when have you changed your mind on a matter?

I think my question somehow got overlooked.

plumjam said:
sorry, like the other anal types on here I can't provide a journal, volume, author, page number etc..

who else comes on here with a load of academic references to cite? It's a forum to exchange ideas and opinions, not a backstage pass to a university library.

Regarding the importance of surroundings and atmosphere in inducing certain favourable mental states I would point to candlelit dinners, soft music, tender utterances, whispering sweet nothings. That's what I mean by subtlety of surroundings and atmosphere. If you ask me for evidence of this then I'm sorry but I'll just have to write you off as a total geek

Not being a geek, just asking you to clarify what you wrote. You said:

plumjam said:
"Science" wants to be able to apply the same method it uses for physical and chemical processes to much more complex and subtle processes such as ESP, clairvoyance etc... and these abilities are much more dependent on the aptitude of the subject and the surroundings, atmosphere etc..

Can you describe the subtlety of surroundings that Clairvoyance and ESP are dependent on?
 
Was any of this meant to mean anything?

well there you go, precisely as I thought. You seem to have nothing positive to offer, but prefer to sit back with your citations and try to demolish other people. It all seems a bit unfriendly to me.
 
I think my question somehow got overlooked.



Not being a geek, just asking you to clarify what you wrote. You said:



Can you describe the subtlety of surroundings that Clairvoyance and ESP are dependent on?

yeah, I ignored the question because it is such an obvious geek question. Like you want me to write a poem to describe the subtlety of all possible situations and atmospheres?
Here's a question for you. Why does music exist?
Open to anyone.
 
well there you go, precisely as I thought. You seem to have nothing positive to offer ...
Apart from information.

Round here, we think information is a positive thing. Indeed, even you actually asked me if you could see the papers I cited online, and I told you how. If you don't like information, why did you ask for it?

We have asked you for information about your Wright Brothers claim. Please provide something positive, i.e. information.

... but prefer to sit back with your citations and try to demolish other people. It all seems a bit unfriendly to me.
Whereas you appear to be trying to "demolish" us --- without the benefit of any citations at all.

Is that more friendly? I don't think so, but it is much, much less likely to succeed.
 
Well, why don't you go and find some less "geeky" people to chat to? Find yourself some forum where you can present what you heard from some fat bloke down the pub, or read on the back of a beer-mat, as unquestionable fact, and no-one will be so "geeky" as to wonder whether it's true or not.

You'd be much more at home there. Round here, we prefer our ideas to be backed up by evidence, it's kind of what we do.

plumjam said:
nice of you to enlighten us all as to how intelligent you are. now perhaps you could attempt to offer something of positive interest to the forum instead of getting me to do it and then demanding scientific journal entries to back up every single point I make.
Might be a first for you ;-)
Don't worry, I won't ask for references from you.

I think the second quote amounts to what he would probably say to the fat bloke down at the pub, were he to challenge anything plumjam said.

That's just my humble opinion, however.
 
Last edited:
well there you go, precisely as I thought. You seem to have nothing positive to offer, but prefer to sit back with your citations and try to demolish other people. It all seems a bit unfriendly to me.

You know, only someone who truly has no idea about the scientific principle and why it's so important to apply to paranormal claims could regard citations as something negative.

And if you find it unfriendly, it's more likely because you have a problem being shown that you're wrong. If you can overcome this, then you'll be able to see just how informative and wonderful those citations that Dr. A rather kindly has provided. I mean, think about it. You're an absolute stranger to him, and he doesn't owe you anything. But yet, he's giving you lots of good tips on literature to pursue where you can learn a lot of facts about biology and evolution. Anyone who's actually interested in a debate should be overjoyed about this.
 
well, i accept you've been on here longer. I must say it's the first internet forum i've been on where people want acacemic citations in your post... dear me!
Perhaps this is the first forum you've been on when you have based an argument on a claim that a specific paper existed in a specific academic journal.

Just seems very extreme to me. I could understand it on some University Research Forum site.. but this is James Randi with his big white beard. You Skeptics are just going to bore off anyone who has a slightly different viewpoint to your own.
Yes, it could happen. After all, you've only made 98 posts in the past, what? day-and-a-half. I can see that your interest is flagging.

But then who would you be able to have a good discussion with, without just echoing each other?
Anyone who is prepared to offer his evidence for views other than mine, instead of just making personal attacks against the people who ask for it.
 
here is a novel idea ... "conversation".. interesting conversation to most people doesn't consist of statement followed by citation... perhaps in an academic paper that is fine, because in that situation it would be beneficial for me to go and search for the particular source of the citation.
you might think this kind of conversation would be limited due to not being backed up by "evidence" (even if the evidence exists in some citation who's to say i might not have good reason to completely disagree with it after reading it?)

Socrates and his mates had a few interesting conversations, and none of them ever referred another to the library.. so pleas get real and just talk, if you're human, that is.
 
yeah, I ignored the question because it is such an obvious geek question. Like you want me to write a poem to describe the subtlety of all possible situations and atmospheres?
Here's a question for you. Why does music exist?
Open to anyone.

You misunderstand. I am skeptical of psychic powers, but if there is way to consistently observe and test these powers by using the correct atmosphere and surroundings, I want to know what those atmosphere and surroundings are so that I can replicate them. Asking for details is not inherently geeky, it's just common sense.

What atmosphere and surroundings do you suggest I create in order to test ESP and Clairvoyance?
 
You misunderstand. I am skeptical of psychic powers, but if there is way to consistently observe and test these powers by using the correct atmosphere and surroundings, I want to know what those atmosphere and surroundings are so that I can replicate them. Asking for details is not inherently geeky, it's just common sense.

What atmosphere and surroundings do you suggest I create in order to test ESP and Clairvoyance?

this is one of science's symptoms, it assumes that there should be an optimum condition for producing optimum results, but this would only apply in areas where the element of consciousness has little part to play, like at the level of physics or chemistry,.. the more consciousness comes into play the more individualised would that optimum condition become.. so in short, you would have to ask each individual psychic how they work best :)

no citations for that, it's just my opinion :)
 
here is a novel idea ... "conversation".. interesting conversation to most people doesn't consist of statement followed by citation... perhaps in an academic paper that is fine, because in that situation it would be beneficial for me to go and search for the particular source of the citation.
you might think this kind of conversation would be limited due to not being backed up by "evidence" (even if the evidence exists in some citation who's to say i might not have good reason to completely disagree with it after reading it?)

Socrates and his mates had a few interesting conversations, and none of them ever referred another to the library.. so pleas get real and just talk, if you're human, that is.

Why are you so insistant that you get a free pass for your claims?

Why shouldn't we challenge your claims about science, especially when we know they are wrong?

And what better way to show you why you're wrong about something in science than referring to the scientific works?
 
You know, only someone who truly has no idea about the scientific principle and why it's so important to apply to paranormal claims could regard citations as something negative.

And if you find it unfriendly, it's more likely because you have a problem being shown that you're wrong. If you can overcome this, then you'll be able to see just how informative and wonderful those citations that Dr. A rather kindly has provided. I mean, think about it. You're an absolute stranger to him, and he doesn't owe you anything. But yet, he's giving you lots of good tips on literature to pursue where you can learn a lot of facts about biology and evolution. Anyone who's actually interested in a debate should be overjoyed about this.

sounds good, but pretty disingenuous methinks. I seriously doubt that if DR A gave you a list of citations you'd subsequently dutifully trot off tomorrow to the library to look them all up, read them, analyse their true significance to your position on fruitflies and then modify your position, this is all just scientific-sounding hokum.. someone please be real and admit this.
 
this is one of science's symptoms, it assumes that there should be an optimum condition for producing optimum results, but this would only apply in areas where the element of consciousness has little part to play, like at the level of physics or chemistry,.. the more consciousness comes into play the more individualised would that optimum condition become.. so in short, you would have to ask each individual psychic how they work best :)

no citations for that, it's just my opinion :)

OK, you said:

plumjam said:
"Science" wants to be able to apply the same method it uses for physical and chemical processes to much more complex and subtle processes such as ESP, clairvoyance etc... and these abilities are much more dependent on the aptitude of the subject and the surroundings, atmosphere etc.

"Abilities dependent on X" is assuming optimum conditions for optimum results. But then you just said:

This is one of science's symptoms, it assumes that there should be an optimum condition for producing optimum results,

You appear to have contradicted yourself. I'm confused.
 
Why are you so insistant that you get a free pass for your claims?

Why shouldn't we challenge your claims about science, especially when we know they are wrong?

And what better way to show you why you're wrong about something in science than referring to the scientific works?

you are just hiding in the classic negative position, not offering anything positive yourself, sitting back, trying to take apart any positive statement anyone makes (in this situation this means me, as I am/was the only one actually saying anything and trying to converse on here)
it's an easy route to take, and a pretty cowardly one. When I talk about conversation I'm trying to get across the fact that all of us on here could offer positive viewpoints and be friendly about it, but it seems no-one wants to.
Possibly that is going to be a characteristic of Skeptics generically.
Pretty dull all round.
 
Argumentum ad hominem, circular reasoning and hasty generalization, plumjam. Try again.

Please tell us, what brought you to the JREF? What information were you seeking?
 
OK, you said:



"Abilities dependent on X" is assuming optimum conditions for optimum results. But then you just said:



You appear to have contradicted yourself. I'm confused.

What I'm saying, in a roundabout way is that Science classically is going to assume that every phenomenon will have its own set of optimum physical conditions which will aid in bringing that phenomenon about. But this applies much more at the lower levels of complexity i.e physics and chemistry... the more complex things get the more consciousness comes into play, and at the human level it's probable that each individual psychic will have their own favourite optimum conditions in which to function. Some might prefer a dark room, alone.. others might have eyes open, others closed etc... this is why classical science is pretty impotent at the human level and why something like psychology is very difficult to make real progress in.. because the subject matter involves the presence of more consciousness thus more freedom... scientists generally prefer predictability because with this comes power, but this only happens at the lower (dumb) levels where consciousness plays little part, like physics and chemistry
 
sounds good, but pretty disingenuous methinks. I seriously doubt that if DR A gave you a list of citations you'd subsequently dutifully trot off tomorrow to the library to look them all up, read them, analyse their true significance to your position on fruitflies and then modify your position, this is all just scientific-sounding hokum.. someone please be real and admit this.

Not in this case, but that's because I've already read a couple of biology books, as well as some referenced scientific literature online. It's not new to me about how the speciation of fruit flies works.

And that's what I do when I do get interested in a scientific subject. Read books about it. Study it. Ask people about sources. Because hey, that's how I learn something. Of course, that's not happening every day, because I have lots of non-scientific interests as well. But every now and then, I get that urge.

So, if you do have any actual citations, there are people here who will do their best to follow them up. But simply throwing up a claim and then project your own laziness onto us when you refuse to both provide evidence as well as looking at the evidence we present to you... Now -that- is disingenious and intellectually dishonest.
 
Argumentum ad hominem, circular reasoning and hasty generalization, plumjam. Try again.

Please tell us, what brought you to the JREF? What information were you seeking?

pretty negative of you, seeing as, like everyone else you're not offering anything.

I came to JREF out of curiosity, and because in my life I see a central contradiction in the whole Skeptical approach... which now I'm not going to offer, cos I obviously have no citations to back it up ;)
 
Not in this case, but that's because I've already read a couple of biology books, as well as some referenced scientific literature online. It's not new to me about how the speciation of fruit flies works.

And that's what I do when I do get interested in a scientific subject. Read books about it. Study it. Ask people about sources. Because hey, that's how I learn something. Of course, that's not happening every day, because I have lots of non-scientific interests as well. But every now and then, I get that urge.

So, if you do have any actual citations, there are people here who will do their best to follow them up. But simply throwing up a claim and then project your own laziness onto us when you refuse to both provide evidence as well as looking at the evidence we present to you... Now -that- is disingenious and intellectually dishonest.


sorry, don't buy it
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom