Belz...
Fiend God
Fair enough. I have made a number of references to "cognitive submodules", as I strongly subscribe to this model of human cognition. I'm simply arguing that belief is not a special mental state that exists in some privileged, executive area of the brain, and (with few exceptions) it is not a binary property. It represents a sum total (or perhaps more of a biased average) of the outputs of these cognitive submodules -- some of which act together in mutually reinforcing ways, and some of which compete against each other.
Has the popular obsession with the personal lives of celebrities, the general decline in attention span, and other symptoms of brain-fry from thousands of hours spent staring slack-jawed at television tubes, rendered the American electorate so collectively incapable of rational discourse and informed decision-making that Democracy in this country is rapidly approaching the point at which it must be considered a failed experiment? I don't know that it is completely meaningful to say that I have a "belief" on this question. It is fragmented. It sort of flickers. Sometimes I believe it, sometimes I don't. When I do believe it, it's usually at times when I'm feeling frustrated, or angry, or fearful, or maybe just tired.
In short: What I believe can be as much a matter of how I feel as what I think. Are you and I different in this regard?
Okay... personally I think that immersion/suspension of disbelief is the lack of either belief or disbelief for the sake of entertainment, and that at no point does one start to belief the truth of the story being unfold. However since this is at best tengential to the thread, I'm willing to accept, for the sake of argument, that they are one and the same.
So what, already ?