Your tactic of getting meat eaters to try to prove to you why it's ok to eat meat really won't work on me, although you do have some others hypnotized by it. So, can you give me a reasoned argument as to why eating meat is wrong?
We've had these arguments many times on these boards. See for instance my thread,
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=120058&highlight=marginal+cases
You may wish to keyword search for "marginal cases" as well as "speciesism."
I think we also cover this argument that the burden of making a case rests with the animal rights/liberation crowd, and I accept it, much the same way I accept atheists are burdened with making a case against God. But one must realize most of the arguments will go back to the largely unexamined acceptance of eating animals/believing in God.
In an above post RandFan uses terms disregarding their meaning, but what he says is very interesting:
The problem is that your argument is circular. We must first determine whether or not these things are immoral absent our own confirmation bias.
How many meat-eaters here were raised as vegetarians or vegans? How many vegetarians/vegans were raised as meat-eaters? It's also worth noting you will occasionally encounter a person who claims to eat meat, but has serious reservations.
--------------------------
Sword of Truth:
Because our arguments haven't reached the place where you have shoved your head, they must poor quality? Brilliant thinking there sherlock.
If you can't back your claim up, at least be man enough to admit it.
It seems as though you think you're saying something substantive here -- and so goes this meaningless back n' forth exchange. As I said, judging by the quality of posts in this thread -- see quotes in my sig, which administrators limit to six lines -- the arguments from your "side," if you want to call it that, are embarrassingly weak. Naturally, I'd expect people to disagree with my view, but your "mind reading" comment, and similar nonsense here, does not seem to do you much good (nor do RandFan's posts). But anyway...
More of the same, the point being made, you have nothing to dispute it with, so you go for the dismissive hand wave.
Because it deals with animal testing, not meat-eating. I know of no hard and fast rules on digression, and it seems certain people like to revise them willy-nilly, but what else do you want me to say? If you want to argue for meat-eating, then argue for meat-eating. If you can. Instead you want to argue for animal testing, and then assert (without support), as an afterthought, that "[the meat industry's] existence is an inevitable side effect of keeping animals in their proper place for the medical research community."
Painter writes:
Is death painful?? Is death "harm"??
Death can be painful. It can also be a harm. Now, why don't we go back to your original comment:
Animus, I know this was touched on earlier, but if killing cows (animals) for food is wrong, how do you justify killing plants? Plants are a life form. Plants are possibly more widespread and diverse than people. It is life. Why is it OK to kill that life. If we are no better than a cow, why are we better that a tree?
Here you were engaged in a standard equivocation straw man, "life is life," but even vegetarians distinguish between different types of life forms. My Socratic questions attempted to nudge you into this direction, but it seems you're not much interested in arguments about ideas. Which is fine. If I took your position, I probably wouldn't be much interested in ideas either. But if you are genuinely interested in the differences between, say, plants and mammals, pleasure and pain plays a prominent role. "Diversity"... not as much.
GreNME:
Which is precisely why the utilitarian answer is so painfully and ridiculously misguided and/or mistaken. It also displays a fundamental rift between the Animal Rights groups and those who advocate Animal Welfare. It also shows the difference between an environmentalist and a conservationist, as a side note.
And how exactly does the utilitarian answer display a fundamental rift between animal rights and animal welfare groups? Based on your previous answers in this area, I advise you approach this question with caution.