when have you changed your mind on a matter?

I think you might want to use that sentence to examine yourself, sweetie.
What inspired you to post on a skeptic's forum?

It does make one wonder. He started 3 provocative threads, kept hurling vases, then ran away when we did not offer cyberhugs, hot coco and a foot massage.
 
What inspired you to post on a skeptic's forum?

He's already answered that.

I came to JREF out of curiosity, and because in my life I see a central contradiction in the whole Skeptical approach... which now I'm not going to offer, cos I obviously have no citations to back it up

He came here to tell us how we're wrong.

Meh...
 
There's no way to make people who really don't care about evidence care.
I think you're either wired to "get it" or you're not.

I think plumjam was expecting the non-critical-thinking style of conversation that goes on in psychic/paranormal/fantasy/horror/conspiracy forums; where rumor is fact, anecdotes are taken as truth, and "science doesn't know everything" trumps all.
 
I think plumjam was expecting the non-critical-thinking style of conversation that goes on in psychic/paranormal/fantasy/horror/conspiracy forums; where rumor is fact, anecdotes are taken as truth, and "science doesn't know everything" trumps all.

Right. And this forum probably would seem like a big, boring downer to someone who was into that. That's ok. People are different.

That's why "we" have our forums, and "they" have theirs. We tend to think endless speculations without any kind of factual basis is unbelieveably pointless and a truly massive waste of time.

They dig that kind of thing.

What's kind of funny is...I've seen this same kind of thread on believer forums when a skeptic shows up and tries to show the light to the believers.

And ne'er the two shall meet, I guess.
 
And it's true, too! :)

It was you who first provided this link for me, wasn't it?

I love it. And, as Amy Wilson is so fond of blurting, "it's true!" :)

Amy Wilson is probably a sock puppet of John Edwards.

Plumjam... he's "interesting ian"-ish. I think it's a kid. Or maybe it just has the frontal lobe of one.
 
My favorite part is that over two-thirds of the adult population believes in psychic powers. Over two-thirds believe in astrology. Close to one-half claim that they have been in contact with a dead relative. Yet this small group of powerful Skeptics prevents these ideas from being accepted. I am surprised that people don't rise up and throw off their shackles.


If I find the time, I will look up all the physics, chemistry, and medicine Nobel Prizes in the past 100 years and see what percent were awarded for ideas that went against the accepted "Skeptic orthodoxy." If plumjam is correct, it should be an amazingly small number.
 
Last edited:
What's kind of funny is...I've seen this same kind of thread on believer forums when a skeptic shows up and tries to show the light to the believers.

And ne'er the two shall meet, I guess.

Except on believer forums, they are a heck of a lot nastier. At least we did try to enlighten before turning into howler monkeys. Believers start the slinging much sooner with greater vigor.
 
Except on believer forums, they are a heck of a lot nastier. At least we did try to enlighten before turning into howler monkeys. Believers start the slinging much sooner with greater vigor.

One of the things I love about this joint is the amazing ability of so many of the posters to be patient, reasonable folks, even if the face of such willful ignorance. Honestly I don't know how you guys do it - if I posted half the stuff I've written to the plumjams if the world, the moderators would be all over me.
 
Right. And this forum probably would seem like a big, boring downer to someone who was into that. That's ok. People are different.

That's why "we" have our forums, and "they" have theirs. We tend to think endless speculations without any kind of factual basis is unbelieveably pointless and a truly massive waste of time.

They dig that kind of thing.

What's kind of funny is...I've seen this same kind of thread on believer forums when a skeptic shows up and tries to show the light to the believers.

And ne'er the two shall meet, I guess.

I bet they like it when a skeptic shows up... it allows them to reinforce each other's belief. Skeptics have an advantage because the truth just keeps being the truth whether you believe it or not. Belief takes active "propping up" and denial to stay afloat. Groupthink is good for belief and having a common enemy (reason) no doubt escalates it.

I wonder why they come here... but I'm glad they do. It gives the shyer more intelligent new members a chance to sharpen their argumentation skills and woo baiting can provide hours of good clean fun. And it's a guilt free pleasure... they willingly traipsed into the skeptic den to preach.
 
maybe i've misread, but i don't remember anyone saying they changed their views after being presented with evidence which would take them away from orthodox Skepticism.

Moving the goalposts, eh? Strange, I kinda sdee the question in front of me "when have you changed your mind on a matter?". And people replied to that question. then you started going on with your silly "Skeptic Orthodoxy".

BTW you are the 8th poster to accuse me of setting up a straw man, pretty clever of me don't you think? when I'd never heard of it before tonight

Uhm, you don't need to know the definition to wallow in strawman building, something you demonstrated many times in your threads.
 
sorry, like the other anal types on here I can't provide a journal, volume, author, page number etc..

Then you shouldn't be making wild assertions, if you can not back them up. No?

who else comes on here with a load of academic references to cite? It's a forum to exchange ideas and opinions, not a backstage pass to a university library.

People who wants their claims taken seriously. You know, normal order of things. You reasearch A, when researching you find references supporting your view on A, once you have your evidence and references you can start spouting off about A. Thought that was pretty basic stuff...
 
I thought that I did. I said that I changed my mind about major woo such as Sylvia Browne when I realized how there was no credible evidence to actually believe she can do what she claims.

<channel poster="plumjam">
yah, but that like.. doesn't count you know. You, like, changed in the wrong direction like. Not away from Da Skeptic Orthodoxy(tm) like. had you like, changed to believe in The Taloned One(tm) it would like, be real you know...
</channel>
 
Except on believer forums, they are a heck of a lot nastier. At least we did try to enlighten before turning into howler monkeys. Believers start the slinging much sooner with greater vigor.

I like science, because it works whether you believe in it or not... but it seems that it doesn't always work. Per your example, it looks like those who don't "believe" in evolution don't evolve-- and are stuck in the poo flinging stage for life.

So sad.
 
well, from what i have learnt Nature Magazine (supposedly the most prestigious science publication on planet Earth) heavily ridiculed the Wright Brothers, even the local paper of the Wright Bros local town after hearing stories of the success of their first flights denied it and ridiculed them, because that was what the prevailing mental orthodoxy of the time dictated.
What closed-minded people they were soon proven to be. My point is that there is a temptation that is all to easy to succumb to which relegates anyone with any new idea or invention to ridicule, and similtaneously gives you, as a Skeptic, the pleasure of feeling yourself intellectualy superior to them

I'll take your word that the "Nature" story is true. I think you miss the critical point of it though.
They were not "closed minded" :
They were wrong.
Factually incorrect.
They had not checked their facts. (Possibly not so easy before TV and in the days of long publication lead times.)
No editor of "Nature " denied heavier than air flight after examining the evidence. No Apollo Moon Hoax claims in "Nature".
On the other hand, proponents of Homoeopathy and Reiki (as examples) do persist in claiming that a real effect exists in the face of a large (and ever growing) body of evidence to the contrary.
This is the crucial difference between science and woo. Either can be wrong. One can recognise it is wrong and correct itself, because it has people checking the facts. (They don't do so out of a selfless dedication to truth. They do so because they delight in proving others wrong and getting the credit themselves. Science is a very human , but rather inhumane activity).

There's nothing wrong with being wrong. There's plenty wrong with being willfully wong.
 
It does make one wonder. He started 3 provocative threads, kept hurling vases, then ran away when we did not offer cyberhugs, hot coco and a foot massage.

shoot, I found these in the emoticon gallery :grouphug: , and I was just coming back here to deliver him some cyberhugs...
 
It seems you, like everybody else, have missed the very excellent post #137. :) Wrong journal.

That was excellent... thanks for reposting.

It's funny how the woo always try to co-op science to support their claims ("they laughed at Galileo too!"). To me, the article shows that science and skepticism work. If things are true today, they will still be true tomorrow. In the mean time, aviation technology has EVOLVED... we've refined the process, learned from errors and increased our understanding. And lets examine the woo modes of flight over the same period of time... let's see, there's magic carpets, levitation, and astral travel. And how much of that info. have we examined and refined? It seems skepticism and science is a pretty good way of separating the wheat from the chaff.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom