Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Cattle exist for no higher purpose than to provide me with hamburgers, steak, baseball gloves, and dashing apparel. The best and most fitting tribute to it is for it to be stunned with a captive bolt, deadified, drained of excess blood, hung upside down and stripped of entrails, its horns plucked from its carcass for mounting on the hood of my Cadillac, and the rest burned asunder or reprocessed into tasty all-beef hot dogs.

Sound barbaric? Whatever. Let's see them organize, or evolve a natural defense against ranchers.

Stop me, I dare you.

And yes, this whole statement boils down to a combination of shock philosophy and a tasteless 'neener-neener,' but it goes down so smooth with veal.
 
Most of the legislation that would fall under 'animal law' in this nation since 1970 has focused more on pets, most notably under the various 'dangerous dog' laws that have been and continue to increasingly make it less and less legal to own certain types of dogs. You have your animal rights groups to thank for that, as well as the constant increase in mandatory spay/neuter laws out there, also designed to lower the number of available pets (though the AR groups have been less successful on the federal level, which are where the problem 'puppy/kitty/animal mills' actually exist, protected by the FDA). If anyone (I'm looking at you, mumblethrax) is looking for examples of where the AR movement went off in their own direction during or after the 1970's, the increase in dangerous dog and mandatory spay/neuter laws that have gone up dramatically since the early 1980's is your proof.

Do you mind pointing me towards spay/neuter laws?

Not saying that they don't exist, just that I'm not familiar with them.

Regardless, pet overpopulation is a VERY serious problem. Having worked in a local SPCA, it's fairly obvious how bad a problem it is. There are many causes, too, many being that some people want ONLY kittens. I can't tell you how many great cats came through the SPCA I worked in that were only 1-2 years old. The owners would dump them cat with us and claim that they were moving and couldn't take it with them.....only to return later. Obviously, the heaviest time for us was around 6-8 months after Christmas.

It was horrid.

Regardless, though, overpopulation is a problem. If there are laws like that on the books, I can only imagine that they're not there to lower the number of available pets, but to reduce the problem of pet overpopulation.
 
Sound barbaric? Whatever. Let's see them organize, or evolve a natural defense against ranchers.
If not domesticated, most cattle in the wild would:
  • Die shortly after birth.
  • Those that did survive their birth, die before they matured.
  • Suffer hunger and exposure.
  • Not have medical care.
  • Be subject to predation.
  • Exist as only as a fraction of the number that there are now.
To paraphrase Dan Dennett, ranchers are an evolutionary adaptation for cattle.
 
Ok. I have to say it. Some of the more vocal anti-meat folks remind me a little too much of the 'Horizon Corporation' from the Tom Clancy novel Rainbow Six.
 
BTW, Peta withdrew, or lost, their bid for the billboards. They say that they're glad that this got some PR so that people can talk about vegetarianism.
 
Most people are capable of getting sufficient nutrients from plants. There are exceptions like Laura Dern.

In any event, we could most certainly eliminate beef from our diet. Beef is a nutrient dense food but it is not necassary for the human diet as many people throughout the world have lived for many centuries without it.

Sorry, we do not have a multi-chambered stomach. Our digestion system is more carnivore then herbivore. There is only meats besides beef, and yes those people did eat those meats.
 
Do you mind pointing me towards spay/neuter laws?

Not saying that they don't exist, just that I'm not familiar with them.

There is no single matrix I can point you to that will list them all. Various cities have them in various degrees. Just last year Dallas, TX passed a mandatory spay/neuter law, and the groups promoting it (HSUS, ASPCA, etc.) were the same people who had done much the same in other cities. I can try to find you a few examples, if you like, from different parts of the country.

Hmmm, that said, it seems PETA is tooting their own legislation horn and offers a semi-accurate list (there are several cities and metro areas missing).

Regardless, pet overpopulation is a VERY serious problem. Having worked in a local SPCA, it's fairly obvious how bad a problem it is. There are many causes, too, many being that some people want ONLY kittens. I can't tell you how many great cats came through the SPCA I worked in that were only 1-2 years old. The owners would dump them cat with us and claim that they were moving and couldn't take it with them.....only to return later. Obviously, the heaviest time for us was around 6-8 months after Christmas.

It was horrid.

Regardless, though, overpopulation is a problem. If there are laws like that on the books, I can only imagine that they're not there to lower the number of available pets, but to reduce the problem of pet overpopulation.

I'm not saying that animals stuck in shelters isn't a very serious problem, but I feel obliged to correct you on the overpopulation myth. Just 30 years ago there were nearly 20 million owner-less dogs making their way through shelters and to euthanasia. That number now is hovering somewhere around 2 million (HSUS numbers are inflated and include many other animal types). The increases in spaying and neutering have helped those numbers along some, particularly in cat and rabbit populations, but another phenomenon that has made a huge difference has been the increased inter-connected-ness of the local rescue groups, particularly the rescue groups who do breed-specific foster and rescue. Certain parts of the country will notice huge numbers of abandoned or homeless animals, while others have more requests than they do animals coming through their shelters. It all depends on where you live, and in some cases whether certain legislations have changed recently-- 'dangerous dog' laws often result in abandonment of animals in that breed.

The problem of pets that have been lost or abandoned in shelters is not something that is going to be legislated away. What laws placing more requirements on owners actually do is cause pet owners to not register their animals, making the owners more difficult to locate if an animal is found lost. Additionally, they do nothing to actually promote responsible pet ownership, they simply produce implied threats of punishment if people fail to meet the state or local requirements being thrust upon them.

For example: while I consider the activity kind of flaky, AR legislation like spay/neuter laws and other restrictions also attempt to stop groups like the AKC from having dog shows (example of an article on AKC's website). While I may not be a fan of AKC dog shows, the consistent drives to force sterilization of dogs and criminalize ownership of 'dangerous' dogs affects not only the AKC groups, but also the average citizen who is looking into owning a dog or has a dog already. Such laws practically ban certain dogs or justify discrimination based on dog breeds, and they also get used to drive away AKC breeders who don't breed enough dogs to fall under FDA protection-- which is precisely what the puppy millers who churn out litter after litter of unhealthy and unstable dogs rely on. The net result is a pot-luck of local and state ordinances that discriminate against the small-time dog breeders who are more often than not producing healthy, stable dogs that are human-socialized and have been treated properly, while skipping right over the millers who are producing questionable dogs in such high quantities that few are ever human-socialized before going to a family or a pet store, which often results in dogs that have health problems and are more difficult to control because they never got used to people at critical points in their early life.

To give you an anecdote to go along with your own anecdote: this past March my better half and I drove from Dallas to Oklahoma City to pick up a dog who was dropped off by the son of a man who passed away. The son couldn't keep the large dog (an Irish wolfhound cross), and the people who the dog was turned over to couldn't foster the dog for long either. However, since our local rescue is networked with theirs, they called us and had me and my better half go pick the dog up. We ended up fostering him (instead of putting him in a shelter) for a week, and took him with us to the Irish festival that happened to be the following weekend. At the festival, someone we already knew as a responsible owner asked if they could adopt him, and the dog was passed on to his new home. It was a bittersweet experience, considering some recent losses in our own home, but we were happy to help find this guy a new home where he likely wouldn't have found a home back in OKC. There's currently another dog being fostered right now that actually may find his way to our home, but he's in another area right now and all the appropriate animal law and potential lost owner (the boy was abandoned) steps are being taken, and we may not see him for two or three weeks (or, if his family is found and they want him, not at all). The point is that we have a wide network of smaller rescue groups working together to keep the dogs out of shelters and thus out of the line to be euthanized. This is an example of how networking rescue groups can and does help.

If you want an example of how 'dangerous dog' legislation is harmful, try to apply for home-owner's insurance if you have a German shepherd-- in some parts of the country you will actually be forced to pay a premium based on the breed of dog you own! This sort of discrimination is based on the prevalence of 'dangerous dog' laws that are based purely on emotional responses and are pushed by groups like the HSUS and PETA, further limiting pet ownership by legislating people's ability to have pets. The current 'dangerous dog' has been the pit bull terrier for about 15 or so years, but 25-30 (or more) years ago it was the German shepherd or the Doberman pincer. Earlier in the 1900's it was even the collie for a brief period. Every few decades the dangerous dog du jour switches, and in the last 30 years groups like PETA and HSUS have increasingly been taking advantage of this to outlaw certain breeds of dogs, dogs over a certain size, or in many places dogs that even do so much as bark in a manner perceived as menacing from the person being barked at. While cultural tendency to be afraid of some certain type of dog is nothing new, the animal rights groups are taking advantage of this phenomenon to outlaw dog ownership of specific breeds.

Sorry, I know that's a whole lot more information than you asked for, but I hope this underscores the seriousness of what I mean when I say that these groups have been focusing on outlawing pet ownership and, despite their allowing members to own pets, the behavior of groups like PETA to systematically legislate the inability to own pets is evident in their advocacy over the past three decades to push such laws through.
 
Sorry, we do not have a multi-chambered stomach.
We don't need multi-chambered stomachs. It's not necessary for our survival.

Our digestion system is more carnivore then herbivore.
I doubt this is true but I don't care. It's not relevant to the discussion. Most of us can survive without eating other animals.

There is only meats besides beef, and yes those people did eat those meats.
There are different levels of vegetarian. Many societies have met many of these definitions.

You need to demonstrate (not simply state it) that humans cannot survive A.) without animal products and or B.) without beef.

FTR: I'm not a vegan or vegetarian. Ethical or otherwise.
 
Last edited:
Our digestion system is more carnivore then herbivore.
I doubt this is true but I don't care. It's not relevant to the discussion. Most of us can survive without eating other animals.

For the record, you are correct and this is not true. Our digestive system is mostly built to draw as many nutrients as it can from whatever it can break down in as quick a fashion as possible-- the rest is discarded. Basically, our digestive system is neither herbivore nor carnivore, it's a high-speed rendering system.
 
Youa re missing the point entirely. It is NOT whether you can do a vegetarian diet as equilibrated as an omnivore one. It is about rationality thus what is most OPTIMAL. You cannot biologically say that vegetarian diet is optimal on that side, all you can say is that with MORE knowledge and MORE planning you can have a vegetarian diet instead of an omnivore one. But under that light you cannot say it is more optimal than an omnivore one.

This is a comically weak, misguided argument. "Rationality" here is narrowed to self-interest and omits exogenous factors such as... morality.

Counter-example: Roark's fifty bucks short on the month's rent. He'd prefer to spend this Sunday hanging out with friends watching the big game, but he's already reluctantly agreed to do yard work for Mrs. Regan up the street. He hates yard work, but needs the money. On the way to Mrs. Regan's he spots a wallet, opens it up and... score: eighty-five bucks. No one around in sight. What's the "optimal" solution?

From the perspective of narrow, self-interest, Roark could pocket the wallet, and go watch the game. Never mind he's breaking a promise and stealing money. (Yes, you could have a strained follow-up: Roark could get caught! Jim may fall short on the rent next month and Mrs. Regan won't help him out. Ah, but Roark is a prudent predator.)

Also, MORE KNOWLEDGE and MORE PLANNING applies to non-vegetarians who consume free-range for moral reasons. Furthermore, you're talking about vegans living in a meat-eater's world. If it was a vegan world, then meat-eaters would have to hunt down their food, and the planning, knowledge, and dangers (not least of all the fact it's illegal) would render that diet less "rational" and "suboptimal." Anyway, I'm sorry simple morality does not extol the virtue of laziness: an unknown ideal.
 
If it was a vegan world, then meat-eaters would have to hunt down their food, and the planning, knowledge, and dangers (not least of all the fact it's illegal) would render that diet less "rational" and "suboptimal."

And yet vegan diets are not considered illegal today. Gee, can't imagine why your hypothetical world looks so ridiculous.
 
And yet vegan diets are not considered illegal today. Gee, can't imagine why your hypothetical world looks so ridiculous.
Yeah, however it's gotta be a wet dream for PETA types to fantasize about locking up people who go fishing or hunting quail. :)
 
The whole gamut of non-human animal-related issues out there really flesh out the idea that if somebody says "there oughtta be a law" there usually oughtn't.
 
Well, now you put it like that - sorry for ever doubting you had a sensible and rational basis for your diet.

:rolleyes:

What ever made me think otherwise, I'll never know.

Oh I do.

It is called "choice".
 
Oh, you guys still amuse me.

And yet vegan diets are not considered illegal today. Gee, can't imagine why your hypothetical world looks so ridiculous.

Well, obviously meat-eaters are just so much more tolerant (apart from that whole killing thing). A world where billions of animals are needlessly raised to be needlessly slaughtered is not at all ridiculous. Now, the one that doesn't have quite so much of the killing... almost unfathomable. My cynical core is often inclined to agree.

P.S. GreNME: I'm pleased to see you sticking to your standard over what constitutes a digression (i.e., "If I do it, it's OK!").

RandFan:
Yeah, however it's gotta be a wet dream for PETA types to fantasize about locking up people who go fishing or hunting quail.

Yeah, I know! You're right, as usual. The fantasy involves not peaceful co-existence, but people who go hunting and then get caught. Yeah, suckahs!

P.S. Why do we lock up people for rape?
 
Well, obviously meat-eaters are just so much more tolerant (apart from that whole killing thing). A world where billions of animals are needlessly raised to be needlessly slaughtered is not at all ridiculous. Now, the one that doesn't have quite so much of the killing... almost unfathomable. My cynical core is often inclined to agree.

P.S. GreNME: I'm pleased to see you sticking to your standard over what constitutes a digression (i.e., "If I do it, it's OK!").

RandFan:


Yeah, I know! You're right, as usual. The fantasy involves not peaceful co-existence, but people who go hunting and then get caught. Yeah, suckahs!

P.S. Why do we lock up people for rape?

If you are seriously comparing eating meat to rape, then you need help, fast.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom