Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
What I am hearing DD, is that they might be ordered to AA and accept same on a purely financial basis. If they had real objections to AA they could seek, and presumably be given, a variation of sorts to seek their own choice of education.

Is that about right?

Maybe in some instances, but not all.

In Griffin v. Coughlin, a prison inmate was told that his eligibility for family visitation rights was conditioned on his attendance at a substance abuse program based on the AA 12 steps. The New York Court of Appeals (the highest court in that state) held that this was improper, and issued an order "prohibiting respondents from conditioning petitioner's participation in the Family Reunion Program on attendance in the subject Alcohol and Substance Abuse Treatment Program, as presently constituted."

In Inouye v. Kemna a parole officer ordered his parolee to attend a Salvation Army program that required attendance at AA/NA meetings. The parolee had already made his objection to AA/NA programs clear. He did not specifically ask to be placed in a different program. When he stopped attending the meetings, his parole officer had him arrested and his parole revoked. The parolee sued the parole officer for civil rights violations. There's a principle in U.S. civil rights laws that a government official may have "qualified immunity" even if he or she violated your rights, as long as the law wasn't sufficiently clear at the time. The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals held that defense was inapplicable, and in doing so cited numerous recent court decisions ruling that forced attendance at AA/NA programs is unconstitutional. The fact that so many such decisions exist is telling.

It appears that some jurisdictions have a routine practice of sending people to AA/NA. This case notes that New York's Orange County routinely required AA/NA meetings as part of probation conditions in alcohol-related cases:

The OCDP's report recommended a term of probation with six special conditions, which the department routinely recommends in cases of defendants with alcohol problems. These included that the probationer "totally abstain from the use of intoxicating beverages," avoid "establishment where the primary business is the sale or consumption of alcohol," and, as the fifth condition, that he "attend Alcoholics Anonymous at the direction of [his] probation officer."

These recommended special conditions were set forth on a standard form rider which OCDP routinely provided to sentencing judges in such cases. Judge Levinson sentenced Warner to three years of probation, imposing the special conditions recommended by the OCDP. In imposing these special conditions, Judge Levinson endorsed the Probation Department's standard form.
 
Interesting that you omit the converse:

"So why is there such aggressiveness in asserting that it IS religious? Why not just say, well, yes, the freedom left to the individual to define "higher power" allows for such a wide range of non-religious concepts that a Protestant Christian might view AA as too secular to qualify as "religious", but here's how a devoutly religious person might fit AA's secular ideas in under his Christian worldview..."

What secular things would AA suggest to a Christian, that would conflict with a typical Christian's world view and require some adaptation?

The situation reminds me of a lineage society I considered joining, until I realized that not only did one need to be a descendant, one needed to take an oath that involved god, join in a prayer at meetings, etc. etc. Well, you didn't actually need to. There were exceptions--they had a way to re-word the oath if someone asked for an exception and of course you weren't required to say "amen" or bow your head at meetings. While there was no official requirement that one needed to be religious and a descendant to join, but it was clearly designed to be easiest for descendants who happened to be religious people, and anyone else would require a few exceptions and not really be fully part of what the group was designed for.

The difference is, they didn't tell me, "We're not a religious organization." They said, "Let me ask and see what exceptions can be made."

I chose not to join, but there was absolutely no defensiveness about the religious parts. The local head was comfortable and confident about them, and they were clearly part of the group's identity, but he was willing to work around them if necessary. It was a totally different attitude.
 
What secular things would AA suggest to a Christian, that would conflict with a typical Christian's world view and require some adaptation?
In my experience, there are very few things one can suggest to a fundamentalist (of any persuasion) that does not conflict with his worldview, unless it is directly in line with the dogma of his choice. He may reject advice coming from a secular source on that basis alone, even if it is indistinguishable from his dogma. He views alcoholism as sin; AA views it as an illness. He searches his scripture for truth; the AA member is advised to seek self-knowledge. He appeals to God for forgiveness; AA suggests making direct amends to the injured parties.

If there is more flexibility when dealing with "the typical Christian", it surely cannot extend to the one thing most pertinent to answering the question of AA's religiousity, that being the open definition of "higher power". Christianity's most central precept simply will not allow this. It's Jehovah God, through his only begotten Son, Jesus Christ -- take it or leave it. You're either on the bus, or you're off the bus. The idea that a group of drunks, or one's own inner strength and wisdom, or nature, or the laws of cause and effect (or any one of the other myriad ways individual AA members may, and do, describe their "higher powers") might be allocated a role in the life of an alcoholic which Christianity regards as exclusive to God/Jesus -- that cannot be adapted to; it must be rejected outright. Hence, when Christians enter AA, they often need to be reminded that each individual AA member is responsible for making his own choices, that AA respects that right, and that proselytizing is not compatible with this "live and let live" approach -- an approach that has never been popular in Christianity, which has a long history of aggressive (and even forceful) efforts to gain converts (surely much of the reason for its success as a meme).
 
The main answer that people are presenting to the "why" seems to be "because it's not religious." Yet there's quite a bit of evidence that it contains a lot of religious elements, was founded by religious people, and so forth.

Hello?!
I have yet to see any of the AAers here (if I can loosely use that word) disagree with that.

So why is there such defensiveness, similar to what you encountered with the counselor? Why not just say, well, yes, it has a lot of religious elements, and I could see why some people consider it religious, and some of the advice will seem familiar if you're already comfortable with the concept of the Protestant Christian God, but here's how a non-religious person can be accepted...

Hello again.
This too has been explained time and again and rejected by the non AAers.
I found the "one day at a time" catchphrase to be unhelpful and counterproductive in every sense of the word.
 
It is beyond me how anyone could consider country pop to be anything but the "lowest" possible form of music -- but I don't see that as a valid basis for rejecting the possibility that it could somehow work for others.

Since we both have things that are _beyond_ us, perhaps we should consider those to be our higher powers... :p

My point is, and always was, that if you can consider anything to be a higher power, even things that cannot really be considered powers, or "higher" things, then the term becomes useless and we should use another phrase.

If it must be the quagmire, you lead the way. Persuade me that the statement: "You is the sum of things that are your body" is not a vacuous truth.

In a way, you're right. But I'd like to remind you of the context of that statement:

I don't mean that people can't help you to reach your goals, but ultimately, YOU are the one making the steps towards recovery, not some imaginary higher power.

We should define 'YOU', perhaps.

Nearly all, if not completely all, the behaviors performed by your brain/body systems are beyond any conscious (can we say ego?) control.

"YOU" are just along for the ride. That sounds like a higher power to 'YOU" as I see things, and I don't see that as imaginary.

AlBell seemed to be implying that there's something more to you than "the sum of things that are your body".
 
So now recovery from alcoholism is itself religious in nature?

Ugh. You're really doing this on purpose now. Did you REALLY not understand Qayak's post ?

Anyway, this thread has been dead for quite some time. Evidence has been presented, and either ignored or "countered" with anecdotes. At this point it's just rhetoric and insults; from one side _and_ the other, so I don't see much point in continuing unless someone can revitalise the thread with something new.
 
This was never fully explored, and I was having far too much fun to bring it up again"

To the OP.
Most AAers that I know, consider the program one of a spiritual nature, rather than religious.

Whilst some definitions might join spirituality and religion at the hip, many see them as totally different: The spiritual being more along the lines of self, ego and our reason for living.
 
My point is, and always was, that if you can consider anything to be a higher power, even things that cannot really be considered powers, or "higher" things, then the term becomes useless and we should use another phrase.
I agree that in this context what matters most is utility. I have indeed made that exact argument a number of times. "Wilson" was useful to Nolan as a companion despite the fact that the word "companion" implies some degree of sentience, a quality which Wilson clearly lacked entirely. Focusing on the validity of the use of the term misses the point.

AlBell seemed to be implying that there's something more to you than "the sum of things that are your body".
Actually, I take his implication to be that there's something less to this YOU than the sum of the things that are your body -- but we're hip deep in the quagmire already. AlBell's observation, "YOU are just along for the ride", might be interpreted as invoking a homunculus; a little man in the brain who experiences the rollercoaster ride but has little or no control over its course. Your observation, "YOU is the sum of things that are your body", might be interpreted as invoking a p-zombie; a being that responds to stimuli without actually experiencing it.

Did you REALLY not understand Qayak's post ?
Did you REALLY not understand my answer to that question in my response to Gate2501?
 
Actually, I take his implication to be that there's something less to this YOU than the sum of the things that are your body -- but we're hip deep in the quagmire already. AlBell's observation, "YOU are just along for the ride", might be interpreted as invoking a homunculus; a little man in the brain who experiences the rollercoaster ride but has little or no control over its course.

Well, one way or another, it implies that there's something more to YOU.

Your observation, "YOU is the sum of things that are your body", might be interpreted as invoking a p-zombie; a being that responds to stimuli without actually experiencing it.

I have no idea how you manage to glean that from my post. I don't deny experience in any way, shape or form.
 
Well, one way or another, it implies that there's something more to YOU.
Something more than what?

I have no idea how you manage to glean that from my post. I don't deny experience in any way, shape or form.
As my choice of words ("might be interpreted as") was intended to indicate, your observation, ("YOU is the sum of things that are your body") is not so much wrong as it is uninformative. You haven't defined self in any way that would make it distinguishable from a p-zombie. You're basically just pointing at the body and saying, "It's there". To be fair, AlBell's homunculus model is not much more informative. He points to the brain and says, "It's in there". (To be even more fair, all the philosophers and psychologists and neurologists and all the king's horses and all the king's men, have arguably not been able to do a much better job).

Each of the stances is, in its own way, an appeal to naive realism. The main difference I see is that while AlBell's "self" appears simply to be an intuitive default, yours has the flavor of a deliberate contrivance, created explicitly for the purpose of excluding the possibility that "a higher power greater than one's self" could meaningly refer to something inside one's self.

I'm willing to risk incurring DD's disdain once more by quoting Dennett, here describing what he calls "adopting the intentional stance":
"Here is how it works: first you decide to treat the object whose behavior is to be predicted as a rational agent; then you figure out what beliefs that agent ought to have, given its place in the world and its purpose. Then you figure out what desires it ought to have, on the same considerations, and finally you predict that this rational agent will act to further its goals in the light of its beliefs. A little practical reasoning from the chosen set of beliefs and desires will in most instances yield a decision about what the agent ought to do; that is what you predict the agent will do." (Daniel Dennett, The Intentional Stance, p. 17)
I submit that this is describes exactly the process by which the character "Wilson" came into being in the movie "Cast Away". I've also argued that this may be regarded as either rational or irrational behavior, depending on whether it is useful to the individual in achieving his goals (and, I suppose, on whether the goals themselves are rationally defensible). AND, I have argued that whether it's rational behavior or not, it is impossible to avoid altogether. It's hardwired.

When the Christian prays to his God, he is attributing agency and intent to something invisible; a supernatural entity which his fellow Christians also agree exists. We call this "religious belief", and the reason we call it that is directly due to the supernatural quality of the proposed "being" -- and also to the public nature of the belief. A hypothetical AA member might direct his appeals toward another type of entity, also invisible, and also supported by others: his "unconscious mind" (or "inner self"). I've suggested that the Christian and that hypothetical AA member might reasonably be considered to be doing not merely effectively the same thing but exactly the same thing (though I wouldn't want to be forced to prove it at gunpoint). It might be argued that it is not meaningful to say that any such thing as an unconscious mind exists. It might be argued that it is not meaningful to say that any such thing as a "self" exists (i.e., that it is nothing more than a "useful fiction", in Dennett's words).

Before we struggle any more with those puzzles, let me simply ask this: Would you argue that the hypothetical AA member's appeals to his "inner self" -- regardless of whether the proposed recipient of those appeals deserves recognition as a genuine entity (or an agent, or a power), and regardless of whether it works -- constitute evidence of religious belief?
 
Last edited:
What secular things would AA suggest to a Christian, that would conflict with a typical Christian's world view and require some adaptation?
At least at our meetings, you are not permitted to talk about jesus or any other biblical characters. If someone starts going off on a jeebus rant, the chairperson will ask them, politely, to refrain from doing so. It does not stop people from trying.

The situation reminds me of a lineage society I considered joining, until I realized that not only did one need to be a descendant, one needed to take an oath that involved god, join in a prayer at meetings, etc. etc. Well, you didn't actually need to. There were exceptions--they had a way to re-word the oath if someone asked for an exception and of course you weren't required to say "amen" or bow your head at meetings. While there was no official requirement that one needed to be religious and a descendant to join, but it was clearly designed to be easiest for descendants who happened to be religious people, and anyone else would require a few exceptions and not really be fully part of what the group was designed for.

The difference is, they didn't tell me, "We're not a religious organization." They said, "Let me ask and see what exceptions can be made."

I chose not to join, but there was absolutely no defensiveness about the religious parts. The local head was comfortable and confident about them, and they were clearly part of the group's identity, but he was willing to work around them if necessary. It was a totally different attitude.
This is how my AA experience has been. I would like to point out the US courts have you swear in on a bible. Just a few years ago, a muslim sued (the state)and now they will also allow the koran. If you object to those two options, then you are permitted to simply affirm that you are going to tell the truth. Most people swear to gawd on the holy KJV bible. This is not directed at you Pup, but to the group, Is the US court system a religious organization?
 
At least at our meetings, you are not permitted to talk about jesus or any other biblical characters. If someone starts going off on a jeebus rant, the chairperson will ask them, politely, to refrain from doing so. It does not stop people from trying.

In over a decade of regular attendance, I can't remember anyone ever talk about Jesus Christ at an AA meeting.

So much for Christian religion in AA. ;)
 
Something more than what?

If I say "you're just along for the ride", it implies that the definition of "you" doesn't include most of your body, as you're, apparently, not in control. What I was saying was that "you" included all of your body, no more, no less.

You think that's uninformative. It wasn't meant to be informative: it was simply meant to be true.
 
In over a decade of regular attendance, I can't remember anyone ever talk about Jesus Christ at an AA meeting.

So much for Christian religion in AA. ;)

Hey that's pretty funny...after your poor behavior on this thread and you expect us to believe you???

HA HA HA HA HA HA HA...


Is this some type of game to you, alfie? Do you think you can say absolutely any unproven thing and people here will fall all over themselves to congratulate you?

Sorry to break this to ya, but people here are not as dumb as you think they are.
 
If I say "you're just along for the ride", it implies that the definition of "you" doesn't include most of your body, as you're, apparently, not in control.
I agree. And, unless one is willing to accept Dennett's notion of the self as a "useful fiction" (or something similar), it's hard to define in a way that does not reduce to some form of Cartesian dualism: the "ghost in the machine". Still, whether it's falling in love, or craving chocolate, or being afraid of the dark, or laughing hysterically in inappropriate situations, or any one of a thousand other things, we are all familiar with the experience of not being in control. With some activities involving a high degree of dexterity, such as playing a musical instrument, I have often found that ahieving peak performance requires the ability to relinquish "control"; to turn the task over to congnitive submodules. I'm not playing the piece so much as I'm watching and listening as my fingers play the piece. When I try to teach it to someone else, I often discover that I don't really even know how I'm doing it (and when I try to break it down into simple steps, it's as much a discovery process for me as it is for the student).

It may not represent the pinnacle of objective truth, but the subjective experience is very much one of being "just along for the ride". I will admit that I probably do more often see myself as a subject than as an object. Just one of my funny little quirks, I guess, but I take comfort in the notion that I am not alone in this. A philosopher, when engaged in that specialized activity for which he is trained, might conclude (/propose) that the "self" is a useful fiction (and the Zen master might agree). But, when engaged in the endless details of simply living "a good and normal life", my guess is that he doesn't trip on the "fiction" part any more than I do. My guess is that he mostly just goes with "useful".

What I was saying was that "you" included all of your body, no more, no less.

You think that's uninformative.
Yes, I do. I could obtain that wisdom from my three-year-old grandson.

It wasn't meant to be informative: it was simply meant to be true.
It looks like what it was meant to be is safe. If it rises above the level of the vacuously true, it surely does not rise above the level of the trivially true. It's true in a "Me Tarzan, YOU Jane" sense. It's true in the same sense that saying, "Let go of my arm" is essentially equivalent to saying, "Let go of ME". It's not informative enough to be useful (not for our purposes here, anyway).

You'll never have to work very hard to defend your position if you limit your postulates to that which is trivially true.
 
Never heard someone thank Jesus?? Wow what was going on in my area it happened at all 20 I was made to go to. It was also done at the treatment center I was stuck in.
 
Still, whether it's falling in love, or craving chocolate, or being afraid of the dark, or laughing hysterically in inappropriate situations, or any one of a thousand other things, we are all familiar with the experience of not being in control.

In some situations, sure, but it's not like you're simply viewing what's going on (from a neurological perspective, perhaps).

Yes, I do. I could obtain that wisdom from my three-year-old grandson.

That's nice. So you were just being rude.

It looks like what it was meant to be is safe.

No. True. AlBell's statement seemed false to me, so I sought to correct him/her. That you find it simplistic is of no interest to me, so long as the statement is true.

You'll never have to work very hard to defend your position if you limit your postulates to that which is trivially true.

I'm not the one making the claim, AlBell was. I just need to show him/her wrong.
 
In over a decade of regular attendance, I can't remember anyone ever talk about Jesus Christ at an AA meeting.

The meetings in Australia might be different than they are here in the US?

The very first AA meeting which I attended involved a woman(who was one of the people organizing this particular meeting) speaking about Jesus. The meeting was supposed to be about "attitude".

I went to different meetings(there are a LOT of them in my area), and Jesus was brought up in at least half of them, probably more like 3/4 of them. I don't feel like Akron is a very religious city overall either.
 
AlBell's statement seemed false to me, so I sought to correct him/her.

I'm not the one making the claim, AlBell was. I just need to show him/her wrong.

And you have neither corrected me nor shown me wrong.

Do you yet understand that Libet's work demonstrates what I said is correct, no 'ghost in the machine' required.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom