Why do anti depressants make some people suicidal?

When I was on prozac I though of suicide every waking minute of every day. I felt ok physically except for the impotence it causes and I was cool and calm as a cucumber. Suicide was on my mind day in and day out until I quit taking that stuff. I tried other medications but with similar problems. You read about this effect all the time and even when anti depressants are advertised this is included as a hazard of taking the medicine. Why?

In your case i don't know, maybe they should try another medication. It really depends on the symptoms. Certainly SSRIs SNRIs and TCAs are not for every person. Some people react adversly.

The main reason that ADs increase the risk of suicide is simple, someone who lacks motivation will think about suicide but not act upon it. Give them motivation and the risk goes up. The other ones is that you start to feel better and then your symptoms crish you and you feel hopeless again.
 
Because many anti-depressants are also downers (in the loosest sense of the term). Things like Prozac are not a good treatment for someone who is depressed due to behavioral, habitual, or emotional issues.
Um that is a really strange statements, SSRIs for most people are stimulating, where did you read that they are downers. The blanket statement above is rather loose care to explain?
Prozac, Celexa, Xanax
Xanax is not an AD and should never be perscribed due to the high addiction profile.
, and other similar drugs only have reasonable efficacy in cases where there seems to be a brain chemistry factor to the depression (or, in some cases, bipolar). Naturally, the trouble is in being able to tell which is the case with people, or whether the case is a mixture of more than one factor.
Please, it doesn't matter is you are depressed then you shopuld get treatement, some prefer CBT, some medication, some both.
I was diagnosed bipolar about ten years ago, and for a while I had a cocktail of things I was taking to help keep the "ups" fairly low and the "downs" less deep. It partially helped, but in reality what helped the most was changing my behavior, my diet (mostly less drinking), and actually learning to approach and interpret things going on in my life in ways that weren't immediately assuming the worst and predicting destruction. It sounds simple to do, but in reality developing those behaviors into habits instead of willful attempts to replace old behavior was very difficult and took time. I no longer take any of the meds, but I do still sometimes get those old feelings trying to creep back in-- though I've learned to recognize them and now know to adjust my sleep and exercise schedule to keep my habits more positive.
CBT is very effective, if you were drinking then the diagnosis may have been wrong.
Back to the point, though: drugs like Prozac work because they dull certain receptors of the brain temporarily. The side-effect of that for people who are depressed is that they feel less depressed. The side-effect for many other people is one similar to that from quaaludes.

Um, yeah right.

Research and data?
 
GrNme
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0CYD/is_9_36/ai_75505263
This is kind of pop do you have a ebtter source, apathy syndome is somewhat controversial.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15330228
Twelve case studies and one trial exam, not much of a syndrome. Maybe a side effect?
http://journals.cambridge.org/actio...66BE3C1AB0.tomcat1?fromPage=online&aid=105153
So a fiveteen patient study with sexual dysfunction. Not again a scream that SSRIS cause apathy except in this group.

Now here is the deal, without my ADs I am moody, irritable, i have thoughts of reference, lability, I feel connected to everything and often overwhelmed by emotions and empathy for other people.

So in my case 'blunting' is a good thing, it return to normal.
 
Hi

I have a theory about this stuff.

After I got out of the Army, I was angry at everything, and any emotional stimulation just made me angrier.

The second time I met one of my current best friends, a full-time therapist, the second sentence out of her mouth was, "You have P.T.S.D.... you should get therapy."

I spent, quite literally, years trying to just stop being angry.

One day, I forgot what I was doing, but I noticed that I wasn't angry! I wasn't angry the next day, either.

About a week later, I realized that I wasn't anything ELSE, either. I was hollow and numb.

It felt awful.

One night, a couple of weeks later, after I tried to fill that terrible hole in myself by thinking I was in love with a girl, a friend dropped in and found me sitting on the couch.

On the other end of the couch was a loaded pistol.

"You're not thinking about... " he asked.

"Not any more," I said as I unload and field strip the firearm. "I think I've got it under control."

I think that people just get used to being depressed. It becomes the default intellectual, physical, and emotional position, response, and state of being.

The anti-depressants take a lot of that away.

Suddenly, the security blanket that the person has had wrapped so tightly around himself that it's strangling him is stripped away, and all this with limited or no preparation for being, suddenly and painfully, emotionally naked and defenseless.

I think that this sometimes manifests itself in a sudden-onset and urgent need to retreat from the thing that's causing the pain, and since what that is, at that point, life itself... well... you get the idea.

But again - it's just a theory.
 
Last edited:
All due respect, it's GreNME, please. I'll show you the same respect you show me.

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0CYD/is_9_36/ai_75505263
This is kind of pop do you have a ebtter source, apathy syndome is somewhat controversial.

Yes, it's controversial because it's a side-effect not originally listed. Predictably the people studying these things want to be more sure of hard data. Currently the process is in gathering data through numerous independent studies.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15330228
Twelve case studies and one trial exam, not much of a syndrome. Maybe a side effect?

Yes, most likely a side effect. Concerns of this sort have been prevalent ever since chemicals to alter the behavior of neuroreceptors have been around.

http://journals.cambridge.org/actio...66BE3C1AB0.tomcat1?fromPage=online&aid=105153
So a fiveteen patient study with sexual dysfunction. Not again a scream that SSRIS cause apathy except in this group.

So, if I keep showing you separate studies are you going to keep doing this? That study is one among many. This is how pharmacological (and many other types of) study works, by the way. No, a single study doesn't "scream" anything, but studies like this are why sexual dysfunction is listed among the known side effects of SSRIs today. This can also become the case with apathy disorder given more studies are allowed to continue.

Now here is the deal, without my ADs I am moody, irritable, i have thoughts of reference, lability, I feel connected to everything and often overwhelmed by emotions and empathy for other people.

I can relate. I don't have those symptoms any more, but my case is somewhat special (and extreme) for why those symptoms aren't prevalent. However, before it was determined by diagnosis from two doctors I took my meds as prescribed. I definitely don't suggest anyone do otherwise. I apologize that I gave you any other impression.

So in my case 'blunting' is a good thing, it return to normal.

Could very well be. I remember that I was taking enough Seroquil to knock out someone twice my size (for the mania), and all it did was make me calmer. As I said to Gurder, sometimes meds are the best treatment. It's for that reason I'm a bit confused as to why you're being so aggressive/defensive at me.
 
Hi

I have a theory about this stuff.

After I got out of the Army, I was angry at everything, and any emotional stimulation just made me angrier.

The second time I met one of my current best friends, a full-time therapist, the second sentence out of her mouth was, "You have P.T.S.D.... you should get therapy."

I spent, quite literally, years trying to just stop being angry.

One day, I forgot what I was doing, but I noticed that I wasn't angry! I wasn't angry the next day, either.

About a week later, I realized that I wasn't anything ELSE, either. I was hollow and numb.

It felt awful.

One night, a couple of weeks later, after I tried to fill that terrible hole in myself by thinking I was in love with a girl, a friend dropped in and found me sitting on the couch.

On the other end of the couch was a loaded pistol.

"You're not thinking about... " he asked.

"Not any more," I said as I unload and field strip the firearm. "I think I've got it under control."

Wow. That story definitely hits me in a very personal way. Things didn't turn out so positively in the story I know. Glad they did for you though.

I think that people just get used to being depressed. It becomes the default intellectual, physical, and emotional position, response, and state of being.

The anti-depressants take a lot of that away.

Suddenly, the security blanket that the person has had wrapped so tightly around himself that it's strangling him is stripped away, and all this with limited or no preparation for being, suddenly and painfully, emotionally naked and defenseless.

I think that this sometimes manifests itself in a sudden-onset and urgent need to retreat from the thing that's causing the pain, and since what that is, at that point, life itself... well... you get the idea.

But again - it's just a theory.

Not a bad theory, especially related to PTSD. I'm not sure I agree completely with it (at least not personally), but I can see ways that it definitely applies in some cases.
 
Wow. Fascinating discussion here.

SSRI's don't make me suicidal--but I have had very different experiences with very similar meds. Effexor and Cymbalta are extremely similar drugs --but one works much better for me, moodwise. Much! Sadly, it has the side-effect of making me unable to get deeply asleep. After a week or so, I'm in the Bizarro World of not enough rest. I *do* have a much cleaner house, since if I'm not able to go back to sleep at 5 am, might as well do some laundry and clean the kids' bathroom, right??
After some tinkering, my doc and I decided to let me stay on the 'transition' doseage of some of one and some of the other. Not orthodox, but the combined dosage is well below anything scary -- slightly below the dosage I take of either alone--and I can now feel better AND sleep at night.

Also, true word on the exercise thing, I had some bad times when I pulled my groin muscle so badly I was hobbling for months. (At least I didn't have to get surgery.) Even the month I spent in a walking cast recently was pulling me down--until I discovered that wheeling a manual wheelchair around is excellent exercise!

I commend anyone who had suicidal ideation that reached the stage of preparing, but didn't go further. I once had to yank a relative back into a car she decided to jump out of (at 40 mph)--the second scariest moment of my life! She still hasn't thanked me, but at least she is moving forward in life and has some happy times now.
 
Hi

I have a theory about this stuff.

After I got out of the Army, I was angry at everything, and any emotional stimulation just made me angrier.

The second time I met one of my current best friends, a full-time therapist, the second sentence out of her mouth was, "You have P.T.S.D.... you should get therapy."

I spent, quite literally, years trying to just stop being angry.

One day, I forgot what I was doing, but I noticed that I wasn't angry! I wasn't angry the next day, either.

About a week later, I realized that I wasn't anything ELSE, either. I was hollow and numb.

It felt awful.

One night, a couple of weeks later, after I tried to fill that terrible hole in myself by thinking I was in love with a girl, a friend dropped in and found me sitting on the couch.

On the other end of the couch was a loaded pistol.

"You're not thinking about... " he asked.

"Not any more," I said as I unload and field strip the firearm. "I think I've got it under control."

I think that people just get used to being depressed. It becomes the default intellectual, physical, and emotional position, response, and state of being.

The anti-depressants take a lot of that away.

Suddenly, the security blanket that the person has had wrapped so tightly around himself that it's strangling him is stripped away, and all this with limited or no preparation for being, suddenly and painfully, emotionally naked and defenseless.

I think that this sometimes manifests itself in a sudden-onset and urgent need to retreat from the thing that's causing the pain, and since what that is, at that point, life itself... well... you get the idea.

But again - it's just a theory.


Pretty good theory there.
 
All due respect, it's GreNME, please. I'll show you the same respect you show me.



Yes, it's controversial because it's a side-effect not originally listed. Predictably the people studying these things want to be more sure of hard data. Currently the process is in gathering data through numerous independent studies.



Yes, most likely a side effect. Concerns of this sort have been prevalent ever since chemicals to alter the behavior of neuroreceptors have been around.



So, if I keep showing you separate studies are you going to keep doing this? That study is one among many. This is how pharmacological (and many other types of) study works, by the way. No, a single study doesn't "scream" anything, but studies like this are why sexual dysfunction is listed among the known side effects of SSRIs today. This can also become the case with apathy disorder given more studies are allowed to continue.



I can relate. I don't have those symptoms any more, but my case is somewhat special (and extreme) for why those symptoms aren't prevalent. However, before it was determined by diagnosis from two doctors I took my meds as prescribed. I definitely don't suggest anyone do otherwise. I apologize that I gave you any other impression.



Could very well be. I remember that I was taking enough Seroquil to knock out someone twice my size (for the mania), and all it did was make me calmer. As I said to Gurder, sometimes meds are the best treatment. It's for that reason I'm a bit confused as to why you're being so aggressive/defensive at me.


I understand what you are saying, and was just reacting to something you didn't say.

So wow, Seroquel is real potent stuff, and it didn't knock you out? I apologise again, I worked in the heat and was responding to stuff you didn't say. I apologize.

I will also think of you as grey enemy, that way I will get the capitals better.It is GreNMe right.

(Sorry I responded in a fashion that was unwarranted)
 
It's all good, and I think I did put things in a manner that needed better clarification in hindsight. :)
 
Out of interest, if I may ask, what does GreNME stand for?
_______

"Gurdur" is a character from one of Terry Pratchett's novels, not a major character, but at least a euphonious name. Mind you, I only found out much later, after years of using "Gurdur" as a username all over the web, that I had in fact spelled it wrongly. Too late to change.
 
Short answer: the human brain is tremendously complex and mind-altering drugs affect each person differently.

This message brought to you by Captain Obvious.
Damn! That was my answer. Though I would have to say tremendously complex might be an understatement but I can't think of a better one.

It is hopped that there will come a time that brain scans and DNA and other diagnostics will lead to more precise treatments. Currently psychiatric treatment is prescribed based almost solely on self reporting. It's kind of like telling your doctor that your foot hurts and he gives you aspirin. When that doesn't work he puts your foot in a cast. When that doesn't work he prescribes ointments.
 
... Currently psychiatric treatment is prescribed based almost solely on self reporting. ....


No, not really, no. The largest amount of psychiatric treatment is based on observation of behaviour, including observation of behaviour while the patient self-reports, and a healthy dose of general knowledge of how people behave.

Minimal self-reporting is only within normal limits similar to that when visiting and reporting a straight body problem to a GP. Maximal psychiatric self-reporting is actually very intensely controlled and checked rigorously through usage of long tests designed both for diagnosis and also for catching liars.
 
No, not really, no. The largest amount of psychiatric treatment is based on observation of behaviour, including observation of behaviour while the patient self-reports, and a healthy dose of general knowledge of how people behave.

Minimal self-reporting is only within normal limits similar to that when visiting and reporting a straight body problem to a GP. Maximal psychiatric self-reporting is actually very intensely controlled and checked rigorously through usage of long tests designed both for diagnosis and also for catching liars.
No, not really, no. That would be like a doctor observing you why you told him that your leg hurt. It's not as helpful as you might think. The doctor might have a pretty good idea that your leg is broken based on the observation but he will still send you down to get an x-ray. And trust me on this, a broken leg is far simpler than neurological/psychological pathology.

But, for the sake of argument, let's go with your premise, the doctor follows you home to observe you for two weeks... ok, well we know that doesn't happen so we will stick with the short amount of time that you are actually in the doctors office aware that you are being observed, the doctor observes your behavior, comes up with a hypothesis and falsifies it by... hmmm, I think we have found a problem with your theory. At best he/she gives you a prescription and then monitors your response to the medicine.

That really is bass ackward but sadly it's the best we have.

So, I'll say it again, no, not really, no.
 
No, not really, no. That would be like a doctor observing you why you told him that your leg hurt. It's not as helpful as you might think. The doctor might have a pretty good idea that your leg is broken based on the observation but he will still send you down to get an x-ray. And trust me on this, a broken leg is far simpler than neurological/psychological pathology.

But, for the sake of argument, let's go with your premise, the doctor follows you home to observe you for two weeks... ok, well we know that doesn't happen so we will stick with the short amount of time that you are actually in the doctors office aware that you are being observed, the doctor observes your behavior, comes up with a hypothesis and falsifies it by... hmmm, I think we have found a problem with your theory. At best he/she gives you a prescription and then monitors your response to the medicine.

That really is bass ackward but sadly it's the best we have.

So, I'll say it again, no, not really, no.

That's not an accurate representation of most diagnoses. It certainly describes a number of types of diagnosis attempts that could range from irresponsible to borderline malpractice. However, most psychiatric doctors are trained to not only request records from a person's primary care physician and make assessments based on a history along with the patient's own descriptions (though not necessarily taking everything said literally), but in some cases such doctors do prescribe CT or MRI scans, among other things.

Anecdotal case in point: I went through an MRI during my diagnosis pretty early on, and also had biofeedback sessions (similar in nature to a polygraph recording) to measure my body's responses so that they could be recorded. After the accident that resulted in a change in my symptoms, I had another MRI and an encephalograph performed, along with an eight-hour neuropsyche exam (four hours a day for two days) to measure my symptoms, state of mind, and for comparison.


If you're arguing that perhaps these things I mentioned should become more commonly applied when the question of prescribing meds comes up, I would say I agree with you on that point. Unfortunately not everyone can afford it right now because of the stupid costs of healthcare. I happened to have the luck of being on a very good PPO (and had very good doctors) back when I went through these tests.
 
Out of interest, if I may ask, what does GreNME stand for?

Long story short: I used to have the nickname "Grendel" and back before I knew it was a publication I had a band called "NME" (yes, I know :) ).

The avatar is also the logo for my site (grenme.com) and also has a history, but the short version of that is that I have a fascination with ancient Mid-Eastern history and I've had a metal left orbital for more than ten years.
 
Last edited:
No, not really, no. That would be like a doctor observing you why you told him that your leg hurt. It's not as helpful as you might think.

Really? I love the inappropriate sarcasm, but I did work in associated fields -- and making a diagnosis of meningitis is often largely done on first on self-reporting, then a simple thermometer and a reflex hammer. Oh, and what I think overall here is based on practice, training and on observation of colleagues. BTW, you missed the point; detailed at bottom.

The doctor might have a pretty good idea that your leg is broken based on the observation but he will still send you down to get an x-ray.

If you want to claim that most GP problems are tackled with hi-tech (beyond low-tech such as a thermometer, self-reporting, a spatula and a pressure cuff), I'm going to have to correct you.

And trust me on this, a broken leg is far simpler than neurological/psychological pathology.

*shrug* I did neuro at uni, academic and clinical training, along with the neurologists, as part of my training in aphasia/apraxia treatment / rehab, training which did include knowing how to differentiate suchlike from the host of disorders that can simulate aphasias. Also did a fair bit of psych. My comments are drawn from experience and training. I'm not a medical doctor, but neither am I inexperienced.

That really is bass ackward but sadly it's the best we have.

Be thankful that you don't have what you're asking for, though you don't realise exactly what you're asking for.

In order to maximally control the brain though medications (and that's part of what you're wishing for), and in order to know how to do so, and what to look for, then not only would we need far more knowledge than we have today, but also we would need to pretty much toss free will and choice out the window, and impose far stricter norms.

So, I'll say it again, no, not really, no.

I'll repeat the point you missed: most psychiatric treatment is based on observation, not just on self-reporting as you wrongly asserted, and which was the point I tackled. Just as well, really, or else all the druggies in New York City would be incredibly happy to get the drugs they wanted after their self-reporting*, rather than the ones they're actually prescribed, if any.

_____

* And druggies are often very skilled at self-reporting -- in a totally duplicitous manner.
 
Last edited:
Long story short: I used to have the nickname "Grendel" and back before I knew it was a publication I had a band called "NME" (yes, I know :) ).

The avatar is also the logo for my site (grenme.com) and also has a history, but the short version of that is that I have a fascination with ancient Mid-Eastern history and I've had a metal left orbital for more than ten years.

(joke) Does this also mean you have a very protective mother? (/joke)

Thanks for the explanation!
 
I'll repeat the point you missed: most psychiatric treatment is based on observation, not just on self-reporting as you wrongly asserted...
I didn't miss anything. Observation of behavior to diagnose any single individual is extremely limited. What exactly is a doctor observing? What exactly is the doctor looking for? What behavior in a doctor's office will indicate manic depression or neurosis? Unless the individual is in an institution the ability to observe an individual under different stresses and situations is impossible. Your claim is simply wrong and without any basis in fact.

I'm going to have to correct you.
Please do so. Let me point out that so far you haven't done so and also note that the more complicated and varied the problem the more likely a doctor will use diagnostic equipment. Psychiatric pathology and psychological problems are far more complicated than the common cold. So by all means correct me but please do so with something more than mere assertions.

In order to maximally control the brain though medications (and that's part of what you're wishing for), and in order to know how to do so, and what to look for, then not only would we need far more knowledge than we have today, but also we would need to pretty much toss free will and choice out the window, and impose far stricter norms.
Appeal to emotion (fear). And it is also presumptive and without any basis. BTW, many drugs that are used now can significantly alter or restrict will (Thorazine comes to mind).

You might have a background but so do I though I will confess mine is somewhat limited. I know researchers in the field at UCLA and have a close relationship with a clinical psychiatrist. It's something I am very interested in and have spent considerable amount of time discussing and reading about. Those who I have spoken with do not at all share your view.
 
Last edited:
I didn't miss anything. Observation of behavior to diagnose any single individual is extremely limited.
Nowhere near as limited as you imagine. And I will repeat:
  1. you asserted that most psychiatric treatment is based on patient self-reporting.
    .
  2. I told you that wasn't true, and in fact that most psychiatric treatment is based on observation of the patient, including observation while they report.

What exactly is a doctor observing? What exactly is the doctor looking for? What behavior in a doctor's office will indicate manic depression or neurosis?
Are you being silly, or are you actually asking me to repeat around 7 different big med textbooks in one post? I wouldn't mind tackling your questions one at a time, but I get the impression you're merely posing with slogans, rather than discussing.

Unless the individual is in an institution the ability to observe an individual under different stresses and situations is impossible.
You're moving the goal-posts now. I repeat: most psychiatric treatment is done on the basis of observation. Like it or lump it. Whether or not it is done under a great range of conditions and stressors is irrelevant.

Your claim is simply wrong and without any basis in fact.

And personally,I don't think you have a clue what you're blathering on about. I guess that leaves you and me at an impasse, but it's certainly no skin off my nose.

Let me point out that so far you haven't done so and also note that the more complicated and varied the problem the more likely a doctor will use diagnostic equipment.
Irrelevant to the original point once again.

So by all means correct me but please do so with something more than mere assertions.
*snicker* Pot, kettle, black on that score.

Appeal to emotion (fear).
Bollocks. Again, you have no idea what you're blathering on about: Why not simply ask me the basis for my assertion, if you don't get it, rather than trying to pretend you know better, and buggering that one up too?

And it is also presumptive and without any basis.

See just above. :D

BTW, many drugs that are used now can significantly alter or restrict will (Thorazine comes to mind).
D'oh. Really? No, really? Amaaaaazing. Was there a point in there somewhere?

You might have a background but so do I though I will confess mine is somewhat limited. I know researchers in the field at UCLA and have a close relationship with a clinical psychiatrist. It's something I am very interested in and have spent considerable amount of time discussing and reading about. Those who I have spoken with do not at all share your view.

Really? Goodness, and I'm supposed to believe that on the basis of your self-reporting? Well, thanks I guess for not blowing my background off completely.

Unfortunately, I don't base things only on self-reporting, or even mainly on it, but on observation instead. :) Back to you! Let's see what you do with this lot, and just how much you actually want to discuss as opposed to defending through slogans your original erroneous assertion (and I'll remind you you gave zero proof for it).
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom