qayak
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2006
- Messages
- 13,844
So, if I have this straight:
When people other than AA members say that they are SBNR, their basis for saying that may be one you could accept . . .
Maybe, yes. Depending on how the term "spiritual" is used which is always the determiner.
. . . but if an AA member describes his beliefs that way, you would dismiss him as either an outlier or simply a liar.
No. I would listen to how he was using the term before deciding.
AA members are bound by AA dogma, defined in its literature;
That is a philosophical discussion of another nature. They are no more bound to AA dogma than a catholic is bound by catholic dogma.
. . . hence, any viewpoint not strictly adhering to that dogma may be rejected as not true AA.
Well, it is definitely not representative of AA.
Passages in AA literature which explicitly contradict this view may also be disregarded as as disingenuous.
No, the literature has to be looked at as a whole. Most of the literature dealing with belief has to do with a belief in God. One statement saying one isn't necessary doesn't wipe out all the others that say it is.
Where the literature says "The only requirement for AA membership is a desire to stop drinking", what it really means is "The only requirement for AA membership is belief in the Protestant God",
Read the literature and you will see that it isn't the only requirement. If that were the only thing people were held to, it would be fine but it isn't. Through various other tenets and doctrine, and through various techniques, members other requirements exist for AA membership.
and where it says "Any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group provided that as a group they have no other affiliation", what it really means is "...provided that as a group they DO have another affiliation; specifically Protestant Christianity".
You have identified the problem here but you refuse to see it. A few passages in AA literature make statements like, "Any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group provided that as a group they have no other affiliation" but then when you look at AA itself and how the "suggested" method of running meetings and what goes on in them, it becomes obvious that AA is affiliated with something else.
If it weren't it wouldn't reference "God" or a "higher power" because both of those are affiliated with religion.
Your method is foolproof, qayak: Accept at face value any passage of AA literature you feel supports your position, and reinforce that with further confirmation bias by taking particular notice when this matches "what is spouted at meetings". Reject or reinterpret any passage in AA literature which contradicts your position, and reject the expression of any such viewpoint by AA members as not representative of AA, or not true AA. I find myself almost tempted to refer to this method as clever, but I think cunning is really a better word for it.
I do nothing of the sort. What I do is exactly what I taught my children in order to protect them from predators and shysters. It is a very simply thing: You listen/read the things that someone tells you and you compare them to what the person/group is really doing.
You are looking for contradictions becuase that is a sign someone is trying to get you to do somewthing they don't want you to know about. If AA isn't a religious organization, why hasn't the mention of God and Higher power been removed and religious practices stopped? Other organizations did exactly that.
