When Machines Rule

Solus,

Self Replicating Nanomachines can be very dangerous if used improperly...
 
StarGate's human form Replicators would also fit the bill.

The point remains though - just because a machine might be able to *think* something doesn't mean it can *do* something. This principle remains regardless of the intelligence or task.
 
URL: http://radio.seti.org/




Do you think people should start regulating science and such technology to avoid such a situation. What if such technology does far more than "turn us into protoplasmic peons", and just decides to eradicate us?

Also, I was thinking, if a singularity was established and they had a theory of everything combined with the fact that that scientist (John Cramer) with the Transactional theory of his, which could explain entanglement and in combination with the Afshar Experiement, which might even explain away the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, it could theoretically last forever (or at least for a really really long time) since it could predict everything that would happen before and everything after, and then fix itself before it starts falling apart and such.


INRM
The only way machines could dominate the human race would be if they were programed to be more intelligent and given manipulative organs. It may be possible to invent a computer more intelligent than a human scientist but hows it going to get out of the box?
 
Any AI that would _not_ behave like animals is very likely to be eliminated by natural selection eventually.

And what would be the value of leaving behind a "legacy", given that "best" is a value judgment - as such entirely subjective - and depends on a subject to perform evaluation?

You need think beyond organic evolution. Imagine a being that has the mental capacity of a a hundred trillion minds in perfect unison. Now give that being the ability to manipulative the environment and itself with nanomachines being a piece and the machine itself. With such abilities this being could advance as much or as little as it would see fit.

The only value is that it's interesting to think that mere humans created it.:cool:
 
You need think beyond organic evolution. Imagine a being that has the mental capacity of a a hundred trillion minds in perfect unison.
It' called "Marvin" and has every reason to be seriously depressed.

Seriously, either the "thing" is self-replicating, or contains self-replicating parts - then it's "kind" will be subject to selection pressure - organic or not. "Things" that do not self-replicate will slowly decay - and due to the lack of selection pressure - the decay will be completely random and very unlikely to produce anything beneficial "just per chance".

I cannot see how any "beyond organic" evolution would not favor "things" that replicate best, even at the expense of other "things" and hence "behave like animals".

Now give that being the ability to manipulative the environment and itself with nanomachines being a piece and the machine itself. With such abilities this being could advance as much or as little as it would see fit.

There already have been numerous discussions of "free will", and the consensus so far seems to be that - absent any woo - the concept of "free will" is nonsensical, any activity being either purely random or deterministic processes or a combination of both at work and there is not even any philosophical wiggle room, since randomness and determinism are also exhaustive, as far as any process.

That in mind, any such "intelligence" will be dysfunctional without environmental influence - that it has no control over on the other hand. It's further development is shaped solely by the environment.

The only value is that it's interesting to think that mere humans created it.:cool:

In the absence of its creators, who is going to "think" and why in particular are they supposed to find it "interesting"?

P.S. An what about the possibility that imperial forces might discover it first and use its computational power to squash the rebellion?
 
The only way machines could dominate the human race would be if they were programed to be more intelligent and given manipulative organs. It may be possible to invent a computer more intelligent than a human scientist but hows it going to get out of the box?

Oh CainKane (unless you are being facetious), have you not ever heard of computer controlled machine tools? Almost everything more complicated than a drill press today has a computerized control. It is not really that far from reality to have a completely computerized factory; it might well be true now if it weren't for union rules.

And how about the robots that you can see on youtube?

All through this thread I've argued that computers are up and coming and will supplant us in the not-to-distant future. Will that actually happen? I don't know, but I'm here to tell you that there are people who know a whole lot more about computers, AI and robotics than I do who do think that the possibility is there, and I can't see any valid argument that convincingly shuts them down. INRM's wishful thinking won't do it, and all the other arguments I've heard here are just weak.

Identifiable electronic computers started out during WWII. They've had 60 years, and they have gotten far enough that they intercommunicate, that they can almost physically reproduce themselves, they're mobile in many different ways, and the research into adaptive programming is close to making them self-realizable, or close enough that to us it looks the same. There will always be pressures to make them faster, bigger and stronger (to borrow an Olympic theme).

I once read a couple of books by Robert Forward named Dragon's Egg and Starquake, about a life form living on the surface of neutron star. They live life much faster than we do; their life times amount to 20 minutes in our time. When a probe from earth investigates the star, they are in an equivalent of the human stone age, but once communication is established, the humans start sending them information, and they gain ground so fast that within two weeks they have space travel to other nearby stars, and go out to visit their visitors, in spite of a catastrophic starquake that sets them back (akin to our Dark Ages). I have a feeling that we may be right at that cusp of that with machine intelligence, and that pretty soon they will zoom right on past us. What that will mean to us is anyone's guess.
 
Last edited:
Wuschel,

What's "Marvin"?


Shadron,

All through this thread I've argued that computers are up and coming and will supplant us in the not-to-distant future. Will that actually happen? I don't know, but I'm here to tell you that there are people who know a whole lot more about computers, AI and robotics than I do who do think that the possibility is there, and I can't see any valid argument that convincingly shuts them down.

Just because you cannot think of a reasonable argument doesn't mean there isn't a reasonable argument btw...

INRM's wishful thinking won't do it, and all the other arguments I've heard here are just weak.

Maybe so, but I think something needs to be done to slow things down and prevent (at least in my lifetime) A.I's from replacing us and god-forbid (yes it's a figurative term) doing a Terminator-like scenario on us all or imprisoning us all.


INRM
 
Which one? Yes doesn't convey too much info...

Fiction?

or

Real?
 
shadron said:
All through this thread I've argued that computers are up and coming and will supplant us in the not-to-distant future. Will that actually happen? I don't know, but I'm here to tell you that there are people who know a whole lot more about computers, AI and robotics than I do who do think that the possibility is there, and I can't see any valid argument that convincingly shuts them down.



Just because you cannot think of a reasonable argument doesn't mean there isn't a reasonable argument btw...
INRM

Perhaps you believe, INRM, that I enjoy drawing that conclusion, just so I can be da winna' in a thread on this forum. While I believe logically that if there's a better being out there let it rule (whatever that means), I do most certainly hope it is homo sap, because I are one. I can't quite seem to get past that hurdle into absolute don't-care-edness. Call me a romantic.

In any case, I certainly hope there's something more that I haven't explored, or that we and the machines can come to an amicable settlement that doesn't leave us as the slum lords in our local star cluster. Being partners in the great space exploration is a grand idea, but just being the spam in a can for nostalgia's sake doesn't, as our astronaut corps has found. I just can't think of such an argument, nor has this thread raised one.
 
Last edited:
Which one? Yes doesn't convey too much info...

Fiction?

or

Real?

But that's a different question. Three of them, actually!

It is an undisputed fact that

MARVIN
("Multithreaded Anthropogenetic Ruggedized Virtual Intelligence Network")

indeed is

Not made by:
Prefect Robotics
42 Research Park
Guildford
England


Also: "England" is known to be non-fiction, and there exists a "Guildford" in England, which is known to be non-fiction...

So where do you believe might there be a fiction aspect to all this? Do you suspect there is no "Research Park"?
 
I maintain that welcoming our robot overlords/replacement or whatever variation of this statement is wrong -- we have a right to preserve our own species.

Any sentient being has the right to place it's own value above that of any other -- humans even have the right to kill other humans if the human in question was threatened by the others.

The fact that we will die does not mean that we forfeit this right -- as long as we are alive, we have this right, we do not just sit and welcome death.


INRM
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom