Why do anti depressants make some people suicidal?

Wow - and this thread was already split for a derail??

Well, I may be ignored, but will weigh in on the original OP anyway just to amuse myself.

The reason that makes most sense to me is that the underlying biological, cellular, chemical, genetic, whatever reasons for depression differ from person to person, and therefore the SSRI's will have different effects (and different adverse effects) in different people.

Yes, we know how SSRIs work, in that we know that they prevent reuptake of released serotonin. But it is also true that we don't know WHY this alleviates depression in many people that take SSRIs. We also know that alleviation of depression isn't seen for 7-14 days after initiation of SSRI treatment - so it probably isn't the immediate effect of blocking serotonin reuptake that is doing the trick (serotonin reuptake blocking happens immediately when taking SSRIs).
I agree absolutely! The actual time can be 5-6 weeks which is the receptor turn over time. It is an imbalance in the system that is at fault. Over activity in depression, under activity is schizophrenia.
We also know that excess serotonin in the synapse (from not being taken back up by the cell) allows prolonged receptor binding (by serotonin) on the next neuron - which leads to a decrease (internalization) of the serotonin receptors that are on the surface of that cell. So maybe this is the effect that does the trick - except that this oughta happen in the first few days of treatment, not two weeks later. We also know that the autoreceptors on the serotonin-releasing cell are also being exposed to excess serotonin, and giving a "stop releasing serotonin" signal back to that 1st cell. Maybe that's it, but doubtful again, as this would happen quickly. Then there is the idea that receptors for serotonin on those cells that are affected by the prolonged exposure are themselves releasing other neurotransmitters in other brain areas - creating an amazing array of possible downstream effects when you tamper with just the serotonin system.
it is the combo of all three, if I am a person who has over activity from over sensitivity to the serotonin and the system regulates over time then it works.

I am very lucky I had a response the first day (other than the GI ones), the multiple thought tracks in my head became one. No more three thought trains all at the same time. However my sleep cycle took about two weeks to improve, my OCD about six weeks, however the depressive symptoms took about six months to improve.
Yes, we know the immediate action of SSRIs at the level of the serotonin transporter (that is blocked by SSRIs) but we don't know all the downstream effects, and we certainly don't know why continuous blocking of reuptake somehow decreases feelings of depression 2 weeks later.

And let's not even start on the way SSRIs treat other mood disorders such as PMDD, which responds much sooner to SSRI treatment than does major depression.

Long story short - everybody is different - on very basic levels - and some people are going to be very happy campers on SSRIs, ready to cope with all life can throw at them, while others aren't going to respond so ideally.


With three hundred plus neurotransmitters, each mental illness is very different. Some just happen to involve some major pathways.
 
Last edited:
... the underlying biological, cellular, chemical, genetic, whatever reasons...

Thanks for this post, Lilith. But I have to say that the mechanisms by which chemicals affect cells -- especially those in the brain -- are still outside my grasp. I want to fully understand this but don't know where to begin.

Can anyone recommend a good book about neurochemistry? I'll take either a popularizing science book or a textbook, whichever is appropriate. And would I need to read about regular chemistry and then biochemistry first? I haven't taken chemistry since high school, and I don't remember most of it.

(I'm still hoping that I can prove that I'm right in this thread. ;) )

Thanks, folks.
 
Can anyone recommend a good book about neurochemistry?

I can't think of a good book offhand, but for someone with not much biology/chemistry/biochemistry background, I recommend that you pick up almost any biopsychology textbook and read their chapter on psychopharmocology. You may have to look up terms along the way, but if you go through it carefully, you'll get what you want. After getting those basics, you can read a more advanced textbook and get most of the info you want.

Feel free to ask me anything along the way - I'll do what I can. I teach this stuff.
 
As far as fear of flying itself goes; a difficult one, and I do not personally know what the best therapy is, though I assume one could treat it as one does treat panic attacks -- and medications (IMvHO) do not have a long-term place in treating panic attacks, only in the short-term; the best thing for panic attacks would be a long-term Cognitive Behavourial Therapy program of some kind geared towards you as an individual and to the exact problem. But that's only my opinion, see a good behavioural psychologist for what they think. Again, IMvHO, SSRI's are simply not indicated for fear of flying, for many different reasons (it's like using an extremely inaccurate blunderbuss to try killing a mosquito; SSRI's also take far too long to tackle such an immediate, context-specific problem; and I just don't think they even really deal with such a problem).

I can only contribute to this issue as an interested patient, but I think the only medication that would be indicated in cases like fear of flying would be benzodiazepines like Xanax or Valium. They come, however, with the very dangerous side-effect of being highly addictive, which for aviophobia shouldn't be much of a problem, unless you fly several days a week. Still, it is dangerous, especially if there is a history of drug dependence.

SSRI's and other anti-depressants do have their place in the treatment of chronic anxiety, not least because depression is often comorbid with it, but they certainly won't help with rarely occuring panic attacks.
 
My problem is that my GP (who I left after this event) is not a quack and I wonder how many others are prescribing SSRIs inappropriately.

I would say: many. You only have to look at the hundreds of forums devoted to protracted withdrawal problems from SSRIs (an under-reported but very serious issue) to see how many GPs will hand out ADs to almost anyone, for almost anything. Now of course, we're talking about online claims, so you have to allow for liars, trolls and those in denial, and not treat all of this as actual data - but it's almost certainly fair to say that a large number of GPs prescribe inappropriately, and this is certainly backed up by my own experience. People I know well, and who have no history of anxiety or depression, have been offered (and sometimes taken) SSRIs for carpal tunnel syndrome, IBS, insomnia, loss of appetite, etc. And, in Britain at least, they will be commonly be offered to you as soon as you complain to a GP about feeling even slightly depressed, no questions asked.

Not saying that SSRIs should be banned or anything stupid like that - they're potentially horrible drugs, but they're probably the best we've got at the moment for serious, life-threatening depression. The problem would appear to be that many GPs listen to the pharma line (which hasn't shifted all that far from the early 90s line that these are safe, non-habit-forming cure-alls) and aren't necessarily aware that in fact, they're very potent and unpredictable drugs that can sometimes cause terrible problems up to and including suicide, either at the beginning of treatment or after discontinuation. Rather than prescribing with care, and making sure to follow up, too many GPs chuck them around and then treat you like some kind of idiot when you run into problems on (or off) them. It was bad enough when, six months after discontinuing an SSRI I'd been left on for ten years (and which had long since stopped working), I presented with a whole raft of brand-new and utterly nightmarish mental and physical symptoms and was told it was my "original depression returning" - when the same thing happened to some of those people who'd originally been put on SSRIs off-label, who then protested that they didn't have depression in the first place, they were effectively treated as hysterical.

Many people can take them for a short while and be helped immeasurably, of course, but taking these things for life is not an option, as they're almost certain to poop out on you within ten years - and after long-term use, coming off them is not easy to say the least. This may be the lesser of two evils for someone experiencing very severe bouts of depression which MUST be treated RIGHT NOW, but (at the risk of using alarmist terminology) we may be sitting on something of a timebomb as thousands of people who don't need the damn things in the first place refill their prescription month after month. Better and more honest information from pharma to GPs and psychs would go a long way towards solving this problem. Since we don't yet know precisely what effect these drugs have on the brain / liver / endocrine system / etc. over the long term, and the anecdotal evidence isn't pretty, prescribing only where necessary strikes me as common sense (and that's before you get to the potential suicide risk). Instead, they are heavily marketed and as a result, massively overprescribed.
 
And of course, if the damn Scientologists shut their damn mouths, this issue could be discussed sensibly in public, but that goes without saying.
 
Another major issue when it comes to overreliance on meds comes in with funding. I've heard from people in a number of places that they can get their insurance to pay for a drug far more easily than to pay for a block of CBT. I'm going through it now, in fact. My doctor thinks I'm an excellent candidate for CBT, but treatment in the public system is not available to me. Since I'm currently underemployed and have no insurance through work, I can't afford the therapy.

That isn't to say I haven't benefited from the medication. But is medication alone the most appropriate course? I doubt it. Meanwhile, a lot of people who could probably recover with therapy alone get meds alone because that's all they have access to.

Of course, the drug I'm taking is not covered on the provincial drug plan either, and I pay for it out of pocket, but it's still about 1/5 the cost of the CBT. (A number of antidepressant drugs are covered, just not mine.)

(This comes less than a year after the provincial government announced, with much fanfare, a new, bigger and better commitment to mental health. Bahh. Sometimes cynicism is justified.)
 
Another major issue when it comes to overreliance on meds comes in with funding. .... Since I'm currently underemployed and have no insurance through work, I can't afford the therapy.


This is an excellent point, and very important. But it's not going to change without a massive cultural change.

In Germany, it is relatively easy in all the medium and big towns and cities to be able to get prescribed therapy, meaning that the health-insurance will pay for it; not enough of it, but then there's never enough. In any case, anyone needing psych therapy is in relatively good luck when in Germany. The Germans believe in a form of cognitive therapy, rather than CBT, which is a bit of a pity, but even so, better relatively speaking than a hell of a lot of other places.

In Britain, you have all the problems with the NHS being chopped up region by region and also semi-privatised. Bloody stupid and wasteful of taxpayers' money; a fully subsidised and good health system that covers everyone is far cheaper to the taxpayer than the kind of mixed crap you have in Britain, where bribing the private sector not to bitch too much has really buggered up the taxpayer, but then of course Britain is heaven on Earth compared to the USA.

In the USA, you have 15 % of the population without any access at all in any way to health-care. Then even those who do have access often don't get access to the psychological therapy they need.

So don't blame GP's too much; they actually want to help their patients, and can't provide psychological therapy, so they provide medications instead; they do what they can.


(This comes less than a year after the provincial government announced, with much fanfare, a new, bigger and better commitment to mental health. Bahh. Sometimes cynicism is justified.)


Wide-spread political activism and cultural change is much more justified than cynicism, with all respect. But it takes a huge amount of time, heartbreak and energy, granted.
 
So don't blame GP's too much; they actually want to help their patients, and can't provide psychological therapy, so they provide medications instead; they do what they can.

Oh sure, to clarify: I'm not blaming GPs necessarily (or rather, I'm not blaming the good ones). They're in an impossible position - not only for the reasons you list, but because they can't be expected to stay up to date on every single drug they prescribe.
 
Last edited:
Oh sure, to clarify: I'm not blaming GPs necessarily (or rather, I'm not blaming the good ones). They're in an impossible position - not only for the reasons you list, but because they can't be expected to stay up to date on every single drug they prescribe.

On that last point, I think it's reasonable to expect them to be at least somewhat informed of semi-recent news.

On the other hand, here in the US there are plenty of locations where GPs are in a tight spot because their patients expect their doctor to solve their ills with a prescription. Between the crappiness of the healthcare system and the litigiousness of some types of individuals, I'd certainly agree that lots of physicians are stuck between a rock and a lawsuit.
 
Wide-spread political activism and cultural change is much more justified than cynicism, with all respect. But it takes a huge amount of time, heartbreak and energy, granted.

Oh, I completely agree with that. What brings out my inner cynic is holding up the sweeping you-all-should-be-applauding-us statements from the government about how much they were going to do, against what they actually did (some staff reshuffling at the hospital psych departments, some money to suicide prevention campaigns, and a good but short-lived PSA campaign -- no significant improvements in access to treatment for anyone not an immediate danger to themselves).

:bandaid: :bandaid: :bandaid: :bandaid: :bandaid: :bandaid: :bandaid: :bandaid: :bandaid: :bandaid:

What grates more is that I recently moved here from Ontario, where CBT would have been covered.

Ah well, that's what advocacy and political activism are for. Down with complacency!
 
Last edited:
--> RandFan:

at the risk of repeating myself, maybe you should learn something about both science and psychiatry before making so many unsubstantiated assertions on both. Many of your assertions are pure woo. But here, they're simply a long derail as well.

There is a thread already for you on exactly those aspects, split off from this one.

I see no need to reply to your comments on this thread at all; go to the other thread, as far as I am concerned. You should also read up on actual clinical practice. Would you like some good references? If so, ask on that other thread and I will be happy to reply there.
Being arrogant and not responding to the points I'm making really isn't very helpful. If all you are going to do is condescend to me then I'm just going to put you on ignore. I've apologized for my behavior but to be sure I was not the one who started neither did I treat you the way you have treated me. You have been extremely rude. Whatever I've done none of that excuses your behavior.

I'm not asking for an apology but a change in attitude would be helpful. A logical argument would be even better.

Let's have a discussion. Let's start from the beginning. Are you capable of leaving your ego behind and discussing this?

RandFan
 
...maybe you should learn something about both science and psychiatry...
Maybe you could actually pick something from post 73 and rebut it if I really don't know anything about science or psychiatry.

ETA: If you prefer to discuss this in the other thread that would be fine.

Just check your ego at the door. I will do the same.
 
Last edited:
The reason that makes most sense to me is that the underlying biological, cellular, chemical, genetic, whatever reasons for depression differ from person to person, and therefore the SSRI's will have different effects (and different adverse effects) in different people.
Do we objectively know what those differences are? Is there a blood test that could identify any or all of these differences? BTW, I concede that some of the same problems are inherent to general medicine however there are tests that can be performed to determine a great number of variables.

Yes, we know how SSRIs work, in that we know that they prevent reuptake of released serotonin. But it is also true that we don't know WHY this alleviates depression in many people that take SSRIs.
Empiricism, understanding the mechanism. You are correct and this is the one of my complaints.


We also know that alleviation of depression isn't seen for 7-14 days after initiation of SSRI treatment - so it probably isn't the immediate effect of blocking serotonin reuptake that is doing the trick (serotonin reuptake blocking happens immediately when taking SSRIs). We also know that excess serotonin in the synapse (from not being taken back up by the cell) allows prolonged receptor binding (by serotonin) on the next neuron - which leads to a decrease (internalization) of the serotonin receptors that are on the surface of that cell. So maybe this is the effect that does the trick - except that this oughta happen in the first few days of treatment, not two weeks later. We also know that the autoreceptors on the serotonin-releasing cell are also being exposed to excess serotonin, and giving a "stop releasing serotonin" signal back to that 1st cell. Maybe that's it, but doubtful again, as this would happen quickly. Then there is the idea that receptors for serotonin on those cells that are affected by the prolonged exposure are themselves releasing other neurotransmitters in other brain areas - creating an amazing array of possible downstream effects when you tamper with just the serotonin system.

Yes, we know the immediate action of SSRIs at the level of the serotonin transporter (that is blocked by SSRIs) but we don't know all the downstream effects, and we certainly don't know why continuous blocking of reuptake somehow decreases feelings of depression 2 weeks later.

And let's not even start on the way SSRIs treat other mood disorders such as PMDD, which responds much sooner to SSRI treatment than does major depression.

Long story short - everybody is different - on very basic levels - and some people are going to be very happy campers on SSRIs, ready to cope with all life can throw at them, while others aren't going to respond so ideally.
Your post highlights a number of issues that conform to my originial critisicm. Thanks.
 
The following is based on Criticisms of the DSM (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders)

  • In regards to my point about empiricism and psychiatry.
"...the existing taxonomy fails to use an integrated evolutionary approach in the conditions it classifies. That is, it is "not guided by any theory about the structure and functioning of normal minds," [44] and fails to make distinctions between those conditions which are "malfunctions" in the cognitive machinery and those which are evolved psychological adaptations which are functioning normally and were evolutionarily adaptive, but cause problems in the modern-day environment (i.e. sexual jealousy, aggression, anxiety). These distinctions have real implications for how conditions are diagnosed and treated. [45]"

  • In regards to my point about self-reporting (symptom-based diagnostics) and the difficulty of taking into account the context of environment.
"It has been argued that purely symptom-based diagnostic criteria fail to adequately take into account the context in which a person is living, and whether there is real internal disorder of an individual or simply a response to their situation.[41][42] It is claimed that the use of distress and disability as additional criteria for many disorders has not solved this false-positives problem, because the level of impairment is often not correlated with symptom counts and can stem from various individual and social factors.[43]"



These aren't posted with the intent of proving my POV so much as to illustrate that the criticism I have posited are not mine alone but shared by others in the scientific community.
 
Last edited:
Review - DSM-IV by Jeffrey S. Poland, Ph.D.

"To begin, nowhere in these 45 chapters is serious attention given to the sorts of foundational issues of concern to the critics of the DAM (e.g., concept of mental disorder, commitment to an theoretical categorical approach, appropriateness of a medical model, etc.) It is a serious shortcoming of the process of development to ignore or give short shrift to these matters in light of the broad ranging dissatisfaction with the DAM in clinical practice...

...the deepest problem with DAM categories in general is their lack of demonstrated construct and predictive validity. Volume 1 of the Source book provides little evidence that such issues were seriously addressed, let alone the issue of whether an adequate research base exists to validate the categories. It is simply not the case, for example, that systematic reviews of treatment efficacy research were conducted for each of the disorders, nor were systematic studies of construct validity conducted for each DAM-IV category."

For context, these posts support Lilith's posts as to our ability to understand (diagnose) the brain sufficiently to understand why anti-depressants cause depression beyond the fact that human phenotypes vary.
 
Last edited:
Being arrogant
doesn't help you at all, I agree.

If all you are going to do is condescend to me then I'm just going to put you on ignore.
Your dishonesty in response was detailed before, previous post in this thread; since it was repetitive, I couldn't care less what you do.

but to be sure I was not the one who started

A lie.

Are you capable of leaving your ego behind and discussing this?

You are projecting again, RandFan. I repeat: you obviously nothing about psychiatry and damned little about science overall, you've cherry-picked a couple of citations of which you know nothing of the context or background, you have had 3 professionals who work in the actual field or assiociated fields try putting you straight as to what happens in practice, whom you've busily ignored, you've been dismally ignorant, rude and sheerly emo- and woo-addicted, and I won't be feeding your ego by letting you derail this particular thread. You're way off-topic -- take it all to Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology if you are being honest in the slightest, but otherwise, bugger off as far as I'm concerned.

This thread is about "Why do anti depressants make some people suicidal?" I realise you don't have a clue about the topic, but that does not mean we need to indulge your ego in your wanting to spoil it for everyone else.
 
Last edited:
Finally, according to The American Psychiatric Publishing Textbook of Consultation the DSM is currently a symptom based classification system. System based is self-reporting. This is the same that all doctors use with the exception that other medical disiplines rely heavily on objective diagnostic tools such as blood tests, x-rays, CT scans, MRI's, urinalysis, fecal tests and many, many more.

Also to GreNME's question about brain imaging and to further butress my claim the APPTC says: "In these studies, diagnostic comparisons with functional imaging may be sensitive for psychiatric illnes but lack specificity for DSM symptom-based diagnosis."
 
In an interesting news report today a mother is taking action against a doctor for prescribing SSRIs to her 16 year old daughter.
http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,24063150-2702,00.html


Hmmm, I guess that had to happen sometime. We know SSRI's can be awfully counter-productive for teens sometimes, since their brains are still developing, they have hormonal swings and rushes, and so on, so their brains & bodies react differently to those of adults, and of course since SRRI's were the magic bullet against depression, and teens often suffer from depression simply caused by, well, life and life's changes, let alone anything else, then I guess it was just one of those nasty accidents waiting to happen.

Oh, I completely agree with that. What brings out my inner cynic is holding up the sweeping you-all-should-be-applauding-us statements from the government about how much they were going to do, against what they actually did ....... Ah well, that's what advocacy and political activism are for. Down with complacency!

In full agreement with you. I can't fault you for being cynical whatsoever in that area. But let's see what can be done to make things better inthe whole politics of health-care.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom