Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is this some type of game to you, alfie? Do you think you can say absolutely any unproven thing and people here will fall all over themselves to congratulate you?

Perhaps you can show me where Jesus Christ is worshipped, even just mentioned in the official literature you place such weight on would be good.

It seems to me that if Christ isn't mentioned, it isn't Christianity.

The meetings in Australia might be different than they are here in the US?

Yep, I've said that over and over.

If alfie would only admit that...admit that since he is in Australia, he doesn't know anything about how AA meetings are "run" in the US...then it would be easier to respect his opinion...

As it stands, alfie only makes AA look "bad" by denying it's basic underlying ideal. Belief that God can help you quit drinking.

No, what is said is:
- a power greater than ourselves can restore us to sanity.
- the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking
- the steps are "suggested as a tool for recovery"

Take what you need and leave the rest.
I have also stated time and again that AA was born in the spirit of religion and has evolved over time - differently from place to place. Whilst certain groups may be inherently religious in nature, that does not mean they are all over nor that AA itself is.

In over two decades of extremely sporadic (until recently) attendance in the US (in various cities, places, etc.) I can't remember anyone ever talk about Jesus Christ at an AA meeting either.

I wonder if they will believe you Norseman?

Alfie has admitted that he doesn't know how meetings are run in the US, many times in this thread.

So I have RAFs respect now?
 
Last edited:
And you have neither corrected me nor shown me wrong.

That's fine, though.

Of course, assuming you're right, we never have any amount of control over our decisions and therefore any human enterprise is worthless, right ?

No matter what neuroscience says, it's simply more productive to continue to act as though we make our choices consciously. For all intents and purposes, it IS the case anyway.

Perhaps you could clarify exactly what you meant by "along for the ride".
 
Probably been posted before but here it is again:

http://www.morerevealed.com/library/coc/chapter1.htm

One lower-court case is illustrative; as the court stated in a 1984 Wisconsin ruling (Grandberg V. Ashland County):

"Alcoholics Anonymous materials . . . and the testimony of the witness established beyond a doubt that religious activities, as defined in constitutional law, were a part of the treatment program. The distinction between religion and spirituality is meaningless, and serves merely to confuse the issue."
 
One lower-court case is illustrative; as the court stated in a 1984 Wisconsin ruling (Grandberg V. Ashland County):

"Alcoholics Anonymous materials . . . and the testimony of the witness established beyond a doubt that religious activities, as defined in constitutional law, were a part of the treatment program. The distinction between religion and spirituality is meaningless, and serves merely to confuse the issue."
Based on that, atheists can't be tried in the existing Court system either, since 'religious activities' are involved there too.

Perhaps they are outside of Laws as well; those darn Legislatures and their 'religious activities'.

Where is Newdow when you need him?
 
Based on that, atheists can't be tried in the existing Court system either, since 'religious activities' are involved there too.

Perhaps they are outside of Laws as well; those darn Legislatures and their 'religious activities'.

Where is Newdow when you need him?

I think you forgot to run a coherence check on your post.
 
Continued Derail:

The Preamble is important, yes, but irrelevant when all that applies is the First Amendment in these matters which is not mere exposition (the Preamble) but actual binding law.

And further, no one that I can tell is trying to take over the role of Creator; just when there's no sign of any sort of Creator, someone has to step in and help keep societies cohesive. :rolleyes:

I agree, The preamble is part of great document, it is however NOT CotUS.
 
Continued Derail:

The Preamble is important, yes, but irrelevant when all that applies is the First Amendment in these matters which is not mere exposition (the Preamble) but actual binding law.

The thing AlBell quoted (the "all men are created equal" etc.) is not the Preamble to the Constitution. It's from the Declaration of Independence. (Which is not binding in any sense.)
 
The thing AlBell quoted (the "all men are created equal" etc.) is not the Preamble to the Constitution. It's from the Declaration of Independence. (Which is not binding in any sense.)

Preamble
We the people of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.


Oops, yes you're right. I honestly should have known better!
 
No matter what neuroscience says, it's simply more productive to continue to act as though we make our choices consciously.
There it is: The practical/intuitive perspective. We consciously choose our actions, but have little control over our feelings and (I for one would argue) our beliefs.
 
I rather believe the 'separation of church and state' concept has been forced into a position where it can now open its' eyes and examine its' molars.

/derail full on
I see some in the US doing their damndest to ignore:

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”,

and prodding Courts, Executive, Legislature, and the squeekiest wheels/better lawyers to take over the role of Creator. I don't think they're up to playing that part.

I think you just showed us your Theistic hand. Not that there's anything wrong with that ;) . But it puzzles me that a Theist would deny that AA is Religious. :confused: :rolleyes:.

GB
 
Probably been posted before but here it is again
Yes, it probably has. In fact, the internet meme you are propagating here appears to have gained quite a bit of traction. Whatever its original source may be, it does not appear to be the transcript of the actual court case to which it refers, available here.

If the Honorable Judge Shabaz made the statement attributed to him, I sure can't find it -- but just for the sake of argument, let's say that instead of (or in addition to) saying things like "It should be noted at the outset that Granberg's complaint leaves much to be desired", Judge Shabaz (or some judge somewhere) really did say:
"The distinction between religion and spirituality is meaningless, and serves merely to confuse the issue."
(or something very much like it).

This is the crux of the disagreement here. Why do people insist that AA is not religious? Because they DO see a meaningful distinction between "religious" and "spiritual".

As part of the fun here at JREF, we often tackle difficult or even impossible problems in philosophy, theology, ethics, etc. If we fail to definitively resolve these questions here, the consequences are minimal. Society, however, often finds itself forced to make certain determinations (such as whether corporations -- or six week old fetuses -- ought to be regarded as persons) regardless of whether all basis for controversy has been laid aside.

In this context, the citing of court rulings is an argument from authority -- and as such, is a conflation of two separate senses of that word. Judges have legal authority; i.e., power. They may or may not have expertise in the matters upon which they are called to rule.
 
There it is: The practical/intuitive perspective. We consciously choose our actions, but have little control over our feelings and (I for one would argue) our beliefs.

Emotions, sure. Little control (but some). But beliefs ? Nah, I've changed my beliefs many times in the past because of evidence.
 
Yes, it probably has. In fact, the internet meme you are propagating here appears to have gained quite a bit of traction. Whatever its original source may be, it does not appear to be the transcript of the actual court case to which it refers, available here.

That isn't the trial transcript. Those are motions within the trial.

This is the crux of the disagreement here. Why do people insist that AA is not religious? Because they DO see a meaningful distinction between "religious" and "spiritual".

But that doesn't mean there is one. In the sense that AA uses it, and people have used it in this thread, there is no distinction.

In this context, the citing of court rulings is an argument from authority -- and as such, is a conflation of two separate senses of that word. Judges have legal authority; i.e., power. They may or may not have expertise in the matters upon which they are called to rule.

It isn't an argument from authority because the argument was cited so anyone can go and look it up if they so desire. It has never been stated that the argument was right because the judge said it. It was stated that the judge was right because his argument was sound.
 
Emotions, sure. Little control (but some). But beliefs ? Nah, I've changed my beliefs many times in the past because of evidence.
Ilustrates my point. You didn't decide to change your beliefs; the evidence decided for you. Another way of saying it is that the reasoning abilities you possess, acting upon the available evidence, informed you that the beliefs had changed. "YOU" had very little say in the matter.
 
That isn't the trial transcript. Those are motions within the trial.
It's all I could find. I submit that the quote was fabricated.

But that doesn't mean there is one. In the sense that AA uses it, and people have used it in this thread, there is no distinction.
A great deal of what you claim is based on what you presume to be going on in the minds of others, but if you've demonstrated nothing else here, it is that your mindreading abilities are abysmal.

Much earlier, I suggested the Wiki article on "spirituality" as a source containing a number of ways in which that word may be used that do not involve any supernatural claims, such as a "sense of connectedness", or a development of "the deepest values and meanings by which people live". One statement, verbatim, is: "At one end of the spectrum, even some atheists are spiritual." (And I will pre-empt your anticipated objection by noting that where the requirement simply is "various ways in which people use a particular word", quoting Wikipedia as a source is valid, as the mere appearance of examples there proves the point).

Tell me why you disagree with any of this, or, alternatively, how you can support a claim that none of this is the sort of thing AA members are referring to as "SBNR":

"Those who speak of spirituality outside of religion often define themselves as SBNR or "spiritual but not religious" and generally believe in the existence of many different "spiritual paths" - emphasizing the importance of finding one's own individual path to spirituality. According to one poll, some 24±4% of the United States population identifies itself as spiritual but not religious.[18] One might say then, that a key difference is that religion is a type of formal external search, while spirituality is defined as a search within oneself."


It isn't an argument from authority because the argument was cited so anyone can go and look it up if they so desire.
Yeah right. Just for a hoot, I tried to do just that, and couldn't find anything but a meme being widely repeated on the internet (mostly AA-bashing sites like orange-papers.org). Since you're the one presenting it as evidence, let's see YOU look it up at the source.

It has never been stated that the argument was right because the judge said it. It was stated that the judge was right because his argument was sound.
I see those as inferences, and of course that is precisely what I'm questioning. If those statements were made directly, I must have missed them. Mind pointing back to where they appear?
 
Same reason they try to make it appear as though science/evolution/atheism is a religion as much as theirs: equivocation.
Or that any theist -- or x-theist -- might actually know what 'religious' is, and notice they don't find it in AA meetings?

Others think atheists who read books and hit-piece screeds are a better judges.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom