Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's all I could find. I submit that the quote was fabricated.

Could have been. There are only references to it on the net.

A great deal of what you claim is based on what you presume to be going on in the minds of others, but if you've demonstrated nothing else here, it is that your mindreading abilities are abysmal.

My claim is not based on what I presume to be going on in their minds, it is based on the words coming out of their mouths and computer keyboard.

Much earlier, I suggested the Wiki article on "spirituality" as a source containing a number of ways in which that word may be used that do not involve any supernatural claims, such as a "sense of connectedness", or a development of "the deepest values and meanings by which people live". One statement, verbatim, is: "At one end of the spectrum, even some atheists are spiritual." (And I will pre-empt your anticipated objection by noting that where the requirement simply is "various ways in which people use a particular word", quoting Wikipedia as a source is valid, as the mere appearance of examples there proves the point).

Tell me why you disagree with any of this, or, alternatively, how you can support a claim that none of this is the sort of thing AA members are referring to as "SBNR":

I don't disagree with any of this. There are times that spitiual definitely does not mean religious. But that is not the way it is used in AA literature, at their meetings or from its most ardent supporters. You will hear people arguing this point, as many have in this thread, but their very words prove that the seperation of religion and spiritual does not exist in what they say.

So, you state that I am presuming and yet you presume to know what the AA literature means outside of any standard meaning to the words. Right now we have AA doctrine and we have your doctrine about what AA means. They are completely different. All we can look at is what AA says and not how you interpret it.
 
There are times that spitiual definitely does not mean religious.
So (regardless of what a lower court Judge in rural Wisconsin may or may not have said) there IS a distinction. There's a bit of progress.

But that is not the way it is used in AA literature...
AA literature makes numerous references to the spiritual nature of the program, the need for spiritual awakening, etc, while flatly stating (in the foreword to the second edition of the Big Book) that "Alcoholics Anonymous is not a religious organization". AA literature apparently IS making a distincition between "spiritual" and "religious".

at their meetings...
The same ones where "spiritual but not religious" is among the most oft-heard phrases. I'll repeat the reminder that implicit in the OP's question is the assumption that significant numbers of people (presumably AA members) insist that AA is not religious. If "spiritual" and "religious" mean the same thing to them, why would they say that?

or from its most ardent supporters.
Which sounds to me like a euphemism for "fanatics". Are large groups of people best judged on the opinions of the fanatics among them?
 
So (regardless of what a lower court Judge in rural Wisconsin may or may not have said) there IS a distinction. There's a bit of progress.

No progress where AA is concerned.

AA literature makes numerous references to the spiritual nature of the program, the need for spiritual awakening, etc, while flatly stating (in the foreword to the second edition of the Big Book) that "Alcoholics Anonymous is not a religious organization". AA literature apparently IS making a distincition between "spiritual" and "religious".

It is not a distinction that holds water. A post or two ago you wanted to use . . .

Wiki article on "spirituality" as a source containing a number of ways in which that word may be used that do not involve any supernatural claims, such as a "sense of connectedness", or a development of "the deepest values and meanings by which people live". One statement, verbatim, is: "At one end of the spectrum, even some atheists are spiritual."

That isn't what the AA literature does. It expressly says a Higher Power and God, those are deities, not connectedness.

The same ones where "spiritual but not religious" is among the most oft-heard phrases. I'll repeat the reminder that implicit in the OP's question is the assumption that significant numbers of people (presumably AA members) insist that AA is not religious. If "spiritual" and "religious" mean the same thing to them, why would they say that?

I do not know why they say it, I don't read minds.

Spiritual but not religious is a claim that doesn't hold up to examination. When you ask a Higher Power or God to help you are you really talking to your "connectedness?" Give me a break.

Which sounds to me like a euphemism for "fanatics". Are large groups of people best judged on the opinions of the fanatics among them?

We can debate large groups of people but the GSO is definitely religious. It writes and prints all AA literature. Also, that the majority of meetings follow that literature and the majority of AA people spout it back at you has to have some bearing on the answer to that question.

In my view, there maybe a few non-religious people inside an AA meeting, but that doesn't mean the meeting is not religious. Following the "suggestions" of the GSO pretty much guarantees it is.
 
No progress where AA is concerned.
I'm having a hard time extracting any relevant meaning from that sentence.

It is not a distinction that holds water.
Aside from those "times when spitiual definitely does not mean religious", of course.

That isn't what the AA literature does. It expressly says a Higher Power and God, those are deities, not connectedness.
You're presuming again; imposing your own values. AA literature expressly says that AA is not religious.

When you ask a Higher Power or God to help you are you really talking to your connectedness?"
You pick one word out of the brief snippet I quoted, play word games with it, and present that as an argument? Where did you learn the fine art of online debating, AOL chatrooms? What matters here is not whether a non-religious spirituality makes sense to you, because the question of AA's religiousity is not about YOU. Whatever it is -- whether it's illogical, irrational, or incoherent -- the only thing that matters for the purpose of this discussion is whether it is religious.

We can debate large groups of people but the GSO is definitely religious.
Here, you are making an appeal to authority using the other sense of that word, and this time it fails not only on the weakness of your assertion, but because in AA, authority flows from the bottom up, not from the top down.
 
You're presuming again; imposing your own values. AA literature expressly says that AA is not religious.

AA literature is lying.

AA literature expressly invokes the Protestant God, therefore its own claims to the contrary--in often the very same piece of literature within sentences of the Invocation--are a lie.

You pick one word out of the brief snippet I quoted, play word games with it, and present that as an argument? Where did you learn the fine art of online debating, AOL chatrooms?

NO! From you.

GB
 
Ilustrates my point. You didn't decide to change your beliefs; the evidence decided for you.

Since this applies to absolutely everything you do or think, I suggest it's not very useful. How did you put it ? A vacuous truth ?

Another way of saying it is that the reasoning abilities you possess, acting upon the available evidence, informed you that the beliefs had changed. "YOU" had very little say in the matter.

And since you persist in this useless line of reasoning, why not simply deny that "you" exist at all, since it serves no function whatsoever ?
 
And since you persist in this useless line of reasoning, why not simply deny that "you" exist at all...
As long as there is anyone willing to persist in the line of reasoning that has it that nothing could be meaningfully said to be higher than (or greater than) a self (or that YOU represents "the sum of the things that are your body") -- why not indeed? Zen's answer to Socrates: No Thyself. Life goes on within you and without YOU.

There is no denying that the notion of the self has a strong intuitive appeal. Many have sought to explain it in terms of an immortal soul -- which, in turn, seems to demand further explanation in terms of a supernatural creator (at which point the investigative process usually bottoms out, the creator being seen as somehow deserving of being treated as exempt from further explanation). The atheist considers the immortal soul and the supernatural creator as extraodinary claims requiring extraordinary evidence, and regards the burden for providing that evidence to fall upon the claimant. Why should the idea of a "self" be treated any differently? Shall we accept its existence as axiomatic; as too bleeding obvious to require proof -- the way it was once regarded as obvious that the Sun revolves around the Earth? If I were to propose that the existence of a "self" is, if not a supernatural claim, at least indistinguishable from a supernatural claim, how would you refute that?

...since it serves no function whatsoever ?
Whether a thing exists -- and whether it may serve some useful function to treat it as if it does -- are two separate questions. The square root of a negative number is a mathematical impossibility; yet, there are applications for which it is useful to ignore this and treat such a number as though it does exist. Dennett does not describe the "self" as a mere fiction; he describes it as a useful fiction; a "center of narrative gravity" (thereby distancing himself from epiphenomenonalists who would argue that it is merely illusory).
 
As long as there is anyone willing to persist in the line of reasoning that has it that nothing could be meaningfully said to be higher than (or greater than) a self (or that YOU represents "the sum of the things that are your body") -- why not indeed? Zen's answer to Socrates: No Thyself. Life goes on within you and without YOU.

That's one of the most eloquently-designed strawmen I've yet seen.

Why should the idea of a "self" be treated any differently?

Because it can easily be defined as the sum of things we already know exist.
 
As long as there is anyone willing to persist in the line of reasoning that has it that nothing could be meaningfully said to be higher than (or greater than) a self (or that YOU represents "the sum of the things that are your body") -- why not indeed? Zen's answer to Socrates: No Thyself. Life goes on within you and without YOU.

That's one of the most eloquently-designed strawmen I've yet seen.

I thought it was a rather eloquent Red Herring myself. :D ***not to mention a non sequitur***

GB
 
That's one of the most eloquently-designed strawmen I've yet seen.
I'm certainly not interested in wasting time countering arguments you're not actually making. Perhaps you can help me identify the point at which I became confused about that by revisiting the following posts:


AlBell said:
As to a higher power, I'd suggest an atheist consider the parts of his mind that used to be termed subconcious as his "higher power"; using his conscious mind to the best of his abilities got him where he's finally decided he needs help with his alcoholism, which is actually help with living a rational life.
Word salad.

The unconscious mind is a decidedly LOWER power.

My point is, and always was, that if you can consider anything to be a higher power, even things that cannot really be considered powers, or "higher" things, then the term becomes useless and we should use another phrase.

The unconscious parts of your mind handle automatic functions, language and the like. How they could be considered "higher" is beyond me.

YOU is the sum of things that are your body. That's not a higher power, that's still you, no matter what percentage of your actions are due to your own choices.
 
I'm having a hard time extracting any relevant meaning from that sentence.

Pretty obvious really. You said we were making progress on the idea that there can be a difference between spiritual and religious. For me, that has never been in question. My sentence referred to the fact that AA hasn't made any progress, that their definition of the two words is identical.

Aside from those "times when spitiual definitely does not mean religious", of course.

I think you are having an understanding issue here. There is two problems:

1) Can there be a difference between the definition of word "spiritual" and the word "religious" or are the two always the same? (My answer to that is: "yes, there can be a difference. One can be spiritual and not religious.")

2) Does AA define/use the word "spiritual" in the sense that it is different from "religious" or, does AA use the term in the sense that it means the same as "religious?" (My answer, and that of many others including the courts, is that AA does not use the term spiritual in the sense that it means something other than religious. By their usage, they show the two to be one and the same.)

You're presuming again; imposing your own values. AA literature expressly says that AA is not religious.

So what? Liars often say they aren't lying, should we believe them?

You have to go with the definitions of the words and how AA specifically uses them.

You pick one word out of the brief snippet I quoted, play word games with it, and present that as an argument? Where did you learn the fine art of online debating, AOL chatrooms? What matters here is not whether a non-religious spirituality makes sense to you, because the question of AA's religiousity is not about YOU. Whatever it is -- whether it's illogical, irrational, or incoherent -- the only thing that matters for the purpose of this discussion is whether it is religious.

Non-religious spirituality makses complete sesne to me, it just isn't happening in AA which is what the discussion is about.

I took that term out of your post not because I disagree with it, I don't, but because it illustrates the absurdity of what AA says as opposed to what you think they say.

Your definition of spirituality without religion is 100% correct in my view, but when you insert it into AA literature/doctrine it is patently absurd. They are not pushing a spirituality seperate from religion, they are pushing religion as spirituality.

Here, you are making an appeal to authority using the other sense of that word, and this time it fails not only on the weakness of your assertion, but because in AA, authority flows from the bottom up, not from the top down.

Clearly you haven't read the AA website. They claim that the power is a reverse pyramid but in reality and practice, it isn't. What the AA power structure does is make it impossible to change anything. They need the entire "collective conscience" to agree but that is impossible to have happen under the structure.
 
Last edited:
Because it can easily be defined as the sum of things we already know exist.
The "soul" can easily be defined, too, as "the incorporeal essence of a person" -- but that doesn't go very far toward establishing that any such thing actually exists.
 
You said we were making progress on the idea that there can be a difference between spiritual and religious. For me, that has never been in question.
Hard to understand why you took the trouble to quote the (unverifiable) opinon of a lower court judge that the distinction is meaningless. It might make it easier to understand your position if, when posting the (alledged) opinions of people you disagree with, you made it clearer that you don't agree with what you're posting. Otherwise, it kinda does look like you're posting it because you agree with it. See how easy it could be for that misunderstanding to arise? Just a suggestion.

Non-religious spirituality makses complete sesne to me, it just isn't happening in AA which is what the discussion is about.
I believe your argument is that just isn't happening in AA literature, and because it isn't happening in AA literature, it cannot be demonstrated to be happening in AA. What I find comical is that you appear completely oblivious to the contradiction in saying that and then turning around and saying this:

Clearly you haven't read the AA website. They claim that the power is a reverse pyramid but in reality and practice, it isn't.
If what happens in reality and practice does not match what they claim, then the expectation that that insight could be obtained by "reading the website" seems to me a complete failure in logic, at the most rudimentary level.

Once again you reveal the quality of the standards you are applying here: "Hey, Louie, da man wants a blue suit; turn on da blue light".
 
Hard to understand why you took the trouble to quote the (unverifiable) opinon of a lower court judge that the distinction is meaningless. It might make it easier to understand your position if, when posting the (alledged) opinions of people you disagree with, you made it clearer that you don't agree with what you're posting. Otherwise, it kinda does look like you're posting it because you agree with it. See how easy it could be for that misunderstanding to arise? Just a suggestion.

You seem to be having trouble grasping this simple point. The judge said that, as used by AA, there is no difference between the two words, I agree completely with the judge. I also agree that there IS a way that the two words can be different but that isn't the way AA uses them.

For AA to be spiritual without being religious it would require the rewriting of a huge percentage of their literature and to have that trickle down to the meetings. Other organizations have done it and it has worked very well.

I believe your argument is that just isn't happening in AA literature, and because it isn't happening in AA literature, it cannot be demonstrated to be happening in AA. What I find comical is that you appear completely oblivious to the contradiction in saying that and then turning around and saying this:

I think you need to think harder.

It isn't happening in AA literature and the AA literature is exactly what is spouted at the meetings. It is also the same tripe spouted by AA zealots in this thread, even the ones who claim to be agnostic.

If what happens in reality and practice does not match what they claim, then the expectation that that insight could be obtained by "reading the website" seems to me a complete failure in logic, at the most rudimentary level.

You really need to read and think without swallowing the pill. They say they have a reverse pyramid power model and yet when you read how decisions are actually made, and how the reverse power model doesn't allow for changes to take place (Go read, it really isd right there.), you realize that they are not a reverse pyramid system.

Simple test: Go see how many changes have been made by one individual in one meeting convincing everyone else in every other meeting it is a good idea. Then go see how many changes are done from the top without any consultation with meetings and individuals.

Once again you reveal the quality of the standards you are applying here: "Hey, Louie, da man wants a blue suit; turn on da blue light".

And you reveal your inability to read, comprehend and think critically but hey, whose counting? :rolleyes:
 
I also agree that there IS a way that the two words can be different but that isn't the way AA uses them.
So, if I have this straight:
When people other than AA members say that they are SBNR, their basis for saying that may be one you could accept; but if an AA member describes his beliefs that way, you would dismiss him as either an outlier or simply a liar. AA members are bound by AA dogma, defined in its literature; hence, any viewpoint not strictly adhering to that dogma may be rejected as not true AA. Passages in AA literature which explicitly contradict this view may also be disregarded as as disingenuous. Where the literature says "The only requirement for AA membership is a desire to stop drinking", what it really means is "The only requirement for AA membership is belief in the Protestant God", and where it says "Any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group provided that as a group they have no other affiliation", what it really means is "...provided that as a group they DO have another affiliation; specifically Protestant Christianity".

Your method is foolproof, qayak: Accept at face value any passage of AA literature you feel supports your position, and reinforce that with further confirmation bias by taking particular notice when this matches "what is spouted at meetings". Reject or reinterpret any passage in AA literature which contradicts your position, and reject the expression of any such viewpoint by AA members as not representative of AA, or not true AA. I find myself almost tempted to refer to this method as clever, but I think cunning is really a better word for it.
 
So, if I have this straight:
When people other than AA members say that they are SBNR, their basis for saying that may be one you could accept; but if an AA member describes his beliefs that way, you would dismiss him as either an outlier or simply a liar. AA members are bound by AA dogma, defined in its literature; hence, any viewpoint not strictly adhering to that dogma may be rejected as not true AA. Passages in AA literature which explicitly contradict this view may also be disregarded as as disingenuous. Where the literature says "The only requirement for AA membership is a desire to stop drinking", what it really means is "The only requirement for AA membership is belief in the Protestant God", and where it says "Any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group provided that as a group they have no other affiliation", what it really means is "...provided that as a group they DO have another affiliation; specifically Protestant Christianity".

Your method is foolproof, qayak: Accept at face value any passage of AA literature you feel supports your position, and reinforce that with further confirmation bias by taking particular notice when this matches "what is spouted at meetings". Reject or reinterpret any passage in AA literature which contradicts your position, and reject the expression of any such viewpoint by AA members as not representative of AA, or not true AA. I find myself almost tempted to refer to this method as clever, but I think cunning is really a better word for it.

So instead of providing evidence, you continue to argue with Straw Men (conflating AA's publications and leadership with its membership and suggesting that Qayak is only giving AA members two options, outliers or liars [how about dupes, or self-deniers?]), thus redefining Qayak's point to suit your unjustified assertions that he is the one "cherry-picking".

Then you accuse Qayak of "rejecting or reinterpreting" passages in AA literature, "accepting at face value" portions of literature that confirm his position, and of thus being "clever" or "cunning."

Well there are several words I can think of to describe your arguments. CONNIVING for one. And Psychological Projection for another. :p

You have proven one thing, that you are a Master of Sophistry.

AA's literature and tenets are so God Bound, that any assertions within the literature itself that it is not Religious are demonstrably False, not merely contradictory, but Flat Out False.

Anecdotes about SBNR AA adherents amounts to nothing but a Red Herring. Many of us have already acknowledged (or agreed with you when you're making points that undermine your case and support ours) that non-theist AA members are able to subsume their intellects to the dictates of AA Doctrine.

GB
 
GB, Your criticisms are appreciated as always, but I find them a bit too vague to be as helpful as they might possibly be.

In helping me to identify exactly which of my arguments are straw men, maybe it would be better to address them one at a time. For example, I am indeed assuming that qayak does not disagree with this:
Where the literature says "The only requirement for AA membership is a desire to stop drinking", what it really means is "The only requirement for AA membership is belief in the Protestant God"
Since you chose to answer for qayak, I'll be happy to direct that to you instead. Do YOU disagree with that statement?
 
GB, Your criticisms are appreciated as always, but I find them a bit too vague to be as helpful as they might possibly be.

In helping me to identify exactly which of my arguments are straw men, maybe it would be better to address them one at a time. For example, I am indeed assuming that qayak does not disagree with this:

Where the literature says "The only requirement for AA membership is a desire to stop drinking", what it really means is "The only requirement for AA membership is belief in the Protestant God"

Since you chose to answer for qayak, I'll be happy to direct that to you instead. Do YOU disagree with that statement?


1) I'm not "answering for Qayak," I'm pointing out what's wrong with your arguments.

2) I already specified your Straw Man:
...(conflating AA's publications and leadership with its membership and suggesting that Qayak is only giving AA members two options, outliers or liars [how about dupes, or self-deniers?]),...


3) Which leads me to conclude that you don't really need any more help on my part to comprehend my statement. Your statement is just a conniving way to lead me into a Red Herring, a Trap; your Trick Question:
Where the literature says "The only requirement for AA membership is a desire to stop drinking", what it really means is "The only requirement for AA membership is belief in the Protestant God"


4) Notice how you frame the question, where you assume only one correct answer:
For example, I am indeed assuming that qayak does not disagree with this:


5) Then the question itself is in fact a statement with a foregone conclusion, a tautology.

6) Why should I agree with your simplistic predetermined equation, that allegedly (Falsely) represents my arguments?

7) One might almost think you were trying to set up another Straw Man. :p

GB
 
Last edited:
Why should I agree with your simplistic predetermined equation, that allegedly (Falsely) represents my arguments?
You either agree or you don't. If you don't, why should you not simply say so instead of going off on some weird disjointed rant?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom