When Machines Rule

Most people can't even put their I-Pods down, let alone become Amish or something.
Most people have never even seen an iPod, let alone picked one up

It's going to happen way faster than 100 to 1000 years. We are talking 20-50 years.
Evidence?

I would not want to live in a dream-state.
Seems to me you're simply describing a nightmare... a sci-fi/fantasy nightmare

If you can cite any real, relevant examples of developments we need to monitor, please do

I don't think so optimistically. I think in one way or another it will be a total washout.
Think? Or fear? If it's the former, please cite real, relevant examples that give rise to your concerns


I did not know that. However, I never saw Terminator 3.
Don't worry, it was NOT a documentary
 
Six7s,

Are you serious? Everybody I know owns an IPod, and a cell-phone including me (I got the IPod as a gift, and have never actually used it, but nonetheless)

Regarding the 20-50 year figure -- I speculate the rate of advance based on the rate of which technology is currently advancing. It seems to me to be about 20-50 years. Now I could be wrong.

Regarding the Scifi-Nightmare thing --I was kind of responding to Shadron's statements. You'd have to read what he wrote to understand what I wrote. In either case, it was largely a hypothetical response to a hypothetical statement. It was not meant to be taken literally.

Regarding the total wash-out statement, I think it's a little bit of both think and fear.

And I, of course, know Terminator 3 is not a documentary.


INRM
 
Six7s,

Are you serious? Everybody I know owns an IPod, and a cell-phone including me (I got the IPod as a gift, and have never actually used it, but nonetheless)

I am serious

Have a look outside at the real world

I'm guessing you are young and/or haven't traveled out of your comfort zone

You said "Most people"

FYI: Most people live in Asia. A significant proportion of all people live in Africa. A small percentage of all people live in North America and Europe
 
Six7's,

-I meant in the United States. Okay?
-I'm pretty sure the Brits, Europeans, and Japanese have their share of I-Pods
-You're right though *MOST* of the world probably does not have them when you consider impoverished areas of Africa and Asia.

Regarding my opinions on the A.I. issue
-Computers are getting more advanced, at an increasingly faster rate
-A.I. is also being developed at an increasingly faster rate in a number of applications from search-engines (minor) to weapons technology, and some computer researchers who want to create robots and A.I. stuff like that (major).
-Computers with A.I. will probably continue to become more intelligent at a faster rate of speed eventually over taking us.
-Humans will end up having no jobs, end up having no function in society -- we will essentially just be taking up space.
-People will of course program A.I. machines not to harm human beings. But a system that becomes suitably intelligent enough, especially when it can use the internet to communicate with other A.I.'s potentially may realize that this is a silly quality (people have abandoned religious beliefs which they were taught from a very young age, people can overcome reflexes -- which are inborn: Such as blink reflex and gag-reflexes for example, the first for women applying mascara, second for men and women putting on contacts, and third for sword-swallowers of both genders, and well I don't need to get into the last part now do I -- people can realize that many urges and responses to external stimuli -- fight or flight are based on ancient primal reasons that largely have no purpose these days...) and may decide that we are troublesome pests that should be eliminated, or at least imprisoned.
-Some A.I.'s will from the beginning be programmed to cause harm -- such as future drones, and unmanned weaponry and such (even to humans), and with their ability to interface with other communications systems and other A.I.'s (especially if they can perform electronics warfare roles) and "persuade" or "override" them into doing what they want... shut down, switch-sides, etc.) -- these systems by necessity probably would be required (at least quickly on) to not have any shut-off switches so they couldn't be shut down by the enemy -- however if they turned on you.

So I think it would be likely a total washout for us in that we'd either end up
-Imprisoned in order to keep us out of the way, as future sentient-A.I.'s would probably see us as troublesome pests.
-Killed off and eliminated to get us out of the way...

And I fear it would be likely a total washout for us in that we'd either end up
-Imprisoned in order to keep us out of the way of the future sentient-A.I.'s, as they'd probably see us as troublesome pest
-Killed off and eliminated to get us out of the way as they'd either see us as troublesome pests...


INRM
 
I don't know if I had sympathy -- but there have been times I've wondered what the world would have been like had Reptiles had remained dominant and evolved as such and eventually (if applicable) became sentient, and what they would have looked like.


INRM

With Will Wright's "Spore" coming out next month, you can play it and find out....
 
@ INRM

I think you overestimate the ability of the computer to become smart. Computers are not smart. a modern quad core system is not smarter than a 30 year old 8008. It only can compute simple logical functions a bazillion times faster. We still are nowhere to make any machine 'smart' or sentient. I see no reason why we will ever be able to do that. But the idea has been implanted in our culture since the days of Jules Verne and got to extreme heights in the golden age of science fiction in the fifties. That was also the time that mankind has made the fastest technological advances in history, in telecommunication, air and spacecraft. So it is no surprise that science fiction got immensely popular in books and movies and has been ever since. One big theme of that is the 'thinking' robot, everybody knows them from my 80 year old grandmother to the 5 year old neighbour kid who gets his first robot toy. C3PO and Isaac Asimov.

The real world is completely different. If you read any old science fiction or future predictions you will see that nobody got it right. We would live on Mars by now and go to work in our personal flying or teleport units. But they never speak of the real modern inventions which are the internet and biological engineering and advances in artificial materials.

We have a robot who can walk around a bit and charm people with his cute behaviour but he is nowhere near any level of intelligence. We also have a few robots who can kick a ball to each other and play in the robot soccer world cup. And we have a robot who can beat the human world champion in chess, because pure mathematics can be used in that game, so robots (computers) can be used. Still I would not call that machine intelligent.

We have a robot lawnmower. It is very cute. It goes around the lawn. (3 times a week, because if it doesn't go that often the grass grows too thick and the poor thing can't manage it anymore) When it rains it sensors 'know' that he has to go back to the docking station, so it comes back. When it's battery gets depleted he 'knows' that he has to return. When it is on operational duty it just rolls around in some chaotic pattern but somehow manages to cut all the grass.. I like it a lot, it doesn't smell, make too much noise or crap on the lawn like a stupid dog.

Notice how I use the words 'it' and 'he.' I noticed that only when I was typing the next bit. We humans personify (I don't know if this is the right word in english) our machines. We did that with trains and cars before, now we do it with computers and robots...

" Ooh poor little thing..." when the robot fell down.

" He might be old, but he still has some spirit left in him." about your trusty old car.

I have no reason to believe we are significant further in AI design than we were 25 years ago. Sure the computers have become faster, still according to the law of Moore but did we have some really earth shattering breakthrough?
 
I have no reason to believe we are significant further in AI design than we were 25 years ago. Sure the computers have become faster, still according to the law of Moore but did we have some really earth shattering breakthrough?

Why are you talking about it as if it's a hardware problem?
 
URL: http://radio.seti.org/
Do you think people should start regulating science and such technology to avoid such a situation.[/qoute]

a) Majority of regulation by governent is specious, and morphs into being based upon personal gain by someone other than the masses.

b) What situation are we avoiding? I can't see that far ahead.


What if such technology does far more than "turn us into protoplasmic peons", and just decides to eradicate us?

Present an argument why you think it would, and what you base that argument upon. And, conversantly, present an argument why you think it wouldn't, and present upon what you would base that argument.

Also, I was thinking, if a singularity was established and they had a theory of everything combined with the fact that that scientist (John Cramer) with the Transactional theory of his, which could explain entanglement and in combination with the Afshar Experiement, which might even explain away the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, it could theoretically last forever (or at least for a really really long time) since it could predict everything that would happen before and everything after, and then fix itself before it starts falling apart and such.

Whoa nelly. TOE? + Singularity? + Transactional Theory + ....

Break each of these down in terms of what you know about them, and then how they correlate with each other.
 
Last edited:
And I fear it would be likely a total washout for us in that we'd either end up
-Imprisoned in order to keep us out of the way of the future sentient-A.I.'s, as they'd probably see us as troublesome pest
-Killed off and eliminated to get us out of the way as they'd either see us as troublesome pests...

Fear. Key word. Plus, the fight or flight. I agree.

I hate getting into commercial airplanes.. I know why. I override it.

a) The plane could crash and survival rates re: crashes are not too groovy.

Sure, the plane -could- crash. It doesn't mean it will. It doesn't mean that the likelihood that it will is even remotely substantial.

b) I have personal issues that make me fearful.

It means that if I know -why- it makes me fearful. e.g. not having control over a situation, etc. because from 1972-1983 I suffered bad situations where I could not escape, and I have a tendency to equate those with regards to being locked into a tuna can with engines, in which I cannot help myself or escape if the plane goes down. I can begin to compute how much of my fear is 'real' and how much is a culmination of blurred issues.

Conclusion: I don't 'know' whether I will die in a plane crash when I get on an airplane. What I do know is that the stats say it is unlikely. What I do know is that I can override unrelated fears that do not belong enmeshed in the topic of getting on an airplane. What I know is that if I am getting on an airplane, to begin with, it is because I need to get somewhere in a shorter amount of time. So, I get on the plane based upon the evidence of safety v danger, and need.

Now, I sleep on airplanes. heh

(As yet, the airplanes have not attacked me nor have they enslaved me- both literally and figuratively.)
 
Polgara,

Regarding your first reply, just read what I posted before. I've been pretty vocal.

Regarding your second reply, you're comparing apples and oranges.


INRM
 
OK, I've been far too lazy to read all the nonsense that's been posted in this thread, but here's my view:

(1) The "Technological Singularity" will be impossible without true ("super") AI. I'll say that again: The Singularity will be impossible without AI. Without it, all technological innovation has to be filtered and implemented through human minds and culture, which takes anywhere from months to a generation.

(2) There is good reason to believe that true AI is nowhere on the short to medium-term technological horizon, that is, not in 10, 20, even 30 years, no matter how much more powerful computers become. The reason: You can't tell a computer enough about the ordinary world for it to sufficiently understand it: about half of such knowledge must be acquired through living in the world -- and this can only be done in real time, with senses and effectors similar to that of humans -- big tasks in themselves; the other half must be built-in beforehand -- and this can only be reasonably done through evolution. Maybe -- maybe! -- we could understand, map, and mechanically duplicate real human brains so thoroughly that these steps could be bypassed. I foresee such a task taking many decades.

(3) The real danger in true AI is not the machines "taking over", but the humans responsible for these machines taking over, by using them as "weapon generators". Even well-meaning AI creators will be tempted to do this, if only to preempt others from acting. (And you know the old saw about "Absolute power...".) And the creators aren't even usually the ones who own the technology in the first place.

Of course weapons are already a reason for censoring knowledge, but true ("super") AI could bypass such prohibitions by allowing entirely new classes of weapons.

(4) Although the current world political setup doesn't encourage this, I do think future technology is a reasonable thing for democracy to guide or even censor. Or would you want, for example, a possible future where your descendants are required to be physically wired into computers, or completely go without sleep, or have no need for romantic attachments, all simply to allow them to compete in school or the job market? Technology is about improving human life and changing humanity to better fit its technology is simply too serious a problem to be left to the technologists.

No matter how much fun it is.
 
Polgara,

Regarding your first reply, just read what I posted before. I've been pretty vocal.

Regarding your second reply, you're comparing apples and oranges.


INRM

Apples and Oranges. Point taken. I was trying to show a need for the OP breakdown from the first para.

Reading now.
 
Why are you talking about it as if it's a hardware problem?

Good point. I guess because I don't really believe we will ever be able to make real AI as projected in those sci-fi stories, but if we make something that can emulate it a bit, it will be on some pretty impressive future hardware

Edit: I am with ttch here. read his post above.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom