When Machines Rule

The evil scientist cabal/cult is still on-- right ??

(I mean I paid my dues and all...)
(and I worship at the altar of the cracker-irreverent PZ)


[Absolutely! Just don't tell anyone else for now - I can't handle any more jealous rants and tears of rage today. This game has just plum worn me out.]

P.S. PZ's gone and done it now - he's gonna desecrate a Koran, too. He says the cracker's gonna get it on Wednesday. Both the catholics and the muslims will be out for blood, and both groups have enough total wackos to pose a real threat. I think his evil plan is to get both groups to rush at him brandishing weapons, and then he'll duck and they'll chop each other to bits, just like the good old days.
 
What I believe, INRM, is that you've been had.

Touche, I stand defeated.

I don't believe most of what I've written in this thread.

Now that I think about it, that would make sense.

Once I found out that you took seriously some of what I'd written as a joke, I decided to see how far down the garden path you could be led.

All the way down the rabbit hole, it seems.

Isn't that a line from The Matrix?

Dude, you've got to quit believing everything you read on the internet.

Much of it is wrong, and some of it is just for fun.

I know, that's true. But there's so much data out there across this vast web -- How do you determine which is BS (I know generally if it involves paranormal stuff and psychics it's BS by default... and in certain fields I know a lot about, I can generally spot a good stinkin' piece of BS) and which is not when some of it sounds pretty plausible?

The following are true:

I have a Ph.D. in computer science.[/quote]

Sounds true to me.

I am interested in AI and specialized in automated reasoning in graduate school.

Sounds about right.

I'm not at all worried about the domination of humans by machine intelligences.

That is obvious.

I am concerned about the ethics of experimentation with artificial intelligences and concerned with how they would be treated by humans.

That I could believe.

I am gay.

I know that, you mentioned it before. In either case, it doesn't really matter much to me.

I am the leader of the North American Branch of the World-Wide Gay Conspiracy, but I haven't decided on a uniform yet.

Now that's a big stinkin' load of BS,

INRM
 
Thank you, INRM, for being a good sport.

A lot of reading of good books will help you develop your BS detector. It is enjoyable and well worth the trouble.

I could be the leader of the North American Branch of the World-Wide Gay Consipiracy but I'm far too lazy and not much of a joiner. I'd have to invent it first, of course, but getting elected as its head wouldn't be difficult. It would be fun until someone else joined...
 
Go to any modern central power control station. Do you really think you'll find something as gauche as an actual breaker switch that does the deed?

Okay, wire cutters then, or a hammer. Or dynamite.

What you will find is computers which, if you enter the correct commands, will start a chain of events which will eventually disconnect the generators from the grid. Right now you may find some people in that chain, but not for much longer. Now, if a computer becomes self-aware ("Self-aware" in this case best means that it knows how to modify its own programming in a very general way, just as we do) and decides that such is tantamount to terminating its existence, and presuming it has been instructed to take steps to forestall just such an event (cf Dept. of Home Security), how are you going to prevent it from stopping you from stopping it? Dynamite? If you even think that, you've already lost.

That's all dependent on the computers on the grid being self-aware. How long until that happens? And if it does, would we put self-aware computers in charge of the grid?

And for the sake of argument, let's say we let it get to the point where we have to use dynamite. We haven't lost, just suffered a setback. The system could be rebuilt with "dumber" computers.

These repair people you speak of - how do they get their orders? I'll give you an inside tip - they started using hand held computers ten years ago. And they are being replaced as fast as possible by cheap mechanisms.

Consider: Sixty years ago, there were no computers at all, in any capacity, in power generation. If we place a telescope on the far side of the moon, how will its power generation needs be handled? See the thread on Men in Space if you think it will be human.

I'm a bit out of my league here, but wouldn't it be handled the same as the Mars rovers or any satellite are now? That is, by automation, which doesn't mean the computers have sentient control.

I can't believe that you think that you'll always have your hands on the switch.

Why not? We have the choice. We can either let AI take control of essential infrastructure or not.

As it is right now, humans do have that control, but I think the time is past when any person in the US below the President himself has the authority of totally shutting down an area, say, the size of any three states. The president could have that authority (see Clancy's "Executive Orders", for example), but I think that soon the power net will be international in scope and even that ability will be lost.

I'm not saying all is lost, and that we'll be extinct in a couple of hundred years, but I think you do need to consider the possibility and what can be done to ameliorate it. It sure would be neat to imagine us and the computers together forming a partnership, but you need to make it happen, not just wait and hope for it. And you'll also need to know that we will definitely be the junior partners.

What happens in the future will depend on us, for sure. My original objection was to your point that computers control the power grid now.

shadron said:
Sorry about that but I was making a point. Read it anyway. Does knowing the outcome of 99% of every TV serial ever played keep you from watching them? Are you here to learn or be entertained?

Sorry, that was just an offhand quip I made :(. I'm still going to read the story, of course. In fact, I'm really anxious to read it.
 
Tumblehome,
Why not? We have the choice. We can either let AI take control of essential infrastructure or not.

I agree, we should *not* let AI take control of essential infrastructure. It will only invite trouble.
 
That might not be as easy as you think. I'm just finishing a sci-fi book by James P. Hogan called "The Two Faces of Tomorrow" which addresses that very scenario.

ETA: Ack! Lensman beat me to it.

It's my Lens, it enables me to read the minds of everyone on this forum & jump in with a post ahead of them if I want to. :D ;)
 
Last edited:
Tumblehome,


I agree, we should *not* let AI take control of essential infrastructure. It will only invite trouble.

Unfortunately, you are outvoted. The power companies travel to the beat of their stock prices, and cheaper (i.e., more automated) is better. Just follow the trend over the last fifty years, extrapolate it out a little bit more from where we are now, and you'll be on the wrong side of the fence.

In Hogan's book, the opening scene depicts just such a scenario (I'll try not to spoil it for Tumblehome). An automated operation on he moon gets out of hand because the AI commanded to do a job wasn't given enough information. Giving it more will only make it more powerful. How does one handle the dilemma? As of now, here in reality, not answered at all.
 
This is an AI we're talking about, no a Mac or a PC.

This is no Deus Ex Machina - a system does not gain magical abilities because you decide it does.
 
Shadron,

Yes, and I understand why they make those decisions. I still respectfully think they're wrong and ultimately could end up disastrous.


cyborg,

What's "Deus Ex Machina" mean?


INRM
 
I can't believe that you think that you'll always have your hands on the switch. As it is right now, humans do have that control, but I think the time is past when any person in the US below the President himself has the authority of totally shutting down an area, say, the size of any three states. The president could have that authority (see Clancy's "Executive Orders", for example), but I think that soon the power net will be international in scope and even that ability will be lost.
The president shutting down an area reminded me of a factoid I learned just earlier this week. A friend in Texas said that that state remains, by law, completely independent of the electrical grid in the USA. He cited the case of a wind farm on the Texas/Oklahoma border where juice from the towers on the Oklahoma side of the farm could not be fed into Texas.

Can any of you Texans confirm this story?
 
In either case, I think A.I. involved in the running of infrastructure should be limited to a certain degree of intelligence (say no more than a 5 or 10 year old, give or take a few years), and should not be sentient to limit a run-away situation.

To cyborg,
Thank you for your explanation


INRM
BTW: When I said equivalent to a 5 or 10 year old, it was a hypothetical figure
 
What's "Deus Ex Machina" mean?

Deus ex machina ("God from a machine") is a literary convention frowned upon by most writers, in which an unexplained miracle occurs to resolve the conflict in a story, thereby cheating the audience of a logically satisfying climax. The term arises from some Greek plays in which "god" is literally dropped onto the stage from a basket suspended on a pulley, and proceeds to wipe out he foe. It essentially means a deceitful resolution. In a sense, Alexander's resolution of the Gordian knot problem was a Deus ex Machina.
 
In either case, I think A.I. involved in the running of infrastructure should be limited to a certain degree of intelligence (say no more than a 5 or 10 year old, give or take a few years), and should not be sentient to limit a run-away situation.

The point you seem to be missing INRM is that a person - no matter how intelligent - who is a quadriplegic isn't going to Riverdance any more than an AI is going to be able to do arbitrary things just because it has a specific level of intelligence.
 
Correct, not until you throw self replicating nanomachines in the mix.

I think it's interesting to consider that an AI would be the best legacy humans could leave behind. Our species certainly isn't going to last, we are animals in the end and we behave too much like animals.
 
I think it's interesting to consider that an AI would be the best legacy humans could leave behind. Our species certainly isn't going to last, we are animals in the end and we behave too much like animals.
Any AI that would _not_ behave like animals is very likely to be eliminated by natural selection eventually.

And what would be the value of leaving behind a "legacy", given that "best" is a value judgment - as such entirely subjective - and depends on a subject to perform evaluation?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom