"Fake it till you make it" is the sort of rehab jargon generally scorned by old-timers (a quibble, perhaps, but there it is). Most pertinent to the OP is the question of whether it is inherently religious in nature. I have long suspected that many who identify themselves as Christians are secretly on a "fake it till you make it" program, and the more vehemently they proclaim their faith, the stronger my suspicions -- but I can't think of a biblical passage that endorses the practice, or one which even vaguely amounts to "fake it till you make it" in any form.
There's a lot of that. I just found this while researching for posts:
http://www.aasources.com/pages/notinbook.html It's a list of slogans and sayings in meetings that aren't congruent with the literature. Check out the section "You're in the right place."
AA wasn't the first place I was told to "fake it till you make it". The first was my church, as I was working my way up the ranks. I do have a tendency to try and excel in whatever group I belong to, and tended (in hindsight) to have blinders on and ignore the niggling doubts while in the groups. All my volunteering while in AA never got rid of the doubts about whether I was a "true alcoholic" or not.
It was easy for me to remain in denial in the city I was living in--there was a large group of involved young folks in and around the area. I volunteered in the local youth psychiatric ward, juvie halls, youth halfway homes--lol kinda like a Peter Pan world of alcoholism. All these teenagers and 20 somethings were convinced they had an addiction to alcohol. Some had serious mental problems. Some had serious drug addictions. Some, I'm convinced, were truly addicted to alcohol. Most, in my opinion, were kids that got in trouble and were saying anything to get out of their situation. By no means had most of these kids "hit bottom". I saw most of the kids and young adults go right back to old behaviors once out.
Others, like me, got caught up in the fellowship. Yes, I had issues with alcohol as a teenager. I had blacked out on occasion, got in a bit of trouble, and nearly lost my license not even a year after getting it. However, was I an alcoholic? Long story short, when I expressed doubts about my alcoholism to my sponsor, old-timers, and friends within the program, the mantra was "fake it until you make it". As I was deep into self-help b.s. at the time, it made sense, and I soldiered on.
That is, until I decided to do what the Big Book said, and try controlled drinking. I made the mistake of talking to my "friends" in the program about it. Then I got some lesser known sayings like "I see kids like you in the morgue all the time". Kinda sucked coming from someone who I knew from day 1 in the program.
Here I am--I've been drinking again twice as long as I was in the program. I have no problem controlling it (although to be honest I have had a few too many on occasion). Those first few years of drinking again were accompanied by horrible guilt but I'm over it, and enjoy drinking.
Almost every single friend I had during my AA stardom is long gone. One or two still hang around, although I'm convinced they just want to see a train wreck. One guy found me on facebook, and was all excited until he found out I was an atheist and/or drinking again and promptly defriended me (not sure which upset him more, we had a long talk about higher powers). I no longer fit into the beliefs of AA and its faithful members.
Another difference between the literature and the groups: the Big Book says "If anyone who is showing inability to control his drinking can do the right- about-face and drink like a gentleman, our hats are off to him." In the groups, an "alcoholic" who does this is a threat to the dogma that has evolved in AA and is treated as such. In this AA is religious in another way, i.e., its set of dogmatic beliefs that AAs these days follow.
Hence, making definitive statements about what produces "dry drunks" is, at best, a very dubious business -- don't you think?
I agree, and withdraw my statement about dry drunks.