Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
GodofPie, that is not what I meant at all when I started this thread. My husband and I were told by a counselor that AA was not religious.

This counselor was very staunchly pro-AA and would not accept any other form of treatment. He also said that "The Lord's Prayer," was not religious. (!)

Even after attending three meetings, and disliking them very much, my husband could not sway this counselor toward providing any other information or treatment besides AA. The counselor even lost his temper and screamed at my husband and myself--for politely questioning the program and the "steps."

This led to my question. Why do people insist that AA is not religious?

What fascinates me about this thread is the "why" more than the "whether."

The main answer that people are presenting to the "why" seems to be "because it's not religious." Yet there's quite a bit of evidence that it contains a lot of religious elements, was founded by religious people, and so forth.

So why is there such defensiveness, similar to what you encountered with the counselor? Why not just say, well, yes, it has a lot of religious elements, and I could see why some people consider it religious, and some of the advice will seem familiar if you're already comfortable with the concept of the Protestant Christian God, but here's how a non-religious person can be accepted...

Instead, the responses tend toward strong denial that it is religious, as if that would be an insult or a terrible thing if it was.

Why? Other organizations don't deny they're religious--they're proud of the fact. So being religious isn't universally a bad thing.
 
What fascinates me about this thread is the "why" more than the "whether."

The main answer that people are presenting to the "why" seems to be "because it's not religious." Yet there's quite a bit of evidence that it contains a lot of religious elements, was founded by religious people, and so forth.

So why is there such defensiveness, similar to what you encountered with the counselor? Why not just say, well, yes, it has a lot of religious elements, and I could see why some people consider it religious, and some of the advice will seem familiar if you're already comfortable with the concept of the Protestant Christian God, but here's how a non-religious person can be accepted...

Instead, the responses tend toward strong denial that it is religious, as if that would be an insult or a terrible thing if it was.

Why? Other organizations don't deny they're religious--they're proud of the fact. So being religious isn't universally a bad thing.
Er, well, because AA members do tend to know what a Religion is and what constitutes a religious ceremony. The AA GSO is a business no more or less religious than any other business; AA meetings may well, in fact almost certainly, have religious people in them. We are back to arguing if the JREF is an Atheist Organization.
 
So why is there such defensiveness, similar to what you encountered with the counselor? Why not just say, well, yes, it has a lot of religious elements, and I could see why some people consider it religious, and some of the advice will seem familiar if you're already comfortable with the concept of the Protestant Christian God, but here's how a non-religious person can be accepted...
Interesting that you omit the converse:

"So why is there such aggressiveness in asserting that it IS religious? Why not just say, well, yes, the freedom left to the individual to define "higher power" allows for such a wide range of non-religious concepts that a Protestant Christian might view AA as too secular to qualify as "religious", but here's how a devoutly religious person might fit AA's secular ideas in under his Christian worldview..."
 
Or even one minute at a time if that is what it takes. :D

I found the "one day at a time" catchphrase to be unhelpful and counterproductive in every sense of the word.

It fed into my obsession with drinking, and made me think about it even more. It made me feel like: "hey, I can drink tomorrow if I want to, I'm just going to focus on today(one day at a time)." This in turn made me feel disappointed and unrewarded every single day, because I really do want to drink on that perpetual tomorrow that always becomes today(the one day I can't drink).
 
The main answer that people are presenting to the "why" seems to be "because it's not religious."

You have pretty much summed up 46 pages of denials with that one statement.

Yet there's quite a bit of evidence that it contains a lot of religious elements, was founded by religious people, and so forth.

Exactly. And the deniers have not managed anything in the way of evidence or a supporting argument for their position.

So why is there such defensiveness, similar to what you encountered with the counselor?

Maybe it is the nature of counsellors. Alfie claims to be a counsellor and he is equally as defensive. Of course, that would be a topic for another thread.

Why not just say, well, yes, it has a lot of religious elements, and I could see why some people consider it religious, and some of the advice will seem familiar if you're already comfortable with the concept of the Protestant Christian God, but here's how a non-religious person can be accepted...

That seems pretty reasonable to me but I suspect that for the denier who has swallowed AA's blue pill it isn't that easy. Their belief system won't allow them to see AA in any negative light.

I also think they understand that if any real thought goes into their beliefs, those beliefs are going to fold like a cheap carnival tent. They seem to be very fearful that AA is not exactly what they have been told it is. Anecdote is far more important to them than any other type of evidence because it is the only one that supports their view. Of course, they have to carefully pick and choose that evidence as well.

Instead, the responses tend toward strong denial that it is religious, as if that would be an insult or a terrible thing if it was.

Nobody likes to admit they swallowed the pill. I think many of these people made a choice based on the idea that they were smart people with strong characters. They found a way to justify ignoring their own beliefs in order to "fit in" at AA. Then along come other people with the same beliefs who do not accept the same justification. In fact, these new interlopers are showing themselves to have stronger characters by refusing to disregard their own beliefs.

Much of this thread consists of the older AA members trying to justify their original justifications and see them as acceptable enough for everyone to adopt. There is a huge amount of cognative dissonance involved.

Why? Other organizations don't deny they're religious--they're proud of the fact. So being religious isn't universally a bad thing.

It is when you make the types of claims that AA does.
 
Interesting that you omit the converse:

"So why is there such aggressiveness in asserting that it IS religious?

One must ask if that is aggression caused by anti-AA feeling or by frustration over the basic dishonsesty, inaccuracy and poor logic of the deniers.

Why not just say, well, yes, the freedom left to the individual to define "higher power" allows for such a wide range of non-religious concepts that a Protestant Christian might view AA as too secular to qualify as "religious", but here's how a devoutly religious person might fit AA's secular ideas in under his Christian worldview..."

Because it isn't the devoutly religious that has to change their entire belief system, it is only the non-believer that must do that. AA can hardly be considered a secular organization.


sec·u·lar   
–adjective

1. of or pertaining to worldly things or to things that are not regarded as religious, spiritual, or sacred;
 
Last edited:
"All these people" (alcoholics) are sharing their transformation from practicing alcoholism to (hopefully) sobriety. For some that might include religion, but certainly not all.

This is a perfect example of the mentality that AA produces.

There is no transformation. How are you going to practice alcoholism?
It's not the piano.
People either drink alcohol or they do not drink alcohol. Some of the people who do drink alcohol lose all control of themselves and their lives while under the effects of the alcohol they drink.
Those people should choose not to drink alcohol.
Others who drink alcohol enjoy the effects and have no problem maintaining a healthy happy life.

Either way drinking or not drinking alcohol is as important in overall life and living as eating or not eating dog poop.

AA wants people who can not handle the effects of alcohol to believe that their entire lives till death will be either as a practicing alcoholic or as a non practicing alcoholic.
Alcoholic is always going to be in there. AA loves labels!

I am NOT an alcoholic! I am simply one of the people who can't handle the effects of alcohol and made a choice to no longer drink it.

My point being, how can you be defined as a person by what you don't do?
I don't murder people. Am I always going to be a non practicing murderer?
I don't set myself on fire. Will I have to always fight this struggle till I die?

Making the choice to not drink alcohol is rough at first like any other major life change but it is also not a badge of honor.
It's a non thing.

If all those higher powers of your own choice had a lick of sense they would explain this on day one!
 
I found the "one day at a time" catchphrase to be unhelpful and counterproductive in every sense of the word.

It fed into my obsession with drinking, and made me think about it even more. It made me feel like: "hey, I can drink tomorrow if I want to, I'm just going to focus on today(one day at a time)." This in turn made me feel disappointed and unrewarded every single day, because I really do want to drink on that perpetual tomorrow that always becomes today(the one day I can't drink).

Wow! I find that very interesting. That catch phrase was the only thing I pulled out of 2 wasted years of going to AA that I thought was worth anything.

Of course after 20 years I think of the 70s TV show when I hear it now.

But, back when I first stopped drinking alcohol that catch phrase got me to sleep at night.
I remember being in bed and thinking "tomorrow I am gonna get so freakin' ripped but I need to get a good nights sleep first."
 
Last edited:
Nobody likes to admit they swallowed the pill. I think many of these people made a choice based on the idea that they were smart people with strong characters. They found a way to justify ignoring their own beliefs in order to "fit in" at AA. Then along come other people with the same beliefs who do not accept the same justification. In fact, these new interlopers are showing themselves to have stronger characters by refusing to disregard their own beliefs.

Much of this thread consists of the older AA members trying to justify their original justifications and see them as acceptable enough for everyone to adopt. There is a huge amount of cognative dissonance involved.

Very well written!
 
Wow! I find that very interesting. That catch phrase was the only thing I pulled out of 2 wasted years of going to AA that I thought was worth anything.

Of course after 20 years I think of the 70s TV show when I hear it now.

But, back when I first stopped drinking alcohol that catch phrase got me to sleep at night.
I remember being in bed and thinking tomorrow I am gonna get so freakin' ripped but I need to get a good nights sleep first.

My habit has been a 6 pack per night or every other night for the last decade(many times the ABV on these beers is high and it makes it more like a 8-10 pack). It has been much easier for me to just tell myself: "I don't drink anymore, it was going to mess up my health eventually".

When I tried to take it "one day at a time", I became ultra obsessed with drinking every single night. I was stuck in that constant cycle of reward anticipation and let-down.

This is why there isn't one blanket solution for substance abusers. As I said before, it is a deeply personal pathology. What worked really well for you actually exacerbated my problem. :boggled:
 
Because it isn't the devoutly religious that has to change their entire belief system, it is only the non-believer that must do that.
Would you like me to link you to some sites cautioning Christians about the dangers inherent in being sucked in by the secular organization known as Alcoholics Anonymous?

sec·u·lar
–adjective

1. of or pertaining to worldly things or to things that are not regarded as religious, spiritual, or sacred;
So now recovery from alcoholism is itself religious in nature?
 
Would you like me to link you to some sites cautioning Christians about the dangers inherent in being sucked in by the secular organization known as Alcoholics Anonymous?

What you link to is irrelevent if it isn't supported by the evidence. That some religious people don't think AA is religious enough for them, doesn't make AA non-religious.

So now recovery from alcoholism is itself religious in nature?

No, but the AA model definitely is.
 
One must ask if that is aggression caused by anti-AA feeling or by frustration over the basic dishonsesty, inaccuracy and poor logic of the deniers.
One need not, however, ask about a possible range of motives among those who question the claim that AA is religious. One knows:
Nobody likes to admit they swallowed the pill. I think many of these people made a choice based on the idea that they were smart people with strong characters. They found a way to justify ignoring their own beliefs in order to "fit in" at AA. Then along come other people with the same beliefs who do not accept the same justification. In fact, these new interlopers are showing themselves to have stronger characters by refusing to disregard their own beliefs.

Much of this thread consists of the older AA members trying to justify their original justifications and see them as acceptable enough for everyone to adopt. There is a huge amount of cognative dissonance involved.
This wisdom comes as a virtue of having a stronger character. Very well written indeed. I cannot imagine how you could have composed a post that would have more transparently revealed either the strength of your character or the quality of the standards you are applying here.
 
So now recovery from alcoholism is itself religious in nature?

Do you see recovery as being religious, spiritual, or sacred*(see below)?

*I assume you understand the context being the very definition of the word secular, that the usage of the word "sacred" shouldn't be equivocated with the more secular usages of the term.

In the absence of such fallacious equivocation, I don't see it being unreasonable to call something "religious, spiritual, or sacred*" religious, or at the very least non-secular.

Recovery for some people may in fact be a religious experience, or religious in nature. I think it all depends on the individual who has recovered, or is "in recovery", however you want to phrase it.
 
Do you see recovery as being religious, spiritual, or sacred*(see below)?
Assuming that I've correctly parsed all of that*, my answer would be: No, I don't see recovery itself as inherently religious, spiritual, or sacred. Hence, AA's primary purpose, as stated in its preamble: "to stay sober and help other alcoholics to achieve sobriety", clearly makes it a secular organization by the above definition.

*As the nature of my question was, I thought, quite obviously rhetorical, and as its implication already contained the answer to your question, I cannot help but wonder if I have made some parsing error. Feel free to rephrase if you think it necessary.
 
One need not, however, ask about a possible range of motives among those who question the claim that AA is religious. One knows:

This wisdom comes as a virtue of having a stronger character. Very well written indeed. I cannot imagine how you could have composed a post that would have more transparently revealed either the strength of your character or the quality of the standards you are applying here.

I think you misunderstand. I have never tried to join AA. I am not an alcoholic, so why would I? I am not one of the people with stronger characters I am speaking of.

"Stronger character" might not be the best way to put it, "Less willing to allow their views to be trivialized" maybe more accurate.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom