Careful with your words here. You just said there is a biological need to eat meat, which is factually false.
No, that's
NOT what I said, and your constant insistence to jump to conclusions is what makes your posts come off as pretentious and self-righteous, quite the antithesis of the reason you're claiming.
There is a biological drive to eat meat, sure. A biological advantage in eating meat, sure. But there is not a biological need to eat meat. Cats are obligate carnivores, they need to eat meat. We aren't obligate carnivores and we don't need to eat meat.
The reason your comments here are false is that this is not a binary, yes/no, on/off type of issue. Just because you insist it's black and white does not make it so. The only way "we don't need to eat meat" works is with caveats, which makes stating it without the caveats either false or misleading.
There's this intellectual construct some of us humans engage in called "rationality". We find "rationality" works out well for us so we like it. One of the hallmarks of rationality is something called "consistency". If you are being inconsistent, you are being irrational.
And here comes the typical black-or-white definitions of what is rational or irrational. In your next reply, I'd like for you to answer the following questions: do you accept that there is even the possibility that two (or more) opposing sides of an argument could both be rationally based? Further, do you think that they could have equal amounts of rationality?
Now if you are going to run an argument of the form "X is natural, therefore X is okay", and you want to be a rational human being, you have to be consistent about embracing this argument. You have to endorse the claim that this argument works for all X, not just the one or two cherry-picked instances of X you like.
So if you argument is "X feels good, I have an instinct to do X, X offers evolutionary advantages, therefore it follows from this that morally I can do X if I want", where X is meat, you have to also accept it where X is rape. If you are being rational and consistent, anyway.
You're making the typical black-or-white argument, which I tend to reject in almost every ideological argument (how's that for consistent?). That only works if you assume X covers everything, that there are no differences or degrees involved in situations, individuals, or context. In the real world, all of those different contributors, particularly context, must be taken into account. This is most evident when dealing with just humans in their various social circles-- family, community, larger society-- but also applies to how humans deal with the environment around them. Not sharing the same values as the example you argue against is one thing, but claiming inconsistency because you refuse to accept the contextual elements involved only makes your argument seem fundamentalist in nature-- like Cain's arguments-- and not really rational at all.
The rape example is a problem for you because you can't consistently argue for eating meat on evolutionary grounds without also being committed to endorsing rape, if it turned out that rape was instinctive and advantageous. Thus you try to get out of explaining what the difference is by saying "Oh, it's just an airy-fairy hypothetical". It's not an airy-fairy hypothetical, it's a direct challenge to your rationality and the basis for your concrete actions in the real world.
You really need to work on your assumptions, because now
you are slipping into a strawman. The rape example doesn't work because rape as a behavior doesn't work in society. Trying to argue as if it does adds no credence to using the example, and instead works to display your argument as an emotional one instead of a rational one. You're basically making an equivocation fallacy and demanding it be taken seriously.
Now you've abandoned morality altogether. This is philosophically consistent, at least, which is in some sense an improvement over your earlier inconsistent position. If you stick to this you may be morally bankrupt but at least you aren't contradicting yourself.
More black-or-white prattle. Just because you disagree with the conclusion does not make it morally bankrupt. That tends to be the difference between my view toward vegetarianism or veganism (fine by me) and your argument toward eating meat (evil or morally bankrupt).
I think you're trying to pass off Volatile's conclusion as Volatile's argument.
I think you have a bad habit of deciding to argue against what you think will be intellectually easy for you instead of what people actually think. As I stated to mumblethrax many pages back, instead of assuming and jumping to conclusions you should instead ask for clarification.
If you asked Volatile for clarification I think you'd find that their actual argument is a little bit more involved than that, and looks something like this: "We do not need to eat meat, and there are compelling reasons X, Y and Z not to eat meat, therefore there is no rational reason for continuing to eat meat."
I'll forgive your ignorance on this (since you may not have known), but I've already had the clarification from Volatile. The argument is false for reasons I've already explained. It assumes far too much about human diets and ignores the cost/benefit ratio as not being meaningful (or to segue into another argument).
You may be surprised to learn this, but I (and I suspect Volatile) are aware that meat is convenient. Yes, and tasty too.
Yet making animals suffer and die so that your life is slightly more convenient, or so that you can have the momentary taste sensation of steak rather than mushroom, seems morally questionable to many people. It even seems inconsistent with their usual behaviour and moral attitudes towards animals.
This happens to be the problem I have with the "don't need to eat meat" arguments in the first place: they're just a segue for the "animals are suffering" argument, and are not meant to stand as their own separate argument. However, the problem with the suffering argument, as I've argued in the past with both Volatile and Cain, the black-or-white arguments only work if one counts the suffering of every animal (including humans) as completely equal and without any delineation or degrees of difference between poor living conditions and death.
And as I pointed out to Volatile (you must have missed that post of mine in this thread), I've already stated that I'm not in favor of the poor conditions in many mass-production meat facilities, and can even agree that this market needs to be either more strictly regulated (whole nother discussion) or done away with in lieu of more local ('organic') markets. However, I don't hold that opinion solely on the "animals are suffering" argument, and instead have a mix of animal welfare, conservationism, and dietary health arguments that I agree with to hold this conclusion.
But, hey, go ahead and keep jumping to conclusions and arguing against some construct you've built up. I'm sure it's easier for you to do that than actually try to understand my point of view.
Or to put in another way, so far I have not claimed "People who eat meat are bad people". I have been arguing the more subtle case that "People who claim that eating meat is moral because of reasons X, Y and Z are irrational, because reasons X, Y and Z are irrational".
I've not seen a lot of people stating that eating meat is morally positive. Instead, I see a lot of people making statements that are either morally neutral or disagreeing with claims that it's morally negative. But hey, if you want to stick to that hay-ride, you're more than welcome. Just remember that you're building a huge strawman if you come at me with that nonsense.
Personally I think that you're experiencing significant cognitive dissonance right now, and you're trying to twist what I said into something you can take offence at, in order to justify running away.
This is a prime example of what I mean when I remark about your comments being full of self-righteous drivel. You're so convinced that you are obviously so right and anyone disagreeing is so wrong that you've got some juvenile narrative already worked out in your head. Sorry to disappoint.
My arguments aren't petty, they go to the heart of how you justify your actions.
I'm not demonizing you, unless it's demonizing you to point out that you participate indirectly in the death and suffering of animals in order to satiate your desire to eat convenient meat, and you don't seem able to articulate any rational basis for why doing so is morally tolerable.
So, you're not demonizing, except for where you're demonizing for a supposed purpose. It's amusing how you claim your arguments aren't petty and then follow it with a petty argument to underscore your claim.
Here's a deal: If you want to ignore the line about the civil rights movement and just engage with the more intellectual arguments I have directed at you, you are at liberty to do that.
Please don't feel obliged to use that line as an excuse to run away. You can use it as an excuse if you wish to, of course, but you don't have to. The choice is yours.
No, here's the deal: try actually reading what I'm saying instead of building up some fantasy poster to argue against next time. You're presenting black-or-white arguments and expecting me to take the bait on them, while demanding that I ignore your constant poisoning the well of discussion as you build up this fictional argument you seem to think I'm making.
Unlike Volatile, whom I
do respect, this attempt to try to catch me in some rhetorical nonsense has really shown me how intellectually dishonest you've been from the get-go in this thread, and not just with your stupid n****r comment earlier on. While I may not agree with Volatile, and I may not come to the same conclusions, I do think that he makes reasonable and rational arguments most of the time (none of us can do so all of the time), and is capable of accepting that we can come to different conclusions on the matter without being a raging douchebag about it.
Now remember, I'd like for you to answer the following questions: do you accept that there is even the possibility that two (or more) opposing sides of an argument could both be rationally based? Further, do you think that they could have equal amounts of rationality?