Pup
Philosopher
- Joined
- Dec 21, 2004
- Messages
- 6,679
GodofPie, that is not what I meant at all when I started this thread. My husband and I were told by a counselor that AA was not religious.
This counselor was very staunchly pro-AA and would not accept any other form of treatment. He also said that "The Lord's Prayer," was not religious. (!)
Even after attending three meetings, and disliking them very much, my husband could not sway this counselor toward providing any other information or treatment besides AA. The counselor even lost his temper and screamed at my husband and myself--for politely questioning the program and the "steps."
This led to my question. Why do people insist that AA is not religious?
What fascinates me about this thread is the "why" more than the "whether."
The main answer that people are presenting to the "why" seems to be "because it's not religious." Yet there's quite a bit of evidence that it contains a lot of religious elements, was founded by religious people, and so forth.
So why is there such defensiveness, similar to what you encountered with the counselor? Why not just say, well, yes, it has a lot of religious elements, and I could see why some people consider it religious, and some of the advice will seem familiar if you're already comfortable with the concept of the Protestant Christian God, but here's how a non-religious person can be accepted...
Instead, the responses tend toward strong denial that it is religious, as if that would be an insult or a terrible thing if it was.
Why? Other organizations don't deny they're religious--they're proud of the fact. So being religious isn't universally a bad thing.
