when have you changed your mind on a matter?

Eventually, they did change their minds... so, your "point" is meaningless.

Now, let's get the question answered: why should I change my mind?

my point is that even when good evidence exists to support a hypothesis, if that hypothesis goes against the grain of the current accepted paradigm then history shows us clearly that such evidence is very often ignored, ridiculed or traduced. Not only this, but scientists who present such evidence are often censored or their careers are ruined.

this whole process retards the whole advancement of knowledge
 
my point is that even when good evidence exists to support a hypothesis, if that hypothesis goes against the grain of the current accepted paradigm then history shows us clearly that such evidence is very often ignored, ridiculed or traduced. Not only this, but scientists who present such evidence are often censored or their careers are ruined.

this whole process retards the whole advancement of knowledge

And the fact that people, including skeptics and scientsists changes their minds when evidence is presented nullifies your so called "point".

And the process does not "retards the whole advancement of knowledge", or haven't you noticed the advances humanity had done the last few decades? The last few centuries?
 
That's an answer to shy I should be capable of changing my mind in general. Why should I change my mind about something specific? Pick any subject, and tell me why I should change my mind about it.

Or, are you saying I should just randomly change my mind about things just to be contrary? After all, that does seem to be your strategy.

I'm sorry, but you're asking a bit of a nonsensical question here. How can I answer that without knowing you and all of your current beliefs about everything?
my original question was whether anyone on here had ever changed their minds in a direction away from current Skeptical Orthodoxy. I still don't have any takers.
It's starting to get spooky :eek:
 
my point is that even when good evidence exists to support a hypothesis, if that hypothesis goes against the grain of the current accepted paradigm then history shows us clearly that such evidence is very often ignored, ridiculed or traduced. Not only this, but scientists who present such evidence are often censored or their careers are ruined.

this whole process retards the whole advancement of knowledge

The problem is, plumjam, we're going to ask for good examples, and then we're going to ask for evidence that these examples are accurate (citations, etc), and then you're going to complain that we can't just have a conversation.

If conversation void of citations and evidence is all you want, then my response to you is:

Nope, you're wrong.
 
I'm sorry, but you're asking a bit of a nonsensical question here. How can I answer that without knowing you and all of your current beliefs about everything?
my original question was whether anyone on here had ever changed their minds in a direction away from current Skeptical Orthodoxy. I still don't have any takers.
It's starting to get spooky :eek:

1) there is no such thing as "Skeptical Orthodoxy", that is a strawman
2) The reason perhaps why people here has not changed their minds in the by you accepted direction just may due to a total lack of empirical evidence for such nonsense.
 
And the fact that people, including skeptics and scientsists changes their minds when evidence is presented nullifies your so called "point".

And the process does not "retards the whole advancement of knowledge", or haven't you noticed the advances humanity had done the last few decades? The last few centuries?

how do you know that, without this kind of clinging to a philosopy, we might not now be a century or two more advanced than we are now?
 
my original question was whether anyone on here had ever changed their minds in a direction away from current Skeptical Orthodoxy. I still don't have any takers.
It's starting to get spooky :eek:

You just ignore the responses.

You've been told myriad times that there is no such thing as "Skeptical Orthodoxy", and you have been given examples of many times skeptical people have changed their minds.
 
The problem is, plumjam, we're going to ask for good examples, and then we're going to ask for evidence that these examples are accurate (citations, etc), and then you're going to complain that we can't just have a conversation.

If conversation void of citations and evidence is all you want, then my response to you is:

Nope, you're wrong.

Ok then, a few examples for you

links at bottom of the page

http://www.suppressedscience.net/
 
how do you know that, without this kind of clinging to a philosopy, we might not now be a century or two more advanced than we are now?

More important then, since you claimed retardation of advancement, how do you know that insisting on empirical testing on claims retards development. After all, you made the claim you back it up.

Oh yeah, in case you have forgotten: repeating your claim is not evidence for your claim.

My point in this case is that despite this humongous orthodoxy and denial amongst scientists and skeptics we have made wonderful advancements in medicine, telecommunications, computers, space tech, nano materials, material technology, agriculture and so on.

Seems hard to have such a huge success if scientist and skeptics keeps holding true discoveries back irregardless of evidence, no?
 
how do you know that, without this kind of clinging to a philosopy, we might not now be a century or two more advanced than we are now?

Or, more likely, a century or two spent going nowhere chasing an impossible dream, like telepathy.

What should we be doing? Trying to create a telepathy powered car before we prove telepathy exists?
 
my point is that even when good evidence exists to support a hypothesis, if that hypothesis goes against the grain of the current accepted paradigm then history shows us clearly that such evidence is very often ignored, ridiculed or traduced. Not only this, but scientists who present such evidence are often censored or their careers are ruined.

this whole process retards the whole advancement of knowledge
Two more points, and a question:

1) The denial is always temporary: science self-adjusts

2) Most new ideas are wrong. This is a fact.

Question: once that new idea that goes against the grain is accepted, it becomes the orthodoxy... do you then automatically reject it?
 
Or, more likely, a century or two spent going nowhere chasing an impossible dream, like telepathy.

What should we be doing? Trying to create a telepathy powered car before we prove telepathy exists?

Nonono... It will obviously be powered by homoeopathic petrol, but controlled with ESP.
 
how do you know that, without this kind of clinging to a philosopy, we might not now be a century or two more advanced than we are now?

Wrong. If we did things your way, we'd still be in the Dark Ages.
 
my point is that even when good evidence exists to support a hypothesis, if that hypothesis goes against the grain of the current accepted paradigm then history shows us clearly that such evidence is very often ignored, ridiculed or traduced. Not only this, but scientists who present such evidence are often censored or their careers are ruined.
Yes, we know what your point is.

What we would like to see is some evidence for it.

The nearest you've got to an example is Galileo --- except that he was "ridiculed and traduced" by a religious orthodoxy.
 
What can explain how everyone changed their minds so rapidly, except a lack of any deep attachment to orthodoxy?

Assuming, of course, that this article is not also total bollocks.

Dr A, interesting that all last night your main argument was that I should provide information to back up what I'm saying. And now that I have done so on several occasions your counter-argument is to use the word "b*****ks"

I really thought better of you
 
Dr A will get a chance when you pick one specific example from that site you just linked to.

We all will. Pick the best one, and let's discuss it.
 
Dr A, interesting that all last night your main argument was that I should provide information to back up what I'm saying. And now that I have done so on several occasions your counter-argument is to use the word "b*****ks"

I really thought better of you

Strong words from someone who amongst other things keeps lying about his OP not being answered.

Why do you keep lying about your OP not being answered? What "positive contribution" do you think that makes?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom