Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
So let me get this straight: I said that the unconscious mind and your body can't be considered to be higher powers
Which (given the context of this discussion) I take to mean: Because I can't consider "the unconscious mind" to be a higher power, no one else can either, and anyone who says otherwise is lying.

...and that if anything can be a higher power the term becomes meaningless... and you think it means that nothing can be a higher power.
Which I take to mean: "Nothing can be a higher power in any meaningful sense".

If neither of those is a fair representation of your position, then we have identified the source of my confusion, so I'll repeat my request that you go ahead and clarify what you did mean.


Apples can be easily defined, too.
I don't see how that's a refutation of the point I was making, which appears to have escaped you: the ability to define a thing does not constitute evidence that the thing exists. Angels, demons, dragons, leprechauns, unicorns, martians, zombies, immortal souls... "The sum of things we already know exist" sounds like gibberish to me, but even if it did constitute a coherent definition of "self", I don't see it as a valid basis for excluding "selves" from that list.
 
Since I started this thread, I have something else to add--I don't know if this will derail the thread or contribute to it.

My husband's therapist, a specialist in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, recommended that my husband have his head checked at the hospital.

A CAT and an MRI confirmed a large mass growing on the frontal cortex.

He's going in for biopsy.

This, this is why I chose science over superstition. If he was still attending AA meetings as a "treatment" for his behavior, i doubt very sincerely he would have had gone to the hospital and had his head checked.

At this current point in time, I probably will not be posting any longer. But I just wanted to get that out.

Thank you to everyone who has contributed to this thread.

I am sorry, may you and yours find comfort and health.
 
Based the remainder of your post, and as it relates to AA and god-as-you-understand him, I'm not sure our understanding is the same.

The program itself says our understanding doesn't have to be the same.
"God as you understand him" or "higher power as you come to understand it" can be anything, right? And I see that as the problem. A form of power higher than your own...well, if it's not your own power, and it's higher than your own power, then it's not human. It's what we commonly think of as a god.

What you say below isn't anything like a "higher power." It's your own power, and you acknowledge that. Calling some process your brain may do while you sleep on a problem a higher power just doesn't make any sense to me. It's just you. It's only ever you. And you aren't giving yourself the credit you deserve when you disassociate like that.


We do agree with that. :)

All right.

You would need to clarify [I know part of my problem with that is how my ex would throw it at me when he'd have a slip. "But I'm powerless over alcohol!" Yeah, and isn't that handy for you?] with your comment below "My ex-husband was 20 years sober."

He went 20 years without drinking, and then is back at it? Or he slipped (numerous times?) and wasn't '20 years sober'?

Although the answer really isn't important to me. Drunks are drunks.

If it isn't important to you, Al, then why would I need to clarify?

But I shall clarify this much: I have a bias and I know it. My ex used the program, and the "only a higher power could restore us to sanity," to excuse his behavior without having to take personal responsibility for it. Not everyone in the program does this, but having seen it used this way, I know it's possible, and I feel the program actually allows for it.

To say that only a higher power can restore you to sanity is to say that something outside of you, not part of you, some mystical "other" force, is what will get your life back on track. Back then, I believed that could happen. Now I know it's sheerest woo. There is no higher power, no outside force. There is only you, with supporting help from other people.


Ever hear of "God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and wisdom to know the difference"?

It's nearly impossible to be around the program and not hear of the Serenity Prayer. But what of it? There is no god to grant anyone anything. It's just more of the same disassociation. I'd find the "prayer" of more use if the person saying it credited him- or herself, instead of some imaginary being:

"I know there are things I cannot change, and I must be at peace with that. And I know there are things I can change, and I must find the courage to do so. But above all, I must use critical thinking to discover the difference."

What's wrong with that? Why does one need to accept some kind of woo in order to get better? I am the master of my fate. I need to accept that I have a big problem, and I need to realize that I am the only one (with support from other humans) who can possibly do anything about it.
I am not powerless over alcohol--indeed, my power is the only power that can get me through this. I know I might fail. But at least if I do fail, I know I have the power to get back on that horse, as it were. I can't say "I can't help it." I can't say my "higher power" failed. I'm the only one who can help it, and I owe it to myself to keep trying.

I certainly hope no one in AA or Alanon ever suggested your approach would be helpful.

They didn't suggest it wouldn't be helpful. They didn't tell me what to call my higher power, and that we both chose to think of god as our higher power wasn't seen as a problem. How could it be? "God as we understand him" is still god, isn't it?

But if god is your higher power, and if only your higher power can "restore you to sanity," then it seems a given that a religious person would indeed be expecting his god to restore the alcoholic to a more sane way of living. And that's the problem. That's how AA can be a religious program. This higher power bunkum isn't needed.

I watched my alcoholic twist the program to allow him to divorce himself from his own responsibility. "I can't help it, I'm powerless," and "My higher power is the only thing that can restore me to sanity," were commonly heard in our home.

As a religious person, I couldn't figure out what god was waiting for, why the alcoholism-spurred abuse kept continuing, or why god wasn't returning him to sanity no matter how hard either of us prayed.

Now, of course, I know it's because talking to your ceiling or to the sky won't get you anything. My ex's attitude was, essentially, "If I'm not getting any better, not making any headway, it's not my fault. It's god's." This did not enable him to take responsibility for his actions. It instead enabled him to make "someone" other than himself responsible. To me, that's a flaw in the program. If the program had made him responsible, had not let him get away with that twisting, who knows what might have been different?


Congratulations. You did get wisdom, and courage to change something that was within your power to change, you (and your situation).

I didn't call it wisdom back then. I called it open rebellion against god. I had to go against everything I was taught God expected of me, and destroy my family once and for all. I had to decide that my will was more important than the unknowable will of god. I had to take matters out of god's ineffectual hands and put them in my own.

This was very difficult for me to do. I only managed it when my own children begged me to leave their father and, in their words, "find someone to really love you, Mom." They were 11 and 12 when they said this to me. All I could think was "if your own children know this farce of a marriage is over, then what the hell are you waiting for?" So, I left. As I've said, I felt horribly rebellious against god, but that just made me angry. If god knows all, he knew this was coming. He could have done something, but he did nothing. Therefore, screw god. I got this.

It would be another 10 years before I'd let go of the idea of god entirely. But this is when it began.


Something did seem to 'answer prayers' for me; I suspect it's the part of me that answered the algebra question after I slept on it, and keeps pushing thoughts out that the conscious 'me' can ignore, or select for more directed thought or action. I choose to call that my 'higher power'.

This is the part to which I referred above. How is that a "higher power?" That's just you. It makes little sense to say your own power is higher than your own power. It's strange to pray to yourself. Of course, you can choose to call it whatever you like, but by the same token, I can choose to disagree with your interpretation.


You've heard the old saw "Man takes the 1st drink, 1st drink takes the 2nd, 2nd takes the 3rd, and 3rd drink takes the man."? For me, and any other alcoholic I know of, it's "Man takes the 1st drink, 1st drink takes the man".

And the only power over alcohol I have is 'don't take the 1st drink'. After one, I had no clue what happens next (and still wouldn't have).

That's right. The only power over alcohol you have is your own power, and sometimes, you may let yourself down and take a drink. Then you'll have to climb back up to where you were before you slipped. But it will all be you doing it or not doing it.

Alcoholism is one of the harder things to deal with in life. There's nothing easy or simple about it. It's a lifelong struggle, and anyone who can manage any success with it is deserving of immense respect. I do not disrespect my ex for his slip. Even though I can't stand the man, I highly respect him for the 20 years he went (that I know of) without drinking. But now that he has slipped, I hope he's at last gotten to the point where he knows it's just him, and not some imaginary sky-daddy, who has anything like control over this situation.

I hope he's not once again saying, "I'm powerless, it's not my fault." But I'll probably never know.
 
Last edited:
Calling some process your brain may do while you sleep on a problem a higher power just doesn't make any sense to me. It's just you. It's only ever you. And you aren't giving yourself the credit you deserve when you disassociate like that.
I wonder: How much credit do *I* deserve for digesting a tuna sandwich? For being able to catch a thrown object? For correctly interpreting a facial expression? For having learned the English language? For remembering the name of an actor?

That last one is an interesting example, and one I find pertinent here. It's exactly the sort of problem *I* often find difficult to solve through conscious effort. But if I quit trying, and turn the task over to some congnitive submodule(s), what very often happens is that the answer just pops into my head later on, as if it had arrived from some external source, and at a time when it was the furthest thing from my mind.

I inherited the above abilities (or the capacity for developing those abilities) from my parents, and my grandparents, and my great-grandparents going back countless generations. Saying that *I* am the underlying processes (or that those processes are *me*) seems to be adding an unnecessary layer. It doesn't explain anything. Might as well just say that the processes are themselves.

To be fair, the alternative of regarding the 'self' as sort of like the driver of a car -- which comes factory equipped with a bunch of features like headlights, a radar detector, and a steering wheel, all for use at the driver's discretion (once he becomes sufficiently familiar with their proper operation, of course) -- is to invoke a homunculus, which encounters the same defect. But it's worth repeating the reminder that AA's primary purpose is not to solve difficult philosophical riddles; nor is it to invent a new breakthrough theory in the field of cognitive science.

Individual recovery does not require these, either. If an individual finds it useful to regard alcoholism as a "disease", and to go a step further and anthropomorphise that as something like an evil twin that lives inside his brain, and to speak of various subtle ways in which that metaphorical personage tries to trick him into feeding it -- telling him things like "you can't live without me", and "remember all the good times we had", and "just this once for old time's sake" -- then as a theoretical model of what's actually going on inside his brain, that may be no more accurate than a stone-age meme regarding evil spirits that dwell in the vicinity of a particular water hole; but if it keeps him from drinking something that would be poisonous (at least to him), then it is functionally equivalent.

Similarly, if regarding some aspect of his "inner self" or "higher self" as a power greater than himself is an idea that feels right to a particular individual, and if adopting that stance is useful to him as a tool for recovery, then it really doesn't matter if it makes sense to someone else or not (or whether it fits with their interpretation of something written in a particular book, or whatever). The goal of a ritual like the Serenity Prayer is to achieve a change in one's inner states. Evolution may have had good reasons for not equipping humans with the ability to exercise complete control over their own inner states, probably because if it had, we'd all starve to death with big, stupid, orgasmic grins on our faces. Substance abuse may be viewed as an attempt to defeat this protective feature so as to achieve desireable inner states without doing the necessary work involved in earning them. AA's steps are a path to re-learning how to do it the old fashioned way.
 
Nicely said, dymanic. :)

It's a funny old world. One person credits AA and a higher power with saving his marriage, career, and life. Someone else credits AA and god-who-isn't-there as being the problem.

ps. Slingblade, I still haven't figured out if you and the drunk were together the 20 years he didn't drink, or if that 20 was all after the separation. Again, irrelevant; the answer would just provide for a better interpretation of your story.

At any rate I wish you a happy life, and salute your courage for sharing.
 
Individual recovery does not require these, either. If an individual finds it useful to regard alcoholism as a "disease", and to go a step further and anthropomorphise that as something like an evil twin that lives inside his brain, and to speak of various subtle ways in which that metaphorical personage tries to trick him into feeding it -- telling him things like "you can't live without me", and "remember all the good times we had", and "just this once for old time's sake" -- then as a theoretical model of what's actually going on inside his brain, that may be no more accurate than a stone-age meme regarding evil spirits that dwell in the vicinity of a particular water hole; but if it keeps him from drinking something that would be poisonous (at least to him), then it is functionally equivalent.
This is commonly called a committee meeting inside my head that I am not invited to.
 
Which (given the context of this discussion) I take to mean: Because I can't consider "the unconscious mind" to be a higher power, no one else can either, and anyone who says otherwise is lying.

Wow. Lying, eh ? Nobody can be simply wrong ? That is one beautiful false dichotomy you've got there.

Since the unconscious mind is part of the person who is trying to find a higher power, it's a little silly to pick it. It's like saying "my arm is my higher power". How can something which is a component of YOU be a higher power than YOU ?

Which I take to mean: "Nothing can be a higher power in any meaningful sense".

Then you have a serious problem with the English language; or you have an obsession with over-extrapolating from what people say. No wonder you think anything can be a higher power. You don't grasp the meaning of words.

Tell you what... why don't you limit yourself to what I actually say instead of trying to determine what you think I _should_ have said ?

"The sum of things we already know exist" sounds like gibberish to me

Well, that's just too bad.
 
Wow. Lying, eh ? Nobody can be simply wrong ?
We're talking about a person reporting an internal state. If a person claims to obtain comfort from praying to a doorknob, there may be any number of possible reasons why they might be lying -- but no, I can't see how they could be simply wrong. If it's even possible to be wrong about that, it surely can't be a simple matter.

Since the unconscious mind is part of the person who is trying to find a higher power, it's a little silly to pick it.
I would have no problem with that if you had phrased it this way: "Since I consider my unconscious mind to be part of myself, I would consider it silly to pick it" -- but instead of that, you are presuming to make a broadly applicable claim here, one based on sparse and dubious evidence. It's not just that I find that so incredibly arrogant and self-centered on your part; it's that you do such a poor job of it. You first began by flatly stating that "YOU are the sum of things that are your body", later changing that to "The sum of things we already know exist". I tried to warn you about this being a quagmire, remember? Now you're thrashing around in water that's way over your head. Why don't you just bite the bullet and admit that you can't define "self" in any robust and logically defensible way?

Tell you what... why don't you limit yourself to what I actually say instead of trying to determine what you think I _should_ have said ?
Uh huh. And if what you say happens to be gibberish, that's just too bad.

You know, Belz, something that happens quite often around here is that a person comes forward presenting ideas which appear not to be very well thought out, and among the standard methods of examining and testing such claims is to extrapolate on them. It also quite often happens that a claimant having trouble defending his ideas will cry "Strawman!" at every turn, waving it like some magic talisman that renders his claims immune to challenge (those challenges that cannot be deflected as "irrelevant", that is).

If having your ideas examined and tested makes you uncomfortable, then participating in discussions on this forum is an activity you may not always find very enjoyable.
 
Wow. Lying, eh ? Nobody can be simply wrong ? That is one beautiful false dichotomy you've got there.

Since the unconscious mind is part of the person who is trying to find a higher power, it's a little silly to pick it. It's like saying "my arm is my higher power". How can something which is a component of YOU be a higher power than YOU ?

Remember, you are asking this of a person who thinks a door knob is a higher power? :D

These are the same people who claim to believe this crap and at the same time, be agnostic or atheist. Does it make sense that they say "I'm not sure there is a god but, boy, that door knob really has some magic powers?"

Well, to them it does! :D
 
Remember, you are asking this of a person who thinks a door knob is a higher power?
Actually, the hypothetical to which Belz was responding was: a person who considers "the unconscious mind" to be a higher power. If you had a genuine interest in any of this, then instead of being in such a hurry to get in these cute quick little jabs, maybe you'd be motivated to take enough time to enable you to at least follow the track of the discussion.

As it is, you appear to be having enough trouble tracking your own logic:
These are the same people who claim to believe this crap and at the same time, be agnostic or atheist. Does it make sense that they say "I'm not sure there is a god but, boy, that door knob really has some magic powers?"

Well, to them it does!
Your choice of words there, claim to believe implies false reporting, but you then turn right around and say that to them, it really does make sense -- which contradicts that.

Keep coming back, qayak; we'll make a critical thinker out of you yet.
 
Hey Dymanic, how about starting a new thread on this topic? It perhaps would be worth pursuing but not here.

I am not the OP, she has left the building (as it were) but I would think that the topic should still be directly addressed.

I only mention this not because of a slight derail but in my perception, it has grown substantially beyond that.
 
Hey Dymanic, how about starting a new thread on this topic? It perhaps would be worth pursuing but not here.

I am not the OP, she has left the building (as it were) but I would think that the topic should still be directly addressed.

I only mention this not because of a slight derail but in my perception, it has grown substantially beyond that.
Since very early in the thread, the question as to whether anything non-supernatural may legitimately be regarded as a "higher power" -- "a power greater than a self" -- has been a keystone of the "AA is religious" argument. And, since that point was first raised, I have challenged it as necessarily resting upon the ability to define "self". My main thrust has been that solving this ancient puzzle is not necessary either for AA's purposes as a whole or for those of an individual member attempting to follow AA's recommended path; that for those purposes it is sufficient to accept the intuitive default (which essentially reduces to some form of Cartesian dualism). My position is and has been that in this context, the question isn't whether it's right so much as whether it works; whether it feels right. For some of the posters in this thread, that is apparently not good enough, because they keep sending the same stupid zombie back into the fray, muttering, in one form or another: "it doesn't make sense unless it makes sense to meeeee"....

I don't disagree that questions about the self are interesting in their own right. Worth pursuing I'm not so sure about. I described it initially as a "quagmire", and expressed reluctance to go romping through it, because I've been there, done that (got the T-shirt, lost several pairs of boots). I said I would follow, but not lead. So if it's a derail, it's not MY derail. It's been a while since I've seen anything on the subject that I haven't seen before, but I'm always on the lookout for new ideas, so if any of the posters in this thread would like to test out their thoughts on this disconnected from the emotionally-charged question of AA's religiousity, I would encourage them (the ones not already there) to see how well those ideas fly in the current incarnation of what must be one of the longest-running controversies in JREF history, a thread already ongoing on what is (in my opinion) essentially the same question:
Has consciousness been fully explained?

(Shouldn't take too long to get up to speed; it's only a measly 20 pages long).
 
Actually, the hypothetical to which Belz was responding was: a person who considers "the unconscious mind" to be a higher power. If you had a genuine interest in any of this, then instead of being in such a hurry to get in these cute quick little jabs, maybe you'd be motivated to take enough time to enable you to at least follow the track of the discussion.

The person who cannot follow the logic stares back at you from the mirror.

Belz was wondering why you couldn't understand that the unconscious mind couldn't be a higher power. I just made the point that it isn't surprising that people who think a door knob is a higher power would also think the unconscious mind is one as well.

As it is, you appear to be having enough trouble tracking your own logic:Your choice of words there, claim to believe implies false reporting, but you then turn right around and say that to them, it really does make sense -- which contradicts that.

"Claim to believe" is exactly that, a claim of belief by someone else. As for the contradiction, it is only in your mind, just like your god and AA's higher power are only in your mind.

Keep coming back, qayak; we'll make a critical thinker out of you yet.

Once again you are looking to semantics and sophistry for support of your argument. By example you have shown that you haven't the faintest idea of what critical thinking is. Real critical thinkers have seen through your ploys and errors this entire thread and continue to post in hopes that you will eventually catch on. I don't hold out hope for you
 
We're talking about a person reporting an internal state. If a person claims to obtain comfort from praying to a doorknob, there may be any number of possible reasons why they might be lying -- but no, I can't see how they could be simply wrong. If it's even possible to be wrong about that, it surely can't be a simple matter.

Now you're moving the goalposts. We're talking about considering something to be a higher power, not whether that makes it comforting.

I would have no problem with that if you had phrased it this way: "Since I consider my unconscious mind to be part of myself, I would consider it silly to pick it" -- but instead of that, you are presuming to make a broadly applicable claim here, one based on sparse and dubious evidence.

What ??? Are you seriously contending that the unconscious is NOT part of "you" ? Okay, then. I'll need your definition of "you", now, because it seems quite apart from mine.

You first began by flatly stating that "YOU are the sum of things that are your body", later changing that to "The sum of things we already know exist".

No, you're confusing two things again. :rolleyes:

I tried to warn you about this being a quagmire, remember? Now you're thrashing around in water that's way over your head. Why don't you just bite the bullet and admit that you can't define "self" in any robust and logically defensible way?

Oh, I've already defined it quite easily.

Uh huh. And if what you say happens to be gibberish, that's just too bad.

You mean your ego doesn't allow you to ask for clarification ?

If having your ideas examined and tested makes you uncomfortable, then participating in discussions on this forum is an activity you may not always find very enjoyable.

I very much enjoy my ideas examined. Having them hand-waved, however, is another matter entirely.
 
Let me put it this way:

The unconscious mind is, traditionally and I'd guess scientifically, considered to be part of the "mind" which, in turn, is part of what we consider to be a human being (you or otherwise). Assuming we accept this definition, how can one consider a part of something to be greater than the whole of that something ? Can a car's engine be greater than the car itself ? Doesn't seem to make sense to me.

What qualifies as higher powers depends on the definition of "higher power" we use. In the broadest possible sense, a higher power could be anything with capabilities beyond that of the individual using it as a higher power. This could include another person, a group of people, laws of physics, volcanoes, ideas, concepts and principles, etc. This would work in the context of AA only if those higher powers are something you can interact with (considering the praying aspect). Since you can't really interact with the laws of physics and volcanoes in a meaningful way, that leaves people and principles.

But that's assuming that we're using the broader definition. The more narrow definition is clear: a supernatural being. Forgetting single-case testimonies for a moment, it's clear from the original AA litterature that the Christian God was the higher power; and I'd venture to guess that most AA members would agree that "higher power" refers to supernatural entities of some sort. If my guess is correct (and in North America it certainly seems like it is) then we have to assume that "higher power" means exactly that. We know (tentatively) that there are no such things as supernatural beigns, but that's irrelevant.

Unfortunately that means that, by definition, AA is religious, although not a religion. The only two assumptions are the definition of "human" and the proportion of people in AA who see higher powers as deities -- neither of which seems problematic to me. That should put the thread to rest, but I know it won't.
 
Last edited:
Just checking in to see if Dymanic or Al had posted any relevant information or evidence for their case yet.

Nope...apparently not.

GB
 
Belz was wondering why you couldn't understand that the unconscious mind couldn't be a higher power. I just made the point that it isn't surprising that people who think a door knob is a higher power would also think the unconscious mind is one as well.

sigh..
I thought the doorknob thing had been put to bed.

Q. Can you show me anyone who thinks a doorknob is their higher power? The answer quite obviously is "No".

As has been repeatedly poiinted out, a higher power is usually one of the following:
- a traditional deity or combination
- nature and the universe (and the laws therein).
- the fellowship of AA and its membership
- a philosophy or 'new' way of living.

That is not to say other things do not qualify.
For some it is all of these things or some (eg, the last three).
 
Are you seriously contending that the unconscious is NOT part of "you" ? Okay, then. I'll need your definition of "you", now, because it seems quite apart from mine.
I've already expressed my willingness to take the position that it cannot be definitively (empirically, logically, scientifically) demonstrated that any such thing as a "self" exists at all.

No, you're confusing two things again.
I'm comparing two very different (and contradictory) definitions for self, provided by YOU on two separate occasions -- and yes, I am confused, about which of them (if either) you're going to stick with

Oh, I've already defined it quite easily.
Vacuous definitions do have the advantage of being easy. Feel free to continue to make it easy on yourself. I wouldn't want to make you work or anything.

You mean your ego doesn't allow you to ask for clarification ?
You mean like I did here?:
I'm certainly not interested in wasting time countering arguments you're not actually making. Perhaps you can help me identify the point at which I became confused about that by revisiting the following posts:
And here?:
If neither of those is a fair representation of your position, then we have identified the source of my confusion, so I'll repeat my request that you go ahead and clarify what you did mean.
Evidently not.


The unconscious mind is, traditionally and I'd guess scientifically, considered to be part of the "mind" which, in turn, is part of what we consider to be a human being (you or otherwise). Assuming we accept this definition, how can one consider a part of something to be greater than the whole of that something ?
I submit that the intuitive default is that the "conscious self" has an existence separate from the "unconscious", by definition. What is at issue here is not whether the intuitive default represents the most accurate view of the self; it's whether adopting that stance might work for an individual chosing to make his appeals to an "inner self", or "higher self" representing his version of the concept, "higher power".

Doesn't seem to make sense to me.
"Doesn't make sense to meeeee..."

What qualifies as higher powers depends on the definition of "higher power" we use.
Ya think?

In the broadest possible sense, a higher power could be anything with capabilities beyond that of the individual using it as a higher power. This could include another person, a group of people, laws of physics, volcanoes, ideas, concepts and principles, etc. This would work in the context of AA only if those higher powers are something you can interact with (considering the praying aspect).
Would you say that Nolan 'interacted' with Wilson?

If my guess is correct (and in North America it certainly seems like it is) then we have to assume that "higher power" means exactly that.
And if your guess is NOT correct?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom