Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

P.S. I'm grilling a steak right now.

It's a black angus strip steak - in most of the country it's called a N.Y. Strip but here we call it a KC strip. I expect it to be juicy and wonderful. I am going to add some potatos and onions from my victory garden with some other fresh herbs - also from my victory garden - and I think it will be wonderful.
 
Has anyone else here ever actually butchered a cow?

I've seen it done a few times - when I was a kid, my dad worked as a butcher, we had friends who were farmers, and ... I went on a primary school trip to an abbatoir.

Where I come from they didn't dick about with where meat came from!

I haven't done it myself - but I live in hope of shooting a deer one day, and will have to do something similar.

I fish regularly and shoot rabbits occassionally, so I know how to do small mammals and fish - but haven't had to process 500kg of meat at once, all by myself...
 
Many of the reasons given for pushing vegetarianism can be shown to be fact. In the process of raising animals for consumption the animals usually suffer, and are killed.

Religion can't show that their God is fact, nor that said God made any of the decrees that they claim.

And vegetarianism can be just as bad, in the morality department.

In fact, I'd say that they are just as likely to be immoral as you think meat-eaters are.
 
OK I give up - having lurked for a year or so I now feel compelled to post...

er Greetings people of JREF, and stuff.

Animal foods contain important nutrients that simply cannot be found in plant foods. The list includes carnitine, creatine, carnosine, conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), vitamin B12 and (in the case of fatty fish) the critical long-chain omega 3 fatty acids EPA and DHA.

er actually....


of that list:

carnitine is synthesised by the body

creatine is synthesised by the body

carnosine is controversial at best and is usually touted as an anti ageing supplement, not required by the body

CLA's aren't required by the body in the slightest tho are said to have anti cancer properties, anti weight gain properties (and also a potential cause of diabetes depending on what flavour of research you prefer)

EPA and DHA (Omega 3) are available from vegetable sources. Linseed Oil is much richer in Omega 3 than most fish based sources in ALA which your body then converts quite happily to EPA and DHA

that leaves Vitamin B12.

B12 is the only nutrient that is required by the body that is usually derived from animal sources. It's the only thing that you cannot get from a purely vegetable based diet that your body needs to survive. However most of the things B12 does for you can also be done by B9 (folic acid) and leafy vegetables are a good source of B9.

B12 is produced neither by plants nor animals but by bacteria. It wasn't snythesised until 1973 - and it took a Nobel prize winning chemist 13 years to work out how to do it. AIUI most of the B12 used in supplements is derived from bacteria.

Humans at no point in history have *needed* to eat meat. Although if I am wrong about that and at some point in the past we did need to consume meat we are way past that point now.

Now if you want to argue that an optimal diet for humans might well include a ratio of about 10% meat to 90% vegetable and there are a bunch of nutrients in food like for example creatine which have a largely beneficial effect that are only found from animal sources - thats different :)

Oh and for the record I'm torn between whether I prefer a nice juicy (blue) ribeye or a lambshank served up in sauce that has extra bone marrow diced through it, I avoid intensively farmed meat like the plague and yes PETA are nucking futz.
 
I guess I'd have to say yes, a being that has no moral responsibility is still entitled to a moral person-hood. A lack of moral responsibility doesn't justify someone who is capable of moral judgement treating that being immorally. This is why severely mentally retarded or insane persons still maintain moral rights.

Well, that's where the idea gets into some bumpy territory. However, that was a better answer than has been previously given (particularly in the older thread), and I do admit jumping directly to this point to save some rhetorical time.

The main contention I'd have is that not all non-human animals are mentally disabled or insane, and if we were to only apply moral person-hood on the basis of cognitive function (or sentience), then that leaves open the ability to deny certain people the same level of person-hood as others depending on their ability to recognize some semblance of self or to function at an acceptable cognitive function-- this goes more into play when dealing with less 'Western' cultures where the value of 'self' versus the value of 'family' or 'my people' is somewhat different than our own. I know it sounds a bit like a slippery slope in my describing it, but keep in mind that we attributed moral value like that not much greater than 150 years ago. In the end, it's no more or less arbitrary than 'human' and 'not human', it's simply using different criteria. On top of that, it still does not designate moral value on sapience as well as sentience, because if it did we'd come right back around to it only applying to humans anyway (as far as we know, though cases could be made for limited sapience in some Great Apes).

Another contention I'd have is that those with mental disabilities, whether decreased function or insanity (or otherwise), have moral person-hood but have a legally protected status. Their moral person-hood is based on their being human (though is arguably different, like in cases where it can be argued "they don't understand what they're doing"), but their legal status is diminished because their judgment is impaired yet they still maintain a legal liability for their actions. Non-human animals do not, except if you want to count "is a danger" and "is not a danger" as liabilities. Now, granted, this goes back to the issue of sapience, but what I'm pointing out here is that stating those with mental disabilities still have moral person-hood as an example of why animals should isn't sufficient, because animals would still lack the facilities that are still expected to a nominal degree in the mentally disabled.

Now, if you want to talk about having certain levels of protected status, I don't necessarily disagree except possibly on the levels of degree. My dogs enjoy a protected status because they are dogs that live in my home, but that doesn't necessarily mean that society should expect from them the same moral status of even the mentally disabled-- as much as I love my dogs, they are simply not capable of handling that kind of responsibility. With every increased level of right or status conferred there is an inherent level of responsibility involved, because without it the proposed right or status is meaningless unless you are talking about strictly property (which I also reject, by the way). Where I would differ on degree, for one example, is that I have no problem with the status of livestock animals to include their being put to death for food, provided conditions for their welfare while alive meets a certain standard. Those degrees about status or rights conferred may be the sticking point here, but my contention is that the level of degree is ultimately going to be arbitrarily assigned by both, based on different value systems. I don't consider a more strict value system necessarily wrong, per se, but neither to I consider it an objective thing any more than I would consider my own an objective thing. Value systems just don't work that way.

If you can at least agree with that premise, particularly the last paragraph, then we have a starting point from which to assert that our own system is somehow more beneficial than the other, and avoid a lot of rhetorical pitfalls that Kevin and Cain have thus far been stuck in.
 
What point?

I seriously doubt that you even know what point I'm making. "X is natural therefore X is moral" (hint: Not the point I'm making)

I'm pretty sure I do know what point you are making, actually.

What argument? That we evolved to like cleare running water? It's true. It's an adaptive trait. A good one that we can consider and not simply dismiss as you would suggest just because it is natural.

Adaptive traits aren't wrong just because they are natural. If existing is good then those traits allowed for you to be here.

Nobody's saying "they are wrong just because they are natural". One more time: they are irrelevant.

There is absolutely no point in bringing up our evolved instincts if what we are discussing is whether is something is actually wrong or right.

This is a discussion about whether eating meat is actually wrong or right.

Therefore there is absolutely no point in you continuing to bring up any of this guff related to what you think our natural instincts are in any situation.

I DIDN'T make that argument!

You bloody did. You said that we had an instinct to like clear running water, and that clear running water was good, in support of the (still silly) claim that our natural instincts have something to do with what is moral. You omitted to mention that we also have an instinct to punch up people who don't look like us, and every other instinct we have which disproves the thesis that our instincts are any kind of guide to morality.

Hmmm.... very interesting statement. With this statement you seem to imply that morality is something significant. Perhaps transcendent. However, this would seem to be a contradiction with the rest of your post. On one hand, morality is something that can be "abandoned" as if it were sacrosanct. Something I should be embarrased to do. On the other morality is nothing more than a cold dry heuristic where ultimatly the only requirements is validity and coherency. If A then B.

Appeal to emotion and straw man.

The straw man is pretending that the only requirements I have for a moral theory are "validity" (whatever the hell that means to you) and coherency. You are a quarter right however: coherency is necessary to an acceptable moral theory. If it's incoherent, it goes out the window immediately. It also goes out the window if it never, ever tells you to do anything that you don't want to do anyway, or which is not in your informed self-interest.

The appeal to emotion is trying to paint my position as "nothing more than a cold, dry heuristic". I could equally well describe your position in emotive terms that sound negative, but it wouldn't get us anywhere.

Disagreements about moral issues are best kept dispassionate. Generally speaking, the one to break off dispassionate discussion in favour of lengthy but semantically empty appeals to emotion is the one who has realised their position won't stand up to dispassionate scrutiny.

Why? No, really, why?

Take a deep breath. Count to 3. It's ok.

I think this is the elephant in the room.


Is moral theory really just cold, dry logic to you? Does (A = Not A) trouble you enough to spend time in a discussion forum in an attempt to correct errors in logic?
  • Or do you really care about sentient beings (animals included)?
  • Does it bother you when people suffer?
  • Do you feel good when you know people in distress have been helped?
  • Is dying for a moral cause a worthy sacrifice?
  • How about any error in logic, would you die for that?
Without moral sentiment, emotion, empathy and caring, morality is meaningless.

Be honest, you care about others. If you didn't you wouldn't even be here.

Appeal to emotion. Not interested. Your bolded claim is merely your assertion and I declare it to be stupid.

In any case, in my life I've done bad things and felt good about them at the time, and I've done things that I knew were right and still felt bad about doing them. One last time: Our feelings are not reliable moral guides.

Yes, but it misses the point. Perhaps soon you will at least understand my point.

I think it's safe to say that the problem is not that I don't understand your point. It's that I do understand it, and I still think it's nonsense for very good reasons, and that you just can't grasp this.
 
Last edited:
er actually....


of that list:

carnitine is synthesised by the body

Not without help.

creatine is synthesised by the body

Not without help, and with the above not in amounts necessarily needed in developing bodies (which is why supplements are suggested for veg[etari]ans who are raising children).

carnosine is controversial at best and is usually touted as an anti ageing supplement, not required by the body

Arguable, at best.

CLA's aren't required by the body in the slightest tho are said to have anti cancer properties, anti weight gain properties (and also a potential cause of diabetes depending on what flavour of research you prefer)

:eye-poppi Considering most research falls in the "good for you" category, I'll stick with the medical consensus, thanks.

EPA and DHA (Omega 3) are available from vegetable sources. Linseed Oil is much richer in Omega 3 than most fish based sources in ALA which your body then converts quite happily to EPA and DHA

Except you have to have it in much more concentrated dosages from the non-meat sources.

that leaves Vitamin B12.

B12 is the only nutrient that is required by the body that is usually derived from animal sources. It's the only thing that you cannot get from a purely vegetable based diet that your body needs to survive. However most of the things B12 does for you can also be done by B9 (folic acid) and leafy vegetables are a good source of B9.

Again, we're talking about amounts.

Humans at no point in history have *needed* to eat meat. Although if I am wrong about that and at some point in the past we did need to consume meat we are way past that point now.

Has been addressed. See my first few posts in the thread. Not a big deal, but it basically boils down to "from a nutritional standpoint, there's no overwhelming argument against eating meat and plenty of benefits from doing so."

Now if you want to argue that an optimal diet for humans might well include a ratio of about 10% meat to 90% vegetable and there are a bunch of nutrients in food like for example creatine which have a largely beneficial effect that are only found from animal sources - thats different :)

Oh and for the record I'm torn between whether I prefer a nice juicy (blue) ribeye or a lambshank served up in sauce that has extra bone marrow diced through it, I avoid intensively farmed meat like the plague and yes PETA are nucking futz.

Gotta agree with you there, on both paragraphs. There is definitely a huge over-consumption of meat compared to what nutritionists suggest as the optimal diet (on the whole, as a consensus, not talking about exceptions). There are definitely medical benefits to reducing consumption of meat, particularly for people with weight problems or digestive problems. Additionally, the predominance of red meat as the main source of meat is another nutritional contention-- though you're just as likely to find someone advocating red meat over fish, poultry, or pork as one of the others over the rest (I tend to err on the side of poultry and fish).
 
Many of the reasons given for pushing vegetarianism can be shown to be fact. In the process of raising animals for consumption the animals usually suffer, and are killed.

Define 'usually suffer'.

The process of raising animals for consumption means the animals actually get to exist.

If there was no raising animals for consumption then a lot of animals would never even get the chance to frolic around in a field, feel the sun on their backs, enjoy whatever passes in animal circles for social interaction, etc etc.

Yes at the end of the farming the animal dies, but what living thing doesn't die?

Why is it so much better to deny animals the chance to exist at all?

Would it not be a better option to advocate that farming practices that cause undue suffering should be outlawed, to educate the meat buying public of the huge gulf in quality between properly farmed produce where the animal doesn't suffer, and the intensively farmed produce where the animals in question often suffer greatly, perhaps provide farmers with incentives and education on how to farm better?

That way more animals get the chance to live - and less animals get badly treated.

Maybe my wishful thinking is in overdrive again or something...
 
You bloody did. You said that we had an instinct to like clear running water, and that clear running water was good, in support of the (still silly) claim that our natural instincts have something to do with what is moral. You omitted to mention that we also have an instinct to punch up people who don't look like us, and every other instinct we have which disproves the thesis that our instincts are any kind of guide to morality.

Aside from the instinct part (humans have no instincts, we lost them hundreds of thousands of years ago), most of our natural tendencies do serve as a good guide toward developing our morality. That doesn't mean that there's a 1::1 correlation of "we have proclivity X, therefore X is morally sound," but there's usually a sound reason that most proclivities have passed down from so far back, having primarily to do with our survival (there's even a few good arguments that homosexuality fills an evolutionary niche, but that's another subject). At several points in time in our history, the response of punching up people who looked different played an integral part in survival, and still does so in our military today. If you really want to play that tired game you can go ahead and pull up some of your list of examples you claim "disproves the thesis" and we can have a go, but on the whole I'm fairly certain you're either bluffing or sticking to your moral absolutism game.
 
In fact, I'd say that they are just as likely to be immoral as you think meat-eaters are.

GOOD POINT! The morality issue only came up because some people involved in this discussion seem to make no distinction between animals and people. In this thread, eating meat has been compared to slavery and rape, among other things. That's absurd. It's not the point that humans are morally superior, we are morally capable. Animals are not. A brown bear choosing to eat berries instead of a fish does so opportunistically, not because it feels bad about the pain and suffering of the fish.

To me, the furor surrounding this issue seems to be anthromorphism at it's finest.
 
You bloody did. You said that we had an instinct to like clear running water, and that clear running water was good, in support of the (still silly) claim that our natural instincts have something to do with what is moral.
Please note bolded text.

Something to do with what is moral is not the equivelant of X is natural therefore X is moral. Not the same. I bloody did not.

The straw man is pretending that the only requirements I have for a moral theory are "validity"
Validity means a logically valid argument.

The appeal to emotion is trying to paint my position as "nothing more than a cold, dry heuristic". I could equally well describe your position in emotive terms that sound negative, but it wouldn't get us anywhere.
Kevin, I'm trying to get to that elephant in the room. It's not meant to paint you with any brush. It's to draw you out. Your morality ISN'T a cold equation. If it were, IMO, you wouldn't be here.

Disagreements about moral issues are best kept dispassionate. Generally speaking, the one to break off dispassionate discussion in favour of lengthy but semantically empty appeals to emotion is the one who has realised their position won't stand up to dispassionate scrutiny.
I'm not trying to appeal to emotion. I'm trying to get you to see the role emotions play in morality. Without feelings or emotion there is no morality.

Your bolded claim is merely your assertion and I declare it to be stupid.
Ok, fine, make a compelling moral argument stripped of any and all emotion. BTW, "suffering" involves emotions so don't use that term. And don't use the term "care". Caring is an emotion.

Golden rule? What does that mean? I don't like to suffer. I like it when people treat me so that I have a sense of wellbeing, to be treated with kindness, dignity and respect. I don't want anyone to cause me unnecassary suffering. But all these things are emotions.

FWIW: I like to help people. I donate blood and volunteer in my community. It makes me feel good. I travel alot and I meet people in need at gas stations when I fill up. It feels good to help. Recently I was stranded a long way from home having lost my walet and unable to get ahold of my wife. I begged for money. It felt awful at first but I desperatly needed it. A kind hearted person seeing me in distress helped me. She was very nice and I felt good about the encounter and I think she did too.

You really think these are all for the wrong reasons? Really?

Our feelings are not reliable moral guides.
I never once said that emotions, in and of themselves, were reliable moral guides! They're not entirely unreliable either. The fact is though that we all rely on them. When faced with a choice between helping a loved one or a stranger, whom do you help?

It's that I do understand it, and I still think it's nonsense for very good reasons, and that you just can't grasp this.
We'll let's see what arguments you can formulate without any reference to feelings or emotions.
 
Last edited:
GOOD POINT! The morality issue only came up because some people involved in this discussion seem to make no distinction between animals and people. In this thread, eating meat has been compared to slavery and rape, among other things. That's absurd. It's not the point that humans are morally superior, we are morally capable. Animals are not. A brown bear choosing to eat berries instead of a fish does so opportunistically, not because it feels bad about the pain and suffering of the fish.

To me, the furor surrounding this issue seems to be anthromorphism at it's finest.

While that is true, my point was different.

I'm willing to bet that those who profess vegetarianism buy their food from genetically non-diverse massive farming operations. Those that have found mutli-crop farm grown food, while better, are still not at the top of the "moral" argument.

In fact, if you want to drag morals into it, the only people who really ARE at the top of the "moral" argument are those who strictly gather their own food every day from what they find in the wild.

Even then, if you drag animal rights into it, you're still skating on morally thin ground.
 
Aside from the instinct part (humans have no instincts, we lost them hundreds of thousands of years ago), most of our natural tendencies do serve as a good guide toward developing our morality. That doesn't mean that there's a 1::1 correlation of "we have proclivity X, therefore X is morally sound," but there's usually a sound reason that most proclivities have passed down from so far back, having primarily to do with our survival (there's even a few good arguments that homosexuality fills an evolutionary niche, but that's another subject). At several points in time in our history, the response of punching up people who looked different played an integral part in survival, and still does so in our military today.
Thank you.

I wanted to make the point Dawkins does in Selfish gene and Robert Wright does in Moral Animal.

Game theory.

If one understands game theory and one understands that a single individual will not significantly alter society then why not forgo reciprocal altruism? Why not game the system? Why be moral?

When I see people stranded on the side of the road I pull over and help them. Why?

I have been stranded on the side of the road and people have helped me. So what? There is no direct connection between the two. Dawkins and Wright tell us that we do it because morality is an evolutionary stable strategy and I feel good to help others and I feel a debt of gratitude when others help me.

I'm not sure if Kevin wants us to abandon our moral sentiments or simply be skeptical of them.

Kevin?
 
Last edited:
In fact, if you want to drag morals into it, the only people who really ARE at the top of the "moral" argument are those who strictly gather their own food every day from what they find in the wild.

Even then, if you drag animal rights into it, you're still skating on morally thin ground.

Even still, where would one draw the moral line (and who gets to draw it)? If it's the sanctity of life on the line, then what about stomping cockroaches and swatting at mosquitos? Consistency, anyone?

I wonder how many PETA folks have leather wallets and mousetraps in their homes?
 
carnitine is synthesised by the body
Not without help.

It's produced in your liver from two of the essential amino acids which are available from combining two LowBiologicalValue protein sources - and if I recall correctly Vitamin C helps it's synthesis....


Is that what you mean by "not without help"?

:eye-poppi Considering most research falls in the "good for you" category, I'll stick with the medical consensus, thanks.

AIUI the jury is still out and more research is needed, tho I'd lean towards the good for you camp as well.

Linseed Oil as source of Omega 3
Except you have to have it in much more concentrated dosages from the non-meat sources.

true.


Not a big deal, but it basically boils down to "from a nutritional standpoint, there's no overwhelming argument against eating meat and plenty of benefits from doing so."

Would agree with that 100%

Additionally, the predominance of red meat as the main source of meat is another nutritional contention-- though you're just as likely to find someone advocating red meat over fish, poultry, or pork as one of the others over the rest

There are lots of contentions in nutrition I have found - "everything in moderation" seems to be a reasonable maxim to follow for me.
 
Has anyone else here ever actually butchered a cow?

Cows, deer, pigs, sheep...

I grilled some cowboy (bone in) rib eyes This past Sunday. One was extra rare as it was the last meal for the farm dog here.

18 years of protecting cats from coyotes. RIP Sheena.
 
Now, if you want to talk about having certain levels of protected status, I don't necessarily disagree except possibly on the levels of degree. My dogs enjoy a protected status because they are dogs that live in my home, but that doesn't necessarily mean that society should expect from them the same moral status of even the mentally disabled-- as much as I love my dogs, they are simply not capable of handling that kind of responsibility. With every increased level of right or status conferred there is an inherent level of responsibility involved, because without it the proposed right or status is meaningless unless you are talking about strictly property (which I also reject, by the way).

I see what you are saying and in some cases the mentally handicapped/retarded still have cognitive ability and understanding above that of an animal. However, there are also cases in which people are mentally handicapped/retarded to the extent that for all intents and purposes they have the intelligence/decision making abilities of animals such as Apes, or dogs. In this instance they are still given greater rights despite not having and equal level of responsibility for no other apparent reason that they are a person rather than another species. Even people in vegetative (no pun intended) states have sparked debates concerning their right to life.

Also there seems to be an underlying rule in what you've said in that a beings rights are tied to what they are able to offer back in return such as their level of responsibility. Though you may not have intended to imply that. I'd need more time to articulate why, but this idea makes me uncomfortable.

Where I would differ on degree, for one example, is that I have no problem with the status of livestock animals to include their being put to death for food, provided conditions for their welfare while alive meets a certain standard.

I would be fine with that as well. Eating meat is fine with me so long as the animals involved are treated respectfully, undue suffering isn't put upon them simply to lower costs or improve quantities that can be raised, and they are allowed to live a full life.

Would it not be a better option to advocate that farming practices that cause undue suffering should be outlawed, to educate the meat buying public of the huge gulf in quality between properly farmed produce where the animal doesn't suffer, and the intensively farmed produce where the animals in question often suffer greatly, perhaps provide farmers with incentives and education on how to farm better?

That sounds great to me :)
 
I see what you are saying and in some cases the mentally handicapped/retarded still have cognitive ability and understanding above that of an animal. However, there are also cases in which people are mentally handicapped/retarded to the extent that for all intents and purposes they have the intelligence/decision making abilities of animals such as Apes, or dogs. In this instance they are still given greater rights despite not having and equal level of responsibility for no other apparent reason that they are a person rather than another species. Even people in vegetative (no pun intended) states have sparked debates concerning their right to life.

Retarded people = animals? Wow. See post 371.

...and here's a question for you: What makes a chicken's life equal to a humans?
 
Has anyone else here ever actually butchered a cow?
No, but I worked on a dairy and I've seen cows killed.

I've butchered rabbits, chicken, turkey and many game birds.

I've killed 30 or 40 animals in a day.

Sometimes it bothered me.

Particularly when I was young.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom