Why do anti depressants make some people suicidal?

You are projecting again, RandFan. I repeat: you obviously nothing about psychiatry and damned little about science overall...
Would you please not focus on me but instead focus on my arguments?
 
Last edited:
This thread is about "Why do anti depressants make some people suicidal?" I realise you don't have a clue about the topic, but that does not mean we need to indulge your ego in your wanting to spoil it for everyone else.
Because we as yet do not empirically understand the brain to the degree necessary and we do not fully understand the underlying mechanisms that cause depression. Nor do we empirically understand the effects, intended and unintended, that many if not all medicines have on the brain.

The problem is one of empiricism and the inability to adequately and objectively diagnose and understand the problem of depression, its root causes and to what effect genetic predisposition and environmental factors play.
 
Last edited:
Randfan and Gurdur... I would appreciate it if you guys would get back on track and avoid uncivil exchanges. Some of the stuff going on is borderline - but more importantly, it doesn't really add anything to the core of the discussion going on.

Thanks.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 
Do we objectively know what those differences are? Is there a blood test that could identify any or all of these differences? BTW, I concede that some of the same problems are inherent to general medicine however there are tests that can be performed to determine a great number of variables.


Ack! I don't want to get into this melee. I've actually been ignoring all posts by Randfan and Gurdur ONLY because of the attacking tones of both (of the few early posts I read). Then I see my name in one of the posts. For the record, I thought you both had good points, but I don't appreciate when two posters take over an entire thread that had some good conversation going by many posters. My two cents on that issue. Please don't use this post to say it supports your claim or squashes someone else's. I'm simply stating my thinking on the issue.

In direct reply to your question, RF, and not wanting to knowingly support either you or G (as I still haven't read all the posts you two are throwing back and forth at each other), there are blood tests that can identify a small portion of the gazillion components at work on the individual's biochemical level - but even if we could test for EVERY KNOWN component involved, we wouldn't know yet how the interaction of even those few might be contributing to the overall picture. And there are many more components we don't have tests for or even know exist. We are slowly teasing apart some major players in mood disorders, and can make some inferences based on, say, the genetic differences of the serotonin transporter between people, but those same people probably differ in many other factors (including experience/non-biological). We can't at this time run a test that allows us to say "Ah, you are deficient in this, abnormal in that, and have an overexpression of suchandsuch - here take this pill and practice these skills and you will be fine." Still, and I suspect for a long time to come, there will be educated guessing going on, to at least a small extent, regarding treatment of cognition and mood. That guessing will entail some biological tests, but will rely heavily on professional observation and narrowing down of symptoms on the diagnosis side, and some trial and error (unfortunately) on the treatment side.

Yes, I think this process is improving, but there are limits to what we can accomplish in a completely unbiased manner. Doesn't mean that we should stop improving it, but I respect what can currently be done.

As for why SSRIs help some and hurt others - it all comes down to the interplay of all those differences that we don't fully understand.
 
Last edited:
Peace bro, if I offend you let me know and I will tone it down.

The following is based on Criticisms of the DSM (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders)


  • In regards to my point about empiricism and psychiatry.
"...the existing taxonomy fails to use an integrated evolutionary approach in the conditions it classifies. That is, it is "not guided by any theory about the structure and functioning of normal minds," [44] and fails to make distinctions between those conditions which are "malfunctions" in the cognitive machinery and those which are evolved psychological adaptations which are functioning normally and were evolutionarily adaptive, but cause problems in the modern-day environment (i.e. sexual jealousy, aggression, anxiety). These distinctions have real implications for how conditions are diagnosed and treated. [45]"
The environmental causes of stress are not meant to be part of the classification except that they are addressed under one of the Axes, four maybe?

‘Sexual jealousy’, wow that sounds rather Freudian!

But the environment is not something that would benefit the use of the diagnosis, which is for communication and hopefully treatement. The environmental issues are not important to the diagnosis. Symptoms will manifest at a higher rate and severeity under stress, but they will not change their basic nature under stress. A person with schizophrenia will still have that cluster of symptoms.

The stress induced nature of symptoms is a fairly common construct in psychiatry and mental health.
  • In regards to my point about self-reporting (symptom-based diagnostics) and the difficulty of taking into account the context of environment.
"It has been argued that purely symptom-based diagnostic criteria fail to adequately take into account the context in which a person is living, and whether there is real internal disorder of an individual or simply a response to their situation.
Sorry, but that seems to be a moot point when you are involved in mental health treatment.

The symptoms of a disorder are biological in nature. They are manifested in an organic body regardless of wether they are primarily stress induced or not. The spectrum is the only question, not all people will develop symptoms in relation to stress unless it is PTSD.

But if a person has OCD that interferes with the tasks of daily living it makes little difference if it is occurring under high or low stress. It is interfering with their daily living.
[41][42] It is claimed that the use of distress and disability as additional criteria for many disorders has not solved this false-positives problem, because the level of impairment is often not correlated with symptom counts and can stem from various individual and social factors.[43]"
the level of false positives is what?

I have seen what happens, it is the obverse (except in medication seeking). People come in for help after they have had their life crash and burn, there is not an issue of false positives. There is an issue of history, validity of history and the tremendous under-reporting of symptoms. Seriously people do not get help when they first begin to have symptoms, they get help after they have crashed and burned.

You are correct, there is no way of accurate diagnosis to guide treatment that is 100%, but part of that is the language barrier and the level of denial.

I have been there in the ER , I have asked a family member., “So have they ever had mental health treatment in the past?”, “Have they ever shown extreme or strange behavior in the past?”, have they had psychiatric hospitalizations?” and you ask them multiple times and multiple ways, and they say No, No, No… Then I go to the debriefing with the admitting psychiatrist: “Well it seems they moved away for a about a year, had some really exciting times and were hospitalized for six months in another state”.

Now I grant you the first course of treatment is not always the right one, and substance abuse, which is way under-reported is a real problem.

Yet the DSM is the best that we have got, it will improve and hopefully be replaced at some point. But it also works. The ICD-9 is out there as well but it is really complex to use, and is used in Europe.
These aren't posted with the intent of proving my POV so much as to illustrate that the criticism I have posited are not mine alone but shared by others in the scientific community.


But at least one of these critiques is not valid, it does not matter what level of stress induction is involved in the presentation of symptoms, if they are functionally impairing the individual then they need help.

Be that medication CBT or both.
 
Last edited:
For context, these posts support Lilith's posts as to our ability to understand (diagnose) the brain sufficiently to understand why anti-depressants cause depression beyond the fact that human phenotypes vary.

Are you sure that is what you mean to say?


Having thoughts of suicide caused by ADs is not the same as depression caused by ADs.
 
http://metapsychology.mentalhelp.net/poc/view_doc.php?type=book&id=557

This is interesting RandFan

But it seems possibly to deny the existance of mental illness at some points. that seems to be rather backwards and well, I can't say.

I shall say that such thinking is very dangerous and will lead to greater stigma.
http://www.jeffreypoland.info/resume.php

And article titles like;
"Steps Toward a Schizophrenia-Free World"
and
"How to Move Beyond the Concept of Schizophrenia"

Makes me wonder, but i can't find a source for it currently.

his professional associations:
American Philosophical Association (Eastern Division)
Philosophy of Science Association

Society for Philosophy and Psychology

Would indicate that he is mote interested in changing the language used in mental health. Which is an ongoing debate and process in mental health. The use of the word 'consumer' as opposed to 'client'.

BUT if he takes the stance of Szsasz then he is very very very dangerous. Pychotic disorders exist, the suicide rate for untread schizophrenia is 16%. In the US the prevalence of schizophrenia is 1% or 3 million people, untreated that is 480,000 suicides.
 
Last edited:
Peace bro, if I offend you let me know and I will tone it down.
:) No. Absolutely not. And thank you for your post.

But the environment is not something that would benefit the use of the diagnosis, which is for communication and hopefully treatement.
The point is, how does a patient respond to the environment? How does the doctor know? People respond to different settings (environmental stimuli). A clinical setting is not a very good setting to observe behavior.

You are correct, there is no way of accurate diagnosis to guide treatment that is 100%, but part of that is the language barrier and the level of denial.
What concerns me is what the error bars are? I think in psychiatry they are significantly greater than perhaps we want to admit.

Yet the DSM is the best that we have got, it will improve and hopefully be replaced at some point. But it also works. The ICD-9 is out there as well but it is really complex to use, and is used in Europe.
Yes, I agree that it is the best we have and I wouldn't throw the baby out with the bath water.

Please forgive my editing. If there was a particular point or points that you specifically wanted addressed let me know.
 
Ack! I don't want to get into this melee. I've actually been ignoring all posts by Randfan and Gurdur ONLY because of the attacking tones of both (of the few early posts I read). Then I see my name in one of the posts. For the record, I thought you both had good points, but I don't appreciate when two posters take over an entire thread that had some good conversation going by many posters. My two cents on that issue. Please don't use this post to say it supports your claim or squashes someone else's. I'm simply stating my thinking on the issue.
My involving you in the dispute was wrong and I appologize.

In direct reply to your question, RF, and not wanting to knowingly support either you or G (as I still haven't read all the posts you two are throwing back and forth at each other), there are blood tests that can identify a small portion of the gazillion components at work on the individual's biochemical level - but even if we could test for EVERY KNOWN component involved, we wouldn't know yet how the interaction of even those few might be contributing to the overall picture. And there are many more components we don't have tests for or even know exist. We are slowly teasing apart some major players in mood disorders, and can make some inferences based on, say, the genetic differences of the serotonin transporter between people, but those same people probably differ in many other factors (including experience/non-biological). We can't at this time run a test that allows us to say "Ah, you are deficient in this, abnormal in that, and have an overexpression of suchandsuch - here take this pill and practice these skills and you will be fine." Still, and I suspect for a long time to come, there will be educated guessing going on, to at least a small extent, regarding treatment of cognition and mood. That guessing will entail some biological tests, but will rely heavily on professional observation and narrowing down of symptoms on the diagnosis side, and some trial and error (unfortunately) on the treatment side.

Yes, I think this process is improving, but there are limits to what we can accomplish in a completely unbiased manner. Doesn't mean that we should stop improving it, but I respect what can currently be done.

As for why SSRIs help some and hurt others - it all comes down to the interplay of all those differences that we don't fully understand.

Yes, and truth be told there are many ailments in medicne generally that are difficult to diagnoss.

Good post.

Thanks Lilith.
 
http://metapsychology.mentalhelp.net/poc/view_doc.php?type=book&id=557

This is interesting RandFan

But it seems possibly to deny the existance of mental illness at some points. that seems to be rather backwards and well, I can't say.

I shall say that such thinking is very dangerous and will lead to greater stigma.
http://www.jeffreypoland.info/resume.php

And article titles like;
"Steps Toward a Schizophrenia-Free World"
and
"How to Move Beyond the Concept of Schizophrenia"

Makes me wonder, but i can't find a source for it currently.

his professional associations:
American Philosophical Association (Eastern Division)
Philosophy of Science Association

Society for Philosophy and Psychology

Would indicate that he is mote interested in changing the language used in mental health. Which is an ongoing debate and process in mental health. The use of the word 'consumer' as opposed to 'client'.

BUT if he takes the stance of Szsasz then he is very very very dangerous. Pychotic disorders exist, the suicide rate for untread schizophrenia is 16%. In the US the prevalence of schizophrenia is 1% or 3 million people, untreated that is 480,000 suicides.
I agree psychotic disorders exist. Your various points are fair. I will withdraw support of the review.
 
Last edited:
Randfan, I think that there are also valid points in what Mr. Poland has to say, but until I can read those two articles, I have to remain unsure.

there are many problems in the use of the DSM, I was very lucky to have good supervisors.
 
Randfan, I think that there are also valid points in what Mr. Poland has to say, but until I can read those two articles, I have to remain unsure.

there are many problems in the use of the DSM, I was very lucky to have good supervisors.
Yes, I think there are some valid points. I've sent emails to some of my associates and other individuals concerning the criticisms of the DSM and I'm trying to find out how far off base my position is. I am sincerely interested in the truth about the subject. At the end of the day that really is more important than my ego.

I really appreciate your tone and willingness to answer questions and address the issues and not dismissing me out of hand.
 
The issue that is a valid point of discussion is that when it comes to the pychotic disorder labeled as schizophrenia there are three hundred potential neurotransmitters that can be implicated. So it is very true that there may be three hundred 'schizophrenias' that exist. So there is some error in labeling them all as schizophrenia.

It is amazing the variety of things that you will see manifested as schizophrenia, those who tend to fall towards the "paranoid' end of the spectrum are higher functioning that those with the 'disorganized' schizophrenias. It would appear that auditory hallucinations are more likely to be associated with the 'negative' symtoms than people who have the delusional complex. So there are two processes that are at work there.

And what is truely amazing about schizophrenia is not so much the 'positive' symptoms that are commonly associated with the disorder but the 'negative' symptoms, these are the things that people living with the disorder lack and they are actualy as about as debilitating if not more so than the 'positive' symptoms.

There is a tremendous gray area where many people fall as well. There is the area of psychotic depression, which tends to sit right between the schizophrenia, major depression and bipolar disorder. It is almost impossible to treat. There is the area between bipolar disorder and schizophrenia the infamous 'scizoaffective' disorder. there is the one I live with (along with major depression) OCD which seems to be related to the psychotic disorders except that there aren't negative symptoms and the person recognises the unreality of the thought insertion and obsessions.

So there is a huge area that needs refinement and I am sure the model will change over time.

Strangely however the symptoms do cluster in the areas set up in the DSM, it could be a total artifact.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom