Why do anti depressants make some people suicidal?

Cainkane1

Philosopher
Joined
Jul 16, 2005
Messages
9,011
Location
The great American southeast
When I was on prozac I though of suicide every waking minute of every day. I felt ok physically except for the impotence it causes and I was cool and calm as a cucumber. Suicide was on my mind day in and day out until I quit taking that stuff. I tried other medications but with similar problems. You read about this effect all the time and even when anti depressants are advertised this is included as a hazard of taking the medicine. Why?
 
How old were you? My understanding is that suicidal thoughts related to antidepressants most commonly strike adolescents and young adults.
 
Because many anti-depressants are also downers (in the loosest sense of the term). Things like Prozac are not a good treatment for someone who is depressed due to behavioral, habitual, or emotional issues. Prozac, Celexa, Xanax, and other similar drugs only have reasonable efficacy in cases where there seems to be a brain chemistry factor to the depression (or, in some cases, bipolar). Naturally, the trouble is in being able to tell which is the case with people, or whether the case is a mixture of more than one factor.

I was diagnosed bipolar about ten years ago, and for a while I had a cocktail of things I was taking to help keep the "ups" fairly low and the "downs" less deep. It partially helped, but in reality what helped the most was changing my behavior, my diet (mostly less drinking), and actually learning to approach and interpret things going on in my life in ways that weren't immediately assuming the worst and predicting destruction. It sounds simple to do, but in reality developing those behaviors into habits instead of willful attempts to replace old behavior was very difficult and took time. I no longer take any of the meds, but I do still sometimes get those old feelings trying to creep back in-- though I've learned to recognize them and now know to adjust my sleep and exercise schedule to keep my habits more positive.

Back to the point, though: drugs like Prozac work because they dull certain receptors of the brain temporarily. The side-effect of that for people who are depressed is that they feel less depressed. The side-effect for many other people is one similar to that from quaaludes.
 
Back to the point, though: drugs like Prozac work because they dull certain receptors of the brain temporarily. The side-effect of that for people who are depressed is that they feel less depressed. The side-effect for many other people is one similar to that from quaaludes.


Actually, no one knows why SSRI's work, but I'm pretty sure it's not by dulling receptors. What it does is to make more neurotransmitters available to the receptors -- exactly HOW that causes depression to abate is unknown.
 
Adding to what GreNME said (though I disagree with GreNME about how SSRI's and similar work):

  • - sometimes depression is (for example; there are other examples too) part of Bipolar Syndrome. Giving SSRI's to a bipolar without first medicating the bipolar syndrome itself is often a very bad idea; it often only makes the bipolar person feel far worse. In bipolar syndrome, medicate the syndrome first (i.e. using things like risperdol, haloperidol and so on), before medicating any other problems. Often, medicating the bipolar syndrome first will get rid of the worst of the depression.

    So, first of all, it really has to be worked out if the depression is:
    1. situational depression
    2. clinical depression
    3. or depression (or similar to it) caused by other syndromes
    Then and only then start medicating; never simply medicate for depression first, but work out what the best diagnosis is first.
    .
  • - sometimes some people, even though correctly medicated, have paradox reactions. That is, they react the opposite of what is intended with the med.
    .
  • - sometimes there are interactions with other chemicals, hormones, meds etc.
 
Last edited:
Magic.

Okay, there is mixed evidence on the issue of SSRI antidepressants causing increased suicidally, but a link has largely been established.

I don't know if anyone has an exact mechanism for why that is though.

But each medication effects people differently, and a lot of them have similar side effects.

And, of course, the exact mechanisms for how SSRI and other antidepressants alleviate depression aren't exactly clear either :p .

Like for me, I have been on many different drugs and we always up the dosage. I don't have any side effects, but I also don't feel any effects from the different medications either. Drugs effect everyone differently, and you have to find the ones that works best for you.
 
Last edited:
Actually, no one knows why SSRI's work, but I'm pretty sure it's not by dulling receptors. What it does is to make more neurotransmitters available to the receptors -- exactly HOW that causes depression to abate is unknown.

That's misleading. Pharmacology knows how it works, there is still some uncertainty as to why it works (for depression) a majority of the time linky. The problem, though, is that they have side-effects due to how they work, which is the reuptake blocking of sarotonin. While the dulling effect is most transparent in the sexual dysfunction (PSSD) PDF journal article, it is at least anecdotally related to apathy syndrome link 1, link 2.

Adding to what GreNME said (though I disagree with GreNME about how SSRI's and similar work):

To be fair, I should admit that I'm aware their intended usage is not meant to dull senses or emotions. Instead, I'm more convinced by journals I've read from studies on the effects of SSRIs (and MAOIs) in particular with regard to amotivational or apathetic conditions in people who are taking them like this.

  • - sometimes depression is (for example; there are other examples too) part of Bipolar Syndrome. Giving SSRI's to a bipolar without first medicating the bipolar syndrome itself is often a very bad idea; it often only makes the bipolar person feel far worse. In bipolar syndrome, medicate the syndrome first (i.e. using things like risperdol, haloperidol and so on), before medicating any other problems. Often, medicating the bipolar syndrome first will get rid of the worst of the depression.

    So, first of all, it really has to be worked out if the depression is:
    1. situational depression
    2. clinical depression
    3. or depression (or similar to it) caused by other syndromes
    Then and only then start medicating; never simply medicate for depression first, but work out what the best diagnosis is first.

This was laid out far better than I could have put it. Quoted for truth. :)

  • - sometimes some people, even though correctly medicated, have paradox reactions. That is, they react the opposite of what is intended with the med.

Yepper, adolescents and children are notorious for having this type of reaction. Not just to SSRIs, too.

  • - sometimes there are interactions with other chemicals, hormones, meds etc.

Again I agree vigorously. The first thing I've had to stress to others I've known who have gone on SSRIs for even temporary treatments was discontinue alcohol consumption for the duration of treatment. That sounds excessive and it's definitely a habit that can be difficult to some, but the risks aren't worth it. For most people alcohol will just cause the liver to work extra hard to process the chemicals, thus rendering them ineffective. For some, though, the side effects can be detrimental and make a depression worse.

The best thing to try to do if you go on an SSRI treatment is to get yourself on a semi-regular exercise schedule. Even twice or three times a week will give you way more positive results and can in many cases help to shorten the time you have to take SSRIs (or, in those who may need them continually, to help lower the necessary dosage). It may sound corny, but it really does work.
 
Here's another hypothesis about why antidepressants lead to suicide although not in this specific description and case.

Patient's with Major Depression have low energy, significant low self esteem and are very depressed. They often are not motivated to do anything. They are suicidal but just don't have the energy to attempt it...now imagine the anti-depressant working early in the process...the energy is returning but the Depressed patient still feels very depressed. Now, they have the "energy" to act on their thoughts.
 
Or IOW, never give SSRI's to an alkie who is still drinking, and to those whom you do give SSRI's, every second day chase them around the streets for a few miles using an electro cattleprod for incentive, and that way you'll both end up with good exercise and cardiovascular-system health, both prescriber and recipient.
________

Adding: GreNME is absolutely right. All the relevant studies show exercise to be very damned helpful indeed.
 
Last edited:
Sorry. My mind works in strange ways. My sense of humour is not .... everyone's cup of tea.
 
Short answer: the human brain is tremendously complex and mind-altering drugs affect each person differently.

This message brought to you by Captain Obvious.
 
Gurdur: that actually falls about at the baseline for me and most of my friends, so no worries on my end.

Another anecdote: I've long since been off my cocktail of Celexa, Depakote, and Seroquil-- the circumstances by which this happened still have yet to be explained by medical science (because I sustained massive head trauma, recovered, and stopped displaying symptoms for two years)-- but now I can head off slipping into depression by upping my (admittedly slacker) exercise schedule.

The best chemicals for helping the body cope with depression, stress, and anxiety are free and available to almost everyone. Cattleprods sold separately.
 
Gurdur: that actually falls about at the baseline for me and most of my friends, so no worries on my end.

Thanks. I guess I've just known too many who did bump themselves off, and others simply doing themselves in veeerry slowly. It makes me kinda rough in sense of humour. Counter-reaction.

The best chemicals for helping the body cope with depression, stress, and anxiety are free and available to almost everyone. Cattleprods sold separately.

Good advice, well-said, and I agree with you, but only to a point, only to a point. A full-blown bipolar spree is ..... dangerous to everyone else around as well as to the bipolar him/her self, owing to the insiduous behaviour that builds up complications over time, and is only amenable to bigtime drugs, i.e. haloperidol or similar. Depressive manic or just manic; someone commented to me that bipolars get depressive in manic phases when they don't get what they want, which seems to me as good an analysis as any. A lot of people, including many healthcare professionals, are terribly ignorant of the fact that bipolars can be both depressive and manic. Most civilians have no idea what mania really is, or how terribly rational it can seem, and why a test of reasonableness instead of rationality applied to looking at behaviour overall and over a long length of time is so necessary.

Or genuine straight depression, suicidal. Strong meds only answer.

So I guess I'm just saying that for some, sometimes, meds are the only answer. Or as another friend of mine once said, just whack 'em in each buttock, one with diazapam, one with haloperidol, and that way at least you (the whacker, not the whackee) get a night's sleep for once. Well, so does the whackee. So you both get a good night's sleep, necessary for all that jogging with cattleprod in the morning.
 
Here's another hypothesis about why antidepressants lead to suicide although not in this specific description and case.

Patient's with Major Depression have low energy, significant low self esteem and are very depressed. They often are not motivated to do anything. They are suicidal but just don't have the energy to attempt it...now imagine the anti-depressant working early in the process...the energy is returning but the Depressed patient still feels very depressed. Now, they have the "energy" to act on their thoughts.

I have also read this, and it is a significant issue that a good doctor will watch out for.
 
Thanks. I guess I've just known too many who did bump themselves off, and others simply doing themselves in veeerry slowly. It makes me kinda rough in sense of humour. Counter-reaction.

Totally understood. I know what it's like to be in that kind of place mentally (suicidal) but I've been lucky.

Good advice, well-said, and I agree with you, but only to a point, only to a point. A full-blown bipolar spree is ..... dangerous to everyone else around as well as to the bipolar him/her self, owing to the insiduous behaviour that builds up complications over time, and is only amenable to bigtime drugs, i.e. haloperidol or similar. Depressive manic or just manic; someone commented to me that bipolars get depressive in manic phases when they don't get what they want, which seems to me as good an analysis as any. A lot of people, including many healthcare professionals, are terribly ignorant of the fact that bipolars can be both depressive and manic. Most civilians have no idea what mania really is, or how terribly rational it can seem, and why a test of reasonableness instead of rationality applied to looking at behaviour overall and over a long length of time is so necessary.

This is very much true. I recall going through manic phases and being reacted to by most people as if I seemed rational, just a bit ramped up. Of course, these people weren't seeing that I was going days without sleeping eating only when I remembered to. It's really weird to look back and see just how unreasonable and irrational you were being from your own introspection.

Or genuine straight depression, suicidal. Strong meds only answer.

Sometimes. I've recently lost a family member to suicide, but I'm unsure how much meds would have helped in his situation as opposed to some more direct personal attention. Still, it's situational and there really isn't a good equation to identify and treat it with full success (yet).

So I guess I'm just saying that for some, sometimes, meds are the only answer. Or as another friend of mine once said, just whack 'em in each buttock, one with diazapam, one with haloperidol, and that way at least you (the whacker, not the whackee) get a night's sleep for once. Well, so does the whackee. So you both get a good night's sleep, necessary for all that jogging with cattleprod in the morning.

True dat. I definitely agree that it's not going to be the same for each person, and sometimes meds are the most appropriate treatment. I focus on first promoting physical health in order to establish a sort of control environment in a person instead of all the wild variables that partying and similar behaviors tend to introduce.
 
From a purely anecdotal point of view, I've always just suspected, as suggested above, that it enables previously suicidal people to carry out what they already intended. I've been on SSRIs (well, SNRI technically) for some years. Venlafaxine mostly, as the first I tried (Cipralex) didn't work too well. Admittedly, I'm not on them for depression, but I have never felt suicidal at all. It's never even occurred to me as an option.

I think that could be quite telling, actually. People with anxiety issues are prescribed SSRIs (and SNRIs) as well as depressed people. Does the apparent increased risk of suicide also occur in those patients who have no diagnosis of depression, but are on the same drugs that seem to enable suicide?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom