Based the remainder of your post, and as it relates to AA and god-as-you-understand him, I'm not sure our understanding is the same.
The program itself says our understanding doesn't have to be the same.
"God as you understand him" or "higher power as you come to understand it" can be anything, right? And I see that as the problem. A form of power higher than your own...well, if it's not your own power, and it's higher than your own power, then it's not human. It's what we commonly think of as a god.
What you say below isn't anything like a "higher power." It's
your own power, and you acknowledge that. Calling some process your brain may do while you sleep on a problem a higher power just doesn't make any sense to me. It's just you. It's only ever you. And you aren't giving yourself the credit you deserve when you disassociate like that.
We do agree with that.
All right.
You would need to clarify [I know part of my problem with that is how my ex would throw it at me when he'd have a slip. "But I'm powerless over alcohol!" Yeah, and isn't that handy for you?] with your comment below "My ex-husband was 20 years sober."
He went 20 years without drinking, and then is back at it? Or he slipped (numerous times?) and wasn't '20 years sober'?
Although the answer really isn't important to me. Drunks are drunks.
If it isn't important to you, Al, then why would I
need to clarify?
But I shall clarify this much: I have a bias and I know it. My ex used the program, and the "only a higher power could restore us to sanity," to excuse his behavior without having to take personal responsibility for it. Not everyone in the program does this, but having seen it used this way, I know it's possible, and I feel the program actually allows for it.
To say that only a higher power can restore you to sanity is to say that something outside of you, not part of you, some mystical "other" force, is what will get your life back on track. Back then, I believed that could happen. Now I know it's sheerest woo. There is no higher power, no outside force. There is only you, with supporting help from other people.
Ever hear of "God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and wisdom to know the difference"?
It's nearly impossible to be around the program and
not hear of the Serenity Prayer. But what of it? There is no god to grant anyone anything. It's just more of the same disassociation. I'd find the "prayer" of more use if the person saying it credited him- or herself, instead of some imaginary being:
"I know there are things I cannot change, and I must be at peace with that. And I know there are things I can change, and I must find the courage to do so. But above all, I must use critical thinking to discover the difference."
What's wrong with that? Why does one need to accept some kind of woo in order to get better? I am the master of my fate. I need to accept that I have a big problem, and I need to realize that I am the only one (with support from other humans) who can possibly do anything about it.
I am not powerless over alcohol--indeed, my power is the only power that
can get me through this. I know I might fail. But at least if I do fail, I know I have the power to get back on that horse, as it were. I can't say "I can't help it." I can't say my "higher power" failed. I'm the only one who can help it, and I owe it to myself to keep trying.
I certainly hope no one in AA or Alanon ever suggested your approach would be helpful.
They didn't suggest it
wouldn't be helpful. They didn't tell me what to call my higher power, and that we both chose to think of god as our higher power wasn't seen as a problem. How could it be? "God as we understand him" is still god, isn't it?
But if god is your higher power, and if only your higher power can "restore you to sanity," then it seems a given that a religious person would indeed be expecting his god to restore the alcoholic to a more sane way of living. And that's the problem. That's how AA
can be a religious program. This higher power bunkum isn't needed.
I watched my alcoholic twist the program to allow him to divorce himself from his own responsibility. "I can't help it, I'm powerless," and "My higher power is the only thing that can restore me to sanity," were commonly heard in our home.
As a religious person, I couldn't figure out what god was waiting for, why the alcoholism-spurred abuse kept continuing, or why god wasn't returning him to sanity no matter how hard either of us prayed.
Now, of course, I know it's because talking to your ceiling or to the sky won't get you anything. My ex's attitude was, essentially, "If I'm not getting any better, not making any headway, it's not my fault. It's god's." This did not enable him to take responsibility for his actions. It instead enabled him to make "someone" other than himself responsible. To me, that's a flaw in the program. If the program had made him responsible, had not let him get away with that twisting, who knows what might have been different?
Congratulations. You did get wisdom, and courage to change something that was within your power to change, you (and your situation).
I didn't call it wisdom back then. I called it open rebellion against god. I had to go against
everything I was taught God expected of me, and destroy my family once and for all. I had to decide that my will was more important than the unknowable will of god. I had to take matters out of god's ineffectual hands and put them in my own.
This was
very difficult for me to do. I only managed it when my own children begged me to leave their father and, in their words, "find someone to really love you, Mom." They were 11 and 12 when they said this to me. All I could think was "if your own children know this farce of a marriage is over, then what the hell are you waiting for?" So, I left. As I've said, I felt horribly rebellious against god, but that just made me angry. If god knows all, he knew this was coming. He could have done something, but he did nothing. Therefore, screw god. I got this.
It would be another 10 years before I'd let go of the idea of god entirely. But this is when it began.
Something did seem to 'answer prayers' for me; I suspect it's the part of me that answered the algebra question after I slept on it, and keeps pushing thoughts out that the conscious 'me' can ignore, or select for more directed thought or action. I choose to call that my 'higher power'.
This is the part to which I referred above. How is that a "higher power?" That's just
you. It makes little sense to say your own power is higher than your own power. It's strange to pray to yourself. Of course, you can choose to call it whatever you like, but by the same token, I can choose to disagree with your interpretation.
You've heard the old saw "Man takes the 1st drink, 1st drink takes the 2nd, 2nd takes the 3rd, and 3rd drink takes the man."? For me, and any other alcoholic I know of, it's "Man takes the 1st drink, 1st drink takes the man".
And the only power over alcohol I have is 'don't take the 1st drink'. After one, I had no clue what happens next (and still wouldn't have).
That's right. The only power over alcohol you have is your own power, and sometimes, you may let yourself down and take a drink. Then you'll have to climb back up to where you were before you slipped. But it will all be
you doing it or not doing it.
Alcoholism is one of the harder things to deal with in life. There's nothing easy or simple about it. It's a lifelong struggle, and anyone who can manage any success with it is deserving of immense respect. I do not disrespect my ex for his slip. Even though I can't stand the man, I highly respect him for the 20 years he went (that I know of) without drinking. But now that he has slipped, I hope he's at last gotten to the point where he knows it's just him, and not some imaginary sky-daddy, who has anything like control over this situation.
I hope he's not once again saying, "I'm powerless, it's not my fault." But I'll probably never know.