Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, for the sake of argument because it's tengential... I just said so in that post.
If belief is tangential to a discussion with religiousity (or the lack thereof) as its central focus, then just how are you defining "religious"?

Still waiting for your point with all this.
I made my point with all of this long ago. I'm still waiting for you to catch up.

This is central to the argument I've been making here all along. Addiction (in my layman's opinion) arises out of irrational thinking/feeling that takes place on levels to which we have limited access, at best.

...what I propose is that in dealing with the irrational, one need not limit one's self solely to what is rational. Sort of a "Render unto Caesar" kinda thing.

Referring again to a discussion presently ongoing in another thread, tell me if you agree with these comments:

"Trust me, if I could just choose to ignore the effect of delusions, gut feelings, and emotional attachments and "easily choose" to believe only what the objective evidence indicates, I would do so all the time. But alas, I cannot."

"You can untentionally turn off certain parts of your mind when the mental and sociatal rewards, such as public acceptance, are great enough to make it worthwhile."

"There's a difference between choosing what you will believe and what you can believe."

context
 
Choosing to believe is what AAers are directed to do by AA literature and many of its proponents to achieve the alleged "benefits" of AA. Yes Dymanic, it's relevant, but as usual, your arguments aren't benefiting your case, but ours.

It looks like you still need to work on not scoring goals for the opposing team. :p

GB

PS: Calling you DOC, isn't intended as an insult per se, just a snarky way to help you recognize the obvious comparisons of some (though certainly not all) of your arguments. You may want to check out some of the threads DOC frequents for examples.
 
Ah, an authority then.

Not claiming that.

Plus, it's plain to anyone who has attended meetings. It stands to reason. Experts agree.

It's simply sufficient to consider the evidence in the text. But speaking of meetings--

I agree. That is an absurd mish-mash of unrelated quotes. As an authority on AA literature, I wonder if you'd care to specify just where the phrase, "fake it until you make it" appears.

Riiight, because if it's not in the literature verbatim, it doesn't really exist in AA. Give it a rest. Again, silly slogans like this are on the lips of the "old timers" and in the catchy bumper stickers present in most meetings. But hey, it's not in the literature, ya got me!!!!!11!1one

In compiling statistics to support this claim, I'd expect that one of the trickier aspects of the methodology would be finding an objective standard by which to distinguish the "recovering alcoholic" (or whatever it would be) from the "dry drunk". Was that your experience?

It's difficult at best to gather statistics on a group that relies on testimonials and self-selected surveys to make up its numbers. Perhaps that's why people think it's the best way to get and stay sober.
 
Riiight, because if it's not in the literature verbatim, it doesn't really exist in AA. Give it a rest. Again, silly slogans like this are on the lips of the "old timers" and in the catchy bumper stickers present in most meetings. But hey, it's not in the literature, ya got me!!!!!11!1one
Time for an interesting aside especially for the cbt proponents.

http://www.addictionpro.com/ME2/Sit...A828D5BF4612B1A4FC59732F0588&SiteID=Main Si_e

"Discussing a client with symptoms of social anxiety, our medical director said, “If only this client could force himself to go to the supermarket. If he could just make himself get going, he might get energized.”

Someone replied, “In AA they say, ‘Bring the body and the mind will follow.'” Over time, we found ourselves frequently drawing upon the language of Alcoholics Anonymous to underscore a point made from a cognitive or behavioral perspective.

We quickly realized that the halls of AA are full of cognitive and behavioral interventions, packaged comfortably as mere suggestions."


It's difficult at best to gather statistics on a group that relies on testimonials and self-selected surveys to make up its numbers. Perhaps that's why people think it's the best way to get and stay sober.
Actual AA stats on recovery would be interesting, but the anonymity proviso makes obtaining them doubly difficult.

And for any recovery programs, gathering longterm stats is time consuming and expensive; not to mention in large part dependent on reporting by addicts who likely spent the addiction part of their lives becoming world-class liars.
 
Other phrases include:

"Take what you need and leave the rest"
"A day at a time"
"Live and let live"
"Easy does it"
 
Time for an interesting aside especially for the cbt proponents.

We quickly realized that the halls of AA are full of cognitive and behavioral interventions, packaged comfortably as mere suggestions."


I mentioned this very thing much earlier in the thread. Because AA did get some things right in relation to positive action taken to improve one's life does nothing to reduce the religiosity of AA.




Actual AA stats on recovery would be interesting, but the anonymity proviso makes obtaining them doubly difficult.


And for any recovery programs, gathering longterm stats is time consuming and expensive; not to mention in large part dependent on reporting by addicts who likely spent the addiction part of their lives becoming world-class liars.


The relevant statement is the 11th tradition which states, "Our public relations policy is based on attraction rather than promotion; we need always maintain personal anonymity at the level of press, radio, and films."


In 1946, Bill W wrote, “The word anonymous has for us an immense spiritual significance. Subtly but powerfully, it reminds us that we are always to place principles before personalities; that we have renounced personal glorification in public; that our movement not only preaches but actually practices a true humility.”


Nothing in the literature nor personal writings I have seen have ever said or even implicated that AAers shouldn't participate in studies tracking progress and success rates.
 
My question is, in the USA, how can a judge order a person to go to an AA meeting, and not be breaking the first amendment of the constitution?

Their pamphlets have "God" sprinkled on them so much that it can't be non-denominational, much less a non-Judeo-Christian deity based organization.

And I know they say it's voluntary, but when it's court ordered, it's voluntary to the point that you don't have to, but if you don't you'll lose your drivers license.

It's a theistic organization that uses abstinence, will power, group support, and surrendering to another greater Power (as they mention, alcohol was definitely a greater power in your life), to treat a drug addiction. Not only is it hazardous to break a junkie off of their drug of choice, but giving into a greater power makes it seem like a gateway into "harder drugs."

I'm not opposed to AA having the right to operate, but I don't believe their methods work enough to merit the government giving an unconstitutional mandate to attend such an event, when therapists and doctors can give you things like Topiramate and counseling.
 
My question is, in the USA, how can a judge order a person to go to an AA meeting, and not be breaking the first amendment of the constitution?

Their pamphlets have "God" sprinkled on them so much that it can't be non-denominational, much less a non-Judeo-Christian deity based organization.

And I know they say it's voluntary, but when it's court ordered, it's voluntary to the point that you don't have to, but if you don't you'll lose your drivers license.

It's a theistic organization that uses abstinence, will power, group support, and surrendering to another greater Power (as they mention, alcohol was definitely a greater power in your life), to treat a drug addiction. Not only is it hazardous to break a junkie off of their drug of choice, but giving into a greater power makes it seem like a gateway into "harder drugs."

I'm not opposed to AA having the right to operate, but I don't believe their methods work enough to merit the government giving an unconstitutional mandate to attend such an event, when therapists and doctors can give you things like Topiramate and counseling.



Yes, do a search of this thread. Tinyal has posted all the relevant US court cases which have concluded that AA is a religious organization and alternatives must be presented to persons who are court-ordered for some kind of treatment or program.
 
Yes, do a search of this thread. Tinyal has posted all the relevant US court cases which have concluded that AA is a religious organization and alternatives must be presented to persons who are court-ordered for some kind of treatment or program.

Unfortunately this is still a battle that has to be fought district by district, and many jurisdictions continue to offer no suitable alternatives.

GB
 
Choosing to believe is what AAers are directed to do by AA literature and many of its proponents to achieve the alleged "benefits" of AA.
I've often heard AA members refer to "My higher power, whom I choose to call God". I don't see that as quite the same thing as choosing to believe. Step 2 says "We came to believe that a power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity". I don't see that as quite the same thing as choosing to believe either... or pretending to believe, or wanting to believe, or trying to believe. There is some less lively (but much more friendly) discussion on these nuances in the thread I just linked.

It looks like you still need to work on not scoring goals for the opposing team.
It really all turns on whether your base assertion can be supported: that the abovementioned "higher power" can only refer to the God of:
Specifically, Christianity, and a Protestant version at that.
Doesn't it? You know, the one who allegedly issued the pronouncement: "Thou shalt have no other gods before me" -- which, if I interpret it correctly, is absolutely and unequivocably incompatible with the notion of "God as we understood him".

Calling you DOC, isn't intended as an insult per se, just a snarky way to help you recognize the obvious comparisons of some (though certainly not all) of your arguments.
Uh huh.
You may want to check out some of the threads DOC frequents for examples.
Pass. I'm always willing to entertain tips on how I might improve my communication skills, and I'll give your criticisms all the consideration they deserve -- but I have no particular interest in this DOC person. I suggest you leave him (?) out of it.
 
Riiight, because if it's not in the literature verbatim, it doesn't really exist in AA.
I'd be happy to agree that AA is more than a collection of literature, and more than a gathering of alcoholics (in fact, I said so in exactly those words more than 1200 posts back). Other posters, however, have argued in the strongest possible terms that AA literature is the only valid source of empirical EVIDENCE on these matters. We may have trouble bringing them onboard.

Again, silly slogans like this are on the lips of the "old timers" and in the catchy bumper stickers present in most meetings.
"Fake it till you make it" is the sort of rehab jargon generally scorned by old-timers (a quibble, perhaps, but there it is). Most pertinent to the OP is the question of whether it is inherently religious in nature. I have long suspected that many who identify themselves as Christians are secretly on a "fake it till you make it" program, and the more vehemently they proclaim their faith, the stronger my suspicions -- but I can't think of a biblical passage that endorses the practice, or one which even vaguely amounts to "fake it till you make it" in any form.

It's difficult at best to gather statistics on a group that relies on testimonials and self-selected surveys to make up its numbers.
Hence, making definitive statements about what produces "dry drunks" is, at best, a very dubious business -- don't you think?
 
You are just rehashing the same tired sophistries and straw men that have already been effectively debunked Dymanic. I see no reason to repeat the debunkings. :rolleyes:

:o Mea Culpa! Yes, it was a little mean of me to compare you to DOC (you are FAR more intelligent and sophisticated--seriously)...but I only did so because as a Christian Apologist he refuses to let go of his same old tired debunked arguments too, and I (apparently wrongly) assumed that his infamy was well known in the Religion and the History sub-forums of JREF.

GB
 
"Fake it till you make it" is the sort of rehab jargon generally scorned by old-timers (a quibble, perhaps, but there it is). Most pertinent to the OP is the question of whether it is inherently religious in nature. I have long suspected that many who identify themselves as Christians are secretly on a "fake it till you make it" program, and the more vehemently they proclaim their faith, the stronger my suspicions -- but I can't think of a biblical passage that endorses the practice, or one which even vaguely amounts to "fake it till you make it" in any form.

There's a lot of that. I just found this while researching for posts: http://www.aasources.com/pages/notinbook.html It's a list of slogans and sayings in meetings that aren't congruent with the literature. Check out the section "You're in the right place."

AA wasn't the first place I was told to "fake it till you make it". The first was my church, as I was working my way up the ranks. I do have a tendency to try and excel in whatever group I belong to, and tended (in hindsight) to have blinders on and ignore the niggling doubts while in the groups. All my volunteering while in AA never got rid of the doubts about whether I was a "true alcoholic" or not.

It was easy for me to remain in denial in the city I was living in--there was a large group of involved young folks in and around the area. I volunteered in the local youth psychiatric ward, juvie halls, youth halfway homes--lol kinda like a Peter Pan world of alcoholism. All these teenagers and 20 somethings were convinced they had an addiction to alcohol. Some had serious mental problems. Some had serious drug addictions. Some, I'm convinced, were truly addicted to alcohol. Most, in my opinion, were kids that got in trouble and were saying anything to get out of their situation. By no means had most of these kids "hit bottom". I saw most of the kids and young adults go right back to old behaviors once out.

Others, like me, got caught up in the fellowship. Yes, I had issues with alcohol as a teenager. I had blacked out on occasion, got in a bit of trouble, and nearly lost my license not even a year after getting it. However, was I an alcoholic? Long story short, when I expressed doubts about my alcoholism to my sponsor, old-timers, and friends within the program, the mantra was "fake it until you make it". As I was deep into self-help b.s. at the time, it made sense, and I soldiered on.

That is, until I decided to do what the Big Book said, and try controlled drinking. I made the mistake of talking to my "friends" in the program about it. Then I got some lesser known sayings like "I see kids like you in the morgue all the time". Kinda sucked coming from someone who I knew from day 1 in the program.

Here I am--I've been drinking again twice as long as I was in the program. I have no problem controlling it (although to be honest I have had a few too many on occasion). Those first few years of drinking again were accompanied by horrible guilt but I'm over it, and enjoy drinking.

Almost every single friend I had during my AA stardom is long gone. One or two still hang around, although I'm convinced they just want to see a train wreck. One guy found me on facebook, and was all excited until he found out I was an atheist and/or drinking again and promptly defriended me (not sure which upset him more, we had a long talk about higher powers). I no longer fit into the beliefs of AA and its faithful members.

Another difference between the literature and the groups: the Big Book says "If anyone who is showing inability to control his drinking can do the right- about-face and drink like a gentleman, our hats are off to him." In the groups, an "alcoholic" who does this is a threat to the dogma that has evolved in AA and is treated as such. In this AA is religious in another way, i.e., its set of dogmatic beliefs that AAs these days follow.

Hence, making definitive statements about what produces "dry drunks" is, at best, a very dubious business -- don't you think?

I agree, and withdraw my statement about dry drunks.
 
Last edited:
Yes, do a search of this thread. Tinyal has posted all the relevant US court cases which have concluded that AA is a religious organization and alternatives must be presented to persons who are court-ordered for some kind of treatment or program.

I meant it in a more rhetorical sense, but thanks for the info. I'll give it a looksy. :D
 
My question is, in the USA, how can a judge order a person to go to an AA meeting, and not be breaking the first amendment of the constitution?

.

Well as in most systems it is not always coherent.

ETA: You can see a counselor CADC is you wish, the court won't pay for it.
 
Last edited:
... Yes, I had issues with alcohol as a teenager. I had blacked out on occasion, got in a bit of trouble, and nearly lost my license not even a year after getting it. However, was I an alcoholic?


That is, until I decided to do what the Big Book said, and try controlled drinking.

Here I am--I've been drinking again twice as long as I was in the program. I have no problem controlling it (although to be honest I have had a few too many on occasion).

the Big Book says "If anyone who is showing inability to control his drinking can do the right- about-face and drink like a gentleman, our hats are off to him."
Moth and flame come to mind. Social drinkers (so to speak) don't seem to worry if they might be "alcoholics".

No one knows where you are except you.

In the groups, an "alcoholic" who does this is a threat to the dogma that has evolved in AA and is treated as such.
That wasn't something I ever ran across. I'm sorry it happened to you.
 
Well as in most systems it is not always coherent.

ETA: You can see a counselor CADC is you wish, the court won't pay for it.

I am curious about this.
Does the court order AA, drug and alcohol counselling, what?
Are they specific or leave it up to the accused?
 
Originally Posted by tsig View Post
All these people witnessing that their organization isn't religious though it saved them from them selves through a higher power.



"AA is religious because it refers to God, and substituting 'higher power' for that is a mere ruse, because everyone knows that God is the only thing to which such a phrase could possibly refer."

I was referring to the similarity of AA meetings to church services.

In many Protestant churches the members are invited to give their witness, that is their story of how they found Christ and gave their life to him and he saved them from sin, in AA meetings members give their witness about how they they found a higher power, gave their life to it and were saved from alcohol.

It seems ironic to me that all the defenders of AA in this thread are exhibiting the "witnessing" behavior while telling us AA isn't religious.
 
Last edited:
You are just rehashing the same tired sophistries and straw men that have already been effectively debunked Dymanic. I see no reason to repeat the debunkings.
I hope you're not thinking about bailing on me here. Tearing your arguments to shreds has become an important part of my day.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom