when have you changed your mind on a matter?

do you think they would have recorded it in some easily accessible place?

I'm asking for your source. Your comment has no bearing on that request. In an honest argument, when one is required to cite their source, they either cite the source, or abandon their argument. You have done neither. You made a very specific claim about a very specific publication. You later posted that virtually all scientists and scientific periodicals denied the Wright's achievement. If you cannot cite the basis of your "facts" how do you expect anyone to take the arguments you base on them seriously?

You may be comfortable throwing out baseless assertions to support flawed arguments, but you will not get away with it here. Be honest and thorough and your arguments will be considered. Make baseless assertions and you will not be taken seriously. If you feel that is a closed-minded approach to discourse, it may be that critical thinking is beyond you.

One other point:
In a rational discussion, one shouldn't ask "who is with me". Skeptics accept arguments without logical fallacies and base personal opinions on them. I have yet to see you assert a single non-flawed argument. I have seen you make unlikely claims and ignore requests to cite your source. Requests for you to support your assertions are met with the kind of response I quoted above.

You should brush up on your logical fallacies so that you may avoid them, or avoid arguments with people who can see through the fallacious arguments you throw out.

no-one wants to change their minds, what a surprise

ETA: BTW - I have directly addressed this in one of my posts. Did you ignore it? Do you reject my statement about how a skeptic changes their mind using reason? If so, why?
 
Last edited:
I am willing to change my mind on any particular subject, I will not however change my approach to dubious claims. This is not orthodoxy in any definition of the word with which I am familiar, and I believe any attempt to make this analogy is intellectually dishonest.

Is this not a clear answer to your OP?
 
You know what I miss?

Killfiles. Ignore lists are all very well, but there's no substitute for the satisfying "plonk" noise as someone hits the killfile at high speed.
 
any scientist or investigator who comes up with a conclusion other than one that confirms and reinforces the currently popular and profitable paradigm, hey, they soon disappear, if they have the bravery to stand up in public to defend their results, which few do

You can't possibly have studied the history of science in any kind of meaningful way if you honestly believe this. Perhaps you should read about Einstein and his thoughts about the theory of relativity. It is only one of many perfect examples of how inaccurate your above statement is.
 
well, probably cos my original post of 7 or 8 busy hours ago asked whether any Skeptic had really changed their view of things due to new evidence, and the only replies I got were people becoming more skeptical, all of which supported my hypothesis that the kind of Randi-lovers who come on these kinds of forum come here beloved of the Big Randi and a bit indoctrinated.

Actually I DID not come here because of Randi. I actually knew next to nothing about the man when I found this place.
I changed my "woo" beliefs (so I, for one, DID change my beliefs due to lack of good evidence for them) before I came here but this place is helping me to see many things and think in ways I never did before.
Why are you so negative about us? You haven't really given this place and the people here an honest chance for a debate.
Why not try?
 
Galileo - exectued, Marconi - widely ridiculed (including in the most respectable Science publications) until he managed to get his radio message across the Atlantic, Maxwell - shunned and ignored by the establishment (partly because he was a commoner) etc etc.. the history of science is full of these examples.. all of which you "Skeptics" would have pooh-poohed with joy, later to make you look like utter fools. The problem with most scientists is that very few of them study the history of science. Also the establishment tends to obscure the way they actively ridiiculed most scientific pioneers
 
Please: don't be so callous as to use facts to destroy plumjam's position. You nasty, terrible skeptic you.
 
well, trials, imprisonment, house arrest and death... as good as execution..
typical science pedant, but keep trying ;)
 
Galileo - exectued, Marconi - widely ridiculed (including in the most respectable Science publications) until he managed to get his radio message across the Atlantic, Maxwell - shunned and ignored by the establishment (partly because he was a commoner) etc etc.. the history of science is full of these examples.. all of which you "Skeptics" would have pooh-poohed with joy, later to make you look like utter fools. The problem with most scientists is that very few of them study the history of science. Also the establishment tends to obscure the way they actively ridiiculed most scientific pioneers

Well, I've had about my fill. This is the perfect summation of your ignorance regarding science, the history of science, and reasoned discourse. Don't you even think to google some of this stuff before you post it? You realize we all have internet access right?
 
The problem with most scientists is that very few of them study the history of science.

I have to say I think it's just funny as all get-out that you state this in the same paragraph you tell us that Galileo was executed.

It's also funny that your Galileo example was irrelevant anyway because it was the Catholic Church (of which I happen to be a member), not "science", not "skepticism", that repressed Galileo's claims, and even that was partly for political reasons.

plumjam, I will give you some advice. If you want to be taken seriously, don't patronize people while making such fundamental mistakes yourself. There are other points to address (such as I made in post 39), but just not tripping over your own pretentiousness would be a good start.
 
The problem with most scientists is that very few of them study the history of science.

I have to say I think it's just funny as all get-out that you state this in the same paragraph you tell us that Galileo was executed.

It's also funny that your Galileo example was irrelevant anyway because it was the Catholic Church (of which I happen to be a member), not "science", not "skepticism", that repressed Galileo's claims, and even that was partly for political reasons.

plumjam, I will give you some advice. If you want to be taken seriously, don't patronize people while making such fundamental mistakes yourself. There are other points to address (such as I made in post 39), but just not tripping over your own pretentiousness would be a good start.

cheers for the advice,

the reason I mentioned Galileo was that he went against the prevailing consensus in society, doesn't matter whether it was religious or non-religious, my wider point being that anyone who goes against the consensus tends to be dismissed, ridiculed, shunned etc... it disappoints me that a lot of people seem to come to science with the view that what they are taught was always self evident. They are left with the impression that it was accepted easily, and why? ..because if they were taught how society and the institutions vehemently resisted these new theories then these institutions would lose face and some of their power,.. it seems to me one area of education that is a bit of a fraud :)
 
plumjam: In my experience Skepticism takes great pains to appear to be purely scientific in that it claims to view evidence on both sides of an argument equally and without bias.
Yet this effort is disingenuous to say the least.


First problem. I don't believe or adhere to any sort of capital-letter Skepticism; I do think skepticism (small 's') is one of the most valuable tools have. But it is only one in our mental toolkit.

Judging from what I have read on here most Skeptics adhere to a quite narrow branch of philosophy that might be characterised as reductionist materialism.

I don't; nor do a number of others. What about those who don't fit your generalization?

Most reductionst materialists do not fully face the fact that if their philosophy were to be true then reality SHOULD be chaotic, devoid of organisation, devoid of life, devoid of intelligence, consciousness, meaning, purpose, emotion, music, humour, selflessness...etc...etc..

Why? Physical laws clearly dictate organization at many scales. There are a number of good theories as to how living matter can arise from nonliving matter (abiogenesis). Intelligence, emotion, etc. can be viewed as emergent properties of increasingly complex evolved organisms' neurological systems* and the interplay with environment and group membership. If you want to dispute such theories, fine, but to baldly claim such things "SHOULD" not happen is begging the question.

To put this in another way, what is either logical or rational about reality having even the most basic of physical laws?

The fact that the laws of physics exist is neither logical nor rational. On the contrary, using a principle which Skeptics often invoke - that of Occam's Razor, it would surely be more reasonable to expect the universe to be completely devoid of the laws of physics, and thus be completely chaotic.


No, not at all. This is simply handwaving. The "laws" of physics are not manmade; they are simply our observations of how the natural world happens to work. And, in fact, the natural world in many ways is chaotic; but various types of order naturally emerge from such chaotic processes.

A couple of you asked whether I have an axe to grind. Well, being a thinking, feeling human being like the rest of you, of course I have an axe to grind.

I like mumbling under my breath with a glassy stare while I grind my axe :D

An implication in my original post is that a lot of people on this forum have axes to grind, but prefer to deny the fact, or perhaps they just haven't yet realised that due to their educational upbringing they have been channelled into one particular school of philosophy among a whole range of possible options.

It seems like most people do. It's almost inevitable.

I would say that the axe I have to grind is that my basic position is that of my old mate Bill who used to pipe up with "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy."

That's what makes science so exciting.

One of the main reasons I think like this is an examination of the history of science and technology and the myriad instances when the Skeptical establishment has been proven spectacularly wrong (e.g. Marconi and the existence of electromagnetism, Maxwell and the existence of electricity, Galileo, the Wright Bros and the possibility of powered flight, science's belief in phlogiston and ether, etc etc.. )

Did you happen to note that it was scientists, using the scientific process, which eventually sorted out what was right and what was not in all those cases?

My point is that most of the people on this forum would (as did the establishment figures of those times) have heartily enjoyed ridiculing such notions, and condemning people like Maxwell, Marconi and the Wright Bros as what are pretty distastefully referred to here as "woos".

Straw man. While skeptics in general and scientists in particular are human beings, and thus prone like everyone else to jealousy, stubbornness, and being to wed to one's own pet ideas, skepticism is not the same as reflexive denial and science is open to any idea which can provide evidence and survive the tests which eventually weed out bunkum.

It's far from a perfect process, but consider the alternative - never, ever discarding a useless and unsound notion. Consider, say, homeopathy, which has survived two centuries without ever providing any evidence, or a plausible mechanism for how it might work, or contributing anything to our knowledge of biology or chemistry. But, despite the ridicule originally accorded to the notion that a bacterium might be the cause of many ulcers, science quickly accepted the claim once real evidence was provided. The simple fact is that science, which embodies a skeptical attitude, is in fact open to change where change is warranted.


*Yes, I know that "evolution" and "increasing complexity" are not one and the same.

the last paragraph is good, and interesting, mainly cos it's honest.. which is often lacking in this forum :)
the whole straw man thing I can't really understand, it has been mentioned to me 3 or 4 times already in one evening, so seems to be a standard rebuttal here. Skepticism I DO find to be refelxive denial in a lot of cases, mainly for socio-cultural reasons supervening those of evidence, such as in parapsychology and some areas akin.
I do feel that this view of science as accepting valid evidence whenever it appears is bogus, and history shows it is only fully accepted when there has been a large accumulation of such evidence which finally manages to crack and break the previous paradigm. Incidentally this often seems to happen not simply through the accumulation of evidence, but more importantly because influential figures in that area just get older and retire or die.

Cheers
 
the last paragraph is good, and interesting, mainly cos it's honest.. which is often lacking in this forum :)

{snip}


I see that you joined this Forum August 13th, and yet you have been able to formulate this opinion?

Casting grand-sweeping aspersions about a forum that you joined a mere two days ago does not garner respect.

Making cogent arguments backed up by evidence does.

That's how things work around here. If you can participate accordingly, you may find that your experience is more rewarding and, potentially, educational to you. If you participate accordingly, you may actually educate others, too.

Welcome to the Forum. We look forward to your participation.
 
BTW, plumjam, I gave you a specific example of the scientific "establishment" changing its mind rather rapidly in the face of new evidence. In fact, the H. Pylori - ulcer link went from being controversial - quite against mainstream medical thought - to pretty much fully accepted in a dozen years, and garnered its proponents the Nobel Prize.

I'll also give you a personal example of being convinced by the evidence. Although I had doubts, I initially accepted that there were significant WMDs (not just leftovers from wars with Iran) in Iraq. Not long after the invasion, this turned out not to be the case, and I changed my mind.

i'm struggling to work out who is for me and who is against me, . ... so let's simplify it, who believes in God and Design and who doesn't?

I'm neither for nor against you; I'm against sloppy reasoning and confusing belief with evidence.

In a poll taken in 2004, almost three-quarters of the President's core group of supporters (evangelical Christians) still believed the WMD claims after they had been disproved. This same group is by far the most likely to profess full-up belief in God and to support creationism in its various manifestations, including ID. I think that's interesting, don't you?

edit to add: I see you've responded to both my posts, and I think you have some valid points, but I won't be able to get back for a while...
 
Last edited:
It seems to me that Skepticism is very similar to a religion/ideology.
Then I suggest that you learn something about skepticism.

Very often any evidence presented which goes against the general ideology and philosophy held by Skepticism is ignored, discounted out of hand, ridiculed, or the ad hominem approach is taken.
If this happens "very often", you could perhaps present some examples?

With this in mind I'd be interested to hear examples from you of when new evidence has prompted you to honestly change your mind on a particular subject.
Like this?
 
One of the main reasons I think like this is an examination of the history of science and technology and the myriad instances when the Skeptical establishment has been proven spectacularly wrong (e.g. Marconi and the existence of electromagnetism, Maxwell and the existence of electricity, Galileo, the Wright Bros and the possibility of powered flight ...
Er ... you seem to have made a lot of stuff up.

It was the Church which doubted Galileo, no-one in Marconi's day doubted electromagnetism, no-one in Maxwell's day doubted the existence of electricity ... I see other posters have been asking you for evidence of your stuff about the Wright Brothers, which you have not provided.

All of them were admired as great men in their day by everyone who understood the magnitude of their achievements, for which, of course, one needs the scientific knowledge we skeptics love so much.

My point is that most of the people on this forum would (as did the establishment figures of those times) have heartily enjoyed ridiculing such notions, and condemning people like Maxwell, Marconi and the Wright Bros as what are pretty distastefully referred to here as "woos".
And if that fantasy comforts you, feel free to indulge it. Do try to bear in mind, though, that you can't really read minds, and that the made-up world in your head doesn't actually reflect reality.
 
BTW, plumjam, I gave you a specific example of the scientific "establishment" changing its mind rather rapidly in the face of new evidence. In fact, the H. Pylori - ulcer link went from being controversial - quite against mainstream medical thought - to pretty much fully accepted in a dozen years, and garnered its proponents the Nobel Prize.

I'll also give you a personal example of being convinced by the evidence. Although I had doubts, I initially accepted that there were significant WMDs (not just leftovers from wars with Iran) in Iraq. Not long after the invasion, this turned out not to be the case, and I changed my mind.

i'm struggling to work out who is for me and who is against me, . ... so let's simplify it, who believes in God and Design and who doesn't?

I'm neither for nor against you; I'm against sloppy reasoning and confusing belief with evidence.

In a poll taken in 2004, almost three-quarters of the President's core group of supporters (evangelical Christians) still believed the WMD claims after they had been disproved. This same group is by far the most likely to profess full-up belief in God and to support creationism in its various manifestations, including ID. I think that's interesting, don't you?

cheers ST60, for the new knowledge. It's interesting, but I do find it a bit sad that the quickest example you can provide of new evidence in science being taken seriously took 12 years... I mean, does this, in any way resemble how science was taught to us in school/university? I think not.
So my broader point is that if, for example, a pretty uncontentious physical "meat and potatoes" hypothesis takes 12 years to be accepted, how long would an equally true, but less "conventional" hypothesis need to be accepted? 50 years? 100 years? never?
that's what makes the kind of flippant dismissal of "woo" on this forum pretty unpopular with me. It's also obvious that those dismissing "woo" really enjoy doing so because it makes them feel intellectually superior to those they dismiss,

cheers
 
no-one in Marconi's day doubted electromagnetism,

crikey, read your history, he was universally ridiculed and couldn't get any funding.
It's true, all you "Skeptics", no one of any great importance really believed in electromagnetic waves until Marconi did his cross-atlantic communication.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom