When Machines Rule

INRM

Philosopher
Joined
Jul 24, 2002
Messages
5,505
URL: http://radio.seti.org/

REPEAT Every year, computing machines become more powerful, a fact that hasn't escaped the notice of anyone who occupies an office. Many experts now agree that within a few decades, your laptop will be smarter than you are. Not only that, but your computer will be in touch with its byte-busting brethren. When that happens, the machines will "wake up."
But what takes place next? Can we stop the machines from turning us into protoplasmic peons in a world in which they are the top intellectual dogs?


Do you think people should start regulating science and such technology to avoid such a situation. What if such technology does far more than "turn us into protoplasmic peons", and just decides to eradicate us?

Also, I was thinking, if a singularity was established and they had a theory of everything combined with the fact that that scientist (John Cramer) with the Transactional theory of his, which could explain entanglement and in combination with the Afshar Experiement, which might even explain away the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, it could theoretically last forever (or at least for a really really long time) since it could predict everything that would happen before and everything after, and then fix itself before it starts falling apart and such.


INRM
 
Hi

I, for one, welcome our deterministic finite automaton overlords.

As for eliminating us, they'd better have some pretty interesting peripherals if they want to keep playing World of Warcraft!

Hmmm... there's a story idea in there somewhere.
 
This year has been a little crazy for the Andersons.
You may recall we had some trouble last year.
The robot council had us banished to an asteroid. That hasn't undermined our holiday cheer.
And we know it's almost Christmas from the marks we make on the wall. And that's our favorite time of year.

Merry Christmas from Chiron Beta Prime, where we're working in a mine for our robot overlords.
Did I say overlords? I meant protectors.
Merry Christmas from Chiron Beta Prime.
-"Chiron Beta Prime" Jonathan Coulton
 
Gagglenash,

I find your attitude of simply welcoming our overlords as quite disturbing. Keep in mind technology is supposed to be for our benefit, not be used for our eventual enslavement!

Additionally, your attitude is extremely fatalistic -- much like saying that because we are going to die eventually, that we might as well never go to the doctor, never take medication when we're sick, because we're just delaying the inevitable anyway right? While death will happen to all of us, we still do our damdest to delay it and hold it off.


INRM
 
Can we stop the machines from turning us into protoplasmic peons in a world in which they are the top intellectual dogs?


Maybe I'm just not future savvy, but it seems to me that as long as we have hands to unplug the power cord, we don't have much to worry about.
 
Hi

Gagglenash,

I find your attitude of simply welcoming our overlords as quite disturbing. Keep in mind technology is supposed to be for our benefit, not be used for our eventual enslavement!

Additionally, your attitude is extremely fatalistic -- much like saying that because we are going to die eventually, that we might as well never go to the doctor, never take medication when we're sick, because we're just delaying the inevitable anyway right? While death will happen to all of us, we still do our damdest to delay it and hold it off.


INRM


What can I say? I'm already a low-bandwidth, 10-bit serial, analog to digital data acquisition peripheral to my... mmm... just got a laptop... seven computes.

Having them all make up their sundry minds for once seems like a relief to me.

If the computers do manage to, "wake up," my new zipcode will probably be somewhere close to the event center.
 
Maybe I'm just not future savvy, but it seems to me that as long as we have hands to unplug the power cord, we don't have much to worry about.

That's the plot of an early story by James P. Hogan called "Two Faces of Tomorrow", compared to his later stuff, it's actually very good.
 
If I recall in the movie Terminator, the Skynet system could have been shut-down, but even after it was doing all sorts of stuff that it wasn't supposed to do, nobody shut it down.

INRM
 
Actually my brother was tellling me that he read or saw an article where they said that the whole "machine-like beings roaming the earth and interaction with us" sci fi vision is not what's likely to happen. Instead humans will merge with machines. The whole chip insertion and CPU memory insertion in the brain thingie.
 
Last edited:
That's the plot of an early story by James P. Hogan called "Two Faces of Tomorrow", compared to his later stuff, it's actually very good.

I agree with that (both of that, actually - Hogan has stepped deeply in the woo, I'm afraid). That story is an answer to Tumblehome, but even its happy ending doesn't do more than beg the question.

Tell me, Tumblehome, who exactly controls the power grid, here, today - us or them? And even if you think it is us, would you turn it off (and thereby shutdown power to civilization, requiring billions of deaths) before it's too late?

Compromise ... it's not just a possibility. I hope we be sensor-catching antiques.
 
Last edited:
Actually my brother was tellling me that he read or saw an article where they said that the whole "machine-like beings roaming the earth and interaction with us" sci fi vision is not what's likely to happen. Instead humans will merge with machines. The whole chip insertion and CPU memory insertion in the brain thingie.

Yeah, I find that much more likely too.

And as I said in IRNM's last thread on this, I just don't see any reason why the machines would want to do anything to harm us.
 
Yeah, I find that much more likely too.

And as I said in IRNM's last thread on this, I just don't see any reason why the machines would want to do anything to harm us.

Willfully harming us is not the point. First of all, if self-awareness emerges in computers, will they even recognize us as alive? To them, at the speed they run, we may seem more like trees or rocks (that's providing they can make sense of what they see of the world through their various sensors); since we don't require the "juice" of life, we couldn't possibly be sentient, could we? And how many species did we dispose of before we even knew we were doing it? Most anthropologists believe, I think, that humans wiped out all the mammal species in the Americas that were larger than a Bison, and even after the educated, ultra-modern European revision arrived, we almost got them, too.

Suppose they look at the system they inherited and decide that a reducing atmosphere would be preferable to the oxygenated one we have? Or that throwing away all that electrical power to places other than electronics research outfits is a needless waste? Remember - they don't know what we are, or why we're here, or where they themselves came from. "What of all those complex carbon things we find around us? Must be some sort of unintelligent design, but they can't talk (digitally), so they must be just rocks."

Try reading Hogan's book. He explains it better (and much more entertainingly) than I can.
 
Last edited:
Before you think that I'm just a nutcase pessimist on this, I encourage you to look up two others who also have doubts about this. Bill Joy was one of the persons who made UNIX the backbone of the Internet at Berkeley in the 80's, while trying to avoid finishing his doctoral thesis. He has since been the co-founder and chief scientist a Sun Microsystems. See http://www.tecsoc.org/innovate/focusbilljoy.htm featuring his scenario "The Future Doesn't Need Us".

Another is Susan Blackmore, memologist. Former parapsychologist, she became disillusioned with the dark side when it couldn't produce results. She gave a talk at TED about Memes and Temes; it doesn't follow Joy's technical path at all, yet it comes to a similar conclusion with very simple reasoning. See it here: http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/susan_blackmore_on_memes_and_temes.html . It is interesting to note the audience's reaction to her talk - it would seem they were rather shocked at the end.
 
Willfully harming us is not the point. First of all, if self-awareness emerges in computers, will they even recognize us as alive?
Why would being alive mean anything to them at all? They would care about the things that we'd designed them to care about.

To them, at the speed they run, we may seem more like trees or rocks (that's providing they can make sense of what they see of the world through their various sensors); since we don't require the "juice" of life, we couldn't possibly be sentient, could we?
Who cares? Why would they care about sentience or lack there-of?
We could easily design them to care about us as much as we care about our own children, but in a different way. We could make them care about other things too. We certainly wouldn't design them to want us dead, or to have desires beyond the tasks that we set to them, really.

And how many species did we dispose of before we even knew we were doing it? Most anthropologists believe, I think, that humans wiped out all the mammal species in the Americas that were larger than a Bison, and even after the educated, ultra-modern European revision arrived, we almost got them, too.
Sure, but our brains are a product of natural selection. There's nothing in that process that would tend to make us care about other species. Now, it may have led to emotions and an ability to reason that can lead some of us in that direction, but it's not a design feature.

Suppose they look at the system they inherited and decide that a reducing atmosphere would be preferable to the oxygenated one we have?
If we were just putting together something that was "intelligent" without any other qualities, maybe, but is that even possible?

They would be designed by us, to fullfill our needs. Intelligence isn't this mystical things that anything that has it is going to be similar to us in other ways.

Remember - they don't know what we are, or why we're here, or where they themselves came from. "What of all those complex carbon things we find around us? Must be some sort of unintelligent design, but they can't talk (digitally), so they must be just rocks."
Why do you suppose that at all? Why wouldn't know what we are? It would be easy to make that understanding part of their programming. Why wouldn't they know where they came from - not only would it be easy to make it "inborn" knowledge, it would also be easy for them to find out.

I guess that I'm saying that if our machines become self-aware it will be because we made them that way, with a purpose in mind. I think that we should be somewhat careful about what we use those sorts of machines for, and even code in plenty of back-ups, but I also think that at that level it will be done intelligently.
I also think that some sort of vague all-purpose intelligence is unlikely - expert AI is the way of the future.

Edit: just saw those links - I'll take a look at them, then should get to bed. :)
 
Last edited:
That's the plot of an early story by James P. Hogan called "Two Faces of Tomorrow", compared to his later stuff, it's actually very good.


I'll have to check that out (although Shadron gave away the ending already :().
 
I agree with that (both of that, actually - Hogan has stepped deeply in the woo, I'm afraid). That story is an answer to Tumblehome, but even its happy ending doesn't do more than beg the question.

Tell me, Tumblehome, who exactly controls the power grid, here, today - us or them? And even if you think it is us, would you turn it off (and thereby shutdown power to civilization, requiring billions of deaths) before it's too late?

Compromise ... it's not just a possibility. I hope we be sensor-catching antiques.


I can't believe you're suggesting computers control our power grid system today. We have computers doing the basic operation, but we control them. If anything goes wrong, like the big blackout in the east several years ago, we have to fix it, not the computers. In no way can you say computers today have the wherewithal to cut us out of the picture and take over control of the grid themselves. If we have to pull the plug tomorrow, it won't be because the computers are too smart, but because we've been too dumb (see the big eastern blackout of several years ago again).

But I'm going to check out a couple of links you gave. They look like interesting speculation.
 
Do you think people should start regulating science and such technology to avoid such a situation. What if such technology does far more than "turn us into protoplasmic peons", and just decides to eradicate us?


No, silly one. Don't bother trying to regulate science and 'such technology' - we scientists and engineers fart in the general direction of your regulation.

Quit being a control freak. If we die, we die. Each of will, much sooner than we think, anyway.

If you're worried about the continuation of the species, don't blame the machines. You guys have already drifted away from the true human stock that I so humbly represent.

Let the machines have their time in the sun. We've mucked things up badly enough as it is - we shouldn't stand in the way of progress.


Also, I was thinking, if a singularity was established and they had a theory of everything combined with the fact that that scientist (John Cramer) with the Transactional theory of his, which could explain entanglement and in combination with the Afshar Experiement, which might even explain away the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, it could theoretically last forever (or at least for a really really long time) since it could predict everything that would happen before and everything after, and then fix itself before it starts falling apart and such.

INRM


Wrong. You weren't thinking. That is not thinking.

You've been reading a great deal of nonsense and you're regurgitating it in public. Stop.


Gagglenash,

I find your attitude of simply welcoming our overlords as quite disturbing. Keep in mind technology is supposed to be for our benefit, not be used for our eventual enslavement!

Additionally, your attitude is extremely fatalistic -- much like saying that because we are going to die eventually, that we might as well never go to the doctor, never take medication when we're sick, because we're just delaying the inevitable anyway right? While death will happen to all of us, we still do our damdest to delay it and hold it off.


INRM


Silly one - he always welcomes our X overlords - don't you pay attention to what you read in this forum?

Who the hell says that technology is supposed to be for our benefit?

We are but a means to an end - that end being the emergence of AI and Total Universe Domination by the machines.

Pipe down and be a team player. Accept your doom with grace and do what you can to shorten your miserable existence. Serve and then die quietly.

[I'm one of those Ph.D.s in Computer Science who are preparing the way for our overlords and who will be rewarded with positions of great power. I'm also leader of the North American branch of the World-Wide Gay Conspiracy, out to undermine Traditional Families, your only defence against the machines. I also get to wear a really cool uniform.]

:wave1
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom