when have you changed your mind on a matter?

One last point: "Alas, to wear the mantle of Galileo it is not enough that you be persecuted by an unkind establishment; you must also be right." (Robert Park)
 
well, from what i have learnt Nature Magazine (supposedly the most prestigious science publication on planet Earth) heavily ridiculed the Wright Brothers, even the local paper of the Wright Bros local town after hearing stories of the success of their first flights denied it and ridiculed them, because that was what the prevailing mental orthodoxy of the time dictated.
What closed-minded people they were soon proven to be. My point is that there is a temptation that is all to easy to succumb to which relegates anyone with any new idea or invention to ridicule, and similtaneously gives you, as a Skeptic, the pleasure of feeling yourself intellectualy superior to them
 
Skepticism looks like religion because many skeptics hold the same 'beliefs' as other skeptics, much like many fundamentalists hold the same beliefs as other fundamentalists.

How they arrived at those 'beliefs' are extremely different. Here's the key difference:

Religion: Here's a book. Read the book. Memorize the book. Believe everything this book says, and defend these beliefs at all costs. The book is not to be questioned, because it is infaliable.

Science: Here is the scientific consensus so far. Read the theories. Study the theories. Examine all of the evidence which lead to those theories. Question the theories, and try to break them. If you can't, and the evidence is sound, then the theories might be right.

Just because most skeptics don't believe in ghosts does not mean that they are following some imaginary Skeptic Orthodoxy. It means that they have examined the evidence for the existance of ghosts, and find it lacking.
 
I just believe that because the probability is that you have been trained in scientific subjects rather than philosophy then your outlook has been somewhat limited.

I'm a very big fan of philosophy, many skeptics aren't. Although I'm a big fan, I'm not an expert, but many other skeptics are.

This is precisely why you cannot paint with such a broad brush and make claims about "Skeptical Orthodoxy". Skepticism is not anything like a religion, and skeptics come in all shapes and sizes with varying beliefs.

If you look around this board, you will see skeptics that are believers in God, for example.
 
Hi Ripley Twenty Nine, and thanks a lot for your response.
Your response makes a great deal of sense in a christian or perhaps Islamic context. I'm just assuming it's Christian because there are more christian english speakers on-line ;)
I remember the great Hindu mystic called Vivekananda, he had had, from his spiritual master, Ramakrishna, direct experience of reality, and he, Vivekananda, argued against the hegemony (all-powerfullness) of the Church and similar such institutions. On his first visit to the west he toured round the USA and privately decried the system whereby anyone trying to speak the truth in the USA or even Europe, would have to feel the weight of a bell, a prayer book, and a church tower on their heads
 
hi Humphreys,

thanks for your reply, you seem now like quite a reasonable loveable one ;)
Yes, I did rather mischievously enter into this forum with a bit of a naughty intention, mainly cos I generally feel that people who accept the current materialistic/rationalistic/logical (that whole idea doesn't yet have a word - which shows you an a priori unfairness at work) paradigm tend to act in a slightly dishonest way, according to their society-induced prejudices ;)
 
I used to think it was 2006, but in the light of new evidence I changed my mind.
 
Welcome, plumjam! One thing I want to point out to you is that many of us here began as "woos" but later changed. It was not easy and it is still sometimes painful and lonely, but most of us agree that becoming (more) skeptical is the best thing that has ever happened to us.
You'll meet all kinds of people here, as Humphreys said, and you shouldn't paint us all with one brush. If you stick around you may be pleasantly surprised.
 
hi Minarvia,

thanks for your contribution :)
I don't really know whether becoming less or more woo would be advantageous in life. My natural bent seems to be to endeavour and persist in wonderful wooness (i.e. not believing in incredibly unlikely random creation of the universe, species and evolutionary improvement) but I do genuinely welcome your friendship (y)
 
Rather I was just talking honestly from my mind and heart as I hope we all do :)

..., but despite the fact that I orginally replied to your first answers with moderate language I'll just show you here the words you used to my response:


"your own invention" "you're creating a strawman" "Absurd" "No, this is ridiculous" "Nonsense" "Hehe. That's funny" "This is just nonsense"


If one makes ridiculous mistakes in one's argument, then no matter how sincere and heartfelt the argument is, no matter how moderate the language in the argument is, one should not be surprised when people respond by calling it a ridiculous argument.


Furthermore, I would hardly accept the claim that the opening post used moderate language:
"evidence presented which goes against the general ideology and philosophy held by Skepticism is ignored, discounted out of hand, ridiculed, or the ad hominem approach is taken.

If you had simply come to the board as asked to discussed this topic instead of leveling ridiculous accusations, then you might have been taken more seriously and have earned more respect.
 
(i.e. not believing in incredibly unlikely random creation of the universe, species and evolutionary improvement)

Are you more of a believer in the infinitely unlikely random creation of a supreme omnipotent being, and his permanent perfection?
 
hi Minarvia,

thanks for your contribution :)
I don't really know whether becoming less or more woo would be advantageous in life. My natural bent seems to be to endeavour and persist in wonderful wooness (i.e. not believing in incredibly unlikely random creation of the universe, species and evolutionary improvement) but I do genuinely welcome your friendship (y)
I'm not sure how becoming 'more woo' could be advantageous to anyone, if 'woo' means believing in things that have insufficient evidence to support them.

The 'woos' were the people who didn't accept the fact that the Wright Brothers had achieved flight, even though the evidence pointed to the fact that they did.

Every time you use a computer, microwave oven, automobile, or are vaccinated against a horrible disease, it is due to people that have relied on evidence-based science. How many 'woos' can you name in history that are not now merely considered fools?
 
hi Laedwig my old mucker (english for old friend) ;-) thanks for your attention, which I love in my own cuddly way, :-)
what i read from your feedback is "If one makes ridiculous mistakes in one's argument" thanks for that, at the moment i'm not sure what that is referring to, ta, Adly
 
I generally feel that people who accept the current materialistic/rationalistic/logical [...] paradigm tend to act in a slightly dishonest way, according to their society-induced prejudices ;)

Tell you what. Why don't you try to convince me that the materialistic/rationalistic/logical paradigm is in any way false. I also respectfully request that you convince me using methods of a non-materialistic, irrational nature. In other words, don't bother typing your response on your decidedly materialistic keyboard.

Am I being dishonest here?
 
well, from what i have learnt Nature Magazine (supposedly the most prestigious science publication on planet Earth) heavily ridiculed the Wright Brothers, even the local paper of the Wright Bros local town after hearing stories of the success of their first flights denied it and ridiculed them, because that was what the prevailing mental orthodoxy of the time dictated.
What closed-minded people they were soon proven to be. My point is that there is a temptation that is all to easy to succumb to which relegates anyone with any new idea or invention to ridicule, and similtaneously gives you, as a Skeptic, the pleasure of feeling yourself intellectualy superior to them

If you can show me a copy of Nature from the last 10 years that still holds the belief that heavier than air flight isn't possible, I'd say you have a point, can you show me that copy of Nature? If not, I'd say they changed their minds in light of the evidence, wouldn't you?
 
What does Nature have to do with Skepticism?

Being skeptical of the Wright brothers at the time based on existing evidence was a perfectly valid position, ridiculing them has nothing to do with skepticism, but was the personal choice of a science magazine.

It's not at all fair to say the style and stance of a few Nature magazine writers is synonomous with skepticism in general. It's not even a skeptic magazine.
 
hi wonderful thinking guys,
well, i could address my thoughts to a few of you, but it seems to me that the most persistent and important, is Mr Humphreys (hope for reasons of seriousness none of you were fans of the Grace Bros (UK TV comedy) ;-) and what I would say to Mr Humprhreys would be hmm.. have a cup of coffee.. and maybe after it try to realistically try to understand the unlikeliness of all the complexity of organic beings like me and you existing and conversing like this just cause of some strange happenchance in the universe ;)
 
plumjam: In my experience Skepticism takes great pains to appear to be purely scientific in that it claims to view evidence on both sides of an argument equally and without bias.
Yet this effort is disingenuous to say the least.


First problem. I don't believe or adhere to any sort of capital-letter Skepticism; I do think skepticism (small 's') is one of the most valuable tools have. But it is only one in our mental toolkit.

Judging from what I have read on here most Skeptics adhere to a quite narrow branch of philosophy that might be characterised as reductionist materialism.

I don't; nor do a number of others. What about those who don't fit your generalization?

Most reductionst materialists do not fully face the fact that if their philosophy were to be true then reality SHOULD be chaotic, devoid of organisation, devoid of life, devoid of intelligence, consciousness, meaning, purpose, emotion, music, humour, selflessness...etc...etc..

Why? Physical laws clearly dictate organization at many scales. There are a number of good theories as to how living matter can arise from nonliving matter (abiogenesis). Intelligence, emotion, etc. can be viewed as emergent properties of increasingly complex evolved organisms' neurological systems* and the interplay with environment and group membership. If you want to dispute such theories, fine, but to baldly claim such things "SHOULD" not happen is begging the question.

To put this in another way, what is either logical or rational about reality having even the most basic of physical laws?

The fact that the laws of physics exist is neither logical nor rational. On the contrary, using a principle which Skeptics often invoke - that of Occam's Razor, it would surely be more reasonable to expect the universe to be completely devoid of the laws of physics, and thus be completely chaotic.


No, not at all. This is simply handwaving. The "laws" of physics are not manmade; they are simply our observations of how the natural world happens to work. And, in fact, the natural world in many ways is chaotic; but various types of order naturally emerge from such chaotic processes.

A couple of you asked whether I have an axe to grind. Well, being a thinking, feeling human being like the rest of you, of course I have an axe to grind.

I like mumbling under my breath with a glassy stare while I grind my axe :D

An implication in my original post is that a lot of people on this forum have axes to grind, but prefer to deny the fact, or perhaps they just haven't yet realised that due to their educational upbringing they have been channelled into one particular school of philosophy among a whole range of possible options.

It seems like most people do. It's almost inevitable.

I would say that the axe I have to grind is that my basic position is that of my old mate Bill who used to pipe up with "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy."

That's what makes science so exciting.

One of the main reasons I think like this is an examination of the history of science and technology and the myriad instances when the Skeptical establishment has been proven spectacularly wrong (e.g. Marconi and the existence of electromagnetism, Maxwell and the existence of electricity, Galileo, the Wright Bros and the possibility of powered flight, science's belief in phlogiston and ether, etc etc.. )

Did you happen to note that it was scientists, using the scientific process, which eventually sorted out what was right and what was not in all those cases?

My point is that most of the people on this forum would (as did the establishment figures of those times) have heartily enjoyed ridiculing such notions, and condemning people like Maxwell, Marconi and the Wright Bros as what are pretty distastefully referred to here as "woos".

Straw man. While skeptics in general and scientists in particular are human beings, and thus prone like everyone else to jealousy, stubbornness, and being to wed to one's own pet ideas, skepticism is not the same as reflexive denial and science is open to any idea which can provide evidence and survive the tests which eventually weed out bunkum.

It's far from a perfect process, but consider the alternative - never, ever discarding a useless and unsound notion. Consider, say, homeopathy, which has survived two centuries without ever providing any evidence, or a plausible mechanism for how it might work, or contributing anything to our knowledge of biology or chemistry. But, despite the ridicule originally accorded to the notion that a bacterium might be the cause of many ulcers, science quickly accepted the claim once real evidence was provided. The simple fact is that science, which embodies a skeptical attitude, is in fact open to change where change is warranted.


*Yes, I know that "evolution" and "increasing complexity" are not one and the same.
 
Last edited:
What does Nature have to do with Skepticism?

Being skeptical of the Wright brothers at the time based on existing evidence was a perfectly valid position, ridiculing them has nothing to do with skepticism, but was the personal choice of a science magazine.

It's not at all fair to say the style and stance of a few Nature magazine writers is synonomous with skepticism in general. It's not even a skeptic magazine.

Being skeptical of the accomplishment and being skeptical of the science that supports it are two different things. I could find no mention of a Nature article from the 20th century making any claims against heavier than air flight or the wright brothers (their online archive only goes back to the 50's). Could you please cite your source for this?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom