the level of false positives is what?
I have seen what happens, it is the obverse (except in medication seeking). People come in for help after they have had their life crash and burn, there is not an issue of false positives. There is an issue of history, validity of history and the tremendous under-reporting of symptoms. Seriously people do not get help when they first begin to have symptoms, they get help after they have crashed and burned.
You are correct, there is no way of accurate diagnosis to guide treatment that is 100%, but part of that is the language barrier and the level of denial.
I have been there in the ER , I have asked a family member., “So have they ever had mental health treatment in the past?”, “Have they ever shown extreme or strange behavior in the past?”, have they had psychiatric hospitalizations?” and you ask them multiple times and multiple ways, and they say No, No, No… Then I go to the debriefing with the admitting psychiatrist: “Well it seems they moved away for a about a year, had some really exciting times and were hospitalized for six months in another state”.
Now I grant you the first course of treatment is not always the right one, and substance abuse, which is way under-reported is a real problem.
Yet the DSM is the best that we have got, it will improve and hopefully be replaced at some point. But it also works. The ICD-9 is out there as well but it is really complex to use, and is used in Europe.
These aren't posted with the intent of proving my POV so much as to illustrate that the criticism I have posited are not mine alone but shared by others in the scientific community.
But at least one of these critiques is not valid, it does not matter what level of stress induction is involved in the presentation of symptoms, if they are functionally impairing the individual then they need help.
Be that medication CBT or both.