Your patronizing really isn't necessary.
I never made this argument. In fact, I said, an argument of the form (X is natural therefore X is moral) is invalid.
Yes, and they acted immoral by our standards but arguably moral by theirs.
The problem, Kevin, is that you are assuming that these things are, on their face, immoral. You must in order to get me to agree with the notion that (X is natural therefore X is moral) is an invalid argument. The problem is that your argument is circular. We must first determine whether or not these things are immoral absent our own confirmation bias. I might agree with you but we might both be wrong.
No. My argument is not circular.
It does assume that we agree that rape, murder, gang warfare, infanticide, theft and so on are, all else being equal, morally wrong. Now pretty much any useful moral philosophy will get to the conclusion that these things are wrong so typically this is not controversial.
I could get to the conclusion that rape, murder, gang warfare, infanticide, theft and so on are wrong by some utilitarian assumptions, or by some abstract logical maneuverings in the style of Kant, or via some form of virtue ethics, or just by mindlessly adopting the mores of my society. For the purposes of that point it doesn't matter as long as we both get to the conclusion that rape, murder, gang warfare, infanticide, theft and so on are morally wrong.
(emphasis mine) And there you go,
error #1.
- There is nothing that is or is not "actually moral".
- Morality is not a priori.
- Morality is not absolute.
(emphasis mine)
Error #2
- I do not subscribe to the concept of moral truth.
There is no more moral truth than there is art truth or music truth. We can make objective statements about morality and we can formulate logically consistent argument based on agreed premises but the idea that there is some "moral truth" is spurious.
Sure, if you define "moral" as being absolutely, knowably,
a priori, eternally and objectively moral then congratulations, you've just defined morality out of existence as a useful word.
What you seem to be arguing for now is a kind of art-woo morality. Just as art-woos claim that anything is art if you think it is, and anything is good art if you think it is, you're claiming that anything is moral if you think it is. Or possibly if you
feel it is due to your instincts.
The problem with that is that genocide is a recurring part of human history and hence has to be held to be as instinctive and natural as charity. So is genocide good if you
feel that it would be okay to kill all the neighboring men and kidnap and rape their women? I submit that as a moral theory this has some serious failings which alternative moral theories do not share.
However, there are near universal human sentiments that we can make objective statements about (see sociobiology, reciprocal altruism, mirror neurons, empathy and compassion).
...and there are near universal human drives to commit rape, murder, gang warfare, infanticide, theft and so on.
Why, may I ask, do you list all the "morally good" instincts we have yet you keep ignoring all the "morally bad" instincts which we also have? I put it to you that you must covertly have assumed beforehand that certain behaviours such as altruism are good, and now you're trying to make your predetermined moral values map on to our instincts. Otherwise your list would read something like "However, there are near universal human sentiments that we can make objective statements about, see sociobiology, reciprocal altruism, mirror neurons, empathy, compassion, rape, murder, gang warfare, infanticide, theft and so on, all of which are good".
It may be that you aren't begging the question, but I can't see how else you got to that list you posted unless you'd determined beforehand what was and was not good.
Please consider the follow two statements.
- The sky is blue because it is natural.
- I percieve that the sky is blue.
Are either true? Why or why not?
Item 1 is nonsensical at face value and hence neither true or false. Item 2 is true assuming you have normal human vision and are looking at a clear sky on a sunny day.
We can construct arguments based on premises that take into account our near universal sentiments and construct rules of behavior to aid social cohesion and improve the social well being of humans and even other species.
So, skip the patronizing and arrogant assumptions. You and I have been around the block before. We can have a discussion without condescending to each other.
Okay. How many times do you expect me to explain the same argumentative fallacy to you, assuming you fail to get it, before I get tetchy? I lose my patience around the third or fourth time.
One more thing: Please address the following hypo.
Whether or not you have an instinct to do X tells us nothing about whether X is or is not moral. It's irrelevant.