Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Another difference between the literature and the groups: the Big Book says "If anyone who is showing inability to control his drinking can do the right- about-face and drink like a gentleman, our hats are off to him." In the groups, an "alcoholic" who does this is a threat to the dogma that has evolved in AA and is treated as such.
There's always a lot of emphasis on the grim future that awaits the practicing alchoholic and what a shame it is that the whole thing is so avoidable and all that, but after twenty years, some of that stuff can get a little stale. I've always enjoyed pointing out that there's always the possibility that a person might end up in AA who was not an alcoholic (or not a real alcoholic), and who might needlessly deprive himself of years of simple and harmless pleasure (and possibly even health benefits -- not to mention the potential social advantages of not being the odd man out at important social functions where the use of alcohol is a prominent feature), and all the while subjecting himself to a grueling and unnecessary discipline -- and just what a crying shame that would be. You kinda have to have a feel for the room before you toss out a teaser like that.

In this AA is religious in another way, i.e., its set of dogmatic beliefs that AAs these days follow.
I would argue that rigid adherence to a set of dogmatic beliefs is a necessary aspect of "religious", but not sufficient. The critical factor is the nature of the beliefs being adhered to. If the "beliefs" are mere principles or convictions (fiscal conservativism being one possible example) rather than being based on specific, supernatural claims, then the word, "belief" is also being used in a different sense than the one most pertinent here.
 
In many Protestant churches the members are invited to give their witness, that is their story of how they found Christ and gave their life to him and he saved them from sin, in AA meetings members give their witness about how they they found a higher power, gave their life to it and were saved from alcohol.
I'm not even sure that "witnessing behavior" is even a necessary condition for "religious"; let alone sufficient.
 
If belief is tangential to a discussion with religiousity (or the lack thereof) as its central focus, then just how are you defining "religious"?

Okay, play your silly games. You can't possibly not understand.

I made my point with all of this long ago. I'm still waiting for you to catch up.

What does that have to do with immersion, I wonder...
 
Okay, play your silly games. You can't possibly not understand.
It was a rhetorical question. My point is that belief is absolutely central to the question at hand. Let me put it to you more directly: Do you dispute this?

What does that have to do with immersion, I wonder...
I introduced the concept of immersion as part of an attempt to illustrate an proposition to which you have shown considerable resistance: that "belief" is complicated; that it is an emergent property which resides on more than one level.

As far as I can tell, the exchange began with this attempt by AlBell to explain how an appeal to one's own inner strength and wisdom might, for some individuals, adequately serve as reliance on a "higher power":
As to a higher power, I'd suggest an atheist consider the parts of his mind that used to be termed subconcious as his "higher power"; using his conscious mind to the best of his abilities got him where he's finally decided he needs help with his alcoholism, which is actually help with living a rational life.

Your response was a trivial play on words:
The unconscious mind is a decidedly LOWER power.
If that sort of thing is all you're interested in accomplishing here, then knock yourself out -- and by all means, continue to add a touch of irony to the fun by accusing others of "playing games".

Another of AlBell's posts also paralleled some of my arguments:
We should define 'YOU', perhaps.

Nearly all, if not completely all, the behaviors performed by your brain/body systems are beyond any conscious (can we say ego?) control.

"YOU" are just along for the ride. That sounds like a higher power to 'YOU" as I see things, and I don't see that as imaginary.
I found your response to be comically naive:
YOU is the sum of things that are your body.
That strikes me as something one might expect to find in the archives of Kids Say the Darndest Things. It's the flipside of the homunculus theory of mind. Presumably, an amputee has a smaller "self". This is the Religion and Philosophy subforum of a foundation dedicated to critical thinking. I just know you can do better than that. The question seems to be whether you have enough genuine interest in the subject to be willing to make the effort.
 
Riiight, because if it's not in the literature verbatim, it doesn't really exist in AA. Give it a rest. Again, silly slogans like this are on the lips of the "old timers" and in the catchy bumper stickers present in most meetings. But hey, it's not in the literature, ya got me!!!!!11
Wow. This was my whole argument earlier. Because I can't "prove" that I was told by everyone that I expressed a concern to(in my AA group) that I didn't believe in god, that I didn't need to worry about that and I could choose whatever I wanted to as my higher power, then it was obviously not true. That the literature trumps everything. This is the case for the religiosity of AA that is presented by tinyal, ad naseum, and the rest of the resentful. I'll be happy to agree (because it's true) that "fake it till you make it" is something commonly heard when newcomers are expressing concern in "not getting it" if you will admit that no religion is required to be in, participate in, join, or be a member of AA. From the beginning I have interpreted the thread title to mean "Why do atheist's insist that AA is not religious?" I think, using shawmutt's logic above, I have proved my case. For those that don't remember the earlier reference to "A Few Good Men" concerning everything not being in the literature-
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?qt0470344
 
As one of AA's 98% failure rate, what method did you find that worked for you?

The method I used was I decided I was no longer going to drink alcohol.
I knew I was the only person who had any power and control over my abuse of alcohol so I decided to use that power and take control of my life.

IMO anyone who claims to need a god to help them do what only they alone have the power of doing either doesn't really want to change anything or is a very weak person.

Support from other people who have been down the same road can be a very good thing as well but it still all comes down to the person owning their weakness and their strengths.

Willpower has nothing to do with it. I don't think willpower is even a real thing people have. I think it is just a word.
It's simply a person knowing their limitations.

Most people wouldn't walk into a burning inferno because they know if they do they will be burned alive.
That is a limitation we all share.
Other limits are not as equal. So it is up to each of us to own our individual limitations and enjoy a happy life.
 
The method I used was I decided I was no longer going to drink alcohol.
I knew I was the only person who had any power and control over my abuse of alcohol so I decided to use that power and take control of my life.

IMO anyone who claims to need a god to help them do what only they alone have the power of doing either doesn't really want to change anything or is a very weak person.

Support from other people who have been down the same road can be a very good thing as well but it still all comes down to the person owning their weakness and their strengths.

Willpower has nothing to do with it. I don't think willpower is even a real thing people have. I think it is just a word.
It's simply a person knowing their limitations.

Most people wouldn't walk into a burning inferno because they know if they do they will be burned alive.
That is a limitation we all share.
Other limits are not as equal. So it is up to each of us to own our individual limitations and enjoy a happy life.
One day at a time. :)
 
I'm not even sure that "witnessing behavior" is even a necessary condition for "religious"; let alone sufficient.

I see so even though AA acts religious, talks religious and looks religious we shouldn't conclude it is religious.
 
I am curious about this.
Does the court order AA, drug and alcohol counselling, what?
Are they specific or leave it up to the accused?

I have not been to court in over a decade, people can say that they do not wish to attend AA, they may then suggest what alternative form of drug treatment they will seek. (And most likely pay for.) Judges will order AA but you can say you want an alternative, it is up to the defendant to get it. (Unless it is court ordered as part of a DCFS case where DCFS pays for it.)
 
I see so even though AA acts religious, talks religious and looks religious we shouldn't conclude it is religious.

Your logic reduces to the following syllogism:

Some churches encourage witnessing.
AA encourages witnessing.
Therefore,
AA is a church.

Do need me to point out why the conclusion does not follow logically from the premises?
 
Originally Posted by tsig View Post
All these people witnessing that their organization isn't religious though it saved them from them selves through a higher power.

It seems ironic to me that all the defenders of AA in this thread are exhibiting the "witnessing" behavior while telling us AA isn't religious.


"All these people" (alcoholics) are sharing their transformation from practicing alcoholism to (hopefully) sobriety. For some that might include religion, but certainly not all.

This practice in itself does not make something religious in nature either.

I hope you're not thinking about bailing on me here. Tearing your arguments to shreds has become an important part of my day.

Giggle. :)

I have not been to court in over a decade, people can say that they do not wish to attend AA, they may then suggest what alternative form of drug treatment they will seek. (And most likely pay for.) Judges will order AA but you can say you want an alternative, it is up to the defendant to get it. (Unless it is court ordered as part of a DCFS case where DCFS pays for it.)

What I am hearing DD, is that they might be ordered to AA and accept same on a purely financial basis. If they had real objections to AA they could seek, and presumably be given, a variation of sorts to seek their own choice of education.

Is that about right?
 
I hope you're not thinking about bailing on me here. Tearing your arguments to shreds has become an important part of my day.


You haven't shredded ANY arguments of mine yet. You would need evidence for that, and you haven't got any :p . Now you're REALLY exhibiting delusional behaviour...hmmm, maybe Dawkin's should write about The AA Delusion. ;)

GB
 
I would argue that rigid adherence to a set of dogmatic beliefs is a necessary aspect of "religious", but not sufficient. The critical factor is the nature of the beliefs being adhered to. If the "beliefs" are mere principles or convictions (fiscal conservativism being one possible example) rather than being based on specific, supernatural claims, then the word, "belief" is also being used in a different sense than the one most pertinent here.

As I have repeatedly pointed out, AA is Religious in ALL senses of the word, both in reference to a deity, and in reference to "religiously" adhering to a secular dogma or football team. Once again your argument only bolsters my team's argument. You still haven't learned how to not kick the ball into your own side's goal posts, nor that AA fits religion in every sense of the word.

GB
 
Your logic reduces to the following syllogism:

Some churches encourage witnessing.
AA encourages witnessing.
Therefore,
AA is a church.

Do need me to point out why the conclusion does not follow logically from the premises?

Actually NO. The point is that the Witnessing was DIRECTLY taken from the Protestant Witnessing as demonstrated by AA's Protestant history. Only through willful ignorance can claim that Tsig's response is a syllogism (which it WOULD be if it weren't based on an Historical Fact).

GB
 
I hope you're not thinking about bailing on me here. Tearing your arguments to shreds has become an important part of my day.

So, fantasy is an important part of your day . . . not surprising actually.
 
Your response was a trivial play on words:

A play on words ? The unconscious parts of your mind handle automatic functions, language and the like. How they could be considered "higher" is beyond me. So, no, it wasn't a play on words.

If that sort of thing is all you're interested in accomplishing here, then knock yourself out -- and by all means, continue to add a touch of irony to the fun by accusing others of "playing games".

If you think that, I'm more and more of the opinion that you're not quite as smart as I gave you credit for initially.

That strikes me as something one might expect to find in the archives of Kids Say the Darndest Things.

You is NOT the sum of things that are you body ? News to me.

Presumably, an amputee has a smaller "self".

Wha ? What in the blue hell are you babbling about, now ? You seriously need help if that's what you gleaned from my statement.
 
My day is now complete; the rest is just gravy

As I have repeatedly pointed out,
As you have asserted ad nauseum
AA is Religious in ALL senses of the word, both in reference to a deity,
Yeah, yeah: "Specifically, the God of Christianity, and a Protestant version at that" (the one that is absolutely and unequivocally incompatible with the notion of "God as we understood him") -- despite numerous statements to the contrary both in AA literature (which you recognize as the ultimate source of empirical EVIDENCE) and by AA members (which you either accept or reject as EVIDENCE of AA's stance, depending on which best suits your purpose).
and in reference to "religiously" adhering to a secular dogma or football team.
Now that part I agree with. If fanaticism is the test for religiousity, AA passes, hands down.

Once again your argument only bolsters my team's argument.
In this entire thread, has any argument been made by any poster that you feel undermines "your team's" argument?

The point is that the Witnessing was DIRECTLY taken from the Protestant Witnessing as demonstrated by AA's Protestant history.
Let me get this straight. You're arguing that the idea of a person standing up before a group and describing his experiences is one which originated with Protestant Christianity?

Only through willful ignorance can claim that Tsig's response is a syllogism (which it WOULD be if it weren't based on an Historical Fact).
No syllogisms are based on Historical Fact.
Tsig's response is based on Historical Fact.
Therefore,
Tsig's response is not a syllogism.
 
Last edited:
... From the beginning I have interpreted the thread title to mean "Why do atheist's insist that AA is not religious?"...

GodofPie, that is not what I meant at all when I started this thread. My husband and I were told by a counselor that AA was not religious.

This counselor was very staunchly pro-AA and would not accept any other form of treatment. He also said that "The Lord's Prayer," was not religious. (!)

Even after attending three meetings, and disliking them very much, my husband could not sway this counselor toward providing any other information or treatment besides AA. The counselor even lost his temper and screamed at my husband and myself--for politely questioning the program and the "steps."

This led to my question. Why do people insist that AA is not religious?

(And on a side note, GodofPie, I still feel badly that you thought I was being condescending, which I wasn't. I do hope that you can reach out to your doctor and he can somehow prescribe the meds that you used to be able to take. I myself have suffered from PTSD and know how frightening and debilitating it can be. And NAMI is a terrific resource. Best wishes.)
 
A play on words ? The unconscious parts of your mind handle automatic functions, language and the like. How they could be considered "higher" is beyond me.
At this point, rather than wading into that quagmire I'll simply offer this:

It is beyond me how anyone could consider country pop to be anything but the "lowest" possible form of music -- but I don't see that as a valid basis for rejecting the possibility that it could somehow work for others.

You is NOT the sum of things that are you body ? News to me.
If it must be the quagmire, you lead the way. Persuade me that the statement: "You is the sum of things that are your body" is not a vacuous truth.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom