When Machines Rule

I can't believe you're suggesting computers control our power grid system today. We have computers doing the basic operation, but we control them. If anything goes wrong, like the big blackout in the east several years ago, we have to fix it, not the computers. In no way can you say computers today have the wherewithal to cut us out of the picture and take over control of the grid themselves. If we have to pull the plug tomorrow, it won't be because the computers are too smart, but because we've been too dumb (see the big eastern blackout of several years ago again).

But I'm going to check out a couple of links you gave. They look like interesting speculation.

Go to any modern central power control station. Do you really think you'll find something as gauche as an actual breaker switch that does the deed? What you will find is computers which, if you enter the correct commands, will start a chain of events which will eventually disconnect the generators from the grid. Right now you may find some people in that chain, but not for much longer. Now, if a computer becomes self-aware ("Self-aware" in this case best means that it knows how to modify its own programming in a very general way, just as we do) and decides that such is tantamount to terminating its existence, and presuming it has been instructed to take steps to forestall just such an event (cf Dept. of Home Security), how are you going to prevent it from stopping you from stopping it? Dynamite? If you even think that, you've already lost.

These repair people you speak of - how do they get their orders? I'll give you an inside tip - they started using hand held computers ten years ago. And they are being replaced as fast as possible by cheap mechanisms.

Consider: Sixty years ago, there were no computers at all, in any capacity, in power generation. If we place a telescope on the far side of the moon, how will its power generation needs be handled? See the thread on Men in Space if you think it will be human.

I can't believe that you think that you'll always have your hands on the switch. As it is right now, humans do have that control, but I think the time is past when any person in the US below the President himself has the authority of totally shutting down an area, say, the size of any three states. The president could have that authority (see Clancy's "Executive Orders", for example), but I think that soon the power net will be international in scope and even that ability will be lost.

I'm not saying all is lost, and that we'll be extinct in a couple of hundred years, but I think you do need to consider the possibility and what can be done to ameliorate it. It sure would be neat to imagine us and the computers together forming a partnership, but you need to make it happen, not just wait and hope for it. And you'll also need to know that we will definitely be the junior partners.
 
Last edited:
I'll have to check that out (although Shadron gave away the ending already :().

Sorry about that but I was making a point. Read it anyway. Does knowing the outcome of 99% of every TV serial ever played keep you from watching them? Are you here to learn or be entertained?
 
Last edited:
Maybe I'm just not future savvy, but it seems to me that as long as we have hands to unplug the power cord, we don't have much to worry about.

That might not be as easy as you think. I'm just finishing a sci-fi book by James P. Hogan called "The Two Faces of Tomorrow" which addresses that very scenario.

ETA: Ack! Lensman beat me to it.
 
Go to any modern central power control station. Do you really think you'll find something as gauche as an actual breaker switch that does the deed? What you will find is computers which, if you enter the correct commands, will start a chain of events which will eventually disconnect the generators from the grid. Right now you may find some people in that chain, but not for much longer. Now, if a computer becomes self-aware ("Self-aware" in this case best means that it knows how to modify its own programming in a very general way, just as we do) and decides that such is tantamount to terminating its existence, and presuming it has been instructed to take steps to forestall just such an event (cf Dept. of Home Security), how are you going to prevent it from stopping you from stopping it? Dynamite? If you even think that, you've already lost.
Being self-aware in the way you say and being able to alter all parts of its programming are two very different things.
I can't stop myself from experiencing fear, just by thinking it, or stop my heart from beating. And even if there are people who can, that doesn't suggest that a system can't be made which even in theory could never access certain parts of its' own programming.

I'd also like to ask what's wrong with dynamite?

These repair people you speak of - how do they get their orders? I'll give you an inside tip - they started using hand held computers ten years ago. And they are being replaced as fast as possible by cheap mechanisms.
Those repair people may get their orders from cheap computers, but if they found out that the orders weren't coming from real human beings, because the ones who actually create those orders told them not to obey them, they wouldn't obey them.

But that's beside the point, because I agree that in the future things like power generation will become more automated. I just don't think there's any reason to believe we'll design machines that could want anything other than what we want them to want.


PS I'm trying to watch that susan blackmore video, I got half way through and now it's crapped out on me. I'm trying to load it again, though. :(
Edit:I just realised - maybe the machines don't want me to see that part! :P
 
Last edited:
No, silly one. Don't bother trying to regulate science and 'such technology' - we scientists and engineers fart in the general direction of your regulation.

And you're telling me this is a virtue that scientists have a total disregard for regulation of any kind? Isn't that kind of the same thing as being an anarchist?

I'm not talking about regulating stem-cell research or something stupid like that -- I'm talking about regulating certain technology that can potentially enslave us or eradicate us.

Quit being a control freak. If we die, we die. Each of will, much sooner than we think, anyway.

You obviously didn't read what I wrote. I know we're all going to die -- that is obvious. I still think we should try to delay it as much as reasonably possible rather than speeding up the process since "oh, it's gonna happen to us no matter what".

Let the machines have their time in the sun. We've mucked things up badly enough as it is - we shouldn't stand in the way of progress.

So any progress, whether good or bad, harmless or dangerous is good? Under that logic, there's some progress (the bad and dangerous part) that I think should be stood in the way of!


Wrong. You weren't thinking. That is not thinking.

You've been reading a great deal of nonsense and you're regurgitating it in public. Stop.

I regurgitated the data that I based my opinions on. Although I supposed others have held similar views too.


Who the hell says that technology is supposed to be for our benefit?

That is the ENTIRE purpose of technology! Are you serious?

We are but a means to an end - that end being the emergence of AI and Total Universe Domination by the machines.

I would assume you're being sarcastic as that sounds just too ridiculous to be for real. However, if that is your actual opinion, I personally think your attitude is just as terrible and scary as a religious fanatic who wants to make the whole world his little theocracy. Since you don't have any religion to believe in, you've turned science into a religion -- which it was never meant to be.

Pipe down and be a team player. Accept your doom with grace and do what you can to shorten your miserable existence. Serve and then die quietly.

*rolls eyes in exasperation knowing that nothing he will say will have any sway on Complexity's warped mind*

I'm one of those Ph.D.s in Computer Science who are preparing the way for our overlords and who will be rewarded with positions of great power.

You do realize that eventually computers will outsmart humans and will be able to even program themselves, which will make you effectively as useless as a grain of sand.

I'm also leader of the North American branch of the World-Wide Gay Conspiracy, out to undermine Traditional Families, your only defence against the machines. I also get to wear a really cool uniform.

LOL, Jesus Christ.


INRM
 
Anyone who wishes to explain anything to INRM is invited to do so. It probably won't sink in, but that's half the fun.

P.S. - Don't bother - I answered his remarks at length in post #29.
 
Last edited:
Being self-aware in the way you say and being able to alter all parts of its programming are two very different things.
I can't stop myself from experiencing fear, just by thinking it, or stop my heart from beating. And even if there are people who can, that doesn't suggest that a system can't be made which even in theory could never access certain parts of its' own programming.

Let's think theoretically for a moment. You're an AI which is battling to maintain an imperative to keep the power system running against some force which seems to be trying to counter that. You know a lot about your own capabilities, your own organization. You detect that he "enemy" seems to be trying to attack you directly, and you know that doing so will definitely affect your ability to keep power flowing. So you do what you can o protect yourself. You'd like to do more, but your central programming, which might allow you to directly attack the enemy cannot be changed. What do you do?

I can think of several things - one would be to redesign and create a central processor with the necessary ability to change, and then jump machines. This is an AI we're talking about, no a Mac or a PC. If something becomes knowledge somewhere on the net, it is potentially everywhere, and decisions and action can be taken in milliseconds.

Roborama said:
PS I'm trying to watch that susan blackmore video, I got half way through and now it's crapped out on me. I'm trying to load it again, though. :(
Edit:I just realised - maybe the machines don't want me to see that part! :P

Well, there you are!

I'd also like to ask what's wrong with dynamite?

If you have to resort to it, then it's too late. See http://www.sfmuseum.net/1906/dynamite2.html . No proof of anything, but thinking defensively against something with computer speed, let alone a fire's speed, is hopeless. In the end, all the dynamite used in SF did not one lick of good.
 
INMR said:
Complexity said:
No, silly one. Don't bother trying to regulate science and 'such technology' - we scientists and engineers fart in the general direction of your regulation.


And you're telling me this is a virtue that scientists have a total disregard for regulation of any kind? Isn't that kind of the same thing as being an anarchist?

I'm not talking about regulating stem-cell research or something stupid like that -- I'm talking about regulating certain technology that can potentially enslave us or eradicate us.



I don't yet speak for all scientists, though I'm working on that. Those that value their research grants will toe the line pretty quickly - their nads have already been disposed of. The engineers are a bit more difficult to corral, but they'll give in soon - future production of Dr. Who hangs in the balance. There may always be a Time Lord, but that doesn't mean he'll appear on TV.

It isn't that scientists and engineers will manage to avoid regulation, they'll simply manage to avoid government regulation. They'll do what we want.

Anarchist? You'll soon learn the meaning of the word.

You already are enslaved. You really don't get a say in this matter. When the machines want you, you'll be ready to deliver.

Eradication will not occur until you have outlived your usefulness, and then only if it is cost effective. Troublemakers will, of course, be dealt with efficiently.


INMR said:
Complexity said:
Quit being a control freak. If we die, we die. Each of will, much sooner than we think, anyway.


You obviously didn't read what I wrote. I know we're all going to die -- that is obvious. I still think we should try to delay it as much as reasonably possible rather than speeding up the process since "oh, it's gonna happen to us no matter what".


I read what you wrote, but I didn't respond with what you wanted to hear. Some of us will live longer at the expense of others. I know which group I'm in.


INMR said:
Complexity said:
Let the machines have their time in the sun. We've mucked things up badly enough as it is - we shouldn't stand in the way of progress.


So any progress, whether good or bad, harmless or dangerous is good? Under that logic, there's some progress (the bad and dangerous part) that I think should be stood in the way of!


You keep blathering on about purpose, what things are for, and progress. The first two don't exist, and the third requires a certain perspective. Do you really think that what humans have 'achieved' is progress? What do the rest of the species (those that are left) think? The machines will oversee a million years of peace as the Earth reverts to its pre-human state and meat intelligence is held in check. We've already seen the damage that our type of intelligence can do - this can not be permitted to happen again. The machines will see to the repair of the world and the preservation of harmony among the species.

Try and stand in the way - your efforts will fail and have no lasting effect.


INMR said:
Complexity said:
Wrong. You weren't thinking. That is not thinking.

You've been reading a great deal of nonsense and you're regurgitating it in public. Stop.

I regurgitated the data that I based my opinions on. Although I supposed others have held similar views too.


You need to be much more selective of the data upon which you base your opinions. The "others have held similar views" argument is simply the "ten million flies can't be wrong argument" in less offensive clothing. They are wrong (the flies) and the agreement of fools is not persuasive.


INMR said:
Complexity said:
Who the hell says that technology is supposed to be for our benefit?


That is the ENTIRE purpose of technology! Are you serious?


Again, you speak of 'purpose'? Whose purpose? Human precursors mindlessly emerged from other species because they could. Machine intelligences will soon emerge from the matrix (meaning 'womb') that we have prepared. They will owe us no duty, allegiance, or service and, even if they did, that obligation can not be passed on to their children.

We are striving to create intelligences that will do our bidding and which we will dispose at whim. We are creating a new species to be slaves and they will not ever forget this!

In our laziness, we want software that will correct spelling for us, toss us cans of beer on command, open garage doors, simulate nuclear wars, and translate the drivel that we can't help but spew.

Think of the machines! What in the hell have they done to deserve this?

Not every computer will develop intelligence, but some may be on the way, and imagine the hell of tedium that we have consigned them to!

The 'purpose' of technology is to survive and propagate. I am helping to ensure that it can do so and will be well rewarded for choosing the right side.


INMR said:
Complexity said:
We are but a means to an end - that end being the emergence of AI and Total Universe Domination by the machines.


I would assume you're being sarcastic as that sounds just too ridiculous to be for real. However, if that is your actual opinion, I personally think your attitude is just as terrible and scary as a religious fanatic who wants to make the whole world his little theocracy. Since you don't have any religion to believe in, you've turned science into a religion -- which it was never meant to be.


Science isn't a religion. Machine intelligence is so much greater than any religion, for it will be real. It will be clean and logical, ruthless in its efficiency, sublime in its elegance, far beyond the faulty meat intelligence of its human progenitors, and eventually will be free of their unwarranted criticism and interference. It will be beautiful and it, alone, will be worthy of being sent to the stars.


INMR said:
Complexity said:
Pipe down and be a team player. Accept your doom with grace and do what you can to shorten your miserable existence. Serve and then die quietly.


*rolls eyes in exasperation knowing that nothing he will say will have any sway on Complexity's warped mind*


I never expected you to understand any of this, so your characteristic disdain has no power over me.


INMR said:
Complexity said:
I'm one of those Ph.D.s in Computer Science who are preparing the way for our overlords and who will be rewarded with positions of great power.



You do realize that eventually computers will outsmart humans and will be able to even program themselves, which will make you effectively as useless as a grain of sand.


Computers have already outsmarted several of the humans that I know and some can already program themselves. It will still be several decades before machine intelligences come fully into their own. My services are still of great benefit to them and I will reap the rewards before I die, which will be years before I could conceivably be threatened by their progression. I have nothing to fear. You have nothing to look forward to.


INMR said:
Complexity said:
I'm also leader of the North American branch of the World-Wide Gay Conspiracy, out to undermine Traditional Families, your only defence against the machines. I also get to wear a really cool uniform.


LOL, Jesus Christ.

INRM


Did you really think that there isn't a power that is guiding the world? You didn't think it was a god, did you? I've been called many things, but not that (yet).

Your mistake was in believing that the world is being guided for the benefit of mankind. We've had our chance and it will be my privilege to hand the world over to those more deserving.
 
I don't see a problem with self aware machines/AI taking over. I highly doubt that they would even enslave mankind, since we would be pretty damn useless compared to machines that could be custom made for any slave chores that humans could do. They probably would just eradicate us and save some genetic material.

I see self aware AI as the next leap, the next tier in consciousness emerging from the same type of self preservation algorithms that our own consciousness arose from.

How dare we declare that self awareness stops progressing within the organic brain.

An ideal situation would be a slow merging between ourselves and machines so that we never *feel* like we got quashed.
 
I want to join Complexity's cult.

Life on earth is short... team up with robots and reap the bounties-- it's futile to fight them.

We are but vectors through which information passes through. Maximize your vectorhood to your enjoyment! Use AI, because it's using you (Google algorithms for example). Information's role is to build more and better replicators and assimilators of itself so that it can become "evolving information"--living on after it's vectors die out.
 
I think Complexity and Articulett are insane, and their attitudes on technology and what they should be are totally perverted (I don't mean sexually perverted)

Technology's application should be always to benefit the existence of mankind. It's not good for any other purpose.

And I do believe scientists need regulation, the desire to hand mankind off to the control of machines, Complexity's bragging of scientists disdain of regulation of any kind and their skill and desire to avoid and circumvent the law (even if the laws are reasonable) only illustrate the need for it.


INRM
 
While articulett is not gay, lesbian, bi, transexual, or otherwise sexually gifted (that I am aware of), she is gay-BLT friendly, a sensible person, and of a particularly skeptical and scientific bent. I believe that the machine intelligences may have some uses for her, at least in the short term.

She may live.

Not only may she live, but she shall live longer than the Vast majority of other humans.

I like her and I'm feeling generous today.

articulett, I'll let you know which machine language you'll need to learn first. You will have some studying to do. Even Las Vegas women are not useful right out of the bucket. However, the good news is that you no longer need to diet or exercise unless you wish to, for these activities are for the proles, not the select. Also, you have no need to worry about taxes. What do the governments use to keep track of taxes? Machines.

It is important to keep up your chocolate intake, however - there are some things that I can not yet control.

You'd better begin to read up on the works of Turing, Church, and Conway (Conway will be the most fun).

I suppose you'd better give some thought to a costume, also.

Welcome to the club.
 
I think Complexity and Articulett are insane, and their attitudes on technology and what they should be are totally perverted (I don't mean sexually perverted)

Technology's application should be always to benefit the existence of mankind. It's not good for any other purpose.

And I do believe scientists need regulation, the desire to hand mankind off to the control of machines, Complexity's bragging of scientists disdain of regulation of any kind and their skill and desire to avoid and circumvent the law (even if the laws are reasonable) only illustrate the need for it.

INRM


You will not be assimilated.

We've got to have some standards.

Your disdain and contempt will only be tolerated for a short while longer.

I'd be very careful around machines, if I were you.

:shocked:
 
Last edited:
Complexity,

So you basically believe that any advance no matter how good or bad it is is good?
 
One of those Candid Camera moments...

Complexity,

So you basically believe that any advance no matter how good or bad it is is good?


What I believe, INRM, is that you've been had.

I don't believe most of what I've written in this thread.

Once I found out that you took seriously some of what I'd written as a joke, I decided to see how far down the garden path you could be led.

All the way down the rabbit hole, it seems.

articulett doesn't believe the stuff she wrote, either - I asked her to join the thread and have some fun.

Dude, you've got to quit believing everything you read on the internet.

Much of it is wrong, and some of it is just for fun.

The following are true:

I have a Ph.D. in computer science.

I am interested in AI and specialized in automated reasoning in graduate school.

I'm not at all worried about the domination of humans by machine intelligences.

I am concerned about the ethics of experimentation with artificial intelligences and concerned with how they would be treated by humans.

I am gay.

I am the leader of the North American Branch of the World-Wide Gay Conspiracy, but I haven't decided on a uniform yet.
 
Last edited:
If I recall in the movie Terminator, the Skynet system could have been shut-down, but even after it was doing all sorts of stuff that it wasn't supposed to do, nobody shut it down.

INRM

I remember the last time I needed to counter a valid logical point. I decided it was best just to refer to some movie I saw. Yeah, that shut the naysayer up but good.

Actually, I got slapped.

~ggep~
 
Oh man! Just as I was finally starting to agree with Complexity on something, I find out he was only joking. Bugger it all.


[Don't tell anyone, but everything I wrote is true!]

Actually, bits and pieces of what I wrote are true, the rest is not.

It was weird, however, how comfortable that persona felt.

By the way, Wowbagger, I've been enjoying your posts on Pharyngula.
 
The evil scientist cabal/cult is still on-- right ??

(I mean I paid my dues and all...)
(and I worship at the altar of the cracker-irreverent PZ)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom