when have you changed your mind on a matter?

Wow I go away for a day and when I come back the thread's already grown to 7 pages (now I've got to try and catch up on it all)
 
interesting website here, which bears out some of what I've been saying

http://www.alternativescience.com/

a point I've been driving at is that judging from this forum Skeptics like to portray themselves as balanced, open-minded, and purely evidence-driven. But the kind of instances detailed on the website show how science often doesn't live up to this ideal; the reason for this failure being an attachment to a particular philosophical viewpoint.
To that extent it's my point that a strict adherence to the Skeptic Ideology very often actually acts as positive hindrance to the advancement of knowledge.
That was why I originally asked whether anyone on here had changed their mind on anything (i.e. away from the current materialistic scientific orthodoxy )
Still, after 7 pages of replies, no-one has been able to do this.

Pretty strange don't you think? - to get such uniformity of thought among so many people. Kim Jong-Il would love it ;-)
 
Please return this thread to the topic under discussion, and stop the personalising of the debate. Any personal comments made about members from here on will be moved to AAH.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero
 
He's already answered that.



He came here to tell us how we're wrong.

Meh...

what the hell is a "central contradiction in the whole skeptical approach"? What the hell is a "central contradiction"? Are there tangential contradictions and peripheral contradictions? And what is the "skeptical approach"? I think of it more of a method than an "approach"-- but then I don't really speak woo.
 
I was going to have sausages last night, but I changed my mind and had chicken instead. Does that count?
 
what the hell is a "central contradiction in the whole skeptical approach"? What the hell is a "central contradiction"? Are there tangential contradictions and peripheral contradictions? And what is the "skeptical approach"? I think of it more of a method than an "approach"-- but then I don't really speak woo.

this is pretty poor stuff.. now you are reduced to trying to find fault with phraseology?

"central contradiction" is an entirely valid use of words, just as would be "central argument" "central thesis" "central contention" etc etc..
maybe you should report me to the OED ;)
 
Here's the important question:

Why should I change my mind?

Let's see if the guy who started this whole mess can answer that one.
 
interesting website here, which bears out some of what I've been saying

http://www.alternativescience.com/
Well, it might if it didn't contain such a lot of complete bollocks.

As it is, it bears out my suspicion that you'll believe any damn thing you read so long as it's wrong.

That was why I originally asked whether anyone on here had changed their mind on anything (i.e. away from the current materialistic scientific orthodoxy )
Yes. I've changed my mind about scientific questions. But as I change my mind based on evidence, and scientists do the same thing, every time I change my mind, so do scientists, so the "scientific orthodoxy" changes too.

"Scientific orthodoxy" = "what the available evidence actually supports".

It's a funny sort of "orthodoxy", really, in that it's all potentially subject to revision in the light of new knowledge.

Pretty strange don't you think? - to get such uniformity of thought among so many people.
Not at all. You'll find even greater uniformity of thought on the proposition that 2 + 2 = 4.

Perhaps you even believe it yourself.
 
Last edited:
interesting website here, which bears out some of what I've been saying

http://www.alternativescience.com/

alternative science said:
For five years, from December 1903 to September 1908, two young bicycle mechanics from Ohio repeatedly claimed to have built a heavier than air flying machine and to have flown it successfully. But despite scores of public demonstrations, affidavits from local dignitaries, and photographs of themselves flying, the claims of Wilbur and Orville Wright were derided and dismissed as a hoax by Scientific American, the New York Herald, the US Army and most American scientists. Experts were so convinced, on purely scientific grounds, that heavier than air flight was impossible that they rejected the Wright brothers' claims without troubling to examine the evidence. It was not until President Theodore Roosevelt ordered public trials at Fort Myers in 1908 that the Wrights were able to prove conclusively their claim and the Army and scientific press were compelled to accept that their flying machine was a reality.
Five years from "Impossible" to government trials. That's not bad going for a bunch of impossible-to-convince skeptics.

Also, note the part that I have emphasised: I'm skeptical of the claim that it was so widely thought to be a hoax in the way the article implies. By 1903 heavier-than-air gliders were common. There was a race across America and Europe to make the first powered aircraft, which was highly publicised and followed avidly. During the development of their experiments the Wright Brothers corresponded with other engineers and scientists, sharing (sometimes inadvertently!) ideas and notes. Wilbur gave a lecture on their progress to the Western Society of Engineers in Chicago. They were not working in a vacuum, and there was nothing inherently ridiculous - or ridiculed - about what they were trying to do.

So why cry "Hoax!"? The state of the art of engines at the time meant that it was very difficult to produce one with an adequate power/weight ratio. There were problems with understanding and developing airfoil designs. Given the efforts being made unsuccessfully around the world, is it really so surprising that it was thought unlikely that two bicycle engineers could get a solution first? But almost nobody at that time thought that powered heavier-than-air flight was impossible per se. And anyone who did think it was impossible was wrong - and when they were shown the evidence they changed their minds.

And isn't that what it's all about?

Edit: I could probably have saved myself some typing by taking a leaf out of Dr. Adequate's book:

Well, it might if it didn't contain such a lot of complete bollocks.

:D
 
Last edited:
Well, it might if it didn't contain such a lot of complete bollocks.

As it is, it bears out my suspicion that you'll believe any damn thing you read so long as it's wrong.

Yes. I've often changed my mind about scientific questions. But as I change my mind based on evidence, and scientists do the same thing, every time I change my mind, so do scientists, so the "scientific orthodoxy" changes too.

"Scientific orthodoxy" = "what the available evidence actually supports".

Not at all. You'll find even greater uniformity of thought on the proposition that 2 + 2 = 4.

Perhaps you even believe it yourself.
Yeah, usually people agree when the facts are obvious and evident. That isn't a flaw or a fault. Being gullible IS a flaw, however... and you have to be gullible to believe some of the nonsense from the woo camp.

More importantly, blaming "orthodoxy" for rejecting an idea due to a lack of evidence doesn't make that lack of evidence any less damning, does it?
 
Five years from "Impossible" to government trials. That's not bad going for a bunch of impossible-to-convince skeptics.

Also, note the part that I have emphasised: I'm skeptical of the claim that it was so widely thought to be a hoax in the way the article implies. By 1903 heavier-than-air gliders were common. There was a race across America and Europe to make the first powered aircraft, which was highly publicised and followed avidly. During the development of their experiments the Wright Brothers corresponded with other engineers and scientists, sharing (sometimes inadvertently!) ideas and notes. Wilbur gave a lecture on their progress to the Western Society of Engineers in Chicago. They were not working in a vacuum, and there was nothing inherently ridiculous - or ridiculed - about what they were trying to do.

So why cry "Hoax!"? The state of the art of engines at the time meant that it was very difficult to produce one with an adequate power/weight ratio. There were problems with understanding and developing airfoil designs. Given the efforts being made unsuccessfully around the world, is it really so surprising that it was thought unlikely that two bicycle engineers could get a solution first? But almost nobody at that time thought that powered heavier-than-air flight was impossible per se. And anyone who did think it was impossible was wrong - and when they were shown the evidence they changed their minds.

And isn't that what it's all about?

Edit: I could probably have saved myself some typing by taking a leaf out of Dr. Adequate's book:



:D

Well, the point from the quote is that those in authority didn't want to see the evidence, they even dismissed photographs.

What can possibly explain this, apart from a deep attachment to orthodoxy?
 
Well, the point from the quote is that those in authority didn't want to see the evidence, they even dismissed photographs.

What can possibly explain this, apart from a deep attachment to orthodoxy?
Eventually, they did change their minds... so, your "point" is meaningless.

Now, let's get the question answered: why should I change my mind?
 
dunno, mabye because you're (hopefully) a conscious, thinking being?

That's an answer to shy I should be capable of changing my mind in general. Why should I change my mind about something specific? Pick any subject, and tell me why I should change my mind about it.

Or, are you saying I should just randomly change my mind about things just to be contrary? After all, that does seem to be your strategy.
 
Well, the point from the quote is that those in authority didn't want to see the evidence, they even dismissed photographs.

What can possibly explain this, apart from a deep attachment to orthodoxy?
What can explain how everyone changed their minds so rapidly, except a lack of any deep attachment to orthodoxy?

Assuming, of course, that this article is not also total bollocks.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom