when have you changed your mind on a matter?

Or, of course, a crank whining about how the difficulty of getting pseudoscience published in scientific journals.

To find out which, you would have to examine the claims made in that article skeptically, in order to find out whether any of them were actually true.

I can tell you one thing --- it contains a bunch of outright lies or idiotic mistakes about the views of "orthodox" scientists. This does not instill confidence.
 
yep, I read it. it describes how suppression of evidence works in science. to that extent it is a specific case.

i'm not quite sure why you're so set on arguing with me about one particular example. my "particular case" is that of the way science works in the real world, as opposed to the way most Skeptics here seem to idealise its function. So my case covers the whole of science.

I wanted to study one specific case because I believe you'd begin to see there is far more than meets the eye to these cases, and that perhaps there was very good reason for certain new theories to be rejected based on the evidence available at the time.

I also wanted to show you that just maybe you're not getting a clear picture from the few websites you're viewing written by people with a major axe to grind against science and skepticism in general. People like you.

On top of that, see my last post.
 
The sceptics posting on this board are just as prone to be influenced by social norms and bias as anyone else.

For example, given that this is an American site I bet (in fact I know) there are sceptics who believe infant circumcision doesn't particularly hurt and has significant advantages for most males. However, if this were a Swedish or Japanese site the predominant view of infant circumcision would be negative.

There are sceptics who post here that believe in God, the efficacy of homeopathy and who knows what else.

Just because someone declares them self to be sceptical and looks at evidence does not mean that they weigh evidence appropriately.

So as Katana has said, I don't think there is any such thing as a "sceptical othodoxy".
 
For example, let's just say that, against all odds and logic, somehow, telepathy is proved beyond a doubt in 100 years time.

I'd wager people like Plumjam will be complaining about the ridiculous skeptics refusing to believe it 100 years ago.

The thing is, even if it is proved later on, we're right to reject it now. There just isn't good enough evidence. A lot of these previous cases are very similar.
 
hurrah ! finally someone supporting me, I knew it had to happen eventually ;)

cheers my friend

Not really. He outright rejects the existence of a skeptical orthodoxy, which destroys your whole argument right from the start.
 
More rubbish about the Wright Brothers and Galileo?

Apparently what you mean by "interesting" is "conforming to plumjam's preconceptions".

Have you not read any of the posts on this thread? Particularly the ones about, for example, the Wright Brothers and Galileo?

It is sad when people refuse to accept evidence presented to them, prefering instead to rely on faulty recollections and anecdotes that conform to their own preconceptions.

It's the kind of thing that can hold society back for centuries, you know.
 
Not really. He outright rejects the existence of a skeptical orthodoxy, which destroys your whole argument right from the start.

of course any orthodoxy is quite a loose term, but it does exist in science, skepticism, religions, politics.. and any other system of beliefs
to say otherwise is pretty absurd
 
If there is any such orthodoxy, is it to beliefs that have supporting empirical evidence instead of anecdotes.
 
of course any orthodoxy is quite a loose term, but it does exist in science, skepticism, religions, politics.. and any other system of beliefs
to say otherwise is pretty absurd
The orthodoxy of science and skepticism both is "thou shalt follow whithersoever the evidence leads".

If anyone is not doing that, then as Arch-MegaPope of the Skeptical Orthodoxy, I shall cast them into the outer darkness, where there is wailing and gnashing of teeth.

But failing to follow the evidence would seem to be your besetting sin. Out, out, ye demons of non-skepticism!
 
Last edited:
If there is any such orthodoxy, is it to beliefs that have supporting empirical evidence instead of anecdotes.

interesting question :)

it seems to me that any orthodoxy is a mixture of beliefs some of which will be supported by evidence, others that won't and others that are somewhere in between. that includes Skepticism too.

interesting that you mention anecdotes. 99% of our lives are purely anecdotal, and in fact, if you think about it, any spoken or written report made by a scientist is purely anecdotal unless you were there with him at the time of the event he's reporting. Even then your experience of the event will be at least slightly different to his experience of it. So that's anecdotal too.

Does falling in love exist? By the definition used by most Skeptics we can't be very sure, because any "evidence" for it will by necessity be purely anecdotal.
 
this is pretty poor stuff.. now you are reduced to trying to find fault with phraseology?

"central contradiction" is an entirely valid use of words, just as would be "central argument" "central thesis" "central contention" etc etc..
maybe you should report me to the OED ;)

Report you? I can't even understand you! Can anyone translate what he means when he came here because of a "central contradiction in the skeptical approach"? Does this parse for anyone else? I know what the words mean...but I don't know what the hell he's trying to say.
 
I gave up on page 2 after I realized he isn't here for a real conversation.
 
Just meandered through this entire ridiculous thread.

For a start. This is a forum dedicated to critical thinking. Its hardly a great surprise that you won't find many people who have started from a skeptical position and then ditched that viewpoint and started believing things based on anecdotal evidence or hearsay, in much the same way that if you went to a Manchester United forum and asked them how many people there used to support MU but now support...say....Luton Town, you wouldn't get many takers.

Secondly, being a skeptic - or critical thinker - is not to be confused with being a cynic. The difference between us and woo's is really very simple when it all boils down to it. You may say 'Sounds good! I'll believe' whereas a skeptic would say 'I'll believe it when I see it'. Simplification I know, but thats the crux of it. There is no church. No pope. No charasmatic leader everyone falls behind blindly. We do not fill in forms and claim our religion as skepticism.

Where it is publicised that a skeptic becomes a 'believer', such as the times where someone claims to see a ghost and says "I used to be skeptical of all this...." is merely showing a lack of critical thinking, as more mundane possibilities are suddenly being ignored before reaching the conclusion. If ghosts were real and someone could provide some form of solid evidence then we would all believe in them to a man. However, if that were to happen, it would be totally in keeping with the skeptical/critical thinking standpoint.

Which brings me to the whole daft Wright Brothers thing. So what if people didn't believe them until it was proven to them? That sounds perfectly reasonable to me. If I invented something brand new that had never been seen before, I would expect exactly the same reaction and this is one of the reasons I would be more than anxious to demonstrate whatever it was I had made. And thats the problem with Woo. It can't be demonstrated under controlled conditions because it doesn't exist, and despite huge financial reward from organisations like the JREF to prove an instance of the paranormal, no-one - in all the years JREF has been in existance - has even passed the preliminary stages. That should tell you all you need to know about the validity of such claims.

And THATS why people want evidence when claims are made around here.
 
interesting website here, which bears out some of what I've been saying

http://www.alternativescience.com/

Oooh - a link!

Interestingly from that link:
Experts were so convinced, on purely scientific grounds, that heavier than air flight was impossible that they rejected the Wright brothers' claims without troubling to examine the evidence

My bold! And what happened when they DID examine the evidence? Why do you think I has been stressed on here ad nausiam that the sceptic position is based on the examination of the evidence?

ETA - nadgers, beaten to it
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom