when have you changed your mind on a matter?

thanks for the references, but I have to admit I'm Skeptical ;)

from the sounds of them these examples all seem to be variations within the same "kind" of microbe/plant.
No, they're all about species formation. Hence, there is no "species barrier".
 
thanks for the references, but I have to admit I'm Skeptical ;)

from the sounds of them these examples all seem to be variations within the same "kind" of microbe/plant.

bit like a yorkshire terrier and a spaniel creating a little dog with big ears ;)
Aaand, we're getting to the "variations within kinds" argument

Tell you what, to save us both some time, here's what you can do. Whenever you think you have some argument that disproves evolution, why don't you just check this list and see if you can find it there. Then, if you still want to maintain your argument, you'll find the scientific literature that supports you, and present it here. That way, we don't have to go back and forth with these posts.
 
When you go to the pub and the barmaid asks you for £2.76 for your pint do you ask her to produce evidence for that figure?
No. It's not an outrageous claim. Her asking for compensation for the pint I've just quaffed is evidence of the figure.

Now, if the bar maid asked you for 276 pounds (sorry, American keyboard) for your pint would you happily pay it and not ask for evidence as to why it is so high?
 
An alleged aptitude is usual for such claims. However please give an example of how ESP or clairvoyance is dependent on "surroundings" and "atmosphere".

sorry, like the other anal types on here I can't provide a journal, volume, author, page number etc..

who else comes on here with a load of academic references to cite? It's a forum to exchange ideas and opinions, not a backstage pass to a university library.

Regarding the importance of surroundings and atmosphere in inducing certain favourable mental states I would point to candlelit dinners, soft music, tender utterances, whispering sweet nothings. That's what I mean by subtlety of surroundings and atmosphere. If you ask me for evidence of this then I'm sorry but I'll just have to write you off as a total geek ;)
 
sorry, like the other anal types on here I can't provide a journal, volume, author, page number etc..

who else comes on here with a load of academic references to cite? It's a forum to exchange ideas and opinions, not a backstage pass to a university library.

Regarding the importance of surroundings and atmosphere in inducing certain favourable mental states I would point to candlelit dinners, soft music, tender utterances, whispering sweet nothings. That's what I mean by subtlety of surroundings and atmosphere. If you ask me for evidence of this then I'm sorry but I'll just have to write you off as a total geek ;)

:D

Oh, wait. You were serious?
 
Woah...

plumjam said:
who else comes on here with a load of academic references to cite?
Pretty much everyone with an idea they'd like to debate?

That's kinda the way it goes around here, man.

It's a forum to exchange ideas and opinions, not a backstage pass to a university library.
There are lots of ideas that are exchanged, but the exchange of evidence for and against various possibilities is kind of...the theme here.

If you ask me for evidence of this then I'm sorry but I'll just have to write you off as a total geek
You might actually be right about that part.
:)
 
sorry, like the other anal types on here I can't provide a journal, volume, author, page number etc..

who else comes on here with a load of academic references to cite? It's a forum to exchange ideas and opinions, not a backstage pass to a university library.

Regarding the importance of surroundings and atmosphere in inducing certain favourable mental states I would point to candlelit dinners, soft music, tender utterances, whispering sweet nothings. That's what I mean by subtlety of surroundings and atmosphere. If you ask me for evidence of this then I'm sorry but I'll just have to write you off as a total geek ;)

Not being a geek, just asking you to clarify what you wrote. You said:

"Science" wants to be able to apply the same method it uses for physical and chemical processes to much more complex and subtle processes such as ESP, clairvoyance etc... and these abilities are much more dependent on the aptitude of the subject and the surroundings, atmosphere etc..

Can you describe the subtlety of surroundings that Clairvoyance and ESP are dependent on?
 
I'm starting to understand your position now. You're complaining that mean old sceptics ignore all your valid evidence, but your idea of evidence is 'things that you know', or 'things that are obvious'.

I'd suggest a remedial science class, or maybe just a dictionary. Good luck!

are you saying that for anyone to be permitted to come onto this forum they have to have a library full of references behind them?
Seems pretty extreme don't you think? Ive read lots of threads, and only one person has listed any academic references.
Totally disingenuous. Seems like people on here can't just discuss things normally. And if I was to copy and paste a list of references what would that really mean? It would just be for show.
 
"George W. Bush is an alien. I remember reading it somewhere.

It's now up to you to follow up and present evidence that I'm wrong."

This is, in effect, what you're saying. And that is why you're not being taken seriously. Again, when -you- make a claim, it's -your- job to provide actual evidence for it. If you're not capable of doing that, you are in no position to have a scientific debate.

So, you're still not showing me you understand the importance of evidence. You claim you do, but you're not showing me you actually do it. And as for the example of that barmaid, that's not even wrong. It's irrelevant. A complete non-sequiteur. A pub can charge whatever they want (though they'd be fools to charge an amount that nobody could afford, of course), they don't need to show any evidence. And if there is any doubt, then they'll most likely have written up a bill.

But this is not a pub, and we're not discussing pints. In here, I hardly consider any scientific claim not supported by actual evidence. Doesn't matter who makes the thread, any lack of citation for a claim will not go unchallenged. And frankly, considering how you've shown many basic misunderstandings of basic biology, I don't really trust your memory either. And why should I? If simply the memory of a stranger was enough to take on trust, then frankly I'd believe that the earth was flat by now.

So, start supporting your claims with evidence. Proper evidence. If you're not interested in doing the homework for the claims -you- started, then guess what, you'll fail the science class. Big time.

Hawk,

This was a nice post. Not a TLA nominee, but nice nonetheless.

Just wanted express my appreciation for the overall tone of the post. Good job.

Skinny
 
Woah...


Pretty much everyone with an idea they'd like to debate?

That's kinda the way it goes around here, man.


There are lots of ideas that are exchanged, but the exchange of evidence for and against various possibilities is kind of...the theme here.


You might actually be right about that part.
:)

I generally don't see people exchanging journal names, volumes, page numbers, article titles, authors etc... on here, in fact, the fact that people are asking me to supply them seems to be a standard strategy because they know that 95% of people (those of us with a life) won't have those things to hand.

So perhaps this is the Skeptics substitute for my "Straw Man"
 
Hawk,

This was a nice post. Not a TLA nominee, but nice nonetheless.

Just wanted express my appreciation for the overall tone of the post. Good job.

Skinny

total pedantic geek post really, pity you can't see that


And you, apparently, haven't seen your Membership Agreement. Civility is strictly enforced in the JREF forum (public) area, and your above commentary is not civil.

Re-read your membership agreement, and going forward, comply with the membership rules, and remain civil toward other members at all times.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 
Last edited by a moderator:
who else comes on here with a load of academic references to cite? It's a forum to exchange ideas and opinions, not a backstage pass to a university library.
In case you haven't noticed, JREF stands for "James Randi Educational Foundation".

We happily exchange ideas, indeed. But when we are in the realm of scientific ideas, those ideas should be accompagnied by proper evidence, because that's really the only way we can -learn- something. Learning not to trust your own opinion on how the world works, for instance, but instead study it, and understand not only the truth or falsehood about claim X, but also why some person makes claim X. Is it because he has evidence for X? Is he simply believing in X for no reason? Is he trying to sell something related to X?

In short, this forum is a few more steps up on the academic scale than you thought you'd find. And that's why I can guarantee that you will continue to be challenged on any scientific claim you won't provide evidence for. Especially claims we -know- are wrong. If you can't take being challenged, this isn't the place for you. But me, I love that kind of thinking. By being challenged by others, I also get reminded to challenge myself, and never take anything for granted - especially not things I seem to remember from several years back - but instead study it and discover the facts. And I'll certainly never be a professor in anything.
 
well, that's just the problem.. because "Science" wants to be able to apply the same method it uses for physical and chemical processes to much more complex and subtle processes such as ESP, clairvoyance etc... and these abilities are much more dependent on the aptitude of the subject and the surroundings, atmosphere etc..

if that was the only problem the figures would be consistently better than chance, but they arent.

heck rsl's website is full of evidence of sylvia browne having levels of accuracy that are very low despite choosing her own conditions and getting questions from people who believe in her.

Another problem is that even if some person were to demonstrate such an ability most Skeptics would be emotionally much more comfortable with dismissing them as frauds/magicians.

it would be great if you didnt tell me how my feelings work. you simply do not know.

anyway, i would be sooooo pumped if these powers exsisted. I would be beyond excited. how amazing it would be if those powers were real! I would be shelling out plenty of cash to find out what to do if there was a real provable psychic out there who could help me with my life. who wouldnt?
 
You asked what I would think if I was shown good experimental evidence. I told you.

Ah, something you've read somewhere you can't cite about a subject in which you're not an expert.

Personally, I'd like a few psi powers. However, I would be more "emotionally comfortable" believing that I'm wealthy, incredibly good-looking, and physically immortal, but I don't. Skepticism doesn't pamper one's emotional comfort.

nice of you to enlighten us all as to how intelligent you are. now perhaps you could attempt to offer something of positive interest to the forum instead of getting me to do it and then demanding scientific journal entries to back up every single point I make.
Might be a first for you ;-)
Don't worry, I won't ask for references from you.
 
I generally don't see people exchanging journal names, volumes, page numbers, article titles, authors etc... on here, in fact, the fact that people are asking me to supply them seems to be a standard strategy because they know that 95% of people (those of us with a life) won't have those things to hand.

So perhaps this is the Skeptics substitute for my "Straw Man"

I've been around this forum for quite some time and while generally you don't see cites for everything, specifically it happens all the time. Asking for evidence is very common practice around here. Slightly more common than actually providing it but it is regularly provided.

I've learned on this forum that if I claim something as fact I had better well be able to back it up with more than my recollection of things. I've also found tremendous respect for admitting you are wrong when faced with contrary facts.
 
Well, why don't you go and find some less "geeky" people to chat to? Find yourself some forum where you can present what you heard from some fat bloke down the pub, or read on the back of a beer-mat, as unquestionable fact, and no-one will be so "geeky" as to wonder whether it's true or not.

You'd be much more at home there. Round here, we prefer our ideas to be backed up by evidence, it's kind of what we do.
 
nice of you to enlighten us all as to how intelligent you are. now perhaps you could attempt to offer something of positive interest to the forum instead of getting me to do it and then demanding scientific journal entries to back up every single point I make.
Might be a first for you ;-)
Don't worry, I won't ask for references from you.
Was any of this meant to mean anything? Only I can't help noticing that it has nothing whatsoever to do with the post to which it was ostensibly a reply.
 
You'd be much more at home there. Round here, we prefer our ideas to be backed up by evidence, it's kind of what we do.

Well that's just unfair Dr A... wanting to discuss reality with facts? That's just cruel.
 
I've been around this forum for quite some time and while generally you don't see cites for everything, specifically it happens all the time. Asking for evidence is very common practice around here. Slightly more common than actually providing it but it is regularly provided.

I've learned on this forum that if I claim something as fact I had better well be able to back it up with more than my recollection of things. I've also found tremendous respect for admitting you are wrong when faced with contrary facts.

well, i accept you've been on here longer. I must say it's the first internet forum i've been on where people want acacemic citations in your post... dear me!
Just seems very extreme to me. I could understand it on some University Research Forum site.. but this is James Randi with his big white beard. You Skeptics are just going to bore off anyone who has a slightly different viewpoint to your own.
Maybe that's what you want.
But then who would you be able to have a good discussion with, without just echoing each other?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom