Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The meetings in Australia might be different than they are here in the US?

If alfie would only admit that...admit that since he is in Australia, he doesn't know anything about how AA meetings are "run" in the US...then it would be easier to respect his opinion...

As it stands, alfie only makes AA look "bad" by denying it's basic underlying ideal. Belief that God can help you quit drinking.

Alfie...why do you insist that AA is not religious?? ...just because you "say so" is not an answer.
 
In some situations, sure, but it's not like you're simply viewing what's going on (from a neurological perspective, perhaps).
I don't see the idea as necessarily incompatable with the "executive function" hypothesis endorsed by some neurologists, but I don't see the "neurological perspective" as the ultimate source of objective truth on this matter anyway (while I'm at it, ditto the "psychological perspective", and the "philosophical perspective"). As I keep trying to convey, sometimes what counts most is the intuitive perspective; the practical perspective. If a person with a headache takes some placebo or folk remedy, and doing so makes their headache go away, your right to insist that what counts is the pharmacology involved (valid though that objection may be) does not rise above that person's right to consider that what counts is that they no longer have a headache.

That's nice. So you were just being rude.
No need to feel insulted. My grandson happens to be a pretty sharp little dude. I learn stuff from him all the time.

That you find it simplistic is of no interest to me, so long as the statement is true.
As you have chosen to post it on an internet forum, it might behoove you to give some thought to whether your trivial observations are likely to be of interest to anyone other than yourself.

I'm not the one making the claim, AlBell was. I just need to show him/her wrong.
Interesting choice of words. I like totally relate to that need ("Honey, are you coming to bed?...")
 
In over a decade of regular attendance, I can't remember anyone ever talk about Jesus Christ at an AA meeting.

So much for Christian religion in AA. ;)


In over two decades of extremely sporadic (until recently) attendance in the US (in various cities, places, etc.) I can't remember anyone ever talk about Jesus Christ at an AA meeting either.

Still wondering how that refutes the core question of how AA is religious (or in your case, how AA isn't religious).
 
If alfie would only admit that...admit that since he is in Australia, he doesn't know anything about how AA meetings are "run" in the US...then it would be easier to respect his opinion...

As it stands, alfie only makes AA look "bad" by denying it's basic underlying ideal. Belief that God can help you quit drinking.

Alfie...why do you insist that AA is not religious?? ...just because you "say so" is not an answer.



Alfie has admitted that he doesn't know how meetings are run in the US, many times in this thread. He cannot, however, explain how his experiences refute the concept that AA has a whole is a religious institution.
 
Alfie has admitted that he doesn't know how meetings are run in the US, many times in this thread. He cannot, however, explain how his experiences refute the concept that AA has a whole is a religious institution.

Exactly, he is quick to point out that each meeting is different but we aren't talking about an individual meeting, we are talking about A.A. itself.
 
Exactly, he is quick to point out that each meeting is different but we aren't talking about an individual meeting, we are talking about A.A. itself.
What is "AA itself"? The GSO is not a religious organization. As a media provider some of the literature it sells might have religious content.

Is every bookstore a religious organization?

If it isn't the GSO, it's meetings, and nope, not one of them are a religious service, at least none I've ever been at.
 
What is "AA itself"? The GSO is not a religious organization. As a media provider some of the literature it sells might have religious content.

Is every bookstore a religious organization?

If it isn't the GSO, it's meetings, and nope, not one of them are a religious service, at least none I've ever been at.


Again, not one of the meetings I've attended would I characterize as a religious service (barring the universal recitation of the Lord's Prayer at the end).

AA is religious in nature.


AA's founders were religious men with religious upbringings who originally joined a religious organization to stop drinking. Bill W. had a religious conversion experience and began preaching to others how to stop drinking by invoking God and the western Christian symbolism of the shepherd and His flock. He recognized the fact that he had to "soften" his approach to garner as many converts as possible, so made as few changes as he could tolerate. The AA Organization has since refused to change any of that basic text, as I've linked to and quoted previously in this thread.

It is hammered home again and again, in the literature produced back then and the official literature produced to this day and by oldtimers alike, that a spiritual change is necessary and if you do not accept the 12 suggestions, you won't really *truly* succeed in sobriety.

The wiki on AA is actually a pretty good read and has some good points to be made:

"AA's program is an inheritor of Counter-Enlightenment philosophy. AA shares the view that acceptance of one's inherent limitations is critical to finding one's proper place among other humans and God. Such ideas are described as "Counter-Enlightenment" because they are contrary to the Enlightenment's ideal that humans have the capacity to make their lives and societies a heaven on earth using their own power and reason."



And the wiki says this about AA itself and it's measured success rates which goes back to those in this thread who have asked about where the high success rate numbers are being given.

"AA's Triennial Surveys
Most people who begin attending AA meetings tend to drop out within a few months. Every third year since 1968, AA has issued a pamphlet summarizing its latest triennial survey of meeting attendants. Additional published comments and analysis for academics and professionals have supplemented the survey results from 1970 through 1990. The 1990 commentary evaluated data of triennial surveys from 1977 through 1989 and found that one quarter (26%) of those who first attend an AA meeting are still attending after one year. Furthermore, nearly one third (31.5%) leave the program after one month, and by the end of the third month, over half (52.6%) leave. After the first year, the rate of attrition slows. Only those in the first year were recorded by month. About 40% of the members sober for less than a year will remain another year. About 80% of those sober less than five years will remain sober and active in the fellowship another year. About 90% of the members sober five years or more will remain sober and active in the fellowship another year. Those who remained sober outside the fellowship could not be calculated using the survey results. The most recent survey of AA membership, conducted in 2007, found that 33% of its members had been sober more than 10 years, 12% had 5 to 10 years of sobriety, 24% between 1 and 5 years, and 31% less than one year. Comprehensively, the average length of sobriety for all members is over 8 years, with 52% of the membership being between the ages of 41 and 60 (http://www.aa.org/pdf/products/p-48_07survey.pdf)."


And finally, the wiki says this about the court rulings which I think is a fair statement:

"United States courts have ruled that inmates, parolees, and probationers cannot be ordered to attend AA. Though AA itself was not deemed a religion, it was ruled that it contained enough religious components to make coerced attendance at AA meetings a violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment of the constitution. In September 2007, United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit stated that a parole office can be sued for ordering a parolee to attend AA."
 
Indeed, The Law in some of the US currently supports your position. Who knows; they may eventually get it right.
 
Indeed, The Law in some of the US currently supports your position. Who knows; they may eventually get it right.


So you're saying that the courts got it wrong in this case? That there are enough components of the AA program that cross the line when it comes to the First Amendment?

Qayak posted the definition of 'secular' above. The cry of "it's not religious, it's spiritual!" would still place it firmly in the category of NON-SECULAR. The AA program and the AA organization is religious by it's very nature.
 
So you're saying that the courts got it wrong in this case? That there are enough components of the AA program that cross the line when it comes to the First Amendment?
I rather believe the 'separation of church and state' concept has been forced into a position where it can now open its' eyes and examine its' molars.

/derail full on
I see some in the US doing their damndest to ignore:

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”,

and prodding Courts, Executive, Legislature, and the squeekiest wheels/better lawyers to take over the role of Creator.

I don't think they're up to playing that part.
 
I rather believe the 'separation of church and state' concept has been forced into a position where it can now open its' eyes and examine its' molars.

/derail full on
I see some in the US doing their damndest to ignore:

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”,

and prodding Courts, Executive, Legislature, and the squeekiest wheels/better lawyers to take over the role of Creator.

I don't think they're up to playing that part.


Continued Derail:

The Preamble is important, yes, but irrelevant when all that applies is the First Amendment in these matters which is not mere exposition (the Preamble) but actual binding law.

And further, no one that I can tell is trying to take over the role of Creator; just when there's no sign of any sort of Creator, someone has to step in and help keep societies cohesive. :rolleyes:
 
What is "AA itself"? The GSO is not a religious organization.

That is not true.

As a media provider some of the literature it sells might have religious content.

Is every bookstore a religious organization?

They aren't just a media provider though. They write and publish the literature.

If it isn't the GSO, it's meetings, and nope, not one of them are a religious service, at least none I've ever been at.

Go to the GSO run website and read the literature. Yes, they make claims about not being religious and give examples of why they don't think they are but that doesn't mean it is true. It certainly isn't.

As for meetings and members, you are completely wrong. The whole "higher power/god" thing is blatantly and irrefutably religious in nature.

From the website:

TheChristian Science Monitor, in its Aug. 17, 1939, edition,
predicted, “The book Alcoholics Anonymous, on the subject
of liquor addiction and its remedy, seems designed for
a wide usefulness.… It has indeed been proved true… that something more than individual willpower—or ‘won’t’ power—is necessary to heal what at least one special sanitarium
recognizes in its advertising as a ‘disease.’”

Bill and his A.A. co-founder Dr. Bob were quick to point
out that the A.A. program of recovery was a synthesis of
principles borrowed from the great religions, movements
like the Oxford Group (a religious movement that was having
some success with alcoholics), and medicine.

Bill did hang on to it, stayed sober, and zealously went to
work on other alcoholics, with no success at first. Dr.
Silkworth straightened him out once again. “Stop preaching
at them,” he said, “and give them the hard medical facts
first. This may soften them up at depth so they will be willing
to do anything to get well. Then they may accept those spiritual ideas of yours, and even a Higher Power.”

Note: Right here we see that "higher power" is meant in a religious sense.

Borrowing from Dr. Silkworth, as he so often did, Bill
described A.A. “as a synthetic concept—a synthetic gadget,
as it were, drawing upon the resources of medicine, psychiatry,
religion amid our own experience of drinking and recovery.
You will search in vain for a single new fundamental.
We have merely streamlined old and proved principles of psychiatry and religion into such forms that the alcoholic will accept them.”

Bill underscored the roles of both medicine and religion in the A.A. program—pointing out, however, that “in one
respect they do differ. Medicine says, ‘Know yourself, be
strong, and you will be able to face life.’ Religion says,
‘Know thyself, ask God for power, and you become truly
free.’” In A.A., Bill said, newcomers may try either method
and stay sober, but added: “If, however, the spiritual
content of the Twelve Steps is actively denied, they can
seldom stay dry.”

Note: It is clear here that Bill is using religion and spirituality to mean the same thing.

Bob M., past trustee, East Central Region, 2005-2009:
While serving as trustee for the last four years, I depended on many of you to give me guidance and support. And that’s the way A.A. is—if you keep looking for help, you will find it. I was on the trustees nominating committee when the chair of the board was being selected. I quoted the following paragraph from A.A. Comes of Age and asked each nominee what they thought of it.

It was taken from Bernard Smith’s talk on page 274, “The Individual, A.A., and Society:

“And I thought of the finger of God determining our course--as individuals,
as a fellowship, and in our relation to the world about us. Clearly, I thought,
the Twelve Steps of A.A. must have been spiritually conceived to meet a
serious and growing challenge to all of us, nonalcoholic as well as alcoholic.
What is that challenge? It is the challenge to a generation that would deny
the spiritual basis for human existence and accept in its place a currently
socially accepted basis that is mechanistic and materialistic. It is a
challenge to which A.A. will never yield, for the tenet of its faith and, indeed, its existence is founded on the certainty of a spiritual basis for life on earth.”

I am reminded of what the Big Book says, not just that we be of service, but that we be of maximum service to God and our fellows.

The Twelve Steps, I believe, are a gift and divinely inspired.

But this is my favourite

Ward Ewing, Class A (nonalcoholic) General Service Board chair:
I believe it is essential that A.A. maintain this distinction as part of the way we live our Third Tradition: The only requirement for A.A. membership is a desire to stop drinking. That is the only acceptable definition of who is in and who is out. And we must be careful that overly religious language might exclude some.

Those are just a few of the many religious references I found in only two articles published on the AA website. Your claims that AA is not religious are laughable.
 
The man who does not understand what he reads in books has no advantage over the man who can't read them.
 
Again, not one of the meetings I've attended would I characterize as a religious service (barring the universal recitation of the Lord's Prayer at the end).
snip



snip
"United States courts have ruled that inmates, parolees, and probationers cannot be ordered to attend AA. Though AA itself was not deemed a religion, it was ruled that it contained enough religious components to make coerced attendance at AA meetings a violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment of the constitution. In September 2007, United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit stated that a parole office can be sued for ordering a parolee to attend AA."
Thanks for that post Norseman. Very informative. I hadn't even thought to look at wiki.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom