when have you changed your mind on a matter?

For me, I prefer being "less woo" in that being more apt to live in the world as it is and to see it for what it is is the most liberating experience I have ever had. It is really hard to explain. I guess you just have to experience the feeling for yourself.

But, boy, was I once VERY "woo." I spent years that way. I'm glad I was because it helped make me the person that I am now, but for me, I prefer being "less woo!" I still cringe at the fact that I once believed in Sylvia Browne. (Ewww!)

Good luck no matter which way you go, plumjam, but I hope you find your stay here helpful to you. We can all learn new things, right?
 
hmm.. have a cup of coffee.. and maybe after it try to realistically try to understand the unlikeliness of all the complexity of organic beings like me and you existing and conversing like this just cause of some strange happenchance in the universe ;)

No offense intended, but I have no problem with believing that we are here by happenchance (meaning we just don't have all the answers yet) in the universe. :)
 
Being skeptical of the accomplishment and being skeptical of the science that supports it are two different things. I could find no mention of a Nature article from the 20th century making any claims against heavier than air flight or the wright brothers (their online archive only goes back to the 50's). Could you please cite your source for this?

Sorry, I wasn't the one making the original claim. I was just accepting that what plumjam said was true. I don't have a source, and it makes little difference to me whether it's true or not, the point is, if this did occur, it is not an argument against skepticism.
 
hi wonderful thinking guys,
well, i could address my thoughts to a few of you, but it seems to me that the most persistent and important, is Mr Humphreys (hope for reasons of seriousness none of you were fans of the Grace Bros (UK TV comedy) ;-) and what I would say to Mr Humprhreys would be hmm.. have a cup of coffee.. and maybe after it try to realistically try to understand the unlikeliness of all the complexity of organic beings like me and you existing and conversing like this just cause of some strange happenchance in the universe ;)

There are several threads on this topic. If you'd liek to discuss creation/evolution, please find one of them. Unelss you aren't really interested in discussing the topic you posted in your OP (because believe me, the creation debate will take over the thread. We could have an entire thread correcting the errors in your statement about what you think evolutionary theory and current cosmology is).

In regards to the OP, it seems you've constructed your argument based on a debateable assumption. You've started with the assumption that there is valid, credible evidence for the paranormal. If this were true, then your argument would be correct.

However, this is where most skeptics form their belief. They've looked into the paranormal in an unbiased manner, taken the time to undertsand the relevent science, at least to the point that they can appreciate the layman's works on the topic written by experts in relevent fields (we can't all be experts in everything), and found that evicdence for paranormal phenomna is woefully lacking.

So, my answer to you would be that skeptics do attempt to take an unbiased view of evidence (we all have biases, you can't prevent them, but you can be aware of them and take steps to limit their influence, which is a large portion of what science is). However, the evidence for the paranormal, once examined with scientific integrity and skepticism, fades away like phantoms when the lights go on. The only bits left are shadows of moths.
 
well i can't give you chapter and verse, but from the books i've read the Wright Bros, even after having demonstrated to a group of their friends their ability to fly unaided, were universally ridiculed in the local and more widely the popular national and international press.... this is what i am getting at.. a lot of you guys who enjoy being on this site to pooh pooh discoverys, you get your kicks from feeling superior to others, and that makes me feel a bit uneasy
 
No need for chapter and verse, just a title or two would help. Even better wuld be for you to provide a primary source.
 
maybe after it try to realistically try to understand the unlikeliness of all the complexity of organic beings like me and you existing and conversing like this just cause of some strange happenchance in the universe ;)

Yeah, it's quite mind boggling, isn't it?

I find lots of things mind boggling, though, like Quantum Physics. That's not a good argument against the truth of QM, tho.

Is our existence incredibly unlikely? Probably, but who knows?

We don't know:

1) How many big bangs there have been that failed to produce a rational Universe
2) How many uninhabited Universes there are
3) How much time went by before a rational Universe came into existence
4) What, if any, underlying laws existed before the creation of this Universe, and why
5) How likely/unlikely it is for a rational Universe to come into existence out of all the possibilities

What we do know is, however unlikely the chance existence of this Universe is, the chance of an omnipotent supreme being coming into existence randomly is infinitely less likely...and yet we exist, and something was responsible.

If a creator always existed, whose to say the Universe didn't always exist in some form, or the laws for building one successfully?

I don't know the answers, but I know adding a God into the equation is unneccesary, and only complicates matters.
 
a lot of you guys who enjoy being on this site to pooh pooh discoverys, you get your kicks from feeling superior to others, and that makes me feel a bit uneasy

Well I can assure you I am not like that. As a matter of fact I don't post as much as I like because I don't feel smart enough or educated enough to do so. I do not feel that I am superior to anyone.

I would wager that I am not alone in saying that you are mistaken about the vast majority of us if you think that. There are always the resident trolls who probably fit that belief of yours, but I doubt that most of us here do. Again, give this place a chance. :)
 
Sorry, I wasn't the one making the original claim. I was just accepting that what plumjam said was true. I don't have a source, and it makes little difference to me whether it's true or not, the point is, if this did occur, it is not an argument against skepticism.

I know you weren't and I agree with you. I was initially going to avoid getting dragged into arguing the benefits of a skeptical (objective) outlook based on philosophical (subjective) arguments.

However, the "Nature ridiculed the Wright Bros. claim surprised me". One could even say I am skeptical that such an article exists. To return to the question in the OP, I am currently skeptical such an article exists because it runs counter to my understanding of the mission of Nature Magazine. Of course, I haven't read much of Nature from the early 20th century, so such an article could possibly exist and as a good skeptic, I request evidence of its existence. If a suitable source for such a claim exists, I will then accept that claim (in the absence of any further evidence). Thus I will have changed my mind about whether I think the article exists. However, I will not change my mind about the correct way to approach a claim that doesn't fit with my current understanding of the world.

Certainly this isn't a world shattering issue, but I apply the same type of logic to world shaterring issues as well with equal success.

Long story short (too late): I am willing to change my mind on any particular subject, I will not however change my approach to dubious claims. This is not orthodoxy in any definition of the word with which I am familiar, and I believe any attempt to make this analogy is intellectually dishonest.
 
well i can't give you chapter and verse, but from the books i've read the Wright Bros, even after having demonstrated to a group of their friends their ability to fly unaided, were universally ridiculed in the local and more widely the popular national and international press.... this is what i am getting at.. a lot of you guys who enjoy being on this site to pooh pooh discoverys, you get your kicks from feeling superior to others, and that makes me feel a bit uneasy

You realize that this of course, is not evidence. Chapter and verse is required when making a dubious claim. That is the foundation of a good argument. I realize no such claims are required when have a completely subjective philosophical discussion and there is certainly room for such discussion on any skeptical issue. There is no basis for it in a definition of skepticism and critical thinking.

Another question about the above: Are you saying that those who saw demonstrations of the wright brothers aircraft didn't believe what they saw? Are you claiming that others didn't believe the recollections of those who saw the demonstrations?

I realize I'm beating to death what might seem to be a small point, but you used this as evidence of your argument (several times). I would expect you would support the evidence with a reliable source or agree that the argument is invalid since it has no basis. I have studied the history of flight in a fair amount of detail and I believe your comparison of public reaction to the Wright Brothers to skepticism in general is misplaced and misleading.

ETA: Once you get in the habit of not making assertions without evidence (in hand) to support those assertions, you will find you have taken a great step towards applying critical thinking to your arguments (and perhaps you life). If this happens, you might catch a glimpse of what skepticism really is. This is how skeptics are born.
 
Last edited:
hi Humphreys,

let me say that of all the replies I have received I am most encouraged by yours. You know what? From what I remember, your initial response to my post was the most negative, but now your reply is the most positive that I have received, so we should be friends one day ;-)

In a sense I love you for your open-mindedness :)
You ask whether a univsere would have come about without anyone knowing about it, without it having laws, without it having any conscious being etc..

well, who really knows... I can only say that my experience of life has pointed towards order to organisation, and as we live we put value into beings who show some kind of order... If the universe before our existence had tried hundreds of trillions of combinations to get to us and our silliness.. then maybe it did... but I just don't intuitively believe it. I rather believe that if some kind of conscious enjoyment and experience of the universe is possible and manifest then those that believe the opposite have a heck of a lot to explain
;)
 
well, thanks for what you wrote, I understand and appreciate it :)

I can only say that a few years ago I got a book from the library here in London, and it was written by a science journalist who was quite well known in the US and the UK. He recounted how it was that before and during the Wright Bros experiments with flight, they were basically ridiculed and no-one of any particular importance or prestige was taking any great notice of their experiments. Their local newspaper had received reports of their success, but because those reports only came from farmers and obviously contradicted the so-called "experts" of the Nature magazine they were pretty much ignored
 
...science's belief in phlogiston and ether, etc etc...


You're confusing "science" with "scientists". Science didn't believe in phlogiston; people did, including some scientists. Science is an objective way for us non-objective humans to find out if phlogiston really exists, or if all objects fall to the ground at the same rate, or if Sylvia Browne is a psychic or a fraud.

So far, every scientific discovery has had a purely physical explanation, but the scientific process isn't limited to the physical world. It's used to look at the supernatural as well. By definition, it doesn't play favourites. It just so happens that there isn't a single, solitary iota of support for the supernatural. On the other hand, there is overwhelming evidence that people can have wildly inventive imaginations, that they can find comfort in magical irrationality, and that there are people willing to exploit that.
 
thanks for your v. intelligent response, which I admire,

regarding an intelligent response, if you were to take the time to read Mysticism by Evelyn Underhill and The Varieties of Religious Experience by William James (both of whom happen to be 19thC authors) then I would feel that I had added something of genuine value to your life :)
they are works of genius, and are not dependent of our so-called modern life, hopefully, my friend, you will follow this and accept or discount what you find, take care, Adrian
 
I can only say that a few years ago I got a book from the library here in London, and it was written by a science journalist who was quite well known in the US and the UK. He recounted how it was that before and during the Wright Bros experiments with flight, they were basically ridiculed and no-one of any particular importance or prestige was taking any great notice of their experiments. Their local newspaper had received reports of their success, but because those reports only came from farmers and obviously contradicted the so-called "experts" of the Nature magazine they were pretty much ignored

And do you know what plumjam? When people were shown real flying planes they had no choice but to accept it.

You show real 'mysticism' and it will be accepted.
 
hi Laedwig

As my journalism teacher used to say, if you cannot be bothered to spell the names correctly, why should I believe that you have recounted any of the facts correctly?

what i read from your feedback is "If one makes ridiculous mistakes in one's argument" thanks for that, at the moment i'm not sure what that is referring to.

I was referring to the errors identified in posts 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 12, 13, 14, 15, and 17. If you were serious, I would suggest that you have a look at those posts.
 
thanks for your v. intelligent response, which I admire,

regarding an intelligent response, if you were to take the time to read Mysticism by Evelyn Underhill and The Varieties of Religious Experience by William James (both of whom happen to be 19thC authors) then I would feel that I had added something of genuine value to your life :)
they are works of genius, and are not dependent of our so-called modern life, hopefully, my friend, you will follow this and accept or discount what you find, take care, Adrian

I've already read "Varieties of Religious Experience." If I and other posters agree to read your book about mysticism, will you read a book on skepticism?
 
well, it has nothing to do with the last ten years, i only remember reading a book by a science journalist who has been rather ignored and badly talked of cos he has the guts to bring these things up, that before the Wright Bros managed their 80 metre flight all the "resepectable" science magazines were riciculing them, and even the local newspaper AFTER they managed it unequivocally was denying it because they hadn't bothered to send their own reporter out, cos they just basically didn't believe it was possible, as did no-one
 
sure I'll read a book about skepticism, so long as it's written by someone with an open mind, unlike Dawkins and old Santa Randi ;)
 
So your point is that any ridiculed claim must be true?

Or just that you have picked one ridiculed claim you like and you want to be true and the fact that there are other true claims that were originally ridiculed means that, in your mind, the chances of the claims you like being true are at least greater in your mind.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom