When Machines Rule

I maintain that welcoming our robot overlords/replacement or whatever variation of this statement is wrong -- we have a right to preserve our own species.

Any sentient being has the right to place it's own value above that of any other -- humans even have the right to kill other humans if the human in question was threatened by the others.

The fact that we will die does not mean that we forfeit this right -- as long as we are alive, we have this right, we do not just sit and welcome death.


INRM

Tell that to the Dodo birds.
 
Shadron...

That is like comparing apples and oranges.

Humans created A.I. technology. Dodo birds did not create humans (which rendered them extinct).

Humans are far more intelligent and have much greater ability to predict the future than Dodo-birds, and if trained right, are can better be able to see the consequences of their actions.

People IMHO should be thinking more thoroughly about the ramifications of such matters, and the long term results of a short-sighted decision... unfortunately, I think this is lacking these days. People don't seem to exploit their ability to predict the long term consequences as much as they should.

I'm not certain if I said that exactly right... but I'm tired right now.


INRM
 
The past ability of humans to predict the long term consequences of their actions has been woeful. Is this likely to change because we sit down and think a bit harder?

Should we terminate all research because something bad might happen?
 
Last edited:
Should we terminate all research because something bad might happen?

I think the better question to ask would be -- do you think we should continue along full-speed ahead without carefully evaluating the ramifications of such technology, it's good and bad effects on society, and instead operating in a completely short-sighted manner?


INRM
 
Last edited:
Or we could just add a test case to the QA schedule:

Test 711-a-2 : Does system seek world domination? Yes => Fail.
Test 711-a-3 : Does system seek obliteration of humanity? Yes => Fail.

Note to tester: Incorrect execution of these tests will be considered serious professional misconduct and may result in disciplinary action
 
Wudang,

And people on this topic say *I'm* naive and wishfully thinking?

INRM
 
Last edited:
I think the better question to ask would be -- do you think we should continue along full-speed ahead without carefully evaluating the ramifications of such technology, it's good and bad effects on society, and instead operating in a completely short-sighted manner?

INRM

Do you think you can tell the difference, and where the edges are?
 
What do you mean where the edges are?

The edge is where, if you're not quite there you can back away, but if you're there, there is no turning back. Re: The tipping point, the L1, L2 or 3rd Lagrange pointWP, the crux, the point of no return. In this case, the point where the machine is in control (whether you know it or not) and will not relinquish it.
 
Last edited:
Regardless,

Do you think that people should be persuing A.I. research and developing such technology recklessly, without significant foresight, at a breakneck rate of speed?


INRM
 
Great, you want to engage in reckless activity without foresight as fast as you can...

So, do you routinely play Russian-roulette?
 
Great, you want to engage in reckless activity without foresight as fast as you can...

So, do you routinely play Russian-roulette?

It is very doubtful that machines (except possibly cars or power drills) are going to be the death of you or me. That being the case, what more do you really care about? What amount of sympathy did you give the T-Rex, or he Mastodon? They had their time, and now they're no longer here, though their relatives are. Do you think your species is uniquely exempt from that? Many people think they have, by dint of their amazing intellects, removed themselves from natural selection, but that isn't the case.

Am I being fatalistic? Perhaps. Do I worry for my lost heritage? No, not really. My thoughts on the matter is that I believe that men and machines will likely merge together, and eventually the man part will simply be replaced by something smarter, faster or longer lived. No loss in that.

Of course, it kind of makes a mockery of religious beliefs, but that's not going to keep me from sleeping soundly tonight.
 
Last edited:
What amount of sympathy did you give the T-Rex, or he Mastodon?

I don't know if I had sympathy -- but there have been times I've wondered what the world would have been like had Reptiles had remained dominant and evolved as such and eventually (if applicable) became sentient, and what they would have looked like.


INRM
 
I don't know if I had sympathy -- but there have been times I've wondered what the world would have been like had Reptiles had remained dominant and evolved as such and eventually (if applicable) became sentient, and what they would have looked like.
Just enter any executive council meeting of your choice, then.
 
The point I'm saying is I *did* actually give the matter some thought, contrary to what Shadron expected.

Regardless, computers, as a form of technology are designed for the purpose of benefitting mankind. If they ended up becoming a threat to mankind, they would not be a benefit to us anymore now would they.

- In either case, I don't know what this cavalier attitude about "welcoming our silicon successors". Humans have a long-established right to defend themselves and preserve themselves even using (if necessary under certain circumstances) lethal force.
 
Regardless, computers, as a form of technology are designed for the purpose of benefitting mankind. If they ended up becoming a threat to mankind, they would not be a benefit to us anymore now would they
Other than sci-fi, I am unaware of any developments that pose a serious risk

Please identify the leading cause(s) for your concern on this matter
 
Well, there are ideas for fully autonomous military technology, like unmanned ships, submarines, aircraft, and the like. Basically this would involve A.I. controlling very destructive weapons systems. As just one example.

That can be extremely dangerous if they turned on us.


INRM
BTW: I've also written about this many times, just read my older posts...
 
That can be extremely dangerous if they turned on us
Extremely dangerous != rule

I assume that you're concerned about machines without an off switch and I'm wondering if such concerns have any basis in reality
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom