RandFan
Mormon Atheist
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2001
- Messages
- 60,135
Or a member of one of many dogmatic religious sects and many that are not so dogmatic.They are if you're an Objectivist...![]()
FWIW: I'm not an Objectivist now nor have I ever been.
Or a member of one of many dogmatic religious sects and many that are not so dogmatic.They are if you're an Objectivist...![]()
Sounds right.The best description of Objectivism I have ever seen states it is a sort of Fudenmentalist Religon for Athiests.....
Or a member of one of many dogmatic religious sects and many that are not so dogmatic.They are if you're an Objectivist...![]()
I do my best to avoid Factory-Farmed beef and pork by buying those products from local companies who are supplied by small-time area farmers. One reason is that I like the idea of supporting a local family instead of a huge corporate operation, another is that I think they take better care of the animals, but also, to be honest, I think that the cattle here which are allowed to graze grass and eat grain instead of a diet of almost pure corn just tastes a whole lot better.
Ah...but does it? Are you suggesting that, if by cutting down the amount of bacon you eat in a day by half (and all other bacon eaters doing the same) we could feed millions now starving, you wouldn't be performing a morally commendable deed?
Duly noted, Mr. [can't finish the sentence because of forum rules].
Painter writes:
Quote:
Is death painful?? Is death "harm"??
Death can be painful. It can also be a harm. Now, why don't we go back to your original comment:
Quote:
Animus, I know this was touched on earlier, but if killing cows (animals) for food is wrong, how do you justify killing plants? Plants are a life form. Plants are possibly more widespread and diverse than people. It is life. Why is it OK to kill that life. If we are no better than a cow, why are we better that a tree?
Here you were engaged in a standard equivocation straw man, "life is life," but even vegetarians distinguish between different types of life forms. My Socratic questions attempted to nudge you into this direction, but it seems you're not much interested in arguments about ideas. Which is fine. If I took your position, I probably wouldn't be much interested in ideas either. But if you are genuinely interested in the differences between, say, plants and mammals, pleasure and pain plays a prominent role. "Diversity"... not as much.
Which is precisely why the utilitarian answer is so painfully and ridiculously misguided and/or mistaken. It also displays a fundamental rift between the Animal Rights groups and those who advocate Animal Welfare. It also shows the difference between an environmentalist and a conservationist, as a side note.
Of course they aren't, which Cain and Kevin seem to keep refusing to comprehend.
I apologize but I never saw an answer.
Where do I use the word "natural"?
I would appreciate it very much if you would stop with the "natural" crap.
I didn't come up with the hypothetical. It's from a text on moral philosophy to demonstrate that what we often percieve as absolute morals break down under many circumstances. BTW: Did you notice that there AREN'T enough resources for everyone. Not unprecedented.
Hey Bill
Hey John
There's not enough food and water for everyone.
Well, let's calmly reason a solution.
No one is going to reason utilitarian vs kantian morality in such times.
Sure we can look back in hindsight and reason what should happen. But what I think is telling is that you can't come up with an answer. You have to give me options for me to decide.
You scolded me for basing my morals on "what works best" and now you are telling me to choose from a menu as if morals were only based on algorythims, à la carte. Aren't morals absolute?
I wanted to update this because the idea is lost in it's poor construction. As Kevin points out. It's non-sensical.
Humans evolved to percieve that:
Clear water from a moving creek or river is better than fouled standing water.
The perception isn't correct simply because it is natural.
Ridicule isn't an argument, nor is a moral theory flawed just because some people, who under that theory are immoral, say "I would never observe the rules that follow from such a theory!".
Maybe you're assuming that living a moral life has to be easy, and that any moral theory that concludes that you have a moral obligation to do anything other than cruise through your life is automatically asking too much?
I said earlier you might want to look into something called "moral philosophy". Absolutism doesn't mean what you think it means in this context, and it's not the opposite of relativism. Nor is what Ayn Rand called objectivism the only moral philosophy which claims to be objective.
Seriously, go hit wikipedia or the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy and read some of this stuff.
Just because a fallacious argument gets you to a factually correct conclusion once in a while doesn't redeem the argument.
2. Humans can judge history, what has worked in the past and what hasn't and given the facts we can reason better morals than our predecessors.
Not quite but close.
If it were then animals that rape, and they exist, would be immoral.
History is usually a useful tool for not repeating past mistakes. On occation the reason something failed in the past was not because it wouldn't work, but because of some other factor which was not yet developed enough to allow it to work. For example some people say that communism or socialism will never work and this can be seen from history. Others claim that we have not reached a point in our own evolution or we have not reached a technological level yet where the principles of communism or socialism can be applied without being distorted and abused.
Animals don't have the ability to choose to do otherwise. Morality cannot exist without choice. One of the problems that comes up in discussions of whether everything is already determines or a result of a set of natural laws is that then there is no accountability. Without the ability to make choices you cannot control your actions and therefor killing someone would not be your fault any more than a rock falling is the rocks fault. Our own justice system seems to agree as can be seen in cases of severe mental retardation or insanity.
Right, and those who claim that the moral theory in question is the objective morality have no greater claim. Funny how that works. You see, I've already pointed out how you've been arguing a strawman against me, assuming I was advocating something I had already explained I was not, yet you persist down this rhetorical path as if you never missed a beat. That, going back to my points about not attributing authority to the self-righteous just because they say so, is why your constant requirements that I have to define or defend myself according to your own arbitrary morality really aren't getting you anywhere. Granted, I'll give you credit for at least admitting you are arguing in black-or-white terms on the subject (Cain repeatedly failed to admit as much in the past thread), but being black-or-white nonetheless makes your arguments no more or less valid than if I were to go shopping for my own self-deigned absolute morality.
Maybe you need to stop trying to play mind-reader, because you're really bad at it. Your petty attempts to paint those who disagree with you as morons really shows the weak basis you're starting from.
That's really lame, man. Now you're not only grasping at straws, you're sneaking in a few personal insults as your rhetorical cherry on top. I'm not saying that absolutism is always the opposite of relativism, I'm saying that you're demanding I accept what you're claiming as a moral absolute without having provided me any reasoning outside of worthless utilitarianism as your basis. Since I've described a few posts ago why I reject utilitarian arguments, perhaps you should re-think your arrogant approach for a minute. While you're at it, it would be nice if you could admit that you were mistaken about the position regarding the market of producing meat, as well as the fact that I do indeed agree that a lowering of intake would be best. You can check this thread, I posted as much before you began addressing me. Honestly, I (personally) believe that you'll admit to such a mistake now that you're so committed rhetorically, but I'm willing to be wrong about your intellectual integrity on this matter and chalk it up to a mistaken impression on my part. Care to disappoint?
What point?Natural, instinctive, normal and whatnot are all synonyms, and you're still banging on exactly the same point, which is still as irrelevant as it was when we started.
What argument? That we evolved to like cleare running water? It's true. It's an adaptive trait. A good one that we can consider and not simply dismiss as you would suggest just because it is natural.See your point below, about how we evolved to like clear, running water?
I said right back at the start that this exact argument was no good.
I DIDN'T make that argument!Just because Fred really is a Golden Retriever doesn't mean that the argument-form "A implies B, B is true, therefore A" is a good argument-form.
A strawman.If your criteria for a useful moral theory is that everyone has to behave morally in times of deadly crisis then once again you've just defined morality out of existence.
Hmmm.... very interesting statement. With this statement you seem to imply that morality is something significant. Perhaps transcendent. However, this would seem to be a contradiction with the rest of your post. On one hand, morality is something that can be "abandoned" as if it were sacrosanct. Something I should be embarrased to do. On the other morality is nothing more than a cold dry heuristic where ultimatly the only requirements is validity and coherency. If A then B.The fact that you would abandon morality in the crunch...
Why? No, really, why?As to the criticism of picking from moral rules à la carte, there are multiple coherent, objectivist moral theories. All of them are intellectually defensible, although my preference is for consequentialism. If you pick any of them and stick to it I have no major criticisms of your position. I'm just here to beat the heads of people who endorse indefensible moral theories.
Yes, but it misses the point. Perhaps soon you will at least understand my point.I've been saying this over and over and over again.
Well, some may argue that point regarding Communism, but in no way, shape, or form does that make the argument a fact. Plenty more argue that Communism failed because it doesn't scale to a national level the size of a nation like the USSR, and one could point to the fact that China has hybridized a free-market-based economy to its own government (while the USSR fell under its own weight) as an example of where this theory has played out. Making the argument is one thing, providing at least a practical enough proof-of-concept to the argument (as relating to our real lives) is quite another.
Now you're getting into the topic of person-hood. Do you, like Cain, feel that a being that has no moral responsibility is still entitled to a moral (and legal) person-hood?
Some species of animal have some sense of sentience, or consciousness, as they have the ability to differentiate themselves as an individual entity separate from that around it. A dog can look in a mirror and understand that what it sees is not another dog but itself. Some animals also share other characteristics with people. If you burn yourself or are attacked by someone else you will generally recoil, run away, or fight back. Some animals do this as well. My mom's dog loves interaction and attention, loves to play fetch and tug of war with a stuffed toy, and understands the difference between various words/phrases such as his name, get the toy, gotta go outside/go potty, who's here, food, and more. It's funny because if I ask him who's here he will run to the various windows and stairs trying to see where they are and who has arrived.
In a similar fashion it can be seen that some animals don't like being caged up or mistreated. I remember reading something about tigers in zoos, though I can't think of what it is called. A formerly wild tiger is put into a zoo, and for a time it continues to act like a wild tiger, it skulks around its cage, learning where it is and if there is a way out. Eventually however, after a period of time it becomes resigned to its circumstances, it's cage, and loses all zest for life becoming a lazy, depressed, uninterested tiger knowing that it is stuck in its little cell.
In certain animals I can see qualities that are all too similar to people, an awareness of themselves, of others, of the good and bad happenings to them, and their circumstances in life. And in seeing this consciousness of theirs I can't help but be reminded of people, if less complex/intelligent people.
Are people who proselytize vegetarianism any better than the one who push religion?