Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Fair enough. I have made a number of references to "cognitive submodules", as I strongly subscribe to this model of human cognition. I'm simply arguing that belief is not a special mental state that exists in some privileged, executive area of the brain, and (with few exceptions) it is not a binary property. It represents a sum total (or perhaps more of a biased average) of the outputs of these cognitive submodules -- some of which act together in mutually reinforcing ways, and some of which compete against each other.

Has the popular obsession with the personal lives of celebrities, the general decline in attention span, and other symptoms of brain-fry from thousands of hours spent staring slack-jawed at television tubes, rendered the American electorate so collectively incapable of rational discourse and informed decision-making that Democracy in this country is rapidly approaching the point at which it must be considered a failed experiment? I don't know that it is completely meaningful to say that I have a "belief" on this question. It is fragmented. It sort of flickers. Sometimes I believe it, sometimes I don't. When I do believe it, it's usually at times when I'm feeling frustrated, or angry, or fearful, or maybe just tired.

In short: What I believe can be as much a matter of how I feel as what I think. Are you and I different in this regard?

Okay... personally I think that immersion/suspension of disbelief is the lack of either belief or disbelief for the sake of entertainment, and that at no point does one start to belief the truth of the story being unfold. However since this is at best tengential to the thread, I'm willing to accept, for the sake of argument, that they are one and the same.

So what, already ? :p
 
"AA is religious because it refers to God, and substituting higher power for that is a mere ruse, because everyone knows that God is the only thing to which such a phrase could possibly refer."

Change "could possibly" by "does" and that's pretty much it, to me.

"An atheist could never work the steps, because doing so requires belief in a higher power, and atheism bespeaks a committment to rational thinking which precludes that."

To me, it's simply that it's more difficult for an atheist to progress in an environment where both he/she and the others might be uncomfortable with the divide between the two belief systems involved. And I wouldn't want him/her to pseudo-convert just to avoid this situation.
 
Every session of the US Congress also opens with a prayer. Does that make Congress a religious organization?

That would be a yes.

One wonders how they'd know.

Because they are sitting right there. There is always a lookout at each table. Standard practice.
If you have never been to an AA meeting then why comment on it at all?
 
Every session of the US Congress also opens with a prayer. Does that make Congress a religious organization?

Why do you continue to use this argument? It has been demonstrated to be False Equivalence time and again. Perhaps because you have a new poster on the thread that you think is more gullible than the rest of us?

Enough Already. You really are starting to sound more and more like DOC, who continually repeats the same refuted arguments.

GB
 
Last edited:
That would be a yes.

Brattus, there is big distinction between a public secular institution violating the separation clause of the constitution with the occasional use of religious language, and an organization that is chock-full of specifically religious language, and based on religious tenets and practices as is AA.

Dymanic knows this by now, and is engaging in verbal trickery (aka sophistry ;) ).

GB
 
Brattus, there is big distinction between a public secular institution violating the separation clause of the constitution with the occasional use of religious language, and an organization that is chock-full of specifically religious language, and based on religious tenets and practices as is AA.

Dymanic knows this by now, and is engaging in verbal trickery (aka sophistry ;) ).

GB

All these people witnessing that their organization isn't religious though it saved them from them selves through a higher power.
 
The program would be better served if it attempted to distinguish the problem drinkers from the alcoholic. In fact, the Big Book says just this.

This last statement I agree with for the most part. Our best experts still haven't fully figured that out so we will have to wait.

On the rest of the post, we were discussing the stance of AA as a whole - not individual opinions and testimonials. Someone said it earlier, some here are happy to use the personal testimonials as long as it suits your purpose.

That would be a yes.

And so everyone in congress, and everyone that falls under the control of congress is also religious I guess?
Same in AA, some are some aren't. The program was originally based in religion but that does not necessarily follow through to the entire membership or program.

For those of you with short memories:
The 12 steps are "suggested" as a program for recovery
"The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking"
"Take what you need and leave the rest"

It really isn't that hard to work within that framework and exclude your supposed requirement for a god - and Tinyal is a perfect example. He rejects god, and has many years sobriety through AA.

All these people witnessing that their organization isn't religious though it saved them from them selves through a higher power.

A "power greater than themselves" restored them to sanity, which may or may not be a deity. :)
That power for many, is simply the fellowship of AA.

Surely, it's not that hard to grasp is it?
 
Last edited:
I spent years going over these chapters.
Ah, an authority then.

Anyone who reads your quote in context will be wholly unconvinced.
Plus, it's plain to anyone who has attended meetings. It stands to reason. Experts agree.

Right, the program demands rigorous honesty and "thoroughly following their path" to get sober but it's OK to "fake it until you make it". Absurd.
I agree. That is an absurd mish-mash of unrelated quotes. As an authority on AA literature, I wonder if you'd care to specify just where the phrase, "fake it until you make it" appears.

The usual result of this is a dry drunk.
In compiling statistics to support this claim, I'd expect that one of the trickier aspects of the methodology would be finding an objective standard by which to distinguish the "recovering alcoholic" (or whatever it would be) from the "dry drunk". Was that your experience?
 
Okay... personally I think that immersion/suspension of disbelief is the lack of either belief or disbelief for the sake of entertainment, and that at no point does one start to belief the truth of the story being unfold. However since this is at best tengential to the thread, I'm willing to accept, for the sake of argument, that they are one and the same.

So what, already ? :p
I don't see the issue of belief to be tangential to the thread at all. Does not the entire concept of religiousity revolve around belief?
 
Because they are sitting right there. There is always a lookout at each table.
Well, if you got caught without your head bowed, you might have just claimed to be acting as a volunteer lookout.

If you have never been to an AA meeting then why comment on it at all?
Interesting question.
 
Why do you continue to use this argument? It has been demonstrated to be False Equivalence time and again.
I guess I'm still prone to slipping back into old thought patterns, like indulging the notion that a trivial argument may be refuted by a trivial counterexample.
 
I guess I'm still prone to slipping back into old thought patterns, like indulging the notion that a trivial argument may be refuted by a trivial counterexample.

Whatever you say DOC. Last time I checked Evidence trumps trivial arguments.

GB
 
All these people witnessing that their organization isn't religious though it saved them from them selves through a higher power.
"AA is religious because it refers to God, and substituting 'higher power' for that is a mere ruse, because everyone knows that God is the only thing to which such a phrase could possibly refer."
 
"AA is religious because it refers to God, and substituting 'higher power' for that is a mere ruse, because everyone knows that God is the only thing to which such a phrase could possibly refer."

Yes I agree 100%!

AA also couldn't help a little old lady cross the street let alone help someone to stop drinking alcohol.
 
Last edited:
Whatever you say DOC.
I don't share your fascination with the poster DOC, and in fact have only a vague familiarity with that name. If your intent is merely to invoke that name as a form of insult, then before you do so again, I would ask that you give thought to whether that constitutes a useful contribution to the discussion we're having.
 
Yes I agree 100%!

AA also couldn't help a little old lady cross the street let alone help someone to stop drinking alcohol.
As one of AA's 98% failure rate, what method did you find that worked for you?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom