when have you changed your mind on a matter?

well I told you what I know, seems like evidence to me..
you'd prefer me to construct a time machine and take you and me back to the start of the last century to watch them, with a big tape measure?
It's a historical event. You can look for the "evidence" yourself. Don't worry it'll be there.
Perhaps you won't believe that the 2nd World War took place until I provide you with "evidence".
Which goes to show you don't really know what evidence means. Again, it's not enough to say "some scientist says something like this". You need to name the scientist, you need to show where he said it, and you need to show the context of his statement. That's when you have -evidence-.

All you presented was a -claim- that you'd read a book. A -claim- that this book supports your -claims- about the Wright brothers.

Since you don't seem to know the difference between making claims and presenting evidence, it's no wonder you're open for ideas about the paranormal. After all, they too are incredibly skilled at making claims. What they aren't good at, though, is to show proper evidence that can be replicated, as well as not being explained by completely natural and "mundane" explanations.
 
Some of the things you say are "known" are in fact known by scientists to be false. Such as the "lack of transitional species" and the "species barrier".

regarding the species barrier... we have been breeding horses and dogs for thousands of years.. despite this highly concentrated intentional, intelligence-driven breeding program, have we ever bred anything that wasn't a dog or a horse?

we have intentionally bred hundreds of thousands of generations of fruit flys, has this ever produced anything that wasn't a fruit fly?

given that we do this using our intelligence to induce differences, and no new species arises, how is it that blind chance "evolution" is supposed to have created millions of incredibly complex and differentiated kinds of living being from a primordial "soup"?

the fact that people believe this on here persuades me it's a religion
 
if an experiment presented good evidence for the paranormal would you accept that the paranormal was real?
If a replicable experiment showed the existence of some power now classed as paranormal, then of course I'd accept the existence of that power.

Show me a reliable mind-reader, who can perform his feats when there's no question that he might be using the tricks known to stage magicians, and I'll believe in mind-reading.
 
Which goes to show you don't really know what evidence means. Again, it's not enough to say "some scientist says something like this". You need to name the scientist, you need to show where he said it, and you need to show the context of his statement. That's when you have -evidence-.

All you presented was a -claim- that you'd read a book. A -claim- that this book supports your -claims- about the Wright brothers.

Since you don't seem to know the difference between making claims and presenting evidence, it's no wonder you're open for ideas about the paranormal. After all, they too are incredibly skilled at making claims. What they aren't good at, though, is to show proper evidence that can be replicated, as well as not being explained by completely natural and "mundane" explanations.

I do understand what evidence is, but really come off it, I'm not going to come onto this forum, while I'm half watching the footy, and hypnotically regress myself to several years ago when I read a particular book. I remember what I read. If you're interested enough to investigate it, do so yourself. I'm not lying.
When you go to the pub and the barmaid asks you for £2.76 for your pint do you ask her to produce evidence for that figure?
What happened with the Wright Brothers happened, it's up to you to follow it up if you want. :)
 
Plumjam, if I told you that I could fly like a bird, under my own power, simply by wearing a special pair of sequined Converse Hi-Tops and flapping my arms up and down in the middle of the street, would you believe me? Why, or Why Not?
 
I do understand what evidence is, but really come off it, I'm not going to come onto this forum, while I'm half watching the footy, and hypnotically regress myself to several years ago when I read a particular book. I remember what I read. If you're interested enough to investigate it, do so yourself. I'm not lying.
When you go to the pub and the barmaid asks you for £2.76 for your pint do you ask her to produce evidence for that figure?
What happened with the Wright Brothers happened, it's up to you to follow it up if you want. :)


Well, I guess that is that.
 
regarding the species barrier...
This "species barrier" which you've invented doesn't exist. New species have been observed to arise both in the wild without human intervention and in the laboratory under human direction.

See, for example:

* Abbott R and Lowe, A. (2004) Origins, establishment and evolution of new polyploid species: Senecio cambrensis and S. eboracensis in the British Isles, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 82:4, 467-474 *
* Boraas M., Seale B. and Boxhorn J. Phagotrophy by a flagellate selects for colonial prey: A possible origin of multicellularity, Evolutionary Ecology 1998, 12, 153±164 *
* Bush, G. L. Host race formation and sympatric speciation in Rhagoletis fruit flies. (Diptera: Tephritidae), Psyche vol 99 no. 4, 1992 *
* Byrne K., Nichols RA. Culex pipiens in London Underground tunnels: differentiation between surface and subterranean populations, Heredity. 1999 Jan;82 ( Pt 1):7-15. *
* de Vries, H. Species and Varieties, Their Origin By Mutation, 1905 *
* Digby, L. The cytology of Primula kewensis and of other related Primula hybrids. Ann. Bot. 26:357-388, 1912 *
* Filchak KE, Roethele JB, Feder JL. Natural selection and sympatric divergence in the apple maggot Rhagoletis pomonella. Nature. 2000 Oct 12;407(6805):739-42.*
* Franzke A. and Mummenhof K. Recent hybrid speciation in Cardamine (Brassicaceae) - conversion of nuclear ribosomal ITS sequences in statu nascendi, Theoretical and Applied Genetics, vol. 98, No. 5, 1999 *
* Gottlieb, L. D. 1973. Genetic differentiation, sympatric speciation, and the origin of a diploid species of Stephanomeria. American Journal of Botany 60(6):545-553 *
* Huskins C. L. The origin of Spartina Townsendii, Genetica vol 12 no 6, 1930 *
* Johnson, M.W. 1953 The copepod Cyclops dimorphus Kiefer from the Salton Sea, American Midland Naturalist 49(1):188-192 *
* Pires ''et al''. Molecular cytogenetic analysis of recently evolved Tragopogon (Asteraceae) allopolyploids reveal a karyotype that is additive of the diploid progenitors. American Journal of Botany. 2004;91:1022-1035. *
* Soltis P, Plunkett G, Novak S, Soltis D, Genetic Variation in Tragopogon Species: Additional Origins of the Allotetraploids T. mirus and T. miscellus (Compositae), American Journal of Botany, Vol. 82, No. 10 (Oct., 1995) , pp. 1329-1341 *
* Walsh, B. On phytophagic varieties and phytophagic species. Proc. Entomol. Soc. Phila. 3: 403-430. 1864
 
Last edited:
I do understand what evidence is, but really come off it, I'm not going to come onto this forum, while I'm half watching the footy, and hypnotically regress myself to several years ago when I read a particular book. I remember what I read. If you're interested enough to investigate it, do so yourself. I'm not lying.
No, but you may be utterly mistaken, like you are about almost every other thing you've posted on this thread.

When you go to the pub and the barmaid asks you for £2.76 for your pint do you ask her to produce evidence for that figure?
Whereas the pub has the ability to set their own prices, you do not have the ability to change reality by your say-so.

What happened with the Wright Brothers happened, it's up to you to follow it up if you want. :)
I have followed it up. I've asked for evidence for your assertion.

If you can't be bothered to find out whether you're right, then why should I care what you say?
 
If a replicable experiment showed the existence of some power now classed as paranormal, then of course I'd accept the existence of that power.

Show me a reliable mind-reader, who can perform his feats when there's no question that he might be using the tricks known to stage magicians, and I'll believe in mind-reading.

well, that's just the problem.. because "Science" wants to be able to apply the same method it uses for physical and chemical processes to much more complex and subtle processes such as ESP, clairvoyance etc... and these abilities are much more dependent on the aptitude of the subject and the surroundings, atmosphere etc..
this isn't because they are inherently fraudulent, more that they are rare and refined skills that exist in only a small number of people.
I'm no expert on the literature, but I read that Rhine got some pretty impressive results.
Another problem is that even if some person were to demonstrate such an ability most Skeptics would be emotionally much more comfortable with dismissing them as frauds/magicians.
 
No, but you may be utterly mistaken, like you are about almost every other thing you've posted on this thread.

Whereas the pub has the ability to set their own prices, you do not have the ability to change reality by your say-so.

I have followed it up. I've asked for evidence for your assertion.

If you can't be bothered to find out whether you're right, then why should I care what you say?

Interesting that you completely avoided the species barrier reply I gave you, and preferred to concentrate on the price of beer in the pub ;)
 
Interesting that you completely avoided the species barrier reply I gave you, and preferred to concentrate on the price of beer in the pub ;)


OK. I think you really just tipped your hand with that one.

Have a nice night.
 
well, that's just the problem.. because "Science" wants to be able to apply the same method it uses for physical and chemical processes to much more complex and subtle processes such as ESP, clairvoyance etc... and these abilities are much more dependent on the aptitude of the subject and the surroundings, atmosphere etc..
this isn't because they are inherently fraudulent, more that they are rare and refined skills that exist in only a small number of people.
You asked what I would think if I was shown good experimental evidence. I told you.

I'm no expert on the literature, but I read that Rhine got some pretty impressive results.
Ah, something you've read somewhere you can't cite about a subject in which you're not an expert.

Another problem is that even if some person were to demonstrate such an ability most Skeptics would be emotionally much more comfortable with dismissing them as frauds/magicians.
Personally, I'd like a few psi powers. However, I would be more "emotionally comfortable" believing that I'm wealthy, incredibly good-looking, and physically immortal, but I don't. Skepticism doesn't pamper one's emotional comfort.
 
plumjam said:
...complex and subtle processes such as ESP, clairvoyance etc... and these abilities are much more dependent on the aptitude of the subject and the surroundings, atmosphere etc..

An alleged aptitude is usual for such claims. However please give an example of how ESP or clairvoyance is dependent on "surroundings" and "atmosphere".
 
I do understand what evidence is, but really come off it, I'm not going to come onto this forum, while I'm half watching the footy, and hypnotically regress myself to several years ago when I read a particular book. I remember what I read. If you're interested enough to investigate it, do so yourself. I'm not lying.
When you go to the pub and the barmaid asks you for £2.76 for your pint do you ask her to produce evidence for that figure?
What happened with the Wright Brothers happened, it's up to you to follow it up if you want. :)
"George W. Bush is an alien. I remember reading it somewhere.

It's now up to you to follow up and present evidence that I'm wrong."


This is, in effect, what you're saying. And that is why you're not being taken seriously. Again, when -you- make a claim, it's -your- job to provide actual evidence for it. If you're not capable of doing that, you are in no position to have a scientific debate.

So, you're still not showing me you understand the importance of evidence. You claim you do, but you're not showing me you actually do it. And as for the example of that barmaid, that's not even wrong. It's irrelevant. A complete non-sequiteur. A pub can charge whatever they want (though they'd be fools to charge an amount that nobody could afford, of course), they don't need to show any evidence. And if there is any doubt, then they'll most likely have written up a bill.

But this is not a pub, and we're not discussing pints. In here, I hardly consider any scientific claim not supported by actual evidence. Doesn't matter who makes the thread, any lack of citation for a claim will not go unchallenged. And frankly, considering how you've shown many basic misunderstandings of basic biology, I don't really trust your memory either. And why should I? If simply the memory of a stranger was enough to take on trust, then frankly I'd believe that the earth was flat by now.

So, start supporting your claims with evidence. Proper evidence. If you're not interested in doing the homework for the claims -you- started, then guess what, you'll fail the science class. Big time.
 
thanks for the references, but I have to admit I'm Skeptical ;)

from the sounds of them these examples all seem to be variations within the same "kind" of microbe/plant.

bit like a yorkshire terrier and a spaniel creating a little dog with big ears ;)
 
sorry, i missed your post
can i see these online?
The underlined asterisks are links to the papers. With some of the papers you only get the abstract for free and would have to pay to see the full article. (Or you can order copies from your local library, which takes longer but works out much cheaper.)
 
thanks for the references, but I have to admit I'm Skeptical ;)

from the sounds of them these examples all seem to be variations within the same "kind" of microbe/plant.

bit like a yorkshire terrier and a spaniel creating a little dog with big ears ;)

OK. I think you really just tipped your hand with this one, too.

Have a nice night.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom