when have you changed your mind on a matter?

I was going to follow up on a number of your comments, plumjam, but it's really not worth it. You're making too many errors of fact, too many self-contradictory claims, and too many claims which actually subvert your own ideas without you appearing to realize it, and clearly you are neither going to convince anyone here nor be convinced. So I'll just distill it down to this:

well there you go, precisely as I thought. You seem to have nothing positive to offer, but prefer to sit back with your citations and try to demolish other people. It all seems a bit unfriendly to me.

You perceive requests for evidence as attacks, rather than attempts to ensure accuracy. You perceive challenges to your claims as attacks and rather than attempting to improve and defend your claims, you complain about how close-minded those nasty ol' skeptics are.

But science and skepticism aren't about unconditional approval of new ideas (or old ones, for that matter). They're not about forgiving ignorance or coddling the self-esteem of those who blithely disregard the laws of Nature, and they are not about promoting arrogance, but rather about challenging our own understanding. No; it's those who are unwilling to critically examine their own claims that are arrogant, for they think that the universe is subordinate to their own wishes.
 
Just meandered through this entire ridiculous thread.

For a start. This is a forum dedicated to critical thinking. Its hardly a great surprise that you won't find many people who have started from a skeptical position and then ditched that viewpoint and started believing things based on anecdotal evidence or hearsay, in much the same way that if you went to a Manchester United forum and asked them how many people there used to support MU but now support...say....Luton Town, you wouldn't get many takers.

Secondly, being a skeptic - or critical thinker - is not to be confused with being a cynic. The difference between us and woo's is really very simple when it all boils down to it. You may say 'Sounds good! I'll believe' whereas a skeptic would say 'I'll believe it when I see it'. Simplification I know, but thats the crux of it. There is no church. No pope. No charasmatic leader everyone falls behind blindly. We do not fill in forms and claim our religion as skepticism.

Where it is publicised that a skeptic becomes a 'believer', such as the times where someone claims to see a ghost and says "I used to be skeptical of all this...." is merely showing a lack of critical thinking, as more mundane possibilities are suddenly being ignored before reaching the conclusion. If ghosts were real and someone could provide some form of solid evidence then we would all believe in them to a man. However, if that were to happen, it would be totally in keeping with the skeptical/critical thinking standpoint.

Which brings me to the whole daft Wright Brothers thing. So what if people didn't believe them until it was proven to them? That sounds perfectly reasonable to me. If I invented something brand new that had never been seen before, I would expect exactly the same reaction and this is one of the reasons I would be more than anxious to demonstrate whatever it was I had made. And thats the problem with Woo. It can't be demonstrated under controlled conditions because it doesn't exist, and despite huge financial reward from organisations like the JREF to prove an instance of the paranormal, no-one - in all the years JREF has been in existance - has even passed the preliminary stages. That should tell you all you need to know about the validity of such claims.

And THATS why people want evidence when claims are made around here.


Cheers

Reread your post for a minute.

first you argue for the importance of evidence and then you let it slip that you've already DECIDED that ghosts and woo don't and can't exist.
This is why I characterise the kind of Skepticism on this forum as an ideology.
 
I'm sorry, but there were a ton of examples in my previous post here

http://www.amasci.com/supress1.html
But I notice that it contains the same old rubbish about Galileo and the Wright Brothers.

Apart from that, a lot of it consists of quotations from one scientist disagreeing with another. This is not "supression".

And a quote from one of the Warner Brothers casting doubt on the commercial value of talkies? What the bleep does that have to do with "Skeptical Orthodoxy"?

I notice, by the way, that among the "supressors" was Adam Sedgewick:

"I laughed till. . . my sides were sore." -Adam Sedgwick, British geologist in a letter to Darwin in regards to his theory of evolution, 1857.

And one was Francis Morris:

"If the whole of the English language could be condensed into one word, it would not suffice to express the utter contempt those invite who are so deluded as to be disciples of such an imposture as Darwinism." -Francis Orpen Morris, British ornithologist 1877

Should no-one have criticised Darwin? I should be interested to hear your views.

I'm a skeptic, and so I think that his ideas should have been open to criticism just like those of every other scientist, though with more substance and less vitriol than in the latter quotation.
 
I can't go and ask Orville and Wilbur myself, so I'm forced to take other people's words for it, as are you, and everyone else.

You do realise that there's a spectrum of reliability here? There's a middle ground between actually being present at the event and believing anything you read on a random website. Hence Dr A's used a term which may come in handy, ' research'.

but the point is that even when the evidence is available scoffers often ignore it, discount it, ridicule it or suppress it.
I don't know if you really think you've shown this to be the case, but let me clarify - you haven't.

And my point is that this IS NOT EVIDENCE BASED as you seem to believe, but is based on a whole complex of other motives, as the articles I have linked to show

Well, at least you've realised that the articles you've linked to aren't evidenced based. Now all you need to do is come up with a reason why we should pay them any attention at all.
 
Cheers

Reread your post for a minute.

first you argue for the importance of evidence and then you let it slip that you've already DECIDED that ghosts and woo don't and can't exist.
This is why I characterise the kind of Skepticism on this forum as an ideology.

Erm....yes, because over the hundreds of years people have been banging on about woo and ghosts, not one single scrap of hard evidence has ever been produced. So taking a standpoint that it doesn't exist as a result is a relatively safe bet wouldn't you think?

And as I said, if such evidence presented itself then I would be more than happy to change my position on the subject.
 
So Plumjam, why aren't you showing us that you've been reading this post here? Why aren't you responding to it? Why are you ignoring the evidence? Why aren't you capable of changing your mind about who persecuted Galileo?
 
I was going to follow up on a number of your comments, plumjam, but it's really not worth it. You're making too many errors of fact, too many self-contradictory claims, and too many claims which actually subvert your own ideas without you appearing to realize it, and clearly you are neither going to convince anyone here nor be convinced. So I'll just distill it down to this:

well there you go, precisely as I thought. You seem to have nothing positive to offer, but prefer to sit back with your citations and try to demolish other people. It all seems a bit unfriendly to me.

You perceive requests for evidence as attacks, rather than attempts to ensure accuracy. You perceive challenges to your claims as attacks and rather than attempting to improve and defend your claims, you complain about how close-minded those nasty ol' skeptics are.

But science and skepticism aren't about unconditional approval of new ideas (or old ones, for that matter). They're not about forgiving ignorance or coddling the self-esteem of those who blithely disregard the laws of Nature, and they are not about promoting arrogance, but rather about challenging our own understanding. No; it's those who are unwilling to critically examine their own claims that are arrogant, for they think that the universe is subordinate to their own wishes.

I wrote that last night when people on here were refusing to discuss matters until I gave them citations etc
So today I have provided lots of links to show how good evidence has been systematically scorned, ignored, suppressed etc.. throughout the history of science and technology.
When I've provided all this the same people have described it as "b*****ks", and I've been called a liar, a bore, delusional etc etc..
still, on the tenth page of this thread not one person has had the honesty or bravery to admit that at some time in their life the evidence has prompted them to move away from the beliefs of current Skeptical Orthodoxy.
That is pretty telling to me, and is reinforcing my argument of Skepticism as a form of ideology :)
 
my other recent posts provide links showing how even after the evidence has been examined scientists and investigators have been shunned, censored, sometimes their careers ended.

shunned, censored etc by whom?
 
Plumjam, I'm not sure if you got the memo or not, but your websites are hardly objective, unbiased, or even factually correct in many instances. Some of their motives are highly suspect. If this is the best "evidence" you can provide, you are severely lacking.

My last post in this thread.
 
I wrote that last night when people on here were refusing to discuss matters until I gave them citations etc

Because you were just making things up.
So today I have provided lots of links to show how good evidence has been systematically scorned, ignored, suppressed etc.. throughout the history of science and technology.

You've linked to other websites that make stuff up.
When I've provided all this the same people have described it as "b*****ks",
Because it's all made up.

and I've been called a liar, a bore, delusional etc etc..

You have, this may have been unfair.

still, on the tenth page of this thread not one person has had the honesty or bravery to admit that at some time in their life the evidence has prompted them to move away from the beliefs of current Skeptical Orthodoxy.
That is pretty telling to me, and is reinforcing my argument of Skepticism as a form of ideology :)

Wait. . .

Here are the lies and delusions. Turns out it wasn't unfair at all.
 
I can't go and ask Orville and Wilbur myself, so I'm forced to take other people's words for it, as are you, and everyone else.
Well, if you take the view that it is impossible to know the actual history of the Wright Brothers, then was it not dishonest of you to claim that their history supports your views?

And why did you not mention our inability to know their true history when you thought that their history did support your views? Why are you only coming out with this after I've presented evidence proving that your sources are wrong?

Oh, yes, because you don't like where the evidence leads, so you don't want to follow it.

You're a poster-boy for the very traits you attribute to "Skeptical Orthodoxy".

but the point is that even when the evidence is available scoffers often ignore it, discount it, ridicule it or suppress it.
Whereas skeptics do not.

And my point is that this IS NOT EVIDENCE BASED as you seem to believe ...
But I do not claim that the actions of such people are "EVIDENCE BASED". As I point out, the people who go on scoffing at Galileo and Darwin are not basing their views on evidence, but on religious fanaticism and halfwitted lies.
 
Congratulations!

You're now an Official JREF Resident Troll (tm) (patent pending)!

T'ai Chi should be sending your membership card in the mail any day.

Cheers for that,

I'm a bit unsure about what you mean when you call me a troll.
I've been taking part in a discussion, and have been relatively polite, I reckon, given that people are calling me a liar, a bore, delusional etc..
I'm so boring that people keep coming back to reply to me :)
 
I'm sorry, but there were a ton of examples in my previous post here

http://www.amasci.com/supress1.html

Let's have a shufti.

Galileo - Already dealt with, 'twas the church
Lavoisier's meteorites - Many of Lavoisier's colleagues disagreed with him when he made his statements in 1772 and by 1794 - 1802 it was pretty universally agreed that they were extraterrestrial.source
Wright brothers - Already dealt with by several people
Turbine Ship Engine - Turbinia - the first ever steam turbine driven ship - spectacularly demonstrated the technology in action in 1897. The director of naval construction at the Admiralty, Sir William White, had kept a keen eye on the proceedings while Turbinia was being developed and visited the ship during a refit in 1897. Within a year the Royal Navy had placed an order for a turbine driven destroyer, HMS Viper, after which steam turbines transformed fleets all over the world. Once people saw the evidence, they all wanted them.
Mechanical Naval Gunnery Control - The Royal Navy saw the advantages of this and actually sponsored two groups of research. Most Navy ships were so equipped by 1916.

....etc etc I shouldn't be at all surprised to learn. However: The key thing is that it doesn't matter what people said before these things were demonstrated, because once they were demonstrated they were seized upon and very widely disseminated. The reaction is so far removed from your claim that "even after the evidence has been examined scientists and investigators have been shunned, censored, sometimes their careers ended.", it is frankly baffling why you would think it is true.
 
I wrote that last night when people on here were refusing to discuss matters until I gave them citations etc
So today I have provided lots of links to show how good evidence has been systematically scorned, ignored, suppressed etc.. throughout the history of science and technology.
When I've provided all this the same people have described it as "b*****ks", and I've been called a liar, a bore, delusional etc etc..
still, on the tenth page of this thread not one person has had the honesty or bravery to admit that at some time in their life the evidence has prompted them to move away from the beliefs of current Skeptical Orthodoxy.
That is pretty telling to me, and is reinforcing my argument of Skepticism as a form of ideology :)


People who ignore and/or suppress evidence are operating in a manner contrary to how skeptics try to live their lives, and they, rightfully, receive our contempt.

Examples of people doing that are only examples of the fact that people exist who are capable of doing that. They're NOT skeptics.

Why would people acting in a manner contrary to skepticism turn people away from skepticism or provide evidence against its worth? I don't understand your argument at all.

That you find suppression of evidence as a negative is encouraging, though.
 
Last edited:
Well, if you take the view that it is impossible to know the actual history of the Wright Brothers, then was it not dishonest of you to claim that their history supports your views?

And why did you not mention our inability to know their true history when you thought that their history did support your views? Why are you only coming out with this after I've presented evidence proving that your sources are wrong?

Oh, yes, because you don't like where the evidence leads, so you don't want to follow it.

You're a poster-boy for the very traits you attribute to "Skeptical Orthodoxy".

Whereas skeptics do not.



But I do not claim that the actions of such people are "EVIDENCE BASED". As I point out, the people who go on scoffing at Galileo and Darwin are not basing their views on evidence, but on religious fanaticism and halfwitted lies.

the sources I quoted said one thing, the sources you quoted said another thing.. who's to know which is right? which is why I have pointed you to dozens of similar examples through history
 
still, on the tenth page of this thread not one person has had the honesty or bravery to admit that at some time in their life the evidence has prompted them to move away from the beliefs of current Skeptical Orthodoxy.

There is no such thing as "skeptical orthodoxy". But I will be happy to change my mind about anything that is bolstered by good evidence.

That is pretty telling to me, and is reinforcing my argument of Skepticism as a form of ideology

Well, I know which ideology you follow. Good luck with that. Bye.
 
I wrote that last night when people on here were refusing to discuss matters until I gave them citations etc
So today I have provided lots of links to show how good evidence has been systematically scorned, ignored, suppressed etc.. throughout the history of science and technology.
When I've provided all this the same people have described it as "b*****ks" ...
And, what's more, we provided evidence to show that those links were bollocks.

still, on the tenth page of this thread not one person has had the honesty or bravery to admit that at some time in their life the evidence has prompted them to move away from the beliefs of current Skeptical Orthodoxy.
The evidence has never prompted me to abandon the idea that my ideas should be determined by the evidence. Hence, it would neither be "honest" nor "brave" of me to "admit" that this has happened, it would be a lie.
 
And, what's more, we provided evidence to show that those links were bollocks.

The evidence has never prompted me to abandon the idea that my ideas should be determined by the evidence. Hence, it would neither be "honest" nor "brave" of me to "admit" that this has happened, it would be a lie.

Well I agree with you that ideas should be determined by the evidence, obviously I have never argued against that. My point all along is that due to ideological considerations many Skeptics hold regarding the nature of reality they pick and choose their evidence while pretending not to.
History bears this out.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom