when have you changed your mind on a matter?

well, i am genuinely encouraged that i have managed to hold your attention for a couple of hours, I bet that's more than any writing of Darwin's managed ;)
How much do you want to bet on that particular proposition?

Remember, as I've explained to you, you can't really read minds, you're just making up fantasies about us. I shall not speculate on what emotional need this fulfils on your part.
 
crikey, read your history, he was universally ridiculed and couldn't get any funding.
It's true, all you "Skeptics", no one of any great importance really believed in electromagnetic waves until Marconi did his cross-atlantic communication.

Is this the same history book you read that told you about Galileo's execution? Maybe it was in that edition of Nature you read, along with their mocking of the Wright brothers. You know, the edition you can't remember now, and think may have been hushed up.
 
well, i've had 3 pages of replies, and no-one has yet been humble or honest enough to admit that at some point in their lives evidence has convinced them of something that would go against Skeptical Orthodoxy..
Well, doesn't terribly surprise me. In fact that's why I asked the question, as an illustration of the ideological basis of a forum like this :)
 
i have no theory whatsoever, cos no such theory could exist, my over-arching theory is ..l.
Make up your mind.

... that every organic physical construction is thousands of times more complex than any designed car or computer, even the simplest kind know to us in all history ...
Ah, you were right first time --- you don't have a theory.

so it is a complete mystery how it and they exist... pity the indoctrinated teenage know-it-alls want to argue differently
It must be even more galling to you that the scientists who actually study nature want to argue differently too.

Just as Galileo, who was also faced with opposition from a stifling religious orthodoxy, argued against it by the light of his knowledge.

Just like Darwin, reviled by the orthodoxy of his day.

Funny how you left him off your little list, eh?
 
Is this the same history book you read that told you about Galileo's execution? Maybe it was in that edition of Nature you read, along with their mocking of the Wright brothers. You know, the edition you can't remember now, and think may have been hushed up.

sure, my life isn't so tragic that I go online with the year, edition and page number of a particular Nature magazine, but I do know it exists. If it bothers you then you can look it up yourself. Of course it's obvous that Nature magazine hasn't been advertising it for years, as it's pretty embarrassing to them.
 
well, i've had 3 pages of replies, and no-one has yet been humble or honest enough to admit that at some point in their lives evidence has convinced them of something that would go against Skeptical Orthodoxy..
Well, doesn't terribly surprise me. In fact that's why I asked the question, as an illustration of the ideological basis of a forum like this :)

See. theres that silly strawman again. First,. these is no such thing as "Skeptical Orthodoxy". Second, people have already described how they changed their views after being presented with evidence, that you choose to ignore it is no fault of the posters here.

As for humble and honest. "Mr Kettle? Mr Pot on line 1. He says you're black."

Order up another irony meter, this one is busted.
 
well, i've had 3 pages of replies, and no-one has yet been humble or honest enough to admit that at some point in their lives evidence has convinced them of something that would go against Skeptical Orthodoxy..
Well of course not. Because "Skeptical Orthodoxy" is that you should change your mind when the evidence shows that you're wrong. That's the whole thing from A to Z. That's skepticism.
 
sure, my life isn't so tragic that I go online with the year, edition and page number of a particular Nature magazine, but I do know it exists. If it bothers you then you can look it up yourself. Of course it's obvous that Nature magazine hasn't been advertising it for years, as it's pretty embarrassing to them.

Ever heard about burden of proof? You made a silly claim, you back it up or retract, Not repeat the claim every time someoen asks for evidence, back up the claim with evidence

See, if youwanna cvlaim Nature published something, then you should back it up with a reference. If you can not to that, yuo should frankly shut up, or withdraw the claim.

The "Of course it's obvous that Nature magazine hasn't been advertising it for years, as it's pretty embarrassing to them." is another baseless, silly claim.

And you wonder why people do not take you seriously?
 
yeah, cos anyone with a brain realises that Darwin, if he knew what is known now about DNA, protein molecules, the complexity of cells, the fossil record, lack of transitional species, the species barrier, irreducible complexity everywhere in nature,.. would never have espoused the theory he did, he could only get away with it due to the ignorance of that age, and his theory only persists due to the lack of anything materialistic that is anything other than laughable
 
sure, my life isn't so tragic that I go online with the year, edition and page number of a particular Nature magazine, but I do know it exists. If it bothers you then you can look it up yourself. Of course it's obvous that Nature magazine hasn't been advertising it for years, as it's pretty embarrassing to them.

Hey, it doesn't bother me, I'm not the one trying to claim it as support for my argument ;)

But being as how your memory seems to have let you down with so many of your other points, perhaps you'd like to check sometime. Who knows, if you actually looked it up, maybe you'd find some evidence that would make you change your mind on a matter. You're not too dogmatic and closed-minded to do that, are you?
 
See. theres that silly strawman again. First,. these is no such thing as "Skeptical Orthodoxy". Second, people have already described how they changed their views after being presented with evidence, that you choose to ignore it is no fault of the posters here.

As for humble and honest. "Mr Kettle? Mr Pot on line 1. He says you're black."

Order up another irony meter, this one is busted.

maybe i've misread, but i don't remember anyone saying they changed their views after being presented with evidence which would take them away from orthodox Skepticism.

BTW you are the 8th poster to accuse me of setting up a straw man, pretty clever of me don't you think? when I'd never heard of it before tonight
 
yeah, cos anyone with a brain realises that Darwin, if he knew what is known now about DNA, protein molecules, the complexity of cells, the fossil record, lack of transitional species, the species barrier, irreducible complexity everywhere in nature,.. would never have espoused the theory he did, he could only get away with it due to the ignorance of that age, and his theory only persists due to the lack of anything materialistic that is anything other than laughable

:popcorn1
 
sure, my life isn't so tragic that I go online with the year, edition and page number of a particular Nature magazine, but I do know it exists.
How nice for you, to "know" things without evidence.

However, experience tells me that people who "know" things without evidence are almost invariably wrong about the things they know.

If it bothers you then you can look it up yourself. Of course it's obvous that Nature magazine hasn't been advertising it for years, as it's pretty embarrassing to them.
Whereas your complete lack of evidence for your assertions doesn't appear to embarrass you in the slightest.

Here we have a test case. You say the article exists. All you have to do is produce it and see if we change our minds about whether it exists.

---

BTW, can anyone work out what the article is that plumjam thinks he's talking about? I believe I can. And oh boy, is he wrong.
 
maybe i've misread, but i don't remember anyone saying they changed their views after being presented with evidence which would take them away from orthodox Skepticism.

BTW you are the 8th poster to accuse me of setting up a straw man, pretty clever of me don't you think? when I'd never heard of it before tonight
But that's because you misunderstand skepticism and refuse to read the explanations. So, we need to tell you several times, in the hopes you'll get it.

Once again, skepticism is -about- changing your mind when presented with proper evidence. The only way to get away from skepticism is to -stop- changing your mind based on new evidence, and instead hold on to outdated dogmas, or just accepting downright silly claims at their face value.

Do you understand how it works now? Or do I need to explain it with a puppet show?
 
Last edited:
maybe i've misread, but i don't remember anyone saying they changed their views after being presented with evidence which would take them away from orthodox Skepticism.

BTW you are the 8th poster to accuse me of setting up a straw man, pretty clever of me don't you think? when I'd never heard of it before tonight


Perhaps you could educate us all with just what it is that you define as "orthodox Skepticism".

That would be a start.
 
How nice for you, to "know" things without evidence.

However, experience tells me that people who "know" things without evidence are almost invariably wrong about the things they know.

Whereas your complete lack of evidence for your assertions doesn't appear to embarrass you in the slightest.

Here we have a test case. You say the article exists. All you have to do is produce it and see if we change our minds about whether it exists.

---

BTW, can anyone work out what the article is that plumjam thinks he's talking about? I believe I can. And oh boy, is he wrong.


Ok, seeing as you persist, I read a book several years ago by a quite well known science journalist, I think he worked for the Sunday Times, but as it's several years ago I don't particularly remember which paper it was. Anyway, I do remember what he said about how the Wright Brothers were widely ridiculed in society. They were ridiculed by the major US newspaper and then by the Science magazines. The social pressure was such that even when they invited reporters from their local newspaper to witness their flights the reporters went, but refused to put in print what they had seen. This is how social pressure works. If an esteemed journale like Nature has already written that powered flight is impossible due to the flying objects being heavier than air and not having a "flapping facility" as birds did, then the humble local reporter isn't going to risk ridicule by publishing anything about it.
Another reason for the Wright Bros being ridiculed is that they weren't professional scientists or engineers, just simple bodging and tinkering carpenters, so they didn't fit into what was expected of the first people to invent powered flight.
 
But that's because you misunderstand skepticism and refuse to read the explanations. So, we need to tell you several times, in the hopes you'll get it.

Once again, skepticism is -about- changing your mind when presented with proper evidence. The only way to get away from skepticism is to -stop- changing your mind based on new evidence, and instead hold on to outdated dogmas, or just accepting downright silly claims at their face value.

Do you understand how it works now? Or do I need to explain it with a puppet show?

thanks, my broader point is that it really isn't as simple as that. Scientists, engineers, technologists etc... get attached to their own theories about reality, and so they tend to accept the evidence that confirms their own opinions and they discount equally valid evidence that contradicts their theories. On the larger scale that's why any evidence for the "paranormal" is generally unaccepted in this society at this time, because this society at this time maintians an over-arching philosophical paradigm which denies the possibility of such evidence, a priori .
 
Ok, seeing as you persist, I read a book several years ago by a quite well known science journalist, I think he worked for the Sunday Times, but as it's several years ago I don't particularly remember which paper it was. Anyway, I do remember what he said about how the Wright Brothers were widely ridiculed in society. They were ridiculed by the major US newspaper and then by the Science magazines. The social pressure was such that even when they invited reporters from their local newspaper to witness their flights the reporters went, but refused to put in print what they had seen. This is how social pressure works. If an esteemed journale like Nature has already written that powered flight is impossible due to the flying objects being heavier than air and not having a "flapping facility" as birds did, then the humble local reporter isn't going to risk ridicule by publishing anything about it.
Another reason for the Wright Bros being ridiculed is that they weren't professional scientists or engineers, just simple bodging and tinkering carpenters, so they didn't fit into what was expected of the first people to invent powered flight.

Damn you Nature magazine. If it weren't for your intransigence, we'd have flying machines by now!

If only sceptics changed their minds when presented with evidence, well, the sky would be the limit.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom