To Steelmage
You're kidding, right? You just linked to a web site by a kook selling a fad diet book, who provides no citations and claims that anonymous "health authorities" are conspiring against us. Try again with a reputable source.
To Randfan
Then, following your logic, there is no right answer.
No.
The problem is that you have simply glomed onto the idea that anything to do with "natural" is simply fallacious and that is itself a spurious concept.
No. This is very simple. The argument of the form "X is natural, therefore X is morally good" is fallacious. Any argument of that form proves nothing and is a waste of electrons to post.
You can go on as long as you like about the hypothesised evolutionary reasons why some people think that X is good, but it's all irrelevant to the question of what is actually good.
This does not mean that other argument-forms might not be good. It just means that the argument-form you are hung up on is worthless, and there can be no intelligent discussion until everyone participating in this thread realises this and abandons it.
This isn't even the argument you recently dismissed.
The way you presented it, it looked very much like it. "It's natural for me to feel pain when another feels pain, and if I feel pain it must be morally bad, therefore it is morally bad to allow others to feel pain (all else being equal)" is just yet another instance of the naturalistic fallacy.
Get this straight: the naturalistic fallacy does
not stop being a fallacy just because you can show hard evidence that X is natural. It does
not stop being a fallacy just because you can show evidence that we are naturally inclined to believe X and X happens to be moral, any more than an appeal to anecdotal evidence stops being a fallacy when the anecdote illustrates something which happens to be true.
Seeing others in pain causes me pain ISN'T of that form.
Nonsense. A.) Right or wrong you will not get your consensus. B.) A good argument for morality would be instructive in ways that arguing over fallacy isn't.
If (A) is true, then discussion is pointless. If the posters in this thread aren't capable of telling the difference between a fallacy and a proper argument when it is clearly explained to them then there's no basis for rational engagement. All we could do is shout at each other or exchange irrational arguments, and I have better things to do.
We can move on to (B) when we've sorted out (A). Until then we might as well be trying to teach a pig to sing
O Fortuna.
To GrenME
Except you're wrong here on both counts. I'm not arguing that it's morally or ethically better to eat meat-- you are, and that's where the naturalistic fallacy would come into play. I'm pointing out that the argument which states there is no need to eat meat is based on a biological falsehood. In the same post I also point out that reducing meat consumption is a valid argument, though due to the long list of debatable reasons and the fact that PETA has jack and squat to do with most of them I don't feel an overwhelming urge to get into all of the details.
Careful with your words here. You just said there is a biological
need to eat meat, which is factually false. There is a biological drive to eat meat, sure. A biological advantage in eating meat, sure. But there is not a biological need to eat meat. Cats are obligate carnivores, they need to eat meat. We aren't obligate carnivores and we don't need to eat meat.
As for this bringing up of rape BS, all I can say is that you're making the same type of mistake Cain did the last time we went around in circles on this topic: using faulty extremes to provoke a reaction is intellectually childish and using unrealistic hypotheticals is avoiding the reality of right now. I understand why you'd go this route-- it's far easier to argue this case in hypotheticals and 'what ifs' while keeping only the emotional arguments anchored in reality-- but just because you're demanding that I follow you on this route isn't sufficient reason for me to follow you on it.
There's this intellectual construct some of us humans engage in called "rationality". We find "rationality" works out well for us so we like it. One of the hallmarks of rationality is something called "consistency". If you are being inconsistent, you are being irrational.
Now if you are going to run an argument of the form "X is natural, therefore X is okay", and you want to be a rational human being, you have to be consistent about embracing this argument. You have to endorse the claim that this argument works for all X, not just the one or two cherry-picked instances of X you like.
So if you argument is "X feels good, I have an instinct to do X, X offers evolutionary advantages, therefore it follows from this that morally I can do X if I want", where X is meat, you have to also accept it where X is rape. If you are being rational and consistent, anyway.
The rape example is a problem for you because you can't consistently argue for eating meat on evolutionary grounds without also being committed to endorsing rape, if it turned out that rape was instinctive and advantageous. Thus you try to get out of explaining what the difference is by saying "Oh, it's just an airy-fairy hypothetical". It's not an airy-fairy hypothetical, it's a direct challenge to your rationality and the basis for your concrete actions in the real world.
Sorry, man, but trying to play both the strictly-logic and the jarring-emotional argument game isn't going to fly with me. The world is an unfair, uneven, and sometimes arbitrary place. Some, some, some I, some I murder; some I, some I let go.
Now you've abandoned morality altogether. This is philosophically consistent, at least, which is in some sense an improvement over your earlier inconsistent position. If you stick to this you may be morally bankrupt but at least you aren't contradicting yourself.
While I'm sure you would love it if I were arguing against that strawman, unfortunately for you that supposed scarecrow is strictly of your own making. Instead, what I'm saying is precisely what I said, that the arguments that since one theoretically can eliminate meat form their diet is not sufficient reason to establish that we should. That, by the way, is no strawman, as Volatile proves in a later post:
I think you're trying to pass off Volatile's conclusion as Volatile's argument.
If you asked Volatile for clarification I think you'd find that their actual argument is a little bit more involved than that, and looks something like this: "We do not
need to eat meat, and there are compelling reasons X, Y and Z not to eat meat, therefore there is no rational reason for continuing to eat meat."
This is demonstrably false. The rational reason to eat meat is that there is no other source of food, pound-for-pound, that contains the potency for energy, nutrients, and hunger satiation that is within meat. This is a double-edged sword, however, because in much of the first-world the consumption of meat is far above the level of meeting that need, but again that argues for a decrease in consumption and not complete cessation. Yes, with appropriate effort enough mixture of non-meat foor can give the same results, but on the whole that requires more effort. If someone finds personal pride or meaning in taking those measures, then more power to them for finding something that works for them. However, that does not make doing so any more an objective 'truth' than does the Catholic who prays to their rosary or the Muslim who follows their daily prayer times.
You may be surprised to learn this, but I (and I suspect Volatile) are aware that meat is convenient. Yes, and tasty too.
Yet making animals suffer and die so that your life is slightly more convenient, or so that you can have the momentary taste sensation of steak rather than mushroom, seems morally questionable to many people. It even seems inconsistent with their usual behaviour and moral attitudes towards animals.
Kevin_Lowe, I don't think you're stupid or wrong for advocating eating a vegetarian diet.
Strictly speaking I haven't advocated eating a vegetarian diet. I've just been pointing out that the reasons you and others have been giving for eating meat are irrational, and in some cases morally revolting and intellectually infantile. (Drudgewire, Trisk et. al.).
Or to put in another way, so far I have not claimed "People who eat meat are bad people". I have been arguing the more subtle case that "People who claim that eating meat is moral because of reasons X, Y and Z are irrational, because reasons X, Y and Z are irrational".
Really, I don't. I do, however, think you're being a self-righteous boor by making petty arguments that have little (if any) basis in fact and serve instead to demonize those who disagree instead of convince someone that your point of view has any merit.
Personally I think that you're experiencing significant cognitive dissonance right now, and you're trying to twist what I said into something you can take offence at, in order to justify running away.
My arguments aren't petty, they go to the heart of how you justify your actions.
I'm not demonizing you, unless it's demonizing you to point out that you participate indirectly in the death and suffering of animals in order to satiate your desire to eat convenient meat, and you don't seem able to articulate any rational basis for why doing so is morally tolerable.
If you expect me to take anything you're arguing seriously then the first thing you need to do is drop the self-righteous BS and approach the subject with a more level head. Yeah, I know that the snide comments from people saying that they're going to eat extra meat or kill a bunny every time PETA says something stupid (the world would have no more bunnies in a week if they actually did) was rude and mean, but trying to cover your tracks by trying to appeal to logic after shooting off with an even more offensive line of crap isn't convincing, at least not to me.
Here's a deal: If you want to ignore the line about the civil rights movement and just engage with the more intellectual arguments I have directed at you, you are at liberty to do that.
Please don't feel obliged to use that line as an excuse to run away. You can use it as an excuse if you wish to, of course, but you don't have to. The choice is yours.