when have you changed your mind on a matter?

interesting website here, which bears out some of what I've been saying

http://www.alternativescience.com/
The specific stuff quoted about the Wright Brothers, in particular, is rubbish.

The Ordnance Office wrote to them in October 1905, asking if they could see the machine in operation.

The Ordnance Office wrote to them again in May 1907. Serious negotiations about the cost and specification of the machine began in the autumn of that year.

(See here for more details.)

Whereas your article claims that "It was not until President Theodore Roosevelt ordered public trials at Fort Myers in 1908 that the Wrights were able to prove conclusively their claim and the Army and scientific press were compelled to accept that their flying machine was a reality."

The Army bought an airplane off the Wright Brothers before the flights at Fort Myers.
 
Last edited:
Well, the point from the quote is that those in authority didn't want to see the evidence, they even dismissed photographs.

What can possibly explain this, apart from a deep attachment to orthodoxy?

This is highly misleading. There may well have been individuals who thought powered flight was impossible. There may have been individuals who thought the flight was a hoax. These may or may not have been the same people in the US war department who were unenthusiastic about investing in flying machines. And let's face it why wouldn't they be? You'd need a good deal of foresight to sit in 1905 and predict how rapidly aircraft design would develop.

But from that you're conflating a position where everyone in authority dismissed heavier-than-air flight as a plain-and-simple hoax. Which is simply not the case. At all.

And even if it was the case, within a very short time the evidence was examined and everyone was satisfied that the Wright Brothers weren't nutcases. And I strongly suspect that if we looked at the other claims on that site we'd find that it doesn't quite support the assertion that it shows that skeptics are one solid block of closed-mindedness.

Well, straight away we find one on Bell being told that his telephone is unnecessary because there is no shortage of Bellboys in London. Unnecessary? So Sir William Preece didn't actually think that the device wouldn't work did he? He just didn't see the point of it. He even acknowledged that it would be a useful device for Americans although the article doesn't appear to think that part of the quotation is useful.

The incandescent light-bulb again was rejected by Preece again on the grounds of usefulness at a time when much of London had perfectly adequate and extensive gas lighting. As a fellow of the Royal Society who had worked with Faraday he was fully aware that these things were possible and that they did not invalidate any of the relevant physical laws.

In fact far from being the closed-minded old fuddy-duddy as he's portrayed in that article, Preece helped Marconi with his experiments on radio waves, which a fair few other people at the time really did doubt would work.

I could go on but I'm probably wasting my time aren't I?

Edit: Hell's teeth, this thread is moving fast.
 
Dr A, interesting that all last night your main argument was that I should provide information to back up what I'm saying. And now that I have done so on several occasions your counter-argument is to use the word "b*****ks"
But what you've produced is misinformation, which is not what I asked for.

You've already provided me with lots of misinformation.

What I want is actual information. Stuff which hasn't been made up.
 
Strong words from someone who amongst other things keeps lying about his OP not being answered.

Why do you keep lying about your OP not being answered? What "positive contribution" do you think that makes?

my OP hasn't really been answered because no-one, as yet, has written a post detailing how they changed their mind in a direction going against the current Skpetical Orthodoxy.

Maybe if I missed one you can direct me to it
 
my OP hasn't really been answered because no-one, as yet, has written a post detailing how they changed their mind in a direction going against the current Skpetical Orthodoxy.

Maybe if I missed one you can direct me to it


As has been repeated many times, there is no "skeptical orthodoxy".
 
my OP hasn't really been answered because no-one, as yet, has written a post detailing how they changed their mind in a direction going against the current Skpetical Orthodoxy.

Maybe if I missed one you can direct me to it

1: That wasn't the question in the OP. All the OP asked was if we had changed our minds on a matter because we discovered new evidence. And several people told you about such times. Adding the "against the current skeptical orthodoxy" was something you added afterwards.

2: It's already been explained to you several times that changing your mind based on good evidence is what skepticism is about. Therefore, the only way to abandond "skeptical orthodoxy" (a rather meaningless term, since "orthodoxy" is about keeping the system the same, and skepticism by definition allows for change) is to stop changing your mind based on the evidence, but instead change it on just about anything, such as someone making a claim.

You may not like these answers, but they are answers, and I suggest you start responding to them instead of just keeping on lying.

Also, when have you ever changed your mind based on actual evidence? Will you ever plan to look at the actual evidence for evolution, for instance? Will you read a biology book? Or will you keep on just saying "evolution is a belief" over and over, refusing to even look at any fact that contradicts this
 

Almost.

"Not in Archive.

The page you requested has not been archived. If the page is still available on the Internet, we will begin archiving it during our next crawl. Try another request or click here to search for all pages on uow.edu.au/arts/sts/bmartin/dissent/documents/Martin_99air/index.htm
See the FAQs for more info and help, or contact us."

Try again?
 
Plumjam, let's stick to the idea of picking ONE. The best one, and we'll discuss it. You did that, but the link went nowhere, now you're posting more without giving anyone the chance to discuss the first one.

Don't do this, it makes it impossible to get to the bottom of the accuracy of any of them.

Choose ONE, please, and let's discuss it, okay?
 
my OP hasn't really been answered because no-one, as yet, has written a post detailing how they changed their mind in a direction going against the current Skpetical Orthodoxy.

Maybe if I missed one you can direct me to it

If you keep stating that there is a skeptical orthodoxy despite being told there is no such thing, I WILL put you on ignore, and we'll have gotten nowhere.

If you really want an honest debate, don't say that again.
 
examples of some scientists formerly ridiculed by the Skeptical establishment, but then proven to be right:

http://amasci.com/weird/vindac.html
And you notice how every single one of their claims came to be accepted by skeptics despite their supposed "orthodoxy"?

And you know why? Because, when put to the test, they could provide evidence for their views.

Whereas people who are wrong cannot.

This is how science works.
 
examples of some scientists formerly ridiculed by the Skeptical establishment, but then proven to be right:

http://amasci.com/weird/vindac.html

Another example of people who tries comparing themselves to the great discoverers of the world in order to excuse themselves from having to provide evidence for their works.

Oh, and look, they bring out Galileo too. Remember who he was actually ridiculed by? Was it the scientific establishment, or was it a religious establishment? Think good and hard before you answer this now.

Yeah, so this paper claims he was ridiculed by fellow scientists... But where is their evidence for this claim? Where is their citation? Sorry, but you're just linking to a webpage full of claims, but with little to no actual evidence.

I've offered you already to learn about presenting proper evidence, because it's obvious you need it. So, are you going to take up this offer, or will you continue to come up with unsubstantiated claims forever, making a fool of yourself and resorting to lies and insults in the process?
 
I only needed to scan that to know it is nothing like what I asked for.

That is not a specific case at all, is it? Did you even read it?
 
And you notice how every single one of their claims came to be accepted by skeptics despite their supposed "orthodoxy"?

And you know why? Because, when put to the test, they could provide evidence for their views.

Whereas people who are wrong cannot.

This is how science works.

the point is that the previous (wrong) theory is supported often for decades even when new evidence points against it
most people on here seem to have what I believe is a very naive view of how science actually works in the real world. they seem to believe that all new evidence is viewed impartially, and new evidence that is shown to be correct will be instantly accepted.
history shows that science hasn't worked anything like this, due to the phenomenon of attachment to current paradigms
 
Another example of people who tries comparing themselves to the great discoverers of the world in order to excuse themselves from having to provide evidence for their works.

Oh, and look, they bring out Galileo too. Remember who he was actually ridiculed by? Was it the scientific establishment, or was it a religious establishment? Think good and hard before you answer this now.

Perhaps something for Plumjam to consider when dredging up the old Galileo chestnut:

"The fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown." - Carl Sagan

=)
 
I only needed to scan that to know it is nothing like what I asked for.

That is not a specific case at all, is it? Did you even read it?

yep, I read it. it describes how suppression of evidence works in science. to that extent it is a specific case.

i'm not quite sure why you're so set on arguing with me about one particular example. my "particular case" is that of the way science works in the real world, as opposed to the way most Skeptics here seem to idealise its function. So my case covers the whole of science.
 
the point is that the previous (wrong) theory is supported often for decades even when new evidence points against it
most people on here seem to have what I believe is a very naive view of how science actually works in the real world. they seem to believe that all new evidence is viewed impartially, and new evidence that is shown to be correct will be instantly accepted.
history shows that science hasn't worked anything like this, due to the phenomenon of attachment to current paradigms

A few comments on this. I don't agree with you, but let's put that aside for the moment.

Science is a method, and individuals are scientists. They are people like you and me, and they are not perfect. They have their biases, and their flaws.

What does this have to do with skepticism?

Is not the final destination what's important? Even the most extreme skeptics only forced the claimants to provide better and better evidence, if anything, propelling research forward. Nothing was held back, or retarded, and when sufficient evidence was provided, a new set of more correct beliefs became mainstream.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom