when have you changed your mind on a matter?

Being skeptical of the accomplishment and being skeptical of the science that supports it are two different things. I could find no mention of a Nature article from the 20th century making any claims against heavier than air flight or the wright brothers (their online archive only goes back to the 50's). Could you please cite your source for this?

do you think they would have recorded it in some easily accessible place?
 
yeah,

well I've given the lot of you about 12 hours and no-one has had the humility to come up with anything... and I didn't expect it. Not cos I dislike you guys, more cos I understand everyone on this site is intellectually and emotionally attached to a particular view of life and the universe.. so no probs. Anyone who came on here to support me, then I'd start to really wonder ;)
Ady
 
Well plumjam, if you want to ignore when people have said they've changed their mind that is your prerogative.

Which is ironic of course if you're trying to paint changing one's mind as a good thing.
 
:)

Oh sorry, I thought we were just inserting pointless smilies.

Again plumjam if you just want to ignore the posts go for it. I don't quite know who you are going to fool apart from yourself. But if your objective is to reaffirm your preconceived notions (and of course dear readers, that ironically means that he thinks changing one's mind is a bad thing) then go ahead.
 
no, seeing as i still endeavour to maintain a life i don't go onto the computer with a list of magazine dates and article numbers, months, days, vol, page, etc... as i'm sure you don't, although I'm sure you too are an intelligent reading individual.
If my whole life was centred around trying to prove other people wrong then perhaps I might.
All I can say is that I definitely listened to a documentary that said exactly that, and if you don't believe me then maybe tomorrow you'll tell a friend the same about that with what you believe is the same historical veracity ;)
 
no, seeing as i still endeavour to maintain a life i don't go onto the computer with a list of magazine dates and article numbers, months, days, vol, page, etc... as i'm sure you don't, although I'm sure you too are an intelligent reading individual.

First rule of this forum: if you say something you are likely to be challenged on it.

Therefore if you aren't ready to back up what you say then don't be surprised if people aren't going to respond positively to it.

If my whole life was centred around trying to prove other people wrong then perhaps I might.

And yet you are tacitly trying to show we are wrong are we not?

Is this not just a lament that you aren't very good at it?

All I can say is that I definitely listened to a documentary that said exactly that,

Eh? There's a documentary involved now? To which one to you refer?

and if you don't believe me then maybe tomorrow you'll tell a friend the same about that with what you believe is the same historical veracity ;)

I cannot parse this sentence fragment.
 
Since you're talking in non-sequiturs now it's patently obvious that you are simply trolling.

Therefore you are now on ignore.

You're an ass: congratulations.
 
Well, what's to defend? It's a fact that natural selection happens, and nobody has any competing scientific theory that can explain the diversity in life. If you know of one - and keep in mind, a scientific theory needs to prove itself right, not simply attack another theory as wrong and then say "god did it" - then please, show us some references to such works.
 
i have no theory whatsoever, cos no such theory could exist, my over-arching theory is that every organic physical construction is thousands of times more complex than any designed car or computer, even the simplest kind know to us in all history, so it is a complete mystery how it and they exist... pity the indoctrinated teenage know-it-alls want to argue differently
 
well, probably cos my original post of 7 or 8 busy hours ago asked whether any Skeptic had really changed their view of things due to new evidence, and the only replies I got were people becoming more skeptical, all of which supported my hypothesis that the kind of Randi-lovers who come on these kinds of forum come here beloved of the Big Randi and a bit indoctrinated.
 
well, probably cos my original post of 7 or 8 busy hours ago asked whether any Skeptic had really changed their view of things due to new evidence, and the only replies I got were people becoming more skeptical, all of which supported my hypothesis that the kind of Randi-lovers who come on these kinds of forum come here beloved of the Big Randi and a bit indoctrinated.

So the problem isn't that people changed their view upon examining the evidence, it's that evidence consistently point people towards positions you don't agree with.

What does that tell you about your position?

ETA: A problem I see is that you equivocate skepticism with a set of conclusions. This is not so. Skepticism is the process through which a conclusion is reached, and not the conclusion itself.

[skepticism]I've looked at the evidence available[/skepticism], and [conclusion]this leads me to conclude that evolution is true[/conclusion].
 
Last edited:
yes! in my experience Skeptics do align themselves with a particular form of specifically materialist determinist reductionist conclusion which, surprisingly enough, conforms with the prevailing socio-political paradigm of our lovely benificent capitalist rich employers... any scientist or investigator who comes up with a conclusion other than one that confirms and reinforces the currently popular and profitable paradigm, hey, they soon disappear, if they have the bravery to stand up in public to defend their results, which few do
 
I'm not sure if I understand your point. People who weight the evidence of various claims reach similar conclusions, therefore they are wrong and endoctrinated? :confused:

How do you reach conclusions?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom