when have you changed your mind on a matter?

This is how social pressure works. If an esteemed journale like Nature has already written that powered flight is impossible due to the flying objects being heavier than air and not having a "flapping facility" as birds did, then the humble local reporter isn't going to risk ridicule by publishing anything about it.

Pity the poor beat reporter for the Greater Bucksnort Fishwrap and Used Car Guide, whose readership demands such strict compliance with the orthodoxies imposed by the leading scientific journals.
 
thanks, my broader point is that it really isn't as simple as that. Scientists, engineers, technologists etc... get attached to their own theories about reality, and so they tend to accept the evidence that confirms their own opinions and they discount equally valid evidence that contradicts their theories. On the larger scale that's why any evidence for the "paranormal" is generally unaccepted in this society at this time, because this society at this time maintians an over-arching philosophical paradigm which denies the possibility of such evidence, a priori .


So in addition to my request that you define "orthodox Skepticism", I would add a request that you provide us with just who it is that you consider to be credible sources for said "evidence that contradicts their theories"?
 
well, i've had 3 pages of replies, and no-one has yet been humble or honest enough to admit that at some point in their lives evidence has convinced them of something that would go against Skeptical Orthodoxy..
Well, doesn't terribly surprise me. In fact that's why I asked the question, as an illustration of the ideological basis of a forum like this :)

At about the age of seven I decided that it was important that I question everything. I was convinced that in order to find truth I had to question the validity of that. I didn't know I was a skeptic until I found out what the word meant.

What that default position did for me was leave me not making up my mind quickly over something. If someone claimed something I wouldn't just buy it until facts were checked and research done. (At age seven I asked my mom lots of dumb questions.) I was and am quite happy to sit on the fence until I understand the facts. This means I don't have to change my mind on things very often because I make a good choice to start with. My critical thinking skills demand that I do change my mind if new evidence comes to light. Something that I eagerly and excitedly do. New facts are very interesting.

I don't do philosophy. I think that philosophy is basically; "Oooo we invented language. What sort of amazing fantastical things we can imagine". I prefer to do reality. Science and critical thinking gives me the best picture of what reality is.

My skepticism serves me well in making sense of the world. It has never let me down (allow me to believe something contrary to evidence). It isn't possible for a fact to be against being skeptical. If it's a fact, it's a fact. Skepticism doesn't alter facts, it illuminates them.
 
Damn you Nature magazine. If it weren't for your intransigence, we'd have flying machines by now!

If only sceptics changed their minds when presented with evidence, well, the sky would be the limit.

your sarcastic point is actually quite relevant. most radically new discoveries/technologies are usually hampered by a lot of social resistance, and this resistance tends to come from the kind of "Skeptics" that inhabit this forum and enjoy dismissing people and ideas. If it weren't for them then society would be probably a lot more advanced by now.
 
thanks, my broader point is that it really isn't as simple as that. Scientists, engineers, technologists etc... get attached to their own theories about reality, and so they tend to accept the evidence that confirms their own opinions and they discount equally valid evidence that contradicts their theories. On the larger scale that's why any evidence for the "paranormal" is generally unaccepted in this society at this time, because this society at this time maintians an over-arching philosophical paradigm which denies the possibility of such evidence, a priori .

So you'll be able to tell us about this equally valid evidence that you know about then? Stuff that proves the paranormal?
 
Pity the poor beat reporter for the Greater Bucksnort Fishwrap and Used Car Guide, whose readership demands such strict compliance with the orthodoxies imposed by the leading scientific journals.

keep trying with the old wit,

generally this process means that whole areas of potentially fruitful research get neglected
 
Ok, seeing as you persist, I read a book several years ago by a quite well known science journalist, I think he worked for the Sunday Times, but as it's several years ago I don't particularly remember which paper it was. Anyway, I do remember what he said about how the Wright Brothers were widely ridiculed in society. They were ridiculed by the major US newspaper and then by the Science magazines. The social pressure was such that even when they invited reporters from their local newspaper to witness their flights the reporters went, but refused to put in print what they had seen. This is how social pressure works. If an esteemed journale like Nature has already written that powered flight is impossible due to the flying objects being heavier than air and not having a "flapping facility" as birds did, then the humble local reporter isn't going to risk ridicule by publishing anything about it.
Another reason for the Wright Bros being ridiculed is that they weren't professional scientists or engineers, just simple bodging and tinkering carpenters, so they didn't fit into what was expected of the first people to invent powered flight.
Once again, more assertions, but no actual evidence, just your recollection. Which, by the way, isn't exactly trustworthy at this moment.

No name of the book.
No name of the author.
No mentioning of the context about the ridiculing they did get. for one thing, in that period, a lot of people claimed to have made a working airplane, but something always went mysteriously wrong. So naturally, people were doubtful anytime someone would say "I've made a working plane!". Read the story "the boy who cried wolf" if you don't understand why this was.
And of course, no mentioning that as soon as the people doing the objections and ridiculing were presented with actual evidence of the plane working, they immediately changed their mind. Which is completely in line with skepticism. Just as we'll change our mind about f.ex. homeopathy if only someone presents proper evidence of it working. Which they haven't. Probably because there is no scientific basis for any of the ideas homeopathy promote. But still, a tiny, tiny, tiny chance it might be that they've all - for several decades now - just been really, really unlucky whenever someone's done an experiment wherein all the safety catches (such as making it properly double-blind) were in place.

So, all in all, not a good effort. Perhaps you'd like to learn what evidence means before trying again? For one thing, you could start with naming the sources you've claim to have read. That way, other people can also read those sources and find out whether you've maybe misunderstood something, or you're taking things out of context, or whether you're right. As it is, you currently look more like you're just making things up on the spot.
 
Ok, seeing as you persist, I read a book several years ago by a quite well known science journalist, I think he worked for the Sunday Times, but as it's several years ago I don't particularly remember which paper it was. Anyway, I do remember what he said about how the Wright Brothers were widely ridiculed in society. They were ridiculed by the major US newspaper and then by the Science magazines. The social pressure was such that even when they invited reporters from their local newspaper to witness their flights the reporters went, but refused to put in print what they had seen. This is how social pressure works. If an esteemed journale like Nature has already written that powered flight is impossible due to the flying objects being heavier than air and not having a "flapping facility" as birds did, then the humble local reporter isn't going to risk ridicule by publishing anything about it.
Another reason for the Wright Bros being ridiculed is that they weren't professional scientists or engineers, just simple bodging and tinkering carpenters, so they didn't fit into what was expected of the first people to invent powered flight.
So, you can't produce any evidence for your claims?

Then I, for one, will not accept your claims.

I want evidence before I change my mind, not your say-so.
 
So in addition to my request that you define "orthodox Skepticism", I would add a request that you provide us with just who it is that you consider to be credible sources for said "evidence that contradicts their theories"?

ey?
could be anyone, obviously
 
thanks, my broader point is that it really isn't as simple as that. Scientists, engineers, technologists etc... get attached to their own theories about reality, and so they tend to accept the evidence that confirms their own opinions and they discount equally valid evidence that contradicts their theories. On the larger scale that's why any evidence for the "paranormal" is generally unaccepted in this society at this time, because this society at this time maintians an over-arching philosophical paradigm which denies the possibility of such evidence, a priori .
Either that, or there is no good evidence for the paranormal any more than there is for your bizarre assertions about the history of science.
 
your sarcastic point is actually quite relevant. most radically new discoveries/technologies are usually hampered by a lot of social resistance, and this resistance tends to come from the kind of "Skeptics" that inhabit this forum and enjoy dismissing people and ideas. If it weren't for them then society would be probably a lot more advanced by now.

Let me rephrase:

"Most radically-new discoveries/technologies are usually hampered by a lot of social resistance, and this resistance tends to come from the kind of hysteria promulgated by the fanatically-religious that inhabit too much of the world and who enjoy dismissing evidence, reason, and anything that contradicts their long-held magical thinking. If it weren't for them, then society would be probably more advanced by now."
 
So, you can't produce any evidence for your claims?

Then I, for one, will not accept your claims.

I want evidence before I change my mind, not your say-so.

well I told you what I know, seems like evidence to me..
you'd prefer me to construct a time machine and take you and me back to the start of the last century to watch them, with a big tape measure?
It's a historical event. You can look for the "evidence" yourself. Don't worry it'll be there.
Perhaps you won't believe that the 2nd World War took place until I provide you with "evidence".
 
Let me rephrase:

"Most radically-new discoveries/technologies are usually hampered by a lot of social resistance, and this resistance tends to come from the kind of hysteria promulgated by the fanatically-religious that inhabit too much of the world and who enjoy dismissing evidence, reason, and anything that contradicts their long-held magical thinking. If it weren't for them, then society would be probably more advanced by now."

pretty laughable, that
 
yeah, cos anyone with a brain realises that Darwin, if he knew what is known now about DNA, protein molecules, the complexity of cells, the fossil record, lack of transitional species, the species barrier, irreducible complexity everywhere in nature,..
Some of the things you say are "known" are in fact known by scientists to be false. Such as the "lack of transitional species" and the "species barrier".

Scientists do indeed know about "DNA, protein molecules, the complexity of cells, the fossil record", which is why they accept the theory of evolution.

Darwin did of course know that there was irreducible complexity in nature, a fact which is perfectly obvious.

... would never have espoused the theory he did, he could only get away with it due to the ignorance of that age, and his theory only persists due to the lack of anything materialistic that is anything other than laughable

The theory of evolution only persists because no-one has found a scrap of a shred of evidence against it.
 
Either that, or there is no good evidence for the paranormal any more than there is for your bizarre assertions about the history of science.

if an experiment presented good evidence for the paranormal would you accept that the paranormal was real?
 
well I told you what I know, seems like evidence to me..
You've told me what you think you know, and since you've been laughably wrong throughout this thread, that is not evidence.

you'd prefer me to construct a time machine and take you and me back to the start of the last century to watch them, with a big tape measure?
No, I'd like you to provide evidence.

It's a historical event. You can look for the "evidence" yourself. Don't worry it'll be there.
Well, if you're so certain that it'll be there --- perhaps you could do your own homework.

Perhaps you won't believe that the 2nd World War took place until I provide you with "evidence".
I have already been supplied with ample evidence for WWII, which is the only reason that I know it took place.
 
Perhaps you won't believe that the 2nd World War took place until I provide you with "evidence".

If the 2nd World War were merely your private assertion/invention, then yes, you would be asked support it. However, evidence for this event is widely available from innumerable sources. You were asked for evidence about your specific claim, which remains unsupported. Sadly, "I know I read it somewhere" isn't the most compelling argument one could make here.
 
well I told you what I know, seems like evidence to me..
you'd prefer me to construct a time machine and take you and me back to the start of the last century to watch them, with a big tape measure?
It's a historical event. You can look for the "evidence" yourself. Don't worry it'll be there.
Perhaps you won't believe that the 2nd World War took place until I provide you with "evidence".


Well, that is then what separates you from the rest of us - namely, what constitutes evidence. Your opinions and recollections will do little to persuade us. We expect more.

You can see that as evidence of our failings, but we, on the other hand, see that as the short-comings of your arguments. We will, accordingly, leave you to your unsupported conclusions about a variety of subjects that you have raised during your short time here, not the least of which is the very Forum in which you have been spending an awful lot of time.

pretty laughable, that


Why am I not surprised that that might be your response?
 
well I told you what I know, seems like evidence to me..

I'm starting to understand your position now. You're complaining that mean old sceptics ignore all your valid evidence, but your idea of evidence is 'things that you know', or 'things that are obvious'.

I'd suggest a remedial science class, or maybe just a dictionary. Good luck!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom