Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, if I have this straight:
When people other than AA members say that they are SBNR, their basis for saying that may be one you could accept . . .

Maybe, yes. Depending on how the term "spiritual" is used which is always the determiner.

. . . but if an AA member describes his beliefs that way, you would dismiss him as either an outlier or simply a liar.

No. I would listen to how he was using the term before deciding.

AA members are bound by AA dogma, defined in its literature;

That is a philosophical discussion of another nature. They are no more bound to AA dogma than a catholic is bound by catholic dogma.

. . . hence, any viewpoint not strictly adhering to that dogma may be rejected as not true AA.

Well, it is definitely not representative of AA.

Passages in AA literature which explicitly contradict this view may also be disregarded as as disingenuous.

No, the literature has to be looked at as a whole. Most of the literature dealing with belief has to do with a belief in God. One statement saying one isn't necessary doesn't wipe out all the others that say it is.

Where the literature says "The only requirement for AA membership is a desire to stop drinking", what it really means is "The only requirement for AA membership is belief in the Protestant God",

Read the literature and you will see that it isn't the only requirement. If that were the only thing people were held to, it would be fine but it isn't. Through various other tenets and doctrine, and through various techniques, members other requirements exist for AA membership.

and where it says "Any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group provided that as a group they have no other affiliation", what it really means is "...provided that as a group they DO have another affiliation; specifically Protestant Christianity".

You have identified the problem here but you refuse to see it. A few passages in AA literature make statements like, "Any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group provided that as a group they have no other affiliation" but then when you look at AA itself and how the "suggested" method of running meetings and what goes on in them, it becomes obvious that AA is affiliated with something else.

If it weren't it wouldn't reference "God" or a "higher power" because both of those are affiliated with religion.

Your method is foolproof, qayak: Accept at face value any passage of AA literature you feel supports your position, and reinforce that with further confirmation bias by taking particular notice when this matches "what is spouted at meetings". Reject or reinterpret any passage in AA literature which contradicts your position, and reject the expression of any such viewpoint by AA members as not representative of AA, or not true AA. I find myself almost tempted to refer to this method as clever, but I think cunning is really a better word for it.

I do nothing of the sort. What I do is exactly what I taught my children in order to protect them from predators and shysters. It is a very simply thing: You listen/read the things that someone tells you and you compare them to what the person/group is really doing.
You are looking for contradictions becuase that is a sign someone is trying to get you to do somewthing they don't want you to know about. If AA isn't a religious organization, why hasn't the mention of God and Higher power been removed and religious practices stopped? Other organizations did exactly that.
 
Read the literature and you will see that it isn't the only requirement. If that were the only thing people were held to, it would be fine but it isn't. Through various other tenets and doctrine, and through various techniques, members other requirements exist for AA membership.

What are these other requirements?

If it weren't it wouldn't reference "God" or a "higher power" because both of those are affiliated with religion.

And currency, and parliaments, and constitutions, and, and, and .....

It would depend on how one defines affiliation wouldn't it?
 
You either agree or you don't. If you don't, why should you not simply say so instead of going off on some weird disjointed rant?

The only thing weird and disjointed is that you actually think I'm stupid enough to play the game by your rules.

Why should I agree or disagree with your Straw Men arguments? Why should I be distracted by your Red Herrings? If you want to call my dissection of your verbal trickery a "rant," feel free.

I suppose that's all you've got though, seeing as you don't have evidence.

GB
 
Maybe, yes. Depending on how the term "spiritual" is used which is always the determiner.
Glad we agree on that much. I'll even stipulate that there may be more than a few AA members who would describe themselves as SBNR yet whose "spirituality" would, on close examination, turn out to rest on beliefs I would also consider religious.

No. I would listen to how he was using the term before deciding.
As would I (if I felt I had some good reason for needing to reach a decision on the matter at all).

That is a philosophical discussion of another nature. They are no more bound to AA dogma than a catholic is bound by catholic dogma.
The understanding provided by my somewhat distant view of Catholicism is that that's pretty dang bound. I wonder if you would concede that AA members are less "bound" by dogma than Catholics are. I mean, Catholicism has that excommunication thing and all, for which there is no correlate in AA, and I don't know for sure that "take what you can use and leave the rest" is the sort of thing one might never expect to hear from a priest, but I've certainly heard the practice strongly (and quite explicitly) denounced by the born-again sorts that represent most of my face to face experiences with Christians in general. They aren't called "bible thumpers" for nothing.

Well, it is definitely not representative of AA.
One of our differences appears to be that you see the matter of what is representative of AA as simple and crisp, while I see it as complex and fuzzy. The comparison has been made a number of times before, but it may bear repeating in light of there having recently been some stink (I think you could call it) over a similar matter: whether atheism is representative of JREF, and whether that's a good thing or not.
http://www.randi.org/site/index.php/swift-blog/1081-new-atheist-directions-at-the-jref.html

Most of the literature dealing with belief has to do with a belief in God. One statement saying one isn't necessary doesn't wipe out all the others that say it is.
The emphasis is really on relying on more than in believing in a "higher power". Faith implies doubt. But that may be a bit of a tangent.

I say that after having once aired the disclaimer that references to "God" are subject to the qualifier: GodAsWeUnderstandHim, all subsequent references to the same as simply "God" may be taken (and are intended to be taken) to subsume the same qualification. So I don't see the cancelling effect you're seeing.

Read the literature and you will see that it isn't the only requirement.
I am quite confident that our differences are not due to a greater familiarity with AA literature on your part. After more than twenty years, I can recite most of the famous "first 164 pages" from memory.

You have identified the problem here but you refuse to see it.
For GB's benefit (because he seems upset), I wonder if you would mind rephrasing that as a clearer statement for the record that (whatever the reasons may be for my not reaching the same conclusions you do) I have correctly summarized your arguments.

You are looking for contradictions becuase that is a sign someone is trying to get you to do somewthing they don't want you to know about.
I will say this about your mind-reading abilities: the results are consistent.
 
Last edited:
As a matter of technical fact, AA does not require a deity belief, only powers greater than yourself. I certainly can't jump from an airplane and expect to save myself through will power. In practice, such groups tend to delve headlong into the religious arena.

The psychological reason for this that will power alone is not enough. You MUST be willing to submit to lifestyle limitations that removes the need for will power to the degree possible. Will power alone WILL fail you. Except in addictive behaviors, we like to pretend it's all about will power. If your will power is completely sufficient, it is an illusion created by a good match between your will and your addictive behavioral patterns. In that sense, the AA "power greater than yourself" condition, is an anti-religious condition. People just make make themselves feel better by wrapping it within religious fairy tales. The notion that your will power has suddenly gotten strong enough to handle a drink (for an alcoholic) is, like religion, a fairy tale. The drink is a power greater than you in that sense.
 
Last edited:
Since I started this thread, I have something else to add--I don't know if this will derail the thread or contribute to it.

My husband's therapist, a specialist in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, recommended that my husband have his head checked at the hospital.

A CAT and an MRI confirmed a large mass growing on the frontal cortex.

He's going in for biopsy.

This, this is why I chose science over superstition. If he was still attending AA meetings as a "treatment" for his behavior, i doubt very sincerely he would have had gone to the hospital and had his head checked.

At this current point in time, I probably will not be posting any longer. But I just wanted to get that out.

Thank you to everyone who has contributed to this thread.
 
I'm sorry to learn of his problem and hope your husband does well.

To my knowledge, AA has no requirement suggesting that people should not seek medical diagnosis. AA is concerned only with providing what assistance it can to those seeking help for problems related to alcohol abuse.
 
This, this is why I chose science over superstition. If he was still attending AA meetings as a "treatment" for his behavior, i doubt very sincerely he would have had gone to the hospital and had his head checked.
That may very well be true.

The assumption made going in is that alcoholism is the problem, and if that assumption turns out to be flawed, AA really isn't set up to handle that any better than the typical fitness trainer would be when it comes to helping a person with obesity due to an undiagnosed metabolic disorder. Dispensing medical advice is often listed among the things AA does NOT do, but individual members -- applying the "take what you can use and leave the rest" principle -- have been known to ignore this.


Nanny Ogg, I'm very sorry to hear this news. You must feel like you've just been run over by a truck. I hope you are able to tap into some kind of a support network.
 
Since I started this thread, I have something else to add--I don't know if this will derail the thread or contribute to it.

My husband's therapist, a specialist in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, recommended that my husband have his head checked at the hospital.

A CAT and an MRI confirmed a large mass growing on the frontal cortex.

He's going in for biopsy.

This, this is why I chose science over superstition. If he was still attending AA meetings as a "treatment" for his behavior, i doubt very sincerely he would have had gone to the hospital and had his head checked.

At this current point in time, I probably will not be posting any longer. But I just wanted to get that out.

Thank you to everyone who has contributed to this thread.

Good luck Nanny Ogg. I trust things work out well.

In my work we see many people coming in with Alcohol induced ABIs (aquired brain injury). It is common practice for me to refer these clients to specialists for the necessary brain scans. Similarly, in AA I often have cause to direct people to other sources of help.
BTW, I am not suggesting for a moment that your husbands condition was caused by, or was the cause of any alcohol problems.

I'm sorry to learn of his problem and hope your husband does well.

To my knowledge, AA has no requirement suggesting that people should not seek medical diagnosis. AA is concerned only with providing what assistance it can to those seeking help for problems related to alcohol abuse.

I may have shared this already but have people come to me all the time with issues outside of alcohol at AA meetings. Recently a young fellow with anxiety approached me wanting to know why his anxiety and depression hadn't left him after a decent period of sobriety. I asked him what his doctor had said, and he said he hadn't been. I gently told him this was alcoholics anonymous, not anxiety anonymous; he needs to seek outside help for outside issues.

Here is what AA does not do (I have bolded two topical points):

http://www.aa.org.au/new-to-aa/what-is-aa.php

AA does not:

1.Furnish initial motivation for alcoholics to recover
2.Solicit members
3.Engage in or sponsor research
4.Keep attendance records or case histories
5.Join "councils" of social agencies
6.Follow up or try to control its members
7.Make medical or psychological diagnoses or prognoses
8.Provide drying-out or nursing services, hospitalisation, drugs, or any medical or psychiatric treatment
9.Offer religious services
10.Engage in education about alcohol
11.Provide housing, food, clothing, jobs, money or any other welfare or social services
12.Provide domestic or vocational counselling
13.Accept any money for its services, or any contributions from non-AA sources
14.Provide letters of reference to parole boards, lawyers, court officials, social agencies, employers, etc.
 
Last edited:
I can't wrap my head around the whole "admit we are powerless," or the "higher power" stuff.

Yes, yes, I know what they mean. I know what they at least attempt to do.

But you aren't powerless. Your power is pretty much the only power that matters. Sure, you can get support from others, and you should, but your power is still the power that's going to get you into the door of the first meeting, and keep you coming back.

I know part of my problem with that is how my ex would throw it at me when he'd have a slip. "But I'm powerless over alcohol!" Yeah, and isn't that handy for you?

But that was okay. There was god, right? And god can do anything. God has power. Come on, god, heal my husband. God? Hello, God? He's still drinking, God. And he's still cheating on me every day, God. And he hits me, God. So, come on, use your power. He says he wants to be healed, so it wouldn't be working against his own will, so heal him already!

God?


God, are you there?


Well, crud. I'm starting to think there's no one there at all... Guess I'll have to use my own power to fix this mess. One divorce later, and my husband was no longer an alcoholic. He was, in fact, a guy I met and married, who didn't really drink.

And now...yeah, I have a big problem with people who distance themselves from their own responsibility. You are not powerless over alcohol. If that were true, no one would ever get sober. There is no higher power than myself,either. I'm all I've got. There is no one else but me who can get over this mess.

I'm also not keen on calling them "recovering" alcoholics. They don't recover. Ever. They just don't drink. But they're still alcoholics, and they can't ever drink again. My ex-husband was 20 years sober.

Notice...I said "was...."
 
Slingblade,
You have a very real point concerning the abdication of responsibility. It doesn't matter whether the Universe is predestined at some foundational level. The fact remains that once you accept this as justification for an action, you remove the potential for that action to change in the future. Whether or not your predestined to point of view, thus predestined to the action, is immaterial to the predictability of the results.

Never accept yourself as powerless, you are merely up against forces more powerful than you. To maintain your power, you must then use these forces, both to avoid situations that taps your weaknesses and to create situations that increases your favorable options, rather than just blindly sitting back and saying: Duh,.. I can't help it.

Your right, your power is the only power that matters. And if your power is insufficient in some circumstances, then you have to use your power to avoid those situations.

I know part of my problem with that is how my ex would throw it at me when he'd have a slip. "But I'm powerless over alcohol!" Yeah, and isn't that handy for you?

Consider what the real message was. He trying to tell you to accept that you also should accept being powerless, thus shut and and be my powerless wife. It was fundamentally a sick request. You can continue to powerlessly object to his behavior, or exercise your power to change your circumstances (him), or remain powerless (his request) with your objections to his behavior. Too many women choose the powerless option. Good for you for not taking that road. Had you stayed, forces were at work more powerful than you.

Even if the Universe is predestined, such that choices are an illusion, the rules by which the situations you associate with leads to your future, and how much that future is at odds with your apparent willpower, is physically identical. Accepting the notion of personal powerlessness is then a determinant of being powerless. Your power, however limited, is maintained by rejecting such a notion.

So yes, your reaction is perfectly valid, and you are a better person for it.
 
I can't wrap my head around the whole "admit we are powerless," or the "higher power" stuff.

Yes, yes, I know what they mean. I know what they at least attempt to do.
Based the remainder of your post, and as it relates to AA and god-as-you-understand him, I'm not sure our understanding is the same.

But you aren't powerless. Your power is pretty much the only power that matters. Sure, you can get support from others, and you should, but your power is still the power that's going to get you into the door of the first meeting, and keep you coming back.
We do agree with that. :)

You would need to clarify
I know part of my problem with that is how my ex would throw it at me when he'd have a slip. "But I'm powerless over alcohol!" Yeah, and isn't that handy for you?
with your comment below "My ex-husband was 20 years sober."

He went 20 years without drinking, and then is back at it? Or he slipped (numerous times?) and wasn't '20 years sober'?

Although the answer really isn't important to me. Drunks are drunks.

But that was okay. There was god, right? And god can do anything. God has power. Come on, god, heal my husband. God? Hello, God? He's still drinking, God. And he's still cheating on me every day, God. And he hits me, God. So, come on, use your power. He says he wants to be healed, so it wouldn't be working against his own will, so heal him already!

God?


God, are you there?
Ever hear of "God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and wisdom to know the difference"?

I certainly hope no one in AA or Alanon ever suggested your approach would be helpful.

Well, crud. I'm starting to think there's no one there at all... Guess I'll have to use my own power to fix this mess. One divorce later, and my husband was no longer an alcoholic. He was, in fact, a guy I met and married, who didn't really drink.
Congratulations. You did get wisdom, and courage to change something that was within your power to change, you (and your situation).

And now...yeah, I have a big problem with people who distance themselves from their own responsibility. You are not powerless over alcohol. If that were true, no one would ever get sober. There is no higher power than myself,either. I'm all I've got. There is no one else but me who can get over this mess.
Something did seem to 'answer prayers' for me; I suspect it's the part of me that answered the algebra question after I slept on it, and keeps pushing thoughts out that the conscious 'me' can ignore, or select for more directed thought or action. I choose to call that my 'higher power'.

I'm also not keen on calling them "recovering" alcoholics. They don't recover. Ever. They just don't drink. But they're still alcoholics, and they can't ever drink again. My ex-husband was 20 years sober.

Notice...I said "was...."
You've heard the old saw "Man takes the 1st drink, 1st drink takes the 2nd, 2nd takes the 3rd, and 3rd drink takes the man."? For me, and any other alcoholic I know of, it's "Man takes the 1st drink, 1st drink takes the man".

And the only power over alcohol I have is 'don't take the 1st drink'. After one, I had no clue what happens next (and still wouldn't have).
 
Based the remainder of your post, and as it relates to AA and god-as-you-understand him, I'm not sure our understanding is the same.

So, her understanding of "god-as-you-understand him" was wrong and you spent an entire post straightening her out.

Isn't that what you AA zealots claim doesn't happen? You lied. You did preach to her. You did force a standard interpretation onto her. There is a standard definition of "God-as-you-know-Him" within AA and you disregarded her interpretation of god to "suggest" what the correct AA version is. Actions speak louder than words.

I think the thread can be put to rest now.

Side Note to Slingblade: I know we don't always see eye to eye on things but I must tip my hat to you on this one. Brilliantly done!
 
Isn't that what you AA zealots claim doesn't happen? You lied. You did preach to her. You did force a standard interpretation onto her. There is a standard definition of "God-as-you-know-Him" within AA and you disregarded her interpretation of god to "suggest" what the correct AA version is. Actions speak louder than words.
Thanks for sharing your usual mis-understanding of the written word.


Side Note to Slingblade: I know we don't always see eye to eye on things but I must tip my hat to you on this one. Brilliantly done!
At least you believe she agrees with your biases.
 
You've fooled me until now thinking that you might have something worth contributing.

Thanks for straightening that out.
 
So, her understanding of "god-as-you-understand him" was wrong and you spent an entire post straightening her out.

Isn't that what you AA zealots claim doesn't happen? You lied. You did preach to her. You did force a standard interpretation onto her. There is a standard definition of "God-as-you-know-Him" within AA and you disregarded her interpretation of god to "suggest" what the correct AA version is. Actions speak louder than words.

I think the thread can be put to rest now.

Side Note to Slingblade: I know we don't always see eye to eye on things but I must tip my hat to you on this one. Brilliantly done!

This thread should have been put to rest after the 12 Commandments...er...Steps, and extended portions of the Big Book were posted. ;)

GB
 
I'm certainly not interested in wasting time countering arguments you're not actually making. Perhaps you can help me identify the point at which I became confused about that by revisiting the following posts:

So let me get this straight: I said that the unconscious mind and your body can't be considered to be higher powers, and that if anything can be a higher power the term becomes meaningless... and you think it means that nothing can be a higher power. I think you were confused before the thread began.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom