, or dogs. In this instance they are still given greater rights despite not having and equal level of responsibility for no other apparent reason that they are a person rather than another species. Even people in vegetative (no pun intended) states have sparked debates concerning their right to life.

Also there seems to be an underlying rule in what you've said in that a beings rights are tied to what they are able to offer back in return such as their level of responsibility. Though you may not have intended to imply that. I'd need more time to articulate why, but this idea makes me uncomfortable.

If I only seemed to imply the latter (about responsibility), then allow me to clear that up: I definitely mean that about the inherent responsibility that comes with rights. Much like how free speech does not absolve one of the responsibility to not shout "fire" in a crowded (and not-on-fire) theatre, having the basic human rights that humans are attributed comes with expectations and responsibilities. With the mentally handicapped, often what is done to make the responsibilities easier on them-- responsibilities that are already well below what one expects of a fully healthy adult-- is to have them under supervised care in facilities where they can be safe. That's not always the case, but it's often the case. However, if someone who very intellectually or emotionally (or both) stunted due to mental handicap winds up killing someone (think Lenny), they can still face legal consequences for their actions even if they don't fully understand them. Animals, on the other hand, do not face such consequences (though they do face other consequences depending on situations).

Now, to the first part, it's not that I'm saying that the mentally handicapped have intellectual capacity or capability above non-human animals, it's that I'm saying that the mentally handicapped are attributed a legal and moral status not much different than that of children, which is a protected status that still confers human rights and legal status while not considering them as capable or self-sufficient as a non-disabled healthy human adult. That non-disabled healthy human adult is the baseline here, from which these other statuses are conferred for the sick, the comatose, the mentally disabled, the children, and so on. It would be unfair to confer those statuses to non-humans primarily because they lack the human baseline. This doesn't negate the possibility of some level of appropriate protected status for animals, but it lacks the level of rights associated with humans based on the characteristic of being human in the first place.

As to the rest of your post, it doesn't look like we have much disagreement there, and I hope this post clears up any questions you had regarding the last quoted text.

-----

Retarded people = animals? Wow. See post 371.

...and here's a question for you: What makes a chicken's life equal to a humans?

That's really not quite what he's (she's?) arguing. What's being proposed is to use the model of legal and moral status we attribute to the mentally handicapped for a framework of moral status given to animals. While I've explained why I don't think that works above, it was proposed in a reasonable enough and non-hostile fashion that it deserves better than to have it shifted into snide hyperbole.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom