Why do anti depressants make some people suicidal?

If you want to claim that most GP problems are tackled with hi-tech (beyond low-tech such as a thermometer, self-reporting, a spatula and a pressure cuff), I'm going to have to correct you.
Sorry, I can't let this stand. This is so wrong. First, my point has nothing whatsoever to do with "hi-tech". Any technology that is objective and removes personal bias is valid diagnostics.

The great contribution of the ancient Greek philosophers to human progress is that they realized that in order to better get to the truth you must make every attempt possible to remove personal bias.

The following is an anecdote. It's not mean to prove anything but illustrate my point.

In February of this year I became very sick. I went to the clinic, met with a doctor who observed me and asked me some questions. I didn't have a fever or any outward signs of sickness so she sent me home with some pain relievers.

I got sicker. I went back to the clinic and saw a different doctor who also asked me questions and observed me. He sent me home with pain relievers and anti-biotics.

I got sicker. I went to a hospital. I still did not have a fever. My outward appearance had not changed. The doctor ordered a white blood count test. When it came back I was admitted to the hospital. Further tests revealed that I had staff infection.

The strength of medicine is that it is scientific. Individuals in the medical field, researchers, doctors, etc. attempt to remove themselves as much as possible from the equation. To think objectively and rely on objective methods.

Psychiatry, at best, is a bit more advanced than leaches and blood letting but not nearly as much as biological medicine for the very reason that personal bias cannot be removed as much as it can from biological medicine and for obvious reasons.
 
Last edited:
Nowhere near as limited as you imagine. And I will repeat:
you asserted that most psychiatric treatment is based on patient self-reporting.
Correct. And that is trivially true. I absolutely stand by it. Until you can tell us what it is exactly that is being observed I'm afraid that is all we have to go on.

I told you that wasn't true, and in fact that most psychiatric treatment is based on observation of the patient, including observation while they report.
Asserting something doesn't make it true. You say it's based on observation, observation of what exactly? What's being observed? How do you observe complex issues of neurological and psychological problems and how do you remove personal bias? How do you objectively measure your observations?


Are you being silly, or are you actually asking me to repeat around 7 different big med textbooks in one post? I wouldn't mind tackling your questions one at a time, but I get the impression you're merely posing with slogans, rather than discussing.
Odd, I was thinking that of you. At least I am making argument and not merely asserting claims.

You're moving the goal-posts now. I repeat: most psychiatric treatment is done on the basis of observation. Like it or lump it. Whether or not it is done under a great range of conditions and stressors is irrelevant.
?

I will ask again, what on earth are they observing?

And personally,I don't think you have a clue what you're blathering on about. I guess that leaves you and me at an impasse, but it's certainly no skin off my nose.
You could be right but you've given no reason for anyone to think that you are right. This is a skeptics forum. What is needed here is argument and not fallacy or special pleading. You are free to think whatever you wish but why should anyone agree with you? Because you have a background? That's not going to fly.

D'oh. Really? No, really? Amaaaaazing. Was there a point in there somewhere?
Yes, and it couldn't be any simpler. Your sky is falling scenario is bogus at worst and already here at best. It is fallacy. An appeal to emotion.

Back to you! Let's see what you do with this lot, and just how much you actually want to discuss as opposed to defending through slogans your original erroneous assertion (and I'll remind you you gave zero proof for it).
We'll you are not really discussing anything only asserting that psychiatry is based on observation but you refuse to establish this. Instead you demand that I prove a negative. I can't prove a negative. I can only tell you what the limits are.

The ball, I'm afraid, is in your court.

Good luck.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, I can't let this stand. This is so wrong.

If you want to pretend my point was factually wrong, better hie thee to a GP's office and stay in it observing :p all day, learn, then hie thee to a nunnery. OK, the nunnery's optional, I threw that in there for the sake of the phrase-associated quotation, nut hey.

First, my point has nothing whatsoever to do with "hi-tech".
But my point did. :D

I was pointing out to you that most diagnoses made by GP's are like diagnoses made by psychiatrists; made using the simplest, most low-tech methods.

Any technology that is objective and removes personal bias is valid diagnostics.

Sounds like you have an inappropriate worship of technology there. Valid diagnostics can be done low-tech as well as hi-tech.

Psychiatry, at best, is a bit more advanced than leaches and blood letting but not nearly as much as biological medicine for the very reason that personal bias cannot be removed as much as it can from biological medicine and for obvious reasons.

Bollocks again, on two different grounds.

  • I can tell you why psychiatry is not as advanced as physics, if you would really like to know, as opposed to chanting at me.
    .
  • And "biological medicine" (since when is psychiatry not biological, BTW?) can be just as uncertain or even more uncertain than psychiatry.

Examples:

diagnosis and treatment of lupus, Crohn's disease, and similar conditions. Dreadfully uncertain at times. So-called "biological medicine", and all out at sea, unfortunately.

diagnosis that one extremely small area towards the upper middle/back of the brain was affected by syphilis can be done with a book (any book or printed text), a small flashlight and a tiny bit of questioning (observation). Reasonably certain (Argyll-Robertson pupil).

diagnosis that there has been a tiny bleeding or stoppage in blood flow to a very small part of the brain, extremely well-known in location, by pure listening to the patient, looking at the patient and a few questions (observation! ;)). Pretty damned certain; Broca's area, then the areal for control of the right hand next to Broca's.

Both those last two diagnoses are ones psychiatrists need to be able to make, in order to make differential diagnoses.
 
Correct. And that is trivially true. I absolutely stand by it. Until you can tell us what it is exactly that is being observed I'm afraid that is all we have to go on.
Wrong on 2 counts. It's not all we have to go on, we have my assertions too. And I don't think you're being terribly honest at all in discussion; what is under observation is how the patient presents themselves, how they talk about their alleged symptoms, how they talk about themselves, what their clothing looks like (useful, for example, in schizophrenia), and how they relate to the outside world. Pupil size, body posture, language usage, attitudes, reactions and all other overall behaviour.

Asserting something doesn't make it true.
Use a mirror. :p

You say it's based on observation, observation of what exactly?
See above.

What's being observed? How do you observe complex issues of neurological and psychological problems
See above and also my other post above,

and how do you remove personal bias?
Through good training and attitudes. :)

How do you objectively measure your observations?

By the use of intersubjective means, just like in mathematics. :)


At least I am making argument and not merely asserting claims.
Bollocks. All you've done up till now is to make unsubstantiated assertions, and you've made vague hints at implying an underlying argument.


You could be right but you've given no reason for anyone to think that you are right.

*shrug* Null problemo. You've given no-one any reason to believe you either. ;)

This is a skeptics forum. What is needed here is argument and not fallacy or special pleading
Best go look in a mirror again, Randfan. :p Really, you're behaving ridiculously here. Finished with the childish rhetoric yet? This stereotyped speech of yours is crap. Tackle the points, will you?

You are free to think whatever you wish but why should anyone agree with you?
It's mutual. :p

Because you have a background?
I did get paid for it. :p Regularly.

That's not going to fly.
See just above. :p Then see further above.

Your sky is falling scenario is bogus at worst and already here at best. It is fallacy. An appeal to emotion.
Finished tantruming yet, or did you want to say anything concrete?

. Instead you demand that I prove a negative. I can't prove a negative. I can only tell you what the limits are.
Fact is, you have no idea what the limits are, you have no idea what you're sloganizing about, and you started off making a positive claim, for which you gave zero evidence. You're not being honest at all. Because of your convenient forgetfulness, I will remind you you made the positive claim that most psychiatric treatment is done only on the basis of self-report. It's a bull.... claim of yours.

Good luck.
I'll wish it back to you. I don't actually need it; you certainly seem to do so.;)
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately diagnosis, which I can't do and assesment which I did for 15 years is a highly skilled practice, you have two hours to get a picture of the person and a clue as to what they say is going on. So it is 50% experience, 40% rapport building and 10% intuition. However I got pretty darm good at it. The real problem comes at first presentation, major depression, bipolar disorder and schizophrenia can be very hard to tell aprt at the ER. Often it takes three years or more for someone to get a clear diagnosis. Substance abuse just muddies the water beyond belief.

The real issue especialy in crisis intervention is that you have to listen to what the person says and then let your intuition/empathy fill in the parts that they don't say, you then have to use your people skills to ask leading questions without overbearing them and constantly adjust your mental response picture. You also have to maintain that empathy and a sense of serious clinical detachment, which wears you out. Then you sit and let your brain try to make the picture while you listen to them. So you end up with a semi consistent hypothesis of what you think they reported to you. Meanwhile you observe the rate of speech, the breathing patterns, affect (emotional presentation), thought processes IE coherency, trains of thought, patterns.

Hopefully they begin to open up and answer the questions that you ask and they go through a learning curve with you, psychoeducation in jargon, to a mild level. Adjusted for their level of consciousness, education, background and culture. It is amazing what people will tell you if you do it right. In the ER you at least have the luxury of taking as long as it needss to tale, something you don't in the office.
 
Last edited:
I was pointing out to you that most diagnoses made by GP's are like diagnoses made by psychiatrists; made using the simplest, most low-tech methods.
GP's rely on thermometers, stethoscopes and blood pressure cuffs and thousands of other objective diagnostic tools. Psychiatrists?

Sounds like you have an inappropriate worship of technology there. Valid diagnostics can be done low-tech as well as hi-tech.

One more time. Hopefully this Will be the last. My point has nothing to do with low-tech or hi-tech. My point has to do with objective diagnostic tools.

Let me repeat since you don't seem to be getting the point.
  • My point has nothing to do with low-tech vs hi-tech.
  • My point as to do with objective diagnostic tools.
I can tell you why psychiatry is not as advanced as physics, if you would really like to know, as opposed to chanting at me.
I would like for you to support your claim. Is that too much to ask?

And "biological medicine" (since when is psychiatry not biological, BTW?) can be just as uncertain or even more uncertain than psychiatry.

Examples:
Those that I know in the field distinguish psycho-biological medicine (psychiatry) from biological medicine. Psycho-biological is known as psychiatry and biological is known simply as biological. It's kinda like science is a branch of philosophy but most people don't refer to science as philosophy but instead make a distinction between the two. Got it?

diagnosis and treatment of lupus...
Lupus: Difficult to diagnose but not impossible.
Please to give me a counter example for a psychiatric diagnosis?

Crohn's disease
Please to give me a counter example for a psychiatric diagnosis?

...and similar conditions. Dreadfully uncertain at times. So-called "biological medicine", and all out at sea, unfortunately.
No. There are limits to science and medicine. The more objective tests there are the more definitive the diagnosis.

But ironically you argue against yourself. I didn't say that psychology or psychiatry were hopeless only that they are limited in diagnostic capability and now you are arguing that I am right. Observation is poor help to chrons and lupus sufferers as it is to sufferers of manic depression and other psychiatric pathologies.

Thank you.

diagnosis that one extremely small area towards the upper middle/back of the brain was affected by syphilis can be done with a book (any book or printed text), a small flashlight and a tiny bit of questioning (observation). Reasonably certain (Argyll-Robertson pupil).

diagnosis that there has been a tiny bleeding or stoppage in blood flow to a very small part of the brain, extremely well-known in location, by pure listening to the patient, looking at the patient and a few questions (observation! ;)). Pretty damned certain; Broca's area, then the areal for control of the right hand next to Broca's.

It's funny that you spend so much time talking about diagnosing complaints that are not neurological. Is it that there is a dearth of objective information on the subject? I suspect so.

Both those last two diagnoses are ones psychiatrists need to be able to make, in order to make differential diagnoses.
"Listening to the patient"? You mean self reporting? How much can you diagnose without self reporting?
 
Wrong on 2 counts. It's not all we have to go on, we have my assertions too. And I don't think you're being terribly honest at all in discussion; what is under observation is how the patient presents themselves, how they talk about their alleged symptoms, how they talk about themselves, what their clothing looks like (useful, for example, in schizophrenia), and how they relate to the outside world. Pupil size, body posture, language usage, attitudes, reactions and all other overall behaviour.
Yes, all useful but very limited. None are worth much without self reporting and none are definitive the way a blood test is.

Most importantly you've got to explain how a doctor avoids subconscious personal bias. So, that is my question to you. How does a psychiatrist remove his or her own personal bias from the process? GPs and others in the medical field use objective diagnostic tools that reduce the possibility of bias. Psychiatrists?

That's the crux of my argument and the only thing that matters. Psychiatry is limited to self reporting and a doctors observations. Both are subject to self deception and the doctor may also suffer from indifference and other problems of observation.

In the end you've made a claim and have failed to support the claim.
 
Last edited:
GP's rely on thermometers, stethoscopes and blood pressure cuffs and thousands of other objective diagnostic tools. Psychiatrists?

How fascinating that your bad habits of Objectivist thought re-emerge. You are side-tracking into what you think diagnosis should be. I am telling you what it is, in response to your initial crap claim about what it is.

To put you straight yet again: :rolleyes:

We are discussing your crap claim that psychiatric treatment is based mainly on self-reporting. I have informed you that you are wrong, and it actually is mostly observation. You do not need to believe me, go buy a good textbook on clinical practice and do a few semesters of study at a good uni. Do tackle the actual point. By the way, that was a positive claim of yours (among others), and like all your other claims, given without any evidence at all.


One more time. Hopefully this Will be the last.

I hope so too, that this will be the last. You've made crap claims, without any evidence at all, that only show your abysmal ignorance of what actually goes on in psychiatry. Read Dancing David's post above and learn something.

I would like for you to support your claim.

After you. Or go read any good textbook on clinical psychiatric practice. Is that too much to ask? Learn something.


Those that I know in the field distinguish psycho-biological medicine (psychiatry) from biological medicine.

You're babbling.

We are discussing your crap claim that psychiatric treatment is based mainly on self-reporting. I have informed you that you are wrong, and it actually is mostly observation. You do not need to believe me, go buy a good textbook on clinical practice and do a few semesters of study at a good uni. Do tackle the actual point. By the way, that was a positive claim of yours (among others), and like all your other claims, given without any evidence at all.

"Listening to the patient"? You mean self reporting? How much can you diagnose without self reporting?

Now you're simply being dishonest yet again. I've told you a million times by now that self-reporting is not simply taken at face value as presented, but is in fact judged by the psychiatrist on the basis of other observation, and I've given you examples why that is so, and I've told you a lot about what that observation actually is of (see my post detailing some observation, and also see my very first response to you).

You deliberately ignore all of that, and play games instead. Now, be a good boy and back up your original positive claim with evidence.

To help you remember:
We are discussing your crap claim that psychiatric treatment is based mainly on self-reporting. I have informed you that you are wrong, and it actually is mostly observation. You do not need to believe me, go buy a good textbook on clinical practice and do a few semesters of study at a good uni. Do tackle the actual point. By the way, that was a positive claim of yours (among others), and like all your other claims, given without any evidence at all.
 
Last edited:
How fascinating that your bad habits of Objectivist thought re-emerge.
I'm not an objectivist and that is an ad hominem argument.

We are discussing your crap claim that psychiatric treatment is based mainly on self-reporting.
For one simple reason. Without it you don't have much. Observation is limited and in many if not perhaps most cases, useless without self reporting.

You do not need to believe me, go buy a good textbook on clinical practice and do a few semesters of study at a good uni.
Special pleading. I could say the same to you. That is a fallacy.

Now you're simply being dishonest yet again. I've told you a million times by now that self-reporting is not simply taken at face value as presented,
Please to show me where I ever said it was?

No, I'm not being dishonest. I stand by my original statement. Psychiatrists lack objective tools for diagnostics (I should note that there are in fact some dignotic tests for a number of ailments but they are the exception and not the rule) and must largely rely on self-reporting. A psychiatrist can't go out into his waiting room, observe his patients and make a diagnosis without talking to the individuals. Self-reporting is crucial to the diagnosis. Only in severe cases do doctors do so and such a diagnosis is never definitive and often very limited.

Non-psychiatric doctors do that all of the time, well, not exactly like that but they do get patients who are unconscious and they use objective diagnostic tools to make diagnosis.

Please to show me a single example of a psychiatrist making a diagnosis of an unconscious patient without any medical history. Non-psychiatric doctors do it every single day.
 
Last edited:
In February of this year I became very sick. I went to the clinic, met with a doctor who observed me and asked me some questions. I didn't have a fever or any outward signs of sickness so she sent me home with some pain relievers.

I got sicker. I went back to the clinic and saw a different doctor who also asked me questions and observed me. He sent me home with pain relievers and anti-biotics.

I got sicker. I went to a hospital. I still did not have a fever. My outward appearance had not changed. The doctor ordered a white blood count test. When it came back I was admitted to the hospital. Further tests revealed that I had staff infection.

The strength of medicine is that it is scientific. Individuals in the medical field, researchers, doctors, etc. attempt to remove themselves as much as possible from the equation. To think objectively and rely on objective methods.

Psychiatry, at best, is a bit more advanced than leaches and blood letting but not nearly as much as biological medicine for the very reason that personal bias cannot be removed as much as it can from biological medicine and for obvious reasons.
You ignored my anecdote but it so perfectly illustrates my point that I had to post again.

Self-reporting and observation are fine to a degree but they are fraught with problems. The brain is such a complex thing that to think one can adequately diagnose problems with it by relying simply on self reporting and observation is intellectually dishonest. We are very limited in our ability to treat mental disorders because we lack a full compliment of diagnostic tools at this time. There is no doubt that in the future we will have much better capability.
 
RandFan, did you even read my post and associated anecdote? Basically, you're wrong on the methodology used in psychiatric practice. Why can't you simply accept that your initial assertion was overgeneralized and inaccurate? Your arguments are moving further away from psychiatric medicine and more into medical practice in general, bringing you further away from the original point you seemed to be making anyway.
 
That's not an accurate representation of most diagnoses. It certainly describes a number of types of diagnosis attempts that could range from irresponsible to borderline malpractice. However, most psychiatric doctors are trained to not only request records from a person's primary care physician and make assessments based on a history along with the patient's own descriptions (though not necessarily taking everything said literally), but in some cases such doctors do prescribe CT or MRI scans, among other things.

Anecdotal case in point: I went through an MRI during my diagnosis pretty early on, and also had biofeedback sessions (similar in nature to a polygraph recording) to measure my body's responses so that they could be recorded. After the accident that resulted in a change in my symptoms, I had another MRI and an encephalograph performed, along with an eight-hour neuropsyche exam (four hours a day for two days) to measure my symptoms, state of mind, and for comparison.

If you're arguing that perhaps these things I mentioned should become more commonly applied when the question of prescribing meds comes up, I would say I agree with you on that point. Unfortunately not everyone can afford it right now because of the stupid costs of healthcare. I happened to have the luck of being on a very good PPO (and had very good doctors) back when I went through these tests.
My apologies. I did miss this.

Let me be very clear. Without self-reporting you don't have much. Medical history, observations, etc., all these are important data but they are not definitive. CT scans and MRI's have come a long way but are still quite crude.

Let me give you an example of what I'm talking about. Let's compare two cases. Cancer vs Manic Depression.

In court of law we can establish as fact that an individual has cancer. We can't, to date, establish many if not most psychological and or psychiatric ailments. Both the defense and plaintiffs in a legal case can put on experts that can argue why or why not an individual is suffering from any number of complaints. It's simply not definitive for the reasons I've outlined over and over. There are not that many objective diagnostic tests to definitively state what a person is suffering from. It all comes down to expert opinion based on statistical analysis and observation of behavior and self-reporting and self-reporting is the most important of all of the data.

If a person refuses to answer questions the expert opinion will be couched in caveats and you know that. That is a simple fact. Self-reporting is crucial.
 
RandFan, did you even read my post and associated anecdote? Basically, you're wrong on the methodology used in psychiatric practice. Why can't you simply accept that your initial assertion was overgeneralized and inaccurate? Your arguments are moving further away from psychiatric medicine and more into medical practice in general, bringing you further away from the original point you seemed to be making anyway.
I would be more than willing to make such a concession if it were so. I've done so on this forum many times. I can't make such a concession because it would be dishonest. My point is simple and quite defensible. Without self-reporting a doctor can't make highly confident diagnosis and even with self-reporting a doctor is limited in the diagnosis. That just stands to reason. If it were that simple we wouldn't need x-rays, MRI's CAT scans and and all of the thousands of diagnostic tests that doctors rely on every day.

Psychiatry borders on woo. I'm sorry but it does. It really does. I say that not because psychiatrists are dishonest or don't strive for objectivity. I think they do largely. The problem lies with personal bias. Science seeks to remove personal opinion when it comes to such. That is why medicine is scientific and relies on the scientific method. Because of the nature of the brain Psychiatrists are limited in their ability to limit their personal bias.

Why can't anyone acknowledge that fact?
 
RandFan, did you even read my post and associated anecdote? Basically, you're wrong on the methodology used in psychiatric practice. Why can't you simply accept that your initial assertion was overgeneralized and inaccurate? Your arguments are moving further away from psychiatric medicine and more into medical practice in general, bringing you further away from the original point you seemed to be making anyway.

No kidding. I've lost all interest, can't even be bothered with one of my favourite examples of how Crohn's Disease is actually most often in actual practice a differential diagnosis by elimination, the diagnosis you have when you don't otherwise have a diagnosis, the Clayton's of diagnoses *. A good example of just how imprecise overall medicine can be.

A big pity. There's actually a tremendously interesting discussion to have in just why we can be bloody thankful that psychiatry is not a hell of a lot more exact than it is (a little more exact would be nice and very helpful, a huge amount more exact would be terrible). There's also an interesting discussion to be had on why psychiatry is alike in its methodology with mathematics; both depend on intersubjectively determining what's significant and also what's important.

There are tons of other interesting discussions to be had.

But I'll be buggered if I am going to listen to endless repetitions of the usual ignorant crap about psychiatry, especially if it's going to fade into nonsense ignorant claims about criteria about what's "objective" and what's not. ** Sheeesh.

My apologies to you, GreNME, and to Dancing David, but after dealing with Oliver on one thread, I don't have the patience to go through two more rounds of exactly the same ignorant thing being said over and over on another thread with someone else, not after I've given 3 chances beforehand on this one, and not after deliberate and unprovoked rudeness right from the very start.

Slap mah face and call me Mr. Impatience, but maybe we can have a good thread some other time, or maybe this one will recover from the derail.

_________

* Advertising slogan in Australia; Clayton's is a non-alcoholic drink meant to look like spirits, and was advertised as, "The drink you have when you're not having a drink".

** Interestingly, statistics has been most advanced by ......... psychology.

Because psychology needs extremely complex statistics, in practice statistics as a science itself has been most advanced within the psychology field.

At least, that's my mooted thought for the day. Could be wrong, of course.
 
.... Psychiatry borders on woo.


No. Wrong. The problem is that you know nothing about psychiatry, and you prefer to keep your prejudices rather than learn.

Why can't anyone acknowledge that fact?


You mean why do people keep trying to burden you with the actual facts rather than simply agreeing with your pet prejudices?

Oh dearie me, I can't imagine why. :boggled:

Never mind, the Scientologists agree whole-heartedly with you, RandFan, the Scientologists agree fully with you, they really hate psychiatry with a vengeance.
 
No. Wrong. The problem is that you know nothing about psychiatry, and you prefer to keep your prejudices rather than learn.
This is not an argument. It is ad hominem.

You mean why do people keep trying to burden you with the actual facts rather than simply agreeing with your pet prejudices?
What facts? You've not provided any facts and you have not provided any arguments. You have relied over and over on special pleading, ad hominem, empty claims and assertions.

Never mind, the Scientologists agree whole-heartedly with you, RandFan, the Scientologists agree fully with you, they really hate psychiatry with a vengeance.
More ad hominem. I don't share Scientologists view on psychiatry. I grew up with a manic depressive father who was effectively treated by psychiatry. I myself spent years in counseling with both psychiatrists and psychologists and I feel a great debt to them as I was also effectively treated.

No, I don't share their view so your ad hominem is fallacious on two fronts. Not bad for fallacy. I'll grant you that.

So, all of your hand waving and invective and you could not once muster anything more than appeal to authority and special pleading.
 
I don't have the patience to go through two more rounds of exactly the same ignorant thing being said over and over on another thread with someone else, not after I've given 3 chances beforehand on this one, and not after deliberate and unprovoked rudeness right from the very start.
?

What of anything substantive have you said? I've made clear and cogent arguments. Arguments that you simply ignore.

Stop taking yourself so seriously and pay closer attention to the arguments that are being made and not simply assuming that you are right and everyone else is wrong. You are not really all that.
 
My apologies. I did miss this.

Let me be very clear. Without self-reporting you don't have much. Medical history, observations, etc., all these are important data but they are not definitive. CT scans and MRI's have come a long way but are still quite crude.

Let me give you an example of what I'm talking about. Let's compare two cases. Cancer vs Manic Depression.

In court of law we can establish as fact that an individual has cancer. We can't, to date, establish many if not most psychological and or psychiatric ailments. Both the defense and plaintiffs in a legal case can put on experts that can argue why or why not an individual is suffering from any number of complaints. It's simply not definitive for the reasons I've outlined over and over. There are not that many objective diagnostic tests to definitively state what a person is suffering from. It all comes down to expert opinion based on statistical analysis and observation of behavior and self-reporting and self-reporting is the most important of all of the data.

If a person refuses to answer questions the expert opinion will be couched in caveats and you know that. That is a simple fact. Self-reporting is crucial.

Why are you telling me how the diagnoses I've gone through went even though I was the person who went through them and not you. Do you not see the fallacy in you're insistence?

I would be more than willing to make such a concession if it were so. I've done so on this forum many times. I can't make such a concession because it would be dishonest. My point is simple and quite defensible. Without self-reporting a doctor can't make highly confident diagnosis and even with self-reporting a doctor is limited in the diagnosis. That just stands to reason. If it were that simple we wouldn't need x-rays, MRI's CAT scans and and all of the thousands of diagnostic tests that doctors rely on every day.

That's not a defensible point, that's falling just shy of saying "why bother?" regarding the entire medical field. Both Gurdur and I have stated explicitly that psychiatric diagnosis involves a great deal more than self-reporting. You continue to insist that self-reporting is crucial, but you're not making a reasonable argument as to how the self-reporting is more crucial in psychiatry than in other medical diagnoses. Instead you have thus far ignored the fact that MRI, CT, and encephalograph scans are used along with other more lengthy and discrete tests in order to make reliable diagnoses.

Psychiatry borders on woo. I'm sorry but it does.

Well, yeah, any sufficiently complex technology would seem like magic to those ignorant of the technology. I can see how you would get that kind of impression considering the things you are choosing to ignore.

It really does. I say that not because psychiatrists are dishonest or don't strive for objectivity. I think they do largely. The problem lies with personal bias. Science seeks to remove personal opinion when it comes to such. That is why medicine is scientific and relies on the scientific method. Because of the nature of the brain Psychiatrists are limited in their ability to limit their personal bias.

Why can't anyone acknowledge that fact?

Because you are not accurately describing psychiatric medical practice. Make no mistake, the same steps involved in diagnosing many standard medical conditions apply in psychiatry as well. There are sources of information that can be shared with you to inform you of this, but thus far you've refused attempts to assure you that such methods exist.
 
Why are you telling me how the diagnoses I've gone through went even though I was the person who went through them and not you. Do you not see the fallacy in you're insistence?
I sincerely don't understand your point. Could you clarify?

Both Gurdur and I have stated explicitly that psychiatric diagnosis involves a great deal more than self-reporting.

Why is what you and Gurdur assert significant? Assertions are not argument. You seem to think that just because you and Gurdur assert something that is the end of the argument. Gurdur did the same. Why? I'll respond to the rest of your post but this is of particular interest to me. A brief response would be sufficient. Are either of you experts? Are you appealing to your own authority? Special pleading?
 
Last edited:
You continue to insist that self-reporting is crucial, but you're not making a reasonable argument as to how the self-reporting is more crucial in psychiatry than in other medical diagnoses. Instead you have thus far ignored the fact that MRI, CT, and encephalograph scans are used along with other more lengthy and discrete tests in order to make reliable diagnoses.
I've conceded that there exists diagnostic tests in psychiatry. My point is that these are still in their infancy and not definitive at this time in the diagnoses of many if not most mental ailments.

Well, yeah, any sufficiently complex technology would seem like magic to those ignorant of the technology. I can see how you would get that kind of impression considering the things you are choosing to ignore.
What exactly is it that I'm ignoring? Your assertions?

...thus far you've refused attempts to assure you that such methods exist.
What attempts? Are you again talking about your assertions and special pleading? Appeals to authority?

Do you have something more than that?

Look, I'm really not that hard to convince. I'm one of a handful of individuals on this forum who apologizes and admits when shown wrong. Just give me something beyond "go read a book". I have read books. I have friends and associates in the field. Why do you know more they?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom