Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

If we want to be sticklers, I thought we were originally talking about "harm." With your humble permission, will you allow me to revise my original comment to "pleasure" and "pain?" If you have any difficulty understanding these terms you may want to check out that one book that keeps definitions for most words.

Is death painful?? Is death "harm"??
 
Kevin,

We could move forward much quicker if you would answer the questions.

Let me make this easy. Is it moral for me to put the welfare of my family before the welfare of strangers?

Separate post because I just noticed this one.

Randfan, I answered the original question when you first asked it, by explaining to you yet again that whether something was natural had nothing to do with whether it was morally good or bad. Now you're asking a totally different question, which is at best very tangentially related to the topic of the thread, and carrying on as if I was avoiding your question. Poor form.

The only answer you really deserve is "Whether it is right to put the welfare of your family before the welfare of strangers has absolutely nothing to do with whether it is natural to do so, do you get it yet? You keep claiming that you get it, but then you keep posting more stuff like this that makes it seem like you don't".

However to give a more complete answer to the new question in red text: utilitarians would say do whatever creates the best overall outcome, viewed dispassionately. Kant would say obey your usual moral rules come what may, which presumably excludes killing your fellow shipwreck victims so you can have their food. Virtue ethicists could conceivably go either way, depending on what they conceived of as a virtue. They would probably all agree that you should talk with your fellow islanders and trying to agree on a course of action rather than bash their heads in with a rock when they least expect it, which is what it looks like you are leading up to.

How this is relevant to the thread topic is beyond me, unless you are trapped on an island with a herd of cows who will kill you unless you kill them first.
 
However to give a more complete answer to the new question in red text: utilitarians would say do whatever creates the best overall outcome, viewed dispassionately.

Which is precisely why the utilitarian answer is so painfully and ridiculously misguided and/or mistaken. It also displays a fundamental rift between the Animal Rights groups and those who advocate Animal Welfare. It also shows the difference between an environmentalist and a conservationist, as a side note.
 
Last edited:
Virtue ethicists could conceivably go either way, depending on what they conceived of as a virtue. They would probably all agree that you should talk with your fellow islanders and trying to agree on a course of action rather than bash their heads in with a rock when they least expect it, which is what it looks like you are leading up to.

Rrrright, so the virtue ethicists will be the first ones I will eat on the Island, as they will be the easiest to catch.

The rest I will have to hunt down later.
 
It just hit me that under vegan standards even the salads I eat wouldn't pass muster since both creamy italian and blue cheese dressing have banned substances (as well as the roast beef shards I like to add but that was more obvious). :(
 
Your tactic of getting meat eaters to try to prove to you why it's ok to eat meat really won't work on me, although you do have some others hypnotized by it. So, can you give me a reasoned argument as to why eating meat is wrong?

We've had these arguments many times on these boards. See for instance my thread, http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=120058&highlight=marginal+cases

You may wish to keyword search for "marginal cases" as well as "speciesism."

I think we also cover this argument that the burden of making a case rests with the animal rights/liberation crowd, and I accept it, much the same way I accept atheists are burdened with making a case against God. But one must realize most of the arguments will go back to the largely unexamined acceptance of eating animals/believing in God.

In an above post RandFan uses terms disregarding their meaning, but what he says is very interesting:

The problem is that your argument is circular. We must first determine whether or not these things are immoral absent our own confirmation bias.

How many meat-eaters here were raised as vegetarians or vegans? How many vegetarians/vegans were raised as meat-eaters? It's also worth noting you will occasionally encounter a person who claims to eat meat, but has serious reservations.
--------------------------

Sword of Truth:
Because our arguments haven't reached the place where you have shoved your head, they must poor quality? Brilliant thinking there sherlock.

If you can't back your claim up, at least be man enough to admit it.

It seems as though you think you're saying something substantive here -- and so goes this meaningless back n' forth exchange. As I said, judging by the quality of posts in this thread -- see quotes in my sig, which administrators limit to six lines -- the arguments from your "side," if you want to call it that, are embarrassingly weak. Naturally, I'd expect people to disagree with my view, but your "mind reading" comment, and similar nonsense here, does not seem to do you much good (nor do RandFan's posts). But anyway...

More of the same, the point being made, you have nothing to dispute it with, so you go for the dismissive hand wave.

Because it deals with animal testing, not meat-eating. I know of no hard and fast rules on digression, and it seems certain people like to revise them willy-nilly, but what else do you want me to say? If you want to argue for meat-eating, then argue for meat-eating. If you can. Instead you want to argue for animal testing, and then assert (without support), as an afterthought, that "[the meat industry's] existence is an inevitable side effect of keeping animals in their proper place for the medical research community."

Painter writes:
Is death painful?? Is death "harm"??

Death can be painful. It can also be a harm. Now, why don't we go back to your original comment:

Animus, I know this was touched on earlier, but if killing cows (animals) for food is wrong, how do you justify killing plants? Plants are a life form. Plants are possibly more widespread and diverse than people. It is life. Why is it OK to kill that life. If we are no better than a cow, why are we better that a tree?

Here you were engaged in a standard equivocation straw man, "life is life," but even vegetarians distinguish between different types of life forms. My Socratic questions attempted to nudge you into this direction, but it seems you're not much interested in arguments about ideas. Which is fine. If I took your position, I probably wouldn't be much interested in ideas either. But if you are genuinely interested in the differences between, say, plants and mammals, pleasure and pain plays a prominent role. "Diversity"... not as much.

GreNME:
Which is precisely why the utilitarian answer is so painfully and ridiculously misguided and/or mistaken. It also displays a fundamental rift between the Animal Rights groups and those who advocate Animal Welfare. It also shows the difference between an environmentalist and a conservationist, as a side note.

And how exactly does the utilitarian answer display a fundamental rift between animal rights and animal welfare groups? Based on your previous answers in this area, I advise you approach this question with caution.
 
I'm assuming from the context that you not only think that this is what Genghis Khan, Alexander, Attila the Hun, Cesar Augustus and Hannibal Barca would say, but also that they would be right to say it.
What yardstick to I have to judge it by? Yes, they would be right to say it (from their perspective).

That's moral relativism of some form - possibly cultural moral relativism (the thesis that moral behaviour is doing what your society says is moral) or possibly personal moral relativism (the thesis that moral behaviour is doing what you personally think is moral).

Regardless of what flavour of moral relativism you're endorsing, it's useless as a moral theory. Personal moral relativism makes literally any revolting behaviour moral if you think it is - under PMR, Ted Bundy was a highly moral guy. Cultural moral relativism is equally bad on that front, and in addition makes the idea of moral progress (which you seem to believe in) self-contradictory, since by definition anyone trying to change society's morals is acting immorally. CMR is also self-defeating in that it would be immoral to embrace CMR unless your culture did.
:) We ARE making progress. I really appreciate your thoughtful consideration of what I'm saying.


I accept the fact of personal and cultural relativism but I think we as a society, using reason, can formulate better and better morals. We can reason morals to allow more people to have greater well being and there is less suffering (with a number of other caveats and this is where the nuance comes in. I won't enumerate them all now.)
  1. Humans have near universal adaptive traits for behavior (in part what we call our sensed morality)
  2. Humans can judge history, what has worked in the past and what hasn't and given the facts we can reason better morals than our predecessors.
Are you arguing that whatever your culture says is right, is right, and that what some cultures said was right changed over time as they learned more about what was an efficient way to run a nation?
Not quite but close.
  1. My culture might accept slavery but I might find it morally repugnant.
  2. I might accept slavery but my culture might find it morally repugnant.
Or are you saying that refraining from rape, murder etc is moral in and of itself?
No. That cannot be. If it were then animals that rape, and they exist, would be immoral.

Same clarification needed. If it turned out that spousal rape, press gangs or whatever were not counter to social cohesion and increased social welfare would they be morally okay? Or are spousal rape, genocide and whatnot always bad regardless of whether a given society thinks so?
To be honest I had to look up press gangs.


It's not as easy for me to answer as you might think because the basis for our morality isn't any single thing. What yardstick do I have to measure the morality of these things against? In the past people relied on religious texts. I don't accept those. so, what am I left with.
  1. My own internal (and faliable) feelings.
  2. Societal mores
  3. History
  4. Reason
I choose to follow my conscious and the customs, ethics and laws of my society and to lend my voice to others to argue in favor of what I deem to be better morals in the hopes of improving the moral zeitgeist.

Okay, it looks like you're a moral relativist. Moral relativism is incoherent, useless, condones any atrocity you can talk yourself into committing and fails all the tests that a useful, coherent moral theory needs to pass.
No. I'm not a strict moral relativist. Believe it or not there is a middle ground between moral relativism and moral absolutism.

Humans were born with near universal adaptive traits. Among these are a group of feelings and behaviors we collectively call morals. Also, humans have reason and the ability to learn from the past. We can decide what is most important to us and reason what is the best path to reach our goals.

Historically speaking moral relativism was a dumb idea anthropologists and sociologists came up with. Philosophers quickly pointed out that it was a useless moral theory and it's now mostly in the dustbin of intellectual history.
So is moral absolutism.

Careful now. You're in danger of defining morality as "whatever works best", which is not morality at all, it's just self-interest. (The moral theory that doing whatever works best for you is moral is called ethical egoism, and as a moral theory it's literally useless).
"Best" at what? Isn't reduced suffering and increased well being a good moral goal? It's not quite that simple but if that, in part, is what works best then what is the problem with that? However, I DON'T simply define morality as that. Don't leave out our near universal and evolved sense of right and wrong.

Thank you very much for the excange and the tone of your post.
 
Last edited:
In an above post RandFan uses terms disregarding their meaning, but what he says is very interesting:
You were doing so well. Ego, aint it a bitch?

How many meat-eaters here were raised as vegetarians or vegans? How many vegetarians/vegans were raised as meat-eaters? It's also worth noting you will occasionally encounter a person who claims to eat meat, but has serious reservations.
It's a very good point. I suspect that society is moving toward your view point. I'm not sure what that proves but given that in modern liberal societies enlightenment tends to increase it would seem something worthy of consideration.

Then again, the only active propaganda (that which moves the zeitgeist) is from the industries that profit from our consumption of animals and those opposed to that.

Take it for what it's worth.
 
Randfan, I answered the original question when you first asked it, by explaining to you yet again that whether something was natural had nothing to do with whether it was morally good or bad. Now you're asking a totally different question, which is at best very tangentially related to the topic of the thread, and carrying on as if I was avoiding your question. Poor form.
I apologize but I never saw an answer.

The only answer you really deserve is "Whether it is right to put the welfare of your family before the welfare of strangers has absolutely nothing to do with whether it is natural to do so, do you get it yet? You keep claiming that you get it, but then you keep posting more stuff like this that makes it seem like you don't".
Where do I use the word "natural"?

I would appreciate it very much if you would stop with the "natural" crap.

How this is relevant to the thread topic is beyond me...
I didn't come up with the hypothetical. It's from a text on moral philosophy to demonstrate that what we often percieve as absolute morals break down under many circumstances. BTW: Did you notice that there AREN'T enough resources for everyone. Not unprecedented.

Hey Bill
Hey John
There's not enough food and water for everyone.
Well, let's calmly reason a solution.

No one is going to reason utilitarian vs kantian morality in such times. Sure we can look back in hindsight and reason what should happen. But what I think is telling is that you can't come up with an answer. You have to give me options for me to decide.

Why is that?

You scolded me for basing my morals on "what works best" and now you are telling me to choose from a menu as if morals were only based on algorythims, à la carte. Aren't morals absolute?
 
Last edited:
GreNME:


And how exactly does the utilitarian answer display a fundamental rift between animal rights and animal welfare groups? Based on your previous answers in this area, I advise you approach this question with caution.

Oh, get off this "caution" BS of yours, you have no authority here but the assumed self-righteous authority you continually claim arbitrarily.

The difference is two-fold, in its most basic make-up. First, the utilitarian approach described ignores any significance to the social and communal benefits of distinction between 'like' and 'not like', or more specifically the difference between a fundamentalist, unchanging approach and a heuristic, nuanced approach. For RandFan's statement, the difference is between 'family' and 'stranger', and while the utilitarian would make no differentiation between the two a more heuristic approach would acknowledge the difference in value, both philosophically and naturally. This particularly applies to the difference between the Animal Rights and Animal Welfare groups because the former ignores distinctions between different animals to make its case while the latter recognizes the distinctions in social, communal, and natural terms.

Essentially, the difference is one of a choice between a fundamentalist and a heuristic approach to things.
 
Now, I'm not saying there is necessarily anything uncertain about where you get your meat, but there sure is a globally wide market for meat with a hideous background.http://news.mongabay.com/2009/0612-abras_beef_wal-mart.html

This speaks to a different issue, which is the treatment of animals while they're being raised and abuse of animals. It doesn't address the core issue of why it's wrong to kill an animal to eat it.

People, like PETA, don't want humans to eat meat because they believe killing certain types of animals is wrong. They even think that having a pet is wrong, and would like people not to "enslave" animals in any way, shape or form.
 
Well that convinces me. I guess it's time to fight for animal suffrage.:rolleyes:

Actually, that thread perfectly illustrates what I'm talking about between the fundamentalist and heuristic approaches. Cain's (and mumblethrax's) fundamental, black-or-white, all-or-not-moral-enough approaches in that thread are a pretty good example of that rift I was speaking to a few posts back.
 
Oh, get off this "caution" BS of yours, you have no authority here but the assumed self-righteous authority you continually claim arbitrarily.

The difference is two-fold, in its most basic make-up. First, the utilitarian approach described ignores any significance to the social and communal benefits of distinction between 'like' and 'not like', or more specifically the difference between a fundamentalist, unchanging approach and a heuristic, nuanced approach. For RandFan's statement, the difference is between 'family' and 'stranger', and while the utilitarian would make no differentiation between the two a more heuristic approach would acknowledge the difference in value, both philosophically and naturally. This particularly applies to the difference between the Animal Rights and Animal Welfare groups because the former ignores distinctions between different animals to make its case while the latter recognizes the distinctions in social, communal, and natural terms.

Essentially, the difference is one of a choice between a fundamentalist and a heuristic approach to things.
Agreed. Good post.
 
Please consider the follow two statements.
  1. The sky is blue because it is natural.
  2. I percieve that the sky is blue.
Are either true? Why or why not?
I wanted to update this because the idea is lost in it's poor construction. As Kevin points out. It's non-sensical.

Humans evolved to percieve that:

Clear water from a moving creek or river is better than fouled standing water.

The perception isn't correct simply because it is natural.

However, we can understand the value of the perception. We percieve one as good and the other as bad because of its adaptive value to humans. Modern science has revealed that the perception (and rule of behavior), statistically, is correct but not absolutely. IOW: Our reason and gained knowledge can inform our adaptive perceptions.

So, if there should be some catastrophic change to the environment so that clear running water is more likely to be bad and fouled standing water is more likely to be good then we would not need to wait for evolution to correct our perception.

We have reason.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom