Why do anti depressants make some people suicidal?

I've conceded that there exists diagnostic tests in psychiatry. My point is that these are still in their infancy and not definitive at this time in the diagnoses of many if not most mental ailments.

Again, you know nothing about them. I'll bet you can't even name five such standardized long tests off-hand. And I'll bet heavily you can't even describe the developmental history of say the single most used long test without looking hurriedly it all up.

But never mind. :p You'll just pull assertions like "not definitive at this time in the diagnoses" out of your ass. Of course, giving actual evidence seems to be a fully foreign concept to you.

Are you again talking about your assertions and special pleading? Appeals to authority? Do you have something more than that?

Good stuff, coming from someone who appeals constantly to prejudice and ignorance. :p
 
And I'll bet heavily you can't even describe the developmental history of say the single most used long test without looking hurriedly it all up.
Special pleading.

Of course, giving actual evidence seems to be a fully foreign concept to you.
As if you have given any actual evidence of anything.
 
I sincerely don't understand your point. Could you clarify?

Your post that I was responding to was making assertions about the diagnostic process, was it not? My response was assuming that you were making such assertions, and was pointing out that two individuals so far have pointed out from separate perspectives (and separate capacities) that the diagnostic process is quite different than what you assert.

Why is what you and Gurdur assert significant?

Because they directly contradict what you were asserting as if it were fact.

Assertions are not argument. You seem to think that just because you and Gurdur assert something that is the end of the argument. Gurdur did the same. Why? I'll respond to the rest of your post but this is of particular interest to me. A brief response would be sufficient. Are either of you experts? Are you appealing to your own authority? Special pleading?

Since all you have done as well is make assertions (which you define as not arguments), I maintain that the authority I am placing to my posts is at least equal to yours.

I've conceded that there exists diagnostic tests in psychiatry. My point is that these are still in their infancy and not definitive at this time in the diagnoses of many if not most mental ailments.

Again, your assertion is incorrect. The anecdotal diagnoses I referred to in my post happened between five and ten years ago (there are two distinct dates involved), and even then some of the tests were already decades old. You are simply making claims that are not based in fact.

What exactly is it that I'm ignoring? Your assertions?

What attempts? Are you again talking about your assertions and special pleading? Appeals to authority?

Do you have something more than that?

Look, I'm not going to play your "let's see how many from the textbook list of logical fallacies can I name" game with you. It's pedantic and distracting from the actual topic of conversation. Are you or are you not claiming that there is not enough discrete and technical analysis following scientific method involved in psychiatric diagnosis?

Look, I'm really not that hard to convince. I'm one of a handful of individuals on this forum who apologizes and admits when shown wrong. Just give me something beyond "go read a book". I have read books. I have friends and associates in the field. Why do you know more they?

This, by the way, is why I'm not playing your "name textbook fallacy lists" game-- you tend to make the very ones you accuse others of doing.

I've not said to you to just go read a book. I'm not making arguments that I know more than your as-yet-unnamed-and-undefined friends. I am telling you that your assertions regarding what is involved in psychiatric diagnosis within this thread have thus far been incorrect.

So, are we going to actually have a conversation where we clarify what our points are and work from there, or is this going to escalate into a contest of who can name the most textbook fallacies in others' posts and who can claim to have more friends in the field?
 
Wow, what a major derail.

Randfan you are wrong, psychiatry is NOT woo.

Homeopathy is woo, psychiatry is based upon trial and error.

Tell you what, did you miss the part where I said diagnosis can take three years to refine?

Presentation of symptoms is very similar for different disorders, yet the clusters in the DSM do exist.

Major Depression is different from Bipolar Disorder, and they are both different from Anxiety Disorders and all three are different from Schizophrenia, then there is the mixed diagnosis of Schizoaffective where you have mixed symptoms in the absence of the other.

Now here is the deal, how do you tell if someone who presents with extreme insomnia has which disorder? By using an assessment tool, or in the case of doctors asking their favorite twenty questions.

It involves some guessing but seriously they do cluster as suggested in the DSM, people forget that it is a description of response to treatment. And that is a crucial key to diagnosis. You will likely treat someone with full blown mania with an atypical antipsychotic, but as you get a more substantial history as the mood related thought disorders clear up, you will start to get the cluster of traits that go with bipolar mania, rather than schizophrenia.

Schizophrenics who are not in the long prodromal period tend to have affective flattening. You give them an antipsychotic and they present much more facial expressions, people with bipolar will calm down with APs and usually show affective blunting.

So while you insist on your notions, there are people doing the work, working with people. People who don't know what is happening to them. I have worked with doctors who were about 95% at making a preliminary diagnosis that would stick. I have known doctors that couldn't bat 25%.

But the better the history and the validity of the self report, the higher accuracy the diagnosis will have, as I said some people it takes about three years to get a refined diagnosis. The biggest confounding factor besides denial is substance abuse.


Now some doctors are bad at diagnosis and there are many bogus 'talk therapies' that are unscientific as all get out. But there are also many decent research based doctors out there as well.
 
Randfan you are wrong, psychiatry is NOT woo.
I never said it was. I said it borders on woo. It's the best we have and I would not get rid of it. It is helpful and I have conceded that both my father and I have benifited from it.

You really are working very hard to distort my position. Why?

...psychiatry is based upon trial and error.
And hypothesis are falsified by...?

Trial and error is not exactly the scientific method.

Tell you what, did you miss the part where I said diagnosis can take three years to refine?

Presentation of symptoms is very similar for different disorders, yet the clusters in the DSM do exist.

Major Depression is different from Bipolar Disorder, and they are both different from Anxiety Disorders and all three are different from Schizophrenia, then there is the mixed diagnosis of Schizoaffective where you have mixed symptoms in the absence of the other.

Now here is the deal, how do you tell if someone who presents with extreme insomnia has which disorder? By using an assessment tool, or in the case of doctors asking their favorite twenty questions.

It involves some guessing but seriously they do cluster as suggested in the DSM, people forget that it is a description of response to treatment. And that is a crucial key to diagnosis. You will likely treat someone with full blown mania with an atypical antipsychotic, but as you get a more substantial history as the mood related thought disorders clear up, you will start to get the cluster of traits that go with bipolar mania, rather than schizophrenia.

Schizophrenics who are not in the long prodromal period tend to have affective flattening. You give them an antipsychotic and they present much more facial expressions, people with bipolar will calm down with APs and usually show affective blunting.

So while you insist on your notions, there are people doing the work, working with people. People who don't know what is happening to them. I have worked with doctors who were about 95% at making a preliminary diagnosis that would stick. I have known doctors that couldn't bat 25%.

But the better the history and the validity of the self report, the higher accuracy the diagnosis will have, as I said some people it takes about three years to get a refined diagnosis. The biggest confounding factor besides denial is substance abuse.

Now some doctors are bad at diagnosis and there are many bogus 'talk therapies' that are unscientific as all get out. But there are also many decent research based doctors out there as well.
(emphasis mine) THAT'S WHAT I SAID!

None of this contradicts my point. Why do you think it does?
 
Last edited:
Um, the scientific method is trial and error. Sorry.

What part of psychiatry borders on the woo? It is what it is, in one hundred years it will be better, that does not make it woo.

Some doctors who tak etime getting decent histories where possible are very good at diagnosis prior to treatment, excluding those who lie to get anxiolytics.
 
Some doctors who tak etime getting decent histories where possible are very good at diagnosis prior to treatment, excluding those who lie to get anxiolytics.

Emphasis mine on the key element to psychiatry that validates it as actual medical diagnosis and not as haphazard as it can sometimes be misrepresented.
 
I think people also underestimate what it is like being a psyciatrist, i was a mental health case manager for ten years. (A helping professional who assists people with persistent and severe mental illness to intergrate in the community and manitain the living conditions. For those who don't know.)

there are two crucial aspects to the job:
1. laison to the mental health treatment system
2. maintaining the supports for living in the community


The first one is crucial, people who have altered perceptions because of thier illness are isolated, alone, frustrated with the people they do know and very reluctant to participate in treatment. the case manager establishes a friendly (but bounded) relationship to help make the treatment happen. It can take years for someone to develop insight into the symptoms of their illness, if ever.

It makes being a psychiatrist really, really hard.

The level of denial is just astounding.
 
Wow - and this thread was already split for a derail??

Well, I may be ignored, but will weigh in on the original OP anyway just to amuse myself.

The reason that makes most sense to me is that the underlying biological, cellular, chemical, genetic, whatever reasons for depression differ from person to person, and therefore the SSRI's will have different effects (and different adverse effects) in different people.

Yes, we know how SSRIs work, in that we know that they prevent reuptake of released serotonin. But it is also true that we don't know WHY this alleviates depression in many people that take SSRIs. We also know that alleviation of depression isn't seen for 7-14 days after initiation of SSRI treatment - so it probably isn't the immediate effect of blocking serotonin reuptake that is doing the trick (serotonin reuptake blocking happens immediately when taking SSRIs). We also know that excess serotonin in the synapse (from not being taken back up by the cell) allows prolonged receptor binding (by serotonin) on the next neuron - which leads to a decrease (internalization) of the serotonin receptors that are on the surface of that cell. So maybe this is the effect that does the trick - except that this oughta happen in the first few days of treatment, not two weeks later. We also know that the autoreceptors on the serotonin-releasing cell are also being exposed to excess serotonin, and giving a "stop releasing serotonin" signal back to that 1st cell. Maybe that's it, but doubtful again, as this would happen quickly. Then there is the idea that receptors for serotonin on those cells that are affected by the prolonged exposure are themselves releasing other neurotransmitters in other brain areas - creating an amazing array of possible downstream effects when you tamper with just the serotonin system.

Yes, we know the immediate action of SSRIs at the level of the serotonin transporter (that is blocked by SSRIs) but we don't know all the downstream effects, and we certainly don't know why continuous blocking of reuptake somehow decreases feelings of depression 2 weeks later.

And let's not even start on the way SSRIs treat other mood disorders such as PMDD, which responds much sooner to SSRI treatment than does major depression.

Long story short - everybody is different - on very basic levels - and some people are going to be very happy campers on SSRIs, ready to cope with all life can throw at them, while others aren't going to respond so ideally.
 
Wow - and this thread was already split for a derail??


Coulda been more, coulda been more, but we make do.


Well, I may be ignored,


Certainly not! :eek:

But it is also true that we don't know WHY this alleviates depression in many people that take SSRIs. We also know that alleviation of depression isn't seen for 7-14 days after initiation of SSRI treatment - so it probably isn't the immediate effect of blocking serotonin reuptake that is doing the trick


Bingo! Good points all, and many thanks for adding them, and for helping this thread resume its positive course that it had at the outset before the derail.

To add something to your many points:

an interesting but valid off-label usage for Zoloft (an SSRI) is to bring blood pressure up to normal for those who suffer from chronic low blood pressure. The dosage for that off-label use is 50mg a day, whereas the minimum psychoactive dosage when using Zoloft for its on-label use for depression is 100 mg a day at a minimum.

Since I suffer from chronic low blood pressure, I once did try Zoloft for that off-label use (didin't really work well on me, so I stopped after a while); since I do not otherwise suffer from endogenous depression, I haven't tried any SSRI's for myself otherwise. It is possible,though, through far too much repetitive daily meditation, to raise the serotonin levels so much (by sheer will, so to speak) that the person suffers from major digestive upsets and other symptoms (serotonin overdose); if anyone likes, I can dig out the study showing that.
 
Um, the scientific method is trial and error. Sorry.

What part of psychiatry borders on the woo? It is what it is, in one hundred years it will be better, that does not make it woo.

Some doctors who tak etime getting decent histories where possible are very good at diagnosis prior to treatment, excluding those who lie to get anxiolytics.

Hey DD.

I'll try and change my tone and approach. I will be a bit less authoritative and obnoxious. Now, some of this might be a bit patronizing and I'm sorry. I'm going to try and keep it to a minimum.

My apologies to everyone.

No. I'm sorry, but with all due respect I would not say that trial and error is the scientific method. I can't agree with that. Now, I could be wrong so let me state why I say that and I promise to read your rebuttals carefully. I only ask that you carefully read and consider what I have to say.

Fair enough?

Trial and error is what humans have always had from the beginning.

Long before modern medicine people would use trial and error to figure out which plants would alleviate pain and discomfort and which ones wouldn't. Sometimes they WERE right and sometimes they only thought they were right. The Asians tried acupuncture and it seemed to worke for them. In fact it seemed to work so well that it's with us to this day and people swear by it. This lead to lots and lots and lots of false beliefs about what was effective and what wasn't.

Then something extraordinary happened. Progress became accelerated. We have progressed more in the last 100 years than in all of the prior thousands of years before that. And the previous 100 years the same is true.

What happened? Well there was a lot of steps but I'll go over the two most important.

First was empiricism. The Ancient Greeks began to focus more on observing mechanisms to deduce what was happening and why rather simply trying things. Or simply beliving things based on supernatural explanations. This was a departure from simple trial and error. Just because sticking a needle into someone seemed to work to alleviate pain didn't mean that it was the needle that alleviated the pain (my example not theirs). One would need to try and understand the underlying mechanism of why it worked before one assumed that it did work.

Second was control. Removing the bias and preconceived notions of the individual performing the experiments. This was absolutely critical to the success of the scientific method. If you don't know why this is true then I would recommend reading Blind Experiment.



In all sincerity and without any attempt to be provocative or belittling I must say again, trial and error is decidedly not the scientific method. Yes, there is trial and error inherent in the scientific method but to simply state that trial and error are the scientific method is to fail to appreciate the incredible accomplishments of those wonderful Greeks and the contributions of the philosophers and scientists that were to follow.
  • I will say again. I value psychology and psychiatry.
  • Both have benefited myself and my father a great deal.
  • I would go back to a licensed and trained therapist should I find the need to do so again.
I would not say Psychiatry IS woo because the researchers do in fact conduct legitimate scientific research and observation. They are following as much as they can the scientific method. They do in fact put into place as many controls as they possibly can.

Why do I say it borders on woo? Because A.) Psychiatry does not, at this time, have the level of empirical control and diagnostic tools that other disciplines in the medical field do and B.) There is so much that we don't know about the brain. C.) Psychiatrists are human. The fewer controls and the less empirical knowledge that we have about any given subject then the greater the human element will intrude into the research and treatment.

I hope this helps and again I apologize for my rude behavior.

RandFan
 
Last edited:
--> RandFan:

at the risk of repeating myself, maybe you should learn something about both science and psychiatry before making so many unsubstantiated assertions on both. Many of your assertions are pure woo. But here, they're simply a long derail as well.

There is a thread already for you on exactly those aspects, split off from this one.

I see no need to reply to your comments on this thread at all; go to the other thread, as far as I am concerned. You should also read up on actual clinical practice. Would you like some good references? If so, ask on that other thread and I will be happy to reply there.
 
Okay back to the OP. What really pisses me off is that SSRIs seem to be prescribed for very flimsy reasons. I went to my GP about fear of flying (which I have since overcome) and he asked me if I had panic attacks in flight and I responded that once I felt like that. He immediately prescribed SSRIs without describing the possible side-effects (oh apart from functional impotence - he said they were often prescribed to men with premature ejaculation problems). So I have to ask are more people put at risk by these drugs than helped?
 
Okay back to the OP. What really pisses me off is that SSRIs seem to be prescribed for very flimsy reasons. I went to my GP about fear of flying (which I have since overcome) and he asked me if I had panic attacks in flight and I responded that once I felt like that. He immediately prescribed SSRIs without describing the possible side-effects (oh apart from functional impotence - he said they were often prescribed to men with premature ejaculation problems). So I have to ask are more people put at risk by these drugs than helped?

Depends what GP, obviously. Let's not forget that there are at the very least 3 different countries represented by posters on this thread, and also, when I make my own comments, I am talking about medicine and psychiatry as I know of them in Britain, Germany, Canada, the USA, Australia and Tanzania (those being the places of whose situations I have some knowledge of).

As far as fear of flying itself goes; a difficult one, and I do not personally know what the best therapy is, though I assume one could treat it as one does treat panic attacks -- and medications (IMvHO) do not have a long-term place in treating panic attacks, only in the short-term; the best thing for panic attacks would be a long-term Cognitive Behavourial Therapy program of some kind geared towards you as an individual and to the exact problem. But that's only my opinion, see a good behavioural psychologist for what they think. Again, IMvHO, SSRI's are simply not indicated for fear of flying, for many different reasons (it's like using an extremely inaccurate blunderbuss to try killing a mosquito; SSRI's also take far too long to tackle such an immediate, context-specific problem; and I just don't think they even really deal with such a problem).

Look on the bright side --- 40 years ago the big fashion was to prescribe sleeping pills for anxiety. Now that's really dangerous.

As for your specific question:

So I have to ask are more people put at risk by these drugs than helped?

The answer to that one would be from all the studies we know of, more people are actually helped than put at risk.

There is a huge controversy raging at the moment as to whether a particular class of SSRI's, a subgroup of them, are in fact any better at all than placebos. A long and difficult argument. But, overall, for SSRI's in the main and as a whole overall, they certainly seem to help far more people than the number of people they put at risk.

And for genuine endogenous depression, there are few other alternatives; SSRI's are better to try first than electroshock therapy, for example.
 
It is possible,though, through far too much repetitive daily meditation, to raise the serotonin levels so much (by sheer will, so to speak) that the person suffers from major digestive upsets and other symptoms (serotonin overdose); if anyone likes, I can dig out the study showing that.

Most of the serotonin and serotonin receptors and serotonin transporter (that protein that SSRIs block) are found in the gut. Only about 10-20% of all the serotonin in your body is found in the brain. Didja know? And the SSRIs block the transporter throughout the body, not just in the brain.

I don't recall if there are SERTs (Serotonin transporters) in the blood vessels, but I'm pretty sure there are. The name serotonin came about when it was first discovered as a substance in the blood that affected blood pressure by regulating the smooth muscle tone of the blood vessel walls. (SEROtonin=of the serum; seroTONIN=tone).
 
Thanks for your considered response. My problem is that my GP (who I left after this event) is not a quack and I wonder how many others are prescribing SSRIs inappropriately.
 
Thanks for your considered response. My problem is that my GP (who I left after this event) is not a quack and I wonder how many others are prescribing SSRIs inappropriately.

I understand the problems. Many GP's are not quacks at all, but may still prescribe inappropriate treatment for a particular problem. There are many reasons for that.

A GP's training is hard, long, very hard, and rushed. I've known many GP's who did only 6 months in med school, one seminar per week, on alcoholism -- yet alcoholism is one of the most constant problems they will see in clinical practice, so they are forced to learn on the job, with no help. It's even worse with all the psychological other stuff -- the GP's are simply being put in an unfair position trying to deal with complex psychology.

Then, the range of problems a GP will see in any typical working day is huge. And keeping huge amounts of info in the head is difficult for anyone. GP's are also typically greatly over-worked and underpaid, and just don't have time to read up on recent studies, so they often depend on info provided by the big pharma companies -- with resultant risk of that info being biased.

The other big problem for GP's is that they are very vulnerable to being sued for malpractice, so they typically do only what the central health board tells them is the standard treatment for any problem. Again, big problems of bias, inertia and conservatism.
 
Most of the serotonin and serotonin receptors and serotonin transporter (that protein that SSRIs block) are found in the gut. Only about 10-20% of all the serotonin in your body is found in the brain. Didja know? And the SSRIs block the transporter throughout the body, not just in the brain.

I don't recall if there are SERTs (Serotonin transporters) in the blood vessels, but I'm pretty sure there are. The name serotonin came about when it was first discovered as a substance in the blood that affected blood pressure by regulating the smooth muscle tone of the blood vessel walls. (SEROtonin=of the serum; seroTONIN=tone).

Many thanks for the additional info!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom