qayak
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2006
- Messages
- 13,844
It's all I could find. I submit that the quote was fabricated.
Could have been. There are only references to it on the net.
A great deal of what you claim is based on what you presume to be going on in the minds of others, but if you've demonstrated nothing else here, it is that your mindreading abilities are abysmal.
My claim is not based on what I presume to be going on in their minds, it is based on the words coming out of their mouths and computer keyboard.
Much earlier, I suggested the Wiki article on "spirituality" as a source containing a number of ways in which that word may be used that do not involve any supernatural claims, such as a "sense of connectedness", or a development of "the deepest values and meanings by which people live". One statement, verbatim, is: "At one end of the spectrum, even some atheists are spiritual." (And I will pre-empt your anticipated objection by noting that where the requirement simply is "various ways in which people use a particular word", quoting Wikipedia as a source is valid, as the mere appearance of examples there proves the point).
Tell me why you disagree with any of this, or, alternatively, how you can support a claim that none of this is the sort of thing AA members are referring to as "SBNR":
I don't disagree with any of this. There are times that spitiual definitely does not mean religious. But that is not the way it is used in AA literature, at their meetings or from its most ardent supporters. You will hear people arguing this point, as many have in this thread, but their very words prove that the seperation of religion and spiritual does not exist in what they say.
So, you state that I am presuming and yet you presume to know what the AA literature means outside of any standard meaning to the words. Right now we have AA doctrine and we have your doctrine about what AA means. They are completely different. All we can look at is what AA says and not how you interpret it.