RandFan
Mormon Atheist
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2001
- Messages
- 60,135
Sorry, I can't let this stand. This is so wrong. First, my point has nothing whatsoever to do with "hi-tech". Any technology that is objective and removes personal bias is valid diagnostics.If you want to claim that most GP problems are tackled with hi-tech (beyond low-tech such as a thermometer, self-reporting, a spatula and a pressure cuff), I'm going to have to correct you.
The great contribution of the ancient Greek philosophers to human progress is that they realized that in order to better get to the truth you must make every attempt possible to remove personal bias.
The following is an anecdote. It's not mean to prove anything but illustrate my point.
In February of this year I became very sick. I went to the clinic, met with a doctor who observed me and asked me some questions. I didn't have a fever or any outward signs of sickness so she sent me home with some pain relievers.
I got sicker. I went back to the clinic and saw a different doctor who also asked me questions and observed me. He sent me home with pain relievers and anti-biotics.
I got sicker. I went to a hospital. I still did not have a fever. My outward appearance had not changed. The doctor ordered a white blood count test. When it came back I was admitted to the hospital. Further tests revealed that I had staff infection.
The strength of medicine is that it is scientific. Individuals in the medical field, researchers, doctors, etc. attempt to remove themselves as much as possible from the equation. To think objectively and rely on objective methods.
Psychiatry, at best, is a bit more advanced than leaches and blood letting but not nearly as much as biological medicine for the very reason that personal bias cannot be removed as much as it can from biological medicine and for obvious reasons.
Last edited:
