when have you changed your mind on a matter?

What I'm saying, in a roundabout way is that Science classically is going to assume that every phenomenon will have its own set of optimum physical conditions which will aid in bringing that phenomenon about. But this applies much more at the lower levels of complexity i.e physics and chemistry... the more complex things get the more consciousness comes into play, and at the human level it's probable that each individual psychic will have their own favourite optimum conditions in which to function. Some might prefer a dark room, alone.. others might have eyes open, others closed etc...
So we test each psychic under their own favorite optimum conditions, so long as these are not the conditions used by stage magicians to disguise their tricks.

There is no assumption that every psychic works best under the same conditions.
 
pretty negative of you, seeing as, like everyone else you're not offering anything.

I came to JREF out of curiosity, and because in my life I see a central contradiction in the whole Skeptical approach... which now I'm not going to offer, cos I obviously have no citations to back it up ;)

I've offered you quite a bit and it was all positive. Did you look up any of those terms I posted? That's how we learn how to base arguments on logic and spot flaws in critical thinking.
 
pretty negative of you, seeing as, like everyone else you're not offering anything.
What are you offering?

Oh yes, personal attacks and stuff you've made up.

I came to JREF out of curiosity, and because in my life I see a central contradiction in the whole Skeptical approach... which now I'm not going to offer, cos I obviously have no citations to back it up ;)
Now you're learning.

If you ever find a scrap of a shred of evidence for this "central contradiction", please feel free to tell us all about it.
 
sorry, don't buy it

It seems a shame to me that if you are all on here supposedly swapping citations like good little postgraduates, that noone seems to have anything of interest to offer, after all that reading and research.
 
sounds good, but pretty disingenuous methinks. I seriously doubt that if DR A gave you a list of citations you'd subsequently dutifully trot off tomorrow to the library to look them all up, read them, analyse their true significance to your position on fruitflies and then modify your position, this is all just scientific-sounding hokum.. someone please be real and admit this.

Here is an experiment you can try. Post some bogus citations about something on here and see how quickly people are calling your citations bogus.

My prediction, knowing how many on this forum think, very, very quickly.

I've spent many hours reading links to citations and information provided on this forum. It increases my knowledge.

Welcome to the skeptical mind.
 
you are just hiding in the classic negative position, not offering anything positive yourself, sitting back, trying to take apart any positive statement anyone makes (in this situation this means me, as I am/was the only one actually saying anything and trying to converse on here)
it's an easy route to take, and a pretty cowardly one. When I talk about conversation I'm trying to get across the fact that all of us on here could offer positive viewpoints and be friendly about it, but it seems no-one wants to.
Possibly that is going to be a characteristic of Skeptics generically.
Pretty dull all round.

Positive statements? Like "Evolution is just a belief"? Yeah sure, that's soo positive, and not at all intended to just provoke...

And showing evidence for speciation is most definitely a positive thing. It shows a willingness to educate, and a devotion to facts. That you refuse to look at it and instead resorts to petty insults...

Sorry, but the cowardly route is to refuse to back up your claims. To not even look at the evidence presented, because that would mean you'd have to admit you're wrong. Because that's what is the real problem here: That you refuse to aknowledge you're wrong. But please, show me I'm wrong on this, by starting to provide evidence for the claims you make, and starting to look at the evidence we've shown you. And stopping with the evading, and the excuses.

So, show me you're actually capable of handling being shown you're factually wrong without taking it as an insult. Then you can actually start learning something, and from learning you'll be able to contribute something worth looking at. I promise you, that's much more fulfilling that living in a closed world where everyone who doesn't agree with you must by default be nasty people.
 
It seems a shame to me that if you are all on here supposedly swapping citations like good little postgraduates, that noone seems to have anything of interest to offer, after all that reading and research.
I notice that that was actually a response to one of your own posts --- which made it curiously apposite.
 
What are you offering?

Oh yes, personal attacks and stuff you've made up.

Now you're learning.

If you ever find a scrap of a shred of evidence for this "central contradiction", please feel free to tell us all about it.

It seems to be your life's mission to come to places like this and prove to everyone how clever and cutting you can be. Sorry, but it isn't a practice I find particularly meaningful or worthwhile, so I will leave you all to your Skeptical negative positions in the cosmos from whence you can sit back and try to take others apart.
Doesn't have much beauty to it, I must say.
Night night all you Believers ;)
 
For some reason I have a feeling plumjam posts on Digital Spy but I just can't track it.
 
oh, just one last point,

noone managed to answer my original question, which just proves my point all along.

closed minds.
 
It seems to be your life's mission to come to places like this and prove to everyone how clever and cutting you can be. Sorry, but it isn't a practice I find particularly meaningful or worthwhile, so I will leave you all to your Skeptical negative positions in the cosmos from whence you can sit back and try to take others apart.
Doesn't have much beauty to it, I must say.
Night night all you Believers ;)

It's what, 1-2AM for you?

This, I think, is one of the biggest problems with internet communications. Middle-of-the-day, fully-caffeinated folks should know better than to attempt conversation with their post-midnight, three-sheets-to-the-wind counterparts.
 
I thought that I did. I said that I changed my mind about major woo such as Sylvia Browne when I realized how there was no credible evidence to actually believe she can do what she claims.
 
oh, just one last point,

noone managed to answer my original question, which just proves my point all along.

closed minds.

And now we're into downright lying. Several people, me included, did answer your OP. It's just that you didn't like the answer*, so you kept on ignoring it.

Is lying part of your "positive contributions"?

*In case you've forgotten, the answer is that it's not really possible to abandon the way of skepticism by being convinced of something outside the mainstream, if they present new evidence. It's when you -stop- doing that and simply -trust- people's claims that you stop being a skeptic.
 
It seems to be your life's mission to come to places like this and prove to everyone how clever and cutting you can be. Sorry, but it isn't a practice I find particularly meaningful or worthwhile, so I will leave you all to your Skeptical negative positions in the cosmos from whence you can sit back and try to take others apart.
Doesn't have much beauty to it, I must say.
Night night all you Believers ;)
Was this intended to be an example of a "positive" post?

Only it looks like more whining and personal attacks.
 
well there you go, precisely as I thought. You seem to have nothing positive to offer, but prefer to sit back with your citations and try to demolish other people. It all seems a bit unfriendly to me.

I think you might want to apply your words above to yourself, sweetie.
What inspired you to post on a skeptic's forum?

Oh and have you ever changed your mind on anything? Skeptics change their mind all the time... but it takes evidence. What sort of evidence would you require to change your conclusion that no one answered your question. Because I see that it was answered quite well multiple times... but like most woo, you just can't compute the answers unless they are the answers you want.
 
Last edited:
There's no way to make people who really don't care about evidence care.
I think you're either wired to "get it" or you're not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom