What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

This is my concept of God as a theist:

The maker of heaven and earth and everything.​


That's a concept of God expressed in eight words.


Now, atheists, you tell me in less than ten words what is your concept of God.


Imaginary being with supernatural powers.

Five words.
 
This is my concept of God as a theist:

The maker of heaven and earth and everything.​


That's a concept of God expressed in eight words.


Now, atheists, you tell me in less than ten words what is your concept of God.


A first cause style creator with libertarian free will.


Which is about as possible as a square circle. Anything that does not conform to this, say, something that could be seen as a first cause on one hand, that does not however have a choice to chose between different creations, does not count.

Preferably, that which is to be called 'God' exhibits clear anthropomorphic characteristics, like for example possesses speech. But I am less insistent here.

Ten words you wanted? Then run with the first line ... if you wish.
 
Now, atheists, you tell me in less than ten words what is your concept of God.

Yrreg

My concept of god is too great or extreme to be expressed in words though there is a school of thought that it is simply too sacred to be uttered. It's also ten words long. Sorry.
 
And please don't bring in names of gods and goddesses of earlier folks or more technologically backward peoples, unless and until you update and upgrade them to the level and quality of our current cognitive sophistication.


Ahura Mazda fits your definition. So does Bagadjimbiri, and Nanabozho. Along with Tezcatlipoca, Kaang and Bunjil.
In fact, every god on this list (some appear more than once under different names) fits your definition.

If a god concept fits your definition (maker of heaven and earth and everything), then what grounds do you have for rejecting it?
"earlier folks" and "more technologically backward peoples" are not grounds to dismiss a claim. They are (say it with me): Ad-Hominem attacks.

If you don't like people bringing in god concepts of "earlier folks or more technologically backward peoples", then perhaps you should ensure that your definition makes clear which particular god concept you are talking about.

The definition you have given is not sufficient convey the concept of a particular god. All it can do is convey a very general concept which applies equally well to many different god concepts.
So you can either improve the definition, or stop whining every time someone mentions a god you don't believe in.


----- ----- -----


Further, I don't think much of your demands that we make short posts. I mean, look at your own. They are long, repetitive, and needlessly wordy.

Until you make your posts short and to the point, your demands that we do so are hypocritical. And I for one will not acquiesce to them.

You asked the question, you've had your answers.

Deal with it.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, yrreg but never told me what was wrong with my definition of the Tooth Fairy. Could you please reply to my post?
 
This is my concept of God as a theist:

The maker of heaven and earth and everything.​


That's a concept of God expressed in eight words.


Now, atheists, you tell me in less than ten words what is your concept of God.

Evasive as this thread's author.
5 words, Gerry.
Now get to the point.
 
Last edited:
The definition you have given is not sufficient convey the concept of a particular god. All it can do is convey a very general concept which applies equally well to many different god concepts.


It also excludes all non-creator gods, which have as much right to be included in the definition of "god" as creator gods, at least from the point of view of atheists, who yrreg claims to be trying to engage with here.
 
Man is the measure of everything even God, wherefore man defines God.

Of course, now that we are so concerned about whether He does exist or not, then we start with the concept itself of God in our brain.

Here is my concept of God in my brain:
The maker of heaven and and earth and everything.
​
And here is my idea of what a definition is good or useful for to man, as understood by man, who is himself the measuring entity of everything that is of concern to man.

At this point of the thread I like to invite people to concentrate on the word God as at least referring to a possible entity inside the brain of humans at least some, which word God refers to the concept again in the brain of at least some people connoting:
The maker of heaven and earth and everything.
​

If you have trouble with everything, it means everything that man knows now and can know in the future and also they thought they knew in the past but now know better.

So if you are a man or a woman or anything in between provided still human with a genetically human brain,* everything means everything you know now or in the future.

Some people know more things than others of course, but everyone knows everything he does know.

If you are again and still having trouble with knowing everything, then just pretend that you don't know something of the everything that you know, then that should still be all right in regard to the everything that you now know, whereas you actually know one more than everything you now know with the pretended ignorance of one thing of the everything you know without pretending to not know the one thing you do know without the said pretension*.

Please, for the love of viable communication, don't be more smart and thus all entangled in useless knots because you want to imagine that you are a super intelligence all knowing entity, and not just a human knowing entity, knowing the limited number of things you do know which to you is everything you know, and include in that also all the things you don't know but can know, and even cannot know because your brain no matter how much it exposes itself to and for how long, will still not know everything in objective reality that can be known by what I postulate to be the concept of God:
The maker of heaven and earth and everything.
​

And please don't bring in names of gods and goddesses of earlier folks or more technologically backward peoples, unless and until you update and upgrade them to the level and quality of our current cognitive sophistication.

Okay? So, for the present let us all if I may include all of you to consider just the intrinsic possibility of the concept of God as:
The maker of heaven and earth and everything.
​
Then we will work on His existence outside the concept in our brain, but of course corresponding to the concept.

He writes this stuff in his native language (Lower Middle Incoherent), then does a copy-paste into Babelfish and posts the resulting "translation," doesn't he?
 
And please don't bring in names of gods and goddesses of earlier folks or more technologically backward peoples, unless and until you update and upgrade them to the level and quality of our current cognitive sophistication.

Right, because those Bronze Age tribal folk from 1800 bce who thought that the Earth was flat and created in six days couldn't possibly have known what they were saying about God.
 
Before anything else, I apologize to any people for my unacceptable words.

Before anything else, I apologize to any people for my unacceptable words.


Please, in the name of camaraderie -- addressing also Tricky as a common poster here, abstain from reporting what you think is an offensive line in my message which you believe should be reported, because it is not necessary to report it to the moderator for him to issue a warning.

Just tell me directly and ask me to rewrite the post with no more offense to you, and also demand even an apology.

That should save a lot of unnecessary time and trouble for all concerned.




I'm not certain your earlier demand for exactness and specificity meets with your new demand for brevity but here you go anyway...

An apparently imaginary being that some believe made everything.

Whoo! Nine words! What do I win?!?!

EDIT: Damn! zooterkin has succinctness down to a fine art.


That is a useful description of God, it says essentially the same concept as mine: the maker of heaven and earth and everything.


I award you with the reference to an online text of The Cloud of Unknowing, a mystical work attributed to a 14th century English monk.


You see AndyD, what I am trying to find out is whether atheists here can accept that concept of God, namely: the maker of heaven and earth and everything, as one that is possible in the human brain, but prescinding from the question of God's existence at this point of the thread.





Yrreg
 
Before anything else, I apologize to any people for my unacceptable words.


Please, in the name of camaraderie -- addressing also Tricky as a common poster here, abstain from reporting what you think is an offensive line in my message which you believe should be reported, because it is not necessary to report it to the moderator for him to issue a warning.

Just tell me directly and ask me to rewrite the post with no more offense to you, and also demand even an apology.

That should save a lot of unnecessary time and trouble for all concerned.


On the evidence of the rest of this thread (and of your last few threads) it doesn't appear that you take much notice of anything that others post here, so this would probably be a futile course of action.
 
Just point out what is impossible in my concept of God as concept.

For the rest of you, just point out what is impossible in my concept of God as concept.

The maker of heaven and earth and everything.​


You see, everyone, atheists bring in so many concepts of God, but theists like yours truly tell you that in many of their concepts of God, they are missing out on what theists like myself harbor in our brain as the concept of God.






Yrreg
 
Remember not to be straitjacketed by dictionaries.

Quote:
You see AndyD, what I am trying to find out is whether atheists here can accept that concept of God, namely: the maker of heaven and earth and everything, as one that is possible in the human brain, but prescinding from the question of God's existence at this point of the thread.
​

Prescind: v.tr. To separate or divide in thought; consider individually.
v.intr. To withdraw one's attention.


In this context, I'm not sure prescind is the word you wanted.



You must remember that language is greater and deeper and higher than any dictionary can contain.


And it is a great catastrophe that people have this idea that they should be enslaved by dictionaries which are made by fellow men who need not be the most versatile and prolific in the use of language.



Anyway, Elizabeth, suppose you tell me what I want to say with that phrase, prescinding from, and rewrite my disputed line for me, then I will examine it and tell you whether you get my thought correctly or not.



Or you want to witness a contest of bringing up the nth number of dictionaries to prove... what?

When people start arguing on the basis of dictionary definition, I usually prescind from their presence.

Wrong use of prescind in that line? You have got to be versatile and prolific in language to understand that word prescind in that line from me.


Haha, gotcha!


Oooops, might get in trouble with some people again.


Can't people here some not ever get any magnanimity of spirit, but must complain to the police precinct for any so much as the most effervescent ether of an offense in the words of Yrreg here?





Yrreg
 
Just tell me directly and ask me to rewrite the post with no more offense to you, and also demand even an apology.

You've already said that you don't read posts. How about just stopping with the name calling?

That should save a lot of unnecessary time and trouble for all concerned.

I don't mind you getting in trouble.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom