Nonsense. Morality is a rule of behavior. It's a fact that morality has evolved over time and is different from society to society. It's demonstrable that it is contextual. It's also clear that morality is often in conflict. What is moral for society isn't always what is moral for the individual.
That makes your position a little clearer but not completely clear. It seems like you're articulating some kind of mishmash of moral relativism and utilitarianism. I'll ask for clarification where necessary as we go along.
You are asking me "is it good"? From whose perspective?
Mine: No, it's not good.
Genghis Khan, Alexander, Attila the Hun, Cesar Augustus, Hannibal Barca: Good. Definitely good.
I'm assuming from the context that you not only think that this is what Genghis Khan, Alexander, Attila the Hun, Cesar Augustus and Hannibal Barca would say, but also that they would be right to say it.
That's moral relativism of some form - possibly cultural moral relativism (the thesis that moral behaviour is doing what your society says is moral) or possibly personal moral relativism (the thesis that moral behaviour is doing what you personally think is moral).
Regardless of what flavour of moral relativism you're endorsing, it's useless as a moral theory. Personal moral relativism makes literally any revolting behaviour moral if you think it is - under PMR, Ted Bundy was a highly moral guy. Cultural moral relativism is equally bad on that front, and in addition makes the idea of moral progress (which you seem to believe in) self-contradictory, since by definition anyone trying to change society's morals is acting immorally. CMR is also self-defeating in that it would be immoral to embrace CMR unless your culture did.
There are objective reasons why individuals and society as a whole might choose to see these as counter productive to both the individual and society. Societies have evolved and we have evolved a moral zeitgeist that now prohibits this list. These things might have been necessary for the survival of small hunter gatherer groups but things have changed. That is the essence of evolution.
Let me give you an example. You mention "theft". Roman soldiers were at times intentionally under resourced when it came to food and clothing and they were encouraged to engage in petty theft of fellow countrymen. This freed up resources for weaponry and other needs and taught the soldiers to adapt.
This was good from the perspective of the army.
This is where I need some more clarification.
Are you arguing that whatever your culture says is right, is right, and that what some cultures said was right changed over time as they learned more about what was an efficient way to run a nation?
Or are you saying that refraining from rape, murder etc is moral
in and of itself?
Because they have become anachronistic. Because we've reasoned them to be counter to social cohesion and increased social welfare and well being.
Same clarification needed. If it turned out that spousal rape, press gangs or whatever were not counter to social cohesion and increased social welfare would they be morally okay? Or are spousal rape, genocide and whatnot
always bad regardless of whether a given society thinks so?
No, that is NOT what I've assumed.
- I know something about history and societies.
- I've studied the history of moral progress and note that some things improve society in ways that improve the overall quality of life for more peple and some things have not.
- I know that the mortality rate has increased and the homicide rates have decreased and I know that objective measures of well being have increased among societies that adopt moral philosophies that favor some moral instincts over others.
- I've seen the arguments and evidence that some instincts are overall counter to social cohesion, social welfare and the well being of individuals.
- Also, I'm aware that I'm a product of the social zeitgeist of my time (as are you) and I value things that individuals in the past did not value.
Wrong (see above)
Same again.
Sometimes it looks like you are advocating pure cultural relativism. Which is about the least useful moral theory around.
Sometimes it looks like you are advocating some form of utilitarianism, probably preference satisfaction utilitarianism or welfare utilitarianism, in which case you're actually arguing for a universalist, consequentialist moral system. This is a much more defensible moral theory, but one that very quickly leads to a strong animal rights position once you figure out that higher mammals have nervous systems very much like our own and are capable of happiness and suffering.
Morality is not absolute. What is moral is what you reason and/or percieve as moral. Whether or not you have an instinct to do X tells you what you might perceive about X and why.
The problem dear Kevin is that what you are arguing against isn't what I'm arguing for.
Okay, it looks like you're a moral relativist. Moral relativism is incoherent, useless, condones any atrocity you can talk yourself into committing and fails all the tests that a useful, coherent moral theory needs to pass.
Bear in mind also that Kevin is arguing in a vacuum with the luxury of living in a society where there are plenty of resources.
How does this moral philosophy stack up when resources are not sufficeint and social cohesion breaks down.
Morality: Contextual, relative.
Yeah, moral relativism.
Historically speaking moral relativism was a dumb idea anthropologists and sociologists came up with. Philosophers quickly pointed out that it was a useless moral theory and it's now mostly in the dustbin of intellectual history.
How is a moral philosophy "useful" if it cuts us off from valuable resources?
Such a philosophy would be harmful and limiting to a society that develops it.
Careful now. You're in danger of defining morality as "whatever works best", which is not morality at all, it's just self-interest. (The moral theory that doing whatever works best for you is moral is called ethical egoism, and as a moral theory it's literally useless).
However it's not "cutting us off from valuable resources" to, say, stop feeding edible grain to pigs so we can make bacon out of them. Making bacon that way is a straightforward expenditure of resources in any universe where the laws of thermodynamics apply, not a net gain of resources.