Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Kevin,

We could move forward much quicker if you would answer the questions.

  1. I'm stranded on a dessert island with my family and some strangers.
  2. After a few months it becomes clear that water and other resources, while sufficient for my family to survive, are currently diminishing and will not hold out for everyone.
  3. My moral sense is to protect my family.
  4. This moral sense will likely lead me to conflict and even bloodshed in order for my family to survive.
  5. That moral sense exists because it is natural.
Let me make this easy. Is it moral for me to put the welfare of my family before the welfare of strangers?
 
It does assume that we agree that rape, murder, gang warfare, infanticide, theft and so on are, all else being equal, morally wrong. Now pretty much any useful moral philosophy will get to the conclusion that these things are wrong so typically this is not controversial.

How is a moral philosophy "useful" if it cuts us off from valuable resources?

Such a philosophy would be harmful and limiting to a society that develops it.
 
To Steelmage
You're kidding, right? You just linked to a web site by a kook selling a fad diet book, who provides no citations and claims that anonymous "health authorities" are conspiring against us. Try again with a reputable source.

That source is bad while the "information" you are providing is good? Also if you closed the pop-up you can get to the article.
Then why did we evoluted as omnivores, if plants had all the so called nutrients for humans.
Human digest system is not as complex as a herbivore to get all the nutrients from plants.

But here is some more links:

Vitamin B12 cannot be found in plant foods, therefore inadequate intakes of B12 are a problem for strict vegetarians. Lacking vitamin B12 can adversely affect neurological function including memory and concentration.

http://www.mla.com.au/TopicHierarch...ews+and+information/Nutrients+in+red+meat.htm
or
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B12


Creatine
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creatine
In humans and animals, approximately half of stored creatine originates from food (mainly from fresh meat). Since vegetables do not contain creatine, vegetarians show lower levels of muscle creatine. With the help of creatine supplementation vegetarians can compensate for this loss.[1]


Carnosine
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnosine
Typical vegetarian diets are thought to be lacking in carnosine, but whether this has a detrimental effect on vegetarians is controversial. Carnosine was found to inhibit diabetic nephropathy by protecting the podocytes and mesangial cells.[14] Because of its antioxidant, antiglycator and metal chelator properties, carnosine supplements have been proposed as a general anti-aging therapy. [15]
 
Last edited:
No. My argument is not circular.

It does assume that we agree that rape, murder, gang warfare, infanticide, theft and so on are, all else being equal, morally wrong. Now pretty much any useful moral philosophy will get to the conclusion that these things are wrong so typically this is not controversial.

How is a moral philosophy "useful" if it cuts us off from valuable resources?

Such a philosophy would be harmful and limiting to a society that develops it.
Bear in mind also that Kevin is arguing in a vacuum with the luxury of living in a society where there are plenty of resources.

How does this moral philosophy stack up when resources are not sufficeint and social cohesion breaks down.

Morality: Contextual, relative.
 
Several times in the past I've read information concerning how it takes more work, resources, land, and crops grown to support eating meat instead of just eating plants. I can't remember where I read it, but it seems someone else has posted an example of that information.

Humans are largely opportunistic. We like the path of least resistance. If it was cheaper and more efficient for people to eat exclusively plants, we'd be eating exclusively plants. The truth is, importing livestock feed and having a cattle farm is more cost effective than growing fields of grain -- and it can also be done in a smaller area. Livestock can also be raised on infertile land. I've posted all this before, but it was ignored. ;)

Almost every single argument in favor of raising animals to eat is based upon the premise that we have the right to do with animals as we please regardless of whether they feel pain or suffer, which I don't agree with.

Supply and demand justifies eating animals, not morality. Humans eat animals because they're an easy and available form of food. (I lived with a vegan - I know how much they have to eat to get their nutrition. It's a lot, and most of it tastes gross.) One thing that's remained constant from the time of tribal humans is the fact that it's quicker to catch and cook some critter than it is to plant and harvest a vegetable. Moving to modern times, the second it's convenient and cheaper for humans to eat vegan diets, we will eat vegan diets.

Some say that fat bottomed girls make the world go round, and others say it's the sun's gravitational pull... but it's really money.
 
Sounds like you don't care about the facts.

We don't need to eat meat to survive.

Sorry but it's a fact. We don't need to eat meat to survive.

We might have needed it at one time. Perhaps your point is valid that humans had to eat animals (I kinda doubt it) but I don't care.

We don't need to eat meat to survive.

I would listen to proof that humans MUST eat meat to survive.

CDC stats on diseases associated with malnutrition would be very nice.

This is the kind of evidence I use to prove to some that America doesn't suffer from starvation (there is stastitcally zero or near zero amount of disease associated with malnutrition in America).

There are a lot of Vegans in America. If what you are saying is true I would expect diseases associated with malnutrion to be listed with the CDC.

No need for long winded explanations. Just proof. It's the skeptic in me. Sorry.

No, it not that I do not care about facts, it is that I do not have time to set around pulling up links and write up long pages to "prove" something to you. If you do not understand that the human body has a simple digestive system and a herbivore has complex one, then is nothing more I can do. If you do not care about the digestive system of humans, then there is little I can write to convince you as you will just brush away the facts. If humans no longer need meat then our bodies would have change to accommodate that ability. Vegetarians have to take a certain amount of supplements to get the requirements they need for their diet. That is why there is no malnutrion problem here.
The vegans I know typical get sick a lot but that is anecdotal information.
Humans are omnivores, that is how we developed. Unless our digestive system changes, our diet needs will still consist of meats, nuts, and vegetables.
 
No, it not that I do not care about facts, it is that I do not have time to set around pulling up links and write up long pages to "prove" something to you. If you do not understand that the human body has a simple digestive system and a herbivore has complex one, then is nothing more I can do. If you do not care about the digestive system of humans, then there is little I can write to convince you as you will just brush away the facts. If humans no longer need meat then our bodies would have change to accommodate that ability. Vegetarians have to take a certain amount of supplements to get the requirements they need for their diet. That is why there is no malnutrion problem here.
The vegans I know typical get sick a lot but that is anecdotal information.
Humans are omnivores, that is how we developed. Unless our digestive system changes, our diet needs will still consist of meats, nuts, and vegetables.

Steelmage - Randfan didn't say that our digestive tracts are different from many herbivores or that these differences were irrelevant. He merely said that we can survive on a vegetarian diet.

Which is true... we may not thrive on it, it may or may not be the best for us. But we can survive on it.
 
If it was cheaper and more efficient for people to eat exclusively plants, we'd be eating exclusively plants. The truth is, importing livestock feed and having a cattle farm is more cost effective than growing fields of grain -- and it can also be done in a smaller area. Livestock can also be raised on infertile land. I've posted all this before, but it was ignored. ;)

Unfortunately I can't address all comments directed towards me as the time it would require from me would be even more enormous than it already is. :) Others are ignored for various reasons but generally I feel that discussion with them is unproductive.

You are correct that much of the economy is based around what is cost effective, however you have to take into account individuals tastes. The reason we don't exclusively eat plants is not because they are not the most cost effective but because people want other things to eat. This is why people are willing to pay $20+ for a lobster or steak when they could just eat some fruits and grains for $2. This sort of thing can be seen in most every part of the economy. People don't buy hummers and convertibles because they are really cheaper to produce than a small 2 or 4 door passenger vehicle, they buy them because they want them and are willing to pay the extra money. However, the cost that you pay for an item doesn't necessarily indicate the cost to produce it due to externalizing costs such as federal subsidies.

http://www.pcrm.org/magazine/gm07autumn/health_pork.html
pyramid.jpg


As another poster pointed out the amount of crops we GROW to feed livestock could feed over 8 billion people. Meat simply costs more to produce than most plants. I say most because I'm sure there are some exceptions.
 
When I was young, our family owned some cattle. My sister insisted on naming a few of them, once and the two we ended up butchering one year were named 'T-Bone' and 'Sir Loin'.
 
You are correct that much of the economy is based around what is cost effective, however you have to take into account individuals tastes. The reason we don't exclusively eat plants is not because they are not the most cost effective but because people want other things to eat. This is why people are willing to pay $20+ for a lobster or steak when they could just eat some fruits and grains for $2. This sort of thing can be seen in most every part of the economy. People don't buy hummers and convertibles because they are really cheaper to produce than a small 2 or 4 door passenger vehicle, they buy them because they want them and are willing to pay the extra money. However, the cost that you pay for an item doesn't necessarily indicate the cost to produce it due to externalizing costs such as federal subsidies.

That's freedom, baby! :D
 
Nonsense. Morality is a rule of behavior. It's a fact that morality has evolved over time and is different from society to society. It's demonstrable that it is contextual. It's also clear that morality is often in conflict. What is moral for society isn't always what is moral for the individual.

That makes your position a little clearer but not completely clear. It seems like you're articulating some kind of mishmash of moral relativism and utilitarianism. I'll ask for clarification where necessary as we go along.

You are asking me "is it good"? From whose perspective?

Mine: No, it's not good.
Genghis Khan, Alexander, Attila the Hun, Cesar Augustus, Hannibal Barca: Good. Definitely good.

I'm assuming from the context that you not only think that this is what Genghis Khan, Alexander, Attila the Hun, Cesar Augustus and Hannibal Barca would say, but also that they would be right to say it.

That's moral relativism of some form - possibly cultural moral relativism (the thesis that moral behaviour is doing what your society says is moral) or possibly personal moral relativism (the thesis that moral behaviour is doing what you personally think is moral).

Regardless of what flavour of moral relativism you're endorsing, it's useless as a moral theory. Personal moral relativism makes literally any revolting behaviour moral if you think it is - under PMR, Ted Bundy was a highly moral guy. Cultural moral relativism is equally bad on that front, and in addition makes the idea of moral progress (which you seem to believe in) self-contradictory, since by definition anyone trying to change society's morals is acting immorally. CMR is also self-defeating in that it would be immoral to embrace CMR unless your culture did.

There are objective reasons why individuals and society as a whole might choose to see these as counter productive to both the individual and society. Societies have evolved and we have evolved a moral zeitgeist that now prohibits this list. These things might have been necessary for the survival of small hunter gatherer groups but things have changed. That is the essence of evolution.

Let me give you an example. You mention "theft". Roman soldiers were at times intentionally under resourced when it came to food and clothing and they were encouraged to engage in petty theft of fellow countrymen. This freed up resources for weaponry and other needs and taught the soldiers to adapt.

This was good from the perspective of the army.

This is where I need some more clarification.

Are you arguing that whatever your culture says is right, is right, and that what some cultures said was right changed over time as they learned more about what was an efficient way to run a nation?

Or are you saying that refraining from rape, murder etc is moral in and of itself?

Because they have become anachronistic. Because we've reasoned them to be counter to social cohesion and increased social welfare and well being.

Same clarification needed. If it turned out that spousal rape, press gangs or whatever were not counter to social cohesion and increased social welfare would they be morally okay? Or are spousal rape, genocide and whatnot always bad regardless of whether a given society thinks so?

No, that is NOT what I've assumed.
  • I know something about history and societies.
  • I've studied the history of moral progress and note that some things improve society in ways that improve the overall quality of life for more peple and some things have not.
  • I know that the mortality rate has increased and the homicide rates have decreased and I know that objective measures of well being have increased among societies that adopt moral philosophies that favor some moral instincts over others.
  • I've seen the arguments and evidence that some instincts are overall counter to social cohesion, social welfare and the well being of individuals.
  • Also, I'm aware that I'm a product of the social zeitgeist of my time (as are you) and I value things that individuals in the past did not value.
Wrong (see above)

Same again.

Sometimes it looks like you are advocating pure cultural relativism. Which is about the least useful moral theory around.

Sometimes it looks like you are advocating some form of utilitarianism, probably preference satisfaction utilitarianism or welfare utilitarianism, in which case you're actually arguing for a universalist, consequentialist moral system. This is a much more defensible moral theory, but one that very quickly leads to a strong animal rights position once you figure out that higher mammals have nervous systems very much like our own and are capable of happiness and suffering.

Morality is not absolute. What is moral is what you reason and/or percieve as moral. Whether or not you have an instinct to do X tells you what you might perceive about X and why.

The problem dear Kevin is that what you are arguing against isn't what I'm arguing for.

Okay, it looks like you're a moral relativist. Moral relativism is incoherent, useless, condones any atrocity you can talk yourself into committing and fails all the tests that a useful, coherent moral theory needs to pass.

Bear in mind also that Kevin is arguing in a vacuum with the luxury of living in a society where there are plenty of resources.

How does this moral philosophy stack up when resources are not sufficeint and social cohesion breaks down.

Morality: Contextual, relative.

Yeah, moral relativism.

Historically speaking moral relativism was a dumb idea anthropologists and sociologists came up with. Philosophers quickly pointed out that it was a useless moral theory and it's now mostly in the dustbin of intellectual history.

How is a moral philosophy "useful" if it cuts us off from valuable resources?

Such a philosophy would be harmful and limiting to a society that develops it.

Careful now. You're in danger of defining morality as "whatever works best", which is not morality at all, it's just self-interest. (The moral theory that doing whatever works best for you is moral is called ethical egoism, and as a moral theory it's literally useless).

However it's not "cutting us off from valuable resources" to, say, stop feeding edible grain to pigs so we can make bacon out of them. Making bacon that way is a straightforward expenditure of resources in any universe where the laws of thermodynamics apply, not a net gain of resources.
 
animus said:
Unfortunately I can't address all comments directed towards me as the time it would require from me would be even more enormous than it already is. Others are ignored for various reasons but generally I feel that discussion with them is unproductive.

Duly noted, Mr. [can't finish the sentence because of forum rules].
 
Careful now. You're in danger of defining morality as "whatever works best", which is not morality at all, it's just self-interest. (The moral theory that doing whatever works best for you is moral is called ethical egoism, and as a moral theory it's literally useless).

Absent a higher power that provides an absolute standard, that's what morality is. Basically whatever works best for society.

However it's not "cutting us off from valuable resources" to, say, stop feeding edible grain to pigs so we can make bacon out of them.

Yes it is... that would be cutting us off from bacon.

Making bacon that way is a straightforward expenditure of resources in any universe where the laws of thermodynamics apply, not a net gain of resources.

The current means of making bacon is the best, most efficient means that we have discovered. If better ways are discovered, we will use them. But efficiency of production has little to do with the morality of slaughtering pigs.
 
There is nothing to defend until you can show a reasoned argument as to why it's wrong.

Did you actually read through the link I posted earlier? For if you did, it's hard for me to understand how you still keep making the same argument. So I'll put forth another one, but before that, some thoughts.

I don't know where you live and how you acquire the meat you eat. But I'm guessing if you're not a rancher or (like me) live in a small town with ranchers nearby, you buy it from a shop/market. So where does the shop/market get the meat? From ranchers. Where are the ranches your meat comes from and how are the animals in these ranches handled?

Now, I'm not saying there is necessarily anything uncertain about where you get your meat, but there sure is a globally wide market for meat with a hideous background.

Example
Cattle ranching is the biggest driver of deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon, accounting for roughly 80 percent of forest clearing. More than 38,600 square miles has been cleared for pasture since 1996, bringing the total area occupied by cattle ranches in the Brazilian Amazon to 214,000 square miles, an area larger than France. The legal Amazon, an region consisting of rainforests and a biologically-rich grassland known as cerrado, is now home to more than 80 million head of cattle, more than 85 percent of the total U.S. herd.


I don't think anybody can give you a reasonable, evidence-based argument, for why eating meat is wrong. But I know the wheight of the evidence with regard to how the meat millions of people eat is raised* is against the "status quo". Or are you explicitly referring to the status quo of a certain people with adequate laws preventing these kinds of disasters? If so, I'd like to know who/where, because I must be ignorant of them.

*to be specific, what the modern (factory-style) raising methods are doing to our environment, how we could more efficiently use the land, feed and water now spent on raising meat, for the benefit of humans...

Now, do you think that people are morally obligated to take responsibilty for where their food comes from, so as to find out whom they are paying and what it means globally that they're favouring certain products over others?
 
Last edited:
The current means of making bacon is the best, most efficient means that we have discovered. If better ways are discovered, we will use them. But efficiency of production has little to do with the morality of slaughtering pigs.

Ah...but does it? Are you suggesting that, if by cutting down the amount of bacon you eat in a day by half (and all other bacon eaters doing the same) we could feed millions now starving, you wouldn't be performing a morally commendable deed?

I feel the question of how much meat eating per person is "morally acceptable" (because of what means are required to produce meat) can not be dissociated from the question of morals and eating meat per se.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm, to me it seems we are mixing absolutes with percentages...

So, my suggestion would be... start cutting down on the number of human beings running around on the planet, then the whole of absolute figures will come down as well.

There was a nice NatGeo docu on what an average human consumes in a lifetime. It is called 'The Human Footprint'.

And after seeing that, one friend argued 'we should cut down on our intake', while I argued 'we should cut down on humans'.

I still stand by that.
 
Absent a higher power that provides an absolute standard, that's what morality is. Basically whatever works best for society.

No. You may want to look into a field of study called "moral philosophy". It's something that people have been working on for over 2000 years and it's taught in some form in virtually every major university.

Yes it is... that would be cutting us off from bacon.

Okay, so now you're defining "access to resources" as "access to whatever we want". If you make that move, it's easy to answer your question about how a moral philosophy might be useful. It might lead us on principled grounds to eschew things that we want but which are bad for us, or bad for others. Easy.

The current means of making bacon is the best, most efficient means that we have discovered. If better ways are discovered, we will use them. But efficiency of production has little to do with the morality of slaughtering pigs.

You started this subthread, not me.
 
Starting with you and/or your loved ones? :rolleyes:
The loved ones part has already been done for me, so why not?

But as far as I can see it is a non-question trying to appeal to some form of attachment and not a rational way of finding a solution.

Cutting down the bio-industry would take time, one-child programs as well.

If I would have to pick between 'being nicer to animals' and 'making people just have sex for fun', well, I know what my standpoint is.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom