Um, the scientific method is trial and error. Sorry.
What part of psychiatry borders on the woo? It is what it is, in one hundred years it will be better, that does not make it woo.
Some doctors who tak etime getting decent histories where possible are very good at diagnosis prior to treatment, excluding those who lie to get anxiolytics.
Hey DD.
I'll try and change my tone and approach. I will be a bit less authoritative and obnoxious. Now, some of this might be a bit patronizing and I'm sorry. I'm going to try and keep it to a minimum.
My apologies to everyone.
No. I'm sorry, but with all due respect I would not say that trial and error
is the scientific method. I can't agree with that. Now, I could be wrong so let me state why I say that and I promise to read your rebuttals carefully. I only ask that you carefully read and consider what I have to say.
Fair enough?
Trial and error is what humans have always had from the beginning.
Long before modern medicine people would use trial and error to figure out which plants would alleviate pain and discomfort and which ones wouldn't. Sometimes they WERE right and sometimes they only thought they were right. The Asians tried acupuncture and it seemed to worke for them. In fact it seemed to work so well that it's with us to this day and people swear by it. This lead to lots and lots and lots of false beliefs about what was effective and what wasn't.
Then something extraordinary happened. Progress became accelerated. We have progressed more in the last 100 years than in all of the prior thousands of years before that. And the previous 100 years the same is true.
What happened? Well there was a lot of steps but I'll go over the two most important.
First was
empiricism. The Ancient Greeks began to focus more on observing mechanisms to deduce what was happening and why rather simply trying things. Or simply beliving things based on supernatural explanations. This was a departure from simple trial and error. Just because sticking a needle into someone seemed to work to alleviate pain didn't mean that it was the needle that alleviated the pain (my example not theirs). One would need to try and understand the underlying mechanism of why it worked before one assumed that it did work.
Second was
control. Removing the bias and preconceived notions of the individual performing the experiments. This was absolutely critical to the success of the scientific method. If you don't know why this is true then I would recommend reading
Blind Experiment.
In all sincerity and without any attempt to be provocative or belittling I must say again, trial and error is decidedly not the scientific method. Yes, there is trial and error inherent in the scientific method but to simply state that trial and error are the scientific method is to fail to appreciate the incredible accomplishments of those wonderful Greeks and the contributions of the philosophers and scientists that were to follow.
- I will say again. I value psychology and psychiatry.
- Both have benefited myself and my father a great deal.
- I would go back to a licensed and trained therapist should I find the need to do so again.
I would not say Psychiatry IS woo because the researchers do in fact conduct legitimate scientific research and observation. They are following as much as they can the scientific method. They do in fact put into place as many controls as they possibly can.
Why do I say it borders on woo? Because A.) Psychiatry does not, at this time, have the level of empirical control and diagnostic tools that other disciplines in the medical field do and B.) There is so much that we don't know about the brain. C.) Psychiatrists are human. The fewer controls and the less empirical knowledge that we have about any given subject then the greater the human element will intrude into the research and treatment.
I hope this helps and again I apologize for my rude behavior.
RandFan