What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

For the rest of you, just point out what is impossible in my concept of God as concept.
The maker of heaven and earth and everything.​
You see, everyone, atheists bring in so many concepts of God, but theists like yours truly tell you that in many of their concepts of God, they are missing out on what theists like myself harbor in our brain as the concept of God.
Getty, it is not about whether the God you conceptualize is logically possible, it is about whether the God you conceptualize is logically necessary. These are two very different things.

I am an atheist. I will happily concede that any concept of God that is not obviously internally incoherent or flat out contradicted by our observations of the Universe may be logically possible. I will then proceed to point out that the Flying Spaghetti Monster, a small teapot in orbit around Saturn, and the majority of dieties and fairy tales that humankind has ever believed in are also logically possible. I do not believe in them either, so why should I believe in your concept of God?

If you want to claim that your concept of God is logically necessary, you must show your work and be able to convince skeptics who will do their best to show that your concept is not logically necessary. So far, all your attempts have been complete and utter failures.
 
You see, everyone, atheists bring in so many concepts of God, but theists like yours truly tell you that in many of their concepts of God, they are missing out on what theists like myself harbor in our brain as the concept of God.


What about theists other than yourself? You are missing out on the concepts of god of all those theists whose concept of god differs from yours.
 
I got that concept of God from The Apostles' Creed which I have memorized from childhood:

I believe in God,
The Father Almighty,
Creator of heaven and earth,

Etc. etc. etc.​


I just rewrite it as a definition of God, making it easy to understand for any brain with a minimum command of English vocabulary:

The maker of heaven and earth and everything.​





Yrreg

You should not have rewritten it. "The father almighty" is an essential element. Even so, I doubt very very much whether any one of the church fathers responsible for standardizing the apostles' creed would have considered that a full definition, rather than a shorthand definition for a concept much more fully fleshed out elsewhere.

In any case, though, you have at least provided us with a background for your definition. We now know that your definition is, indeed, based on a larger context, and whether you acknowledge it or not, the idea in your brain which that definition calls up is based, not only on the definition, but on the unspoken ideas that that context provides. This is no problem. Most of our ideas of complex concepts owe much to context. Your problem is not that this is so, but that you seem unwilling to acknowledge it.

You could as easily, and more productively, simply say "when I mean God I mean the God of the Apostles' Creed." You could even be justified in appending to that a slightly snarky, but entirely permissible comment, such as "if you don't know what that is, look it up." Since there is abundant information and scholarship regarding the creed and its object, anyone needing further clarification could then go to that creed, read it, and if needing even further clarification, study its origins, and from that point on you could, in all good conscience, accuse any opponent of nitpicking and derailment for pretending not to understand what you meant. Anyone can dispute the validity of the creed and its object, but nobody of good sense arguing in good faith could pretend that you are being vague, obscure, disingenuous or misleading for citing the god identified by that creed as what you mean when you use the word. It would be rampant optimism to suggest that this would free your threads of all bickering, but at least we'd be bickering about something more substantial than your arguable understanding of what a definition is.

It requires a certain kind of obstinate hubris to believe that something as elegantly pared down as the Apostles' Creed needs editing. I'm reminded of the verse in John 11:35. Alexander Woollcott once noted that there was only one English sentence that he knew that could not be improved upon: that from the KJ Bible, "Jesus wept." The Jehovah's Witness version reads "Jesus gave way to tears."
 
Because I thought it is a pretty smart definition of God.

Posted by yrreg
I got that concept of God from The Apostles' Creed which I have memorized from childhood:

I believe in God,
The Father Almighty,
Creator of heaven and earth,

Etc. etc. etc.

​




Fairy nuff

One question:

Why the Apostles Creed and not In Which a Search Is Organdized, and Piglet Nearly Meets the Heffalump Again?


Because I thought it is a pretty smart definition of God.


And I can see that the people who produced that very early statement of belief for Christians were very pretty smart and sharp and very versatile and prolific in language of the plain kind.





Yrreg
 
I speak for myself, other theists can speak for themselves.

Posted by yrreg
You see, everyone, atheists bring in so many concepts of God, but theists like yours truly tell you that in many of their concepts of God, they are missing out on what theists like myself harbor in our brain as the concept of God.

​



What about theists other than yourself? You are missing out on the concepts of god of all those theists whose concept of god differs from yours.



I speak for myself, other theists can speak for themselves.




Yrreg
 
God for me as maker of heaven and earth and everything, that is essential to God.

You should not have rewritten it. "The father almighty" is an essential element. Even so, I doubt very very much whether any one of the church fathers responsible for standardizing the apostles' creed would have considered that a full definition, rather than a shorthand definition for a concept much more fully fleshed out elsewhere.

In any case, though, you have at least provided us with a background for your definition. We now know that your definition is, indeed, based on a larger context, and whether you acknowledge it or not, the idea in your brain which that definition calls up is based, not only on the definition, but on the unspoken ideas that that context provides. This is no problem. Most of our ideas of complex concepts owe much to context. Your problem is not that this is so, but that you seem unwilling to acknowledge it.

You could as easily, and more productively, simply say "when I mean God I mean the God of the Apostles' Creed." You could even be justified in appending to that a slightly snarky, but entirely permissible comment, such as "if you don't know what that is, look it up." Since there is abundant information and scholarship regarding the creed and its object, anyone needing further clarification could then go to that creed, read it, and if needing even further clarification, study its origins, and from that point on you could, in all good conscience, accuse any opponent of nitpicking and derailment for pretending not to understand what you meant. Anyone can dispute the validity of the creed and its object, but nobody of good sense arguing in good faith could pretend that you are being vague, obscure, disingenuous or misleading for citing the god identified by that creed as what you mean when you use the word. It would be rampant optimism to suggest that this would free your threads of all bickering, but at least we'd be bickering about something more substantial than your arguable understanding of what a definition is.

It requires a certain kind of obstinate hubris to believe that something as elegantly pared down as the Apostles' Creed needs editing. I'm reminded of the verse in John 11:35. Alexander Woollcott once noted that there was only one English sentence that he knew that could not be improved upon: that from the KJ Bible, "Jesus wept." The Jehovah's Witness version reads "Jesus gave way to tears."


As a matter of fact, God for me as maker of heaven and earth and everything, that is essential to God.


As for the God of the Bible or the God of the Koran, that is for me a script by men of what they want God maker of heaven and earth and everything to be for them in particular.



So, as far as I am concerned here in this thread, let us just keep to the concept of God, the maker of heaven and earth and everything.


By the way didn't I mention about scripts by men for God to play in some earlier threads, posts?







Yrreg
 
As a matter of fact, God for me as maker of heaven and earth and everything, that is essential to God.
Sounds Fine.

Ok.
To me, God is a dog seen in a mirror.
Perhaps we should provide evidence for our differing definitions? You start.
 
That is why it is almost impossible to have any productive exchange of thoughts with atheists.
Yrreg

I am curious as to your definition here, of "almost".

Are you productively filling your atheistic boots?
 
As a matter of fact, God for me as maker of heaven and earth and everything, that is essential to God.


As for the God of the Bible or the God of the Koran, that is for me a script by men of what they want God maker of heaven and earth and everything to be for them in particular.



So, as far as I am concerned here in this thread, let us just keep to the concept of God, the maker of heaven and earth and everything.


By the way didn't I mention about scripts by men for God to play in some earlier threads, posts?







Yrreg
If what you are ultimately saying is that all you believe or know of god is that whatever god might be, it created the universe, and all else remains to be determined, then fair enough.

I do wonder why, if you rely on the Apostles' Creed for your script, you are so reluctant to include the other half of its definition of God.

Just curious, do you have an issue with the "father almighty" part of it? I know I do, but I'm surprised to see you so reticent to acknowledge that part of the creed.

You're beginning to sound like more of a deist than a theist.
 
As a matter of fact, God for me as maker of heaven and earth and everything, that is essential to God.


As for the God of the Bible or the God of the Koran, that is for me a script by men of what they want God maker of heaven and earth and everything to be for them in particular.



So, as far as I am concerned here in this thread, let us just keep to the concept of God, the maker of heaven and earth and everything.


By the way didn't I mention about scripts by men for God to play in some earlier threads, posts?

Ok, a concept derived from the Apostle's Creed. Now we know which God you have chosen.
Now, what I find interesting is that you mention in this post about the Bible and the Koran as being scripts of men and how the interpretation is for them in particular.
So the reason for not using the Bible or Koran for your interpretation is because the Apostle's Creed expresses it more to your particular liking? Even though the Creed is also a script of man?
 
You see, everyone, atheists bring in so many concepts of God, but theists like yours truly tell you that in many of their concepts of God, they are missing out on what theists like myself harbor in our brain as the concept of God.
So why don't you tell us what you harbour in your brain as the concept of God.

If it's "maker of heaven and earth and everything", let me assure you that we get it. We most certainly understand by now that this is what you harbour in your brain as the concept of God.

That has absolutely nothing to do with our brains.
 
yrreg said:
I got that concept of God from The Apostles' Creed which I have memorized from childhood:

I believe in God,
The Father Almighty,
Creator of heaven and earth,

Etc. etc. etc.
Fairy nuff

One question:

Why the Apostles Creed and not In Which a Search Is Organdized, and Piglet Nearly Meets the Heffalump Again?
Because I thought it is a pretty smart definition of God.
OK... again... fairy nuff...

However, your answer simply prompts another line of questions:

Is, in your book, having "a pretty smart definition of God" a pretty smart thing? If so, I sincerely ask why?

And I can see that the people who produced that very early statement of belief for Christians were very pretty smart and sharp and very versatile and prolific in language of the plain kind.
Are you suggesting that AA Milne was not "very pretty smart and sharp and very versatile and prolific in language of the plain kind"? :confused:
 
Because I thought it is a pretty smart definition of God.


If the Apostles' Creed is a pretty smart definition of God, why did you feel obligated to change to something that is....shall we politely say....not quite so smart?


It's like when someone asks you to define Shakespeare's writings and you hand them the Cliff Notes.
 

Posted by yrreg
As a matter of fact, God for me as maker of heaven and earth and everything, that is essential to God.


As for the God of the Bible or the God of the Koran, that is for me a script by men of what they want God maker of heaven and earth and everything to be for them in particular.



So, as far as I am concerned here in this thread, let us just keep to the concept of God, the maker of heaven and earth and everything.


By the way didn't I mention about scripts by men for God to play in some earlier threads, posts?


Yrreg
​



If what you are ultimately saying is that all you believe or know of god is that whatever god might be, it created the universe, and all else remains to be determined, then fair enough.

I do wonder why, if you rely on the Apostles' Creed for your script, you are so reluctant to include the other half of its definition of God.

Just curious, do you have an issue with the "father almighty" part of it? I know I do, but I'm surprised to see you so reticent to acknowledge that part of the creed.

You're beginning to sound like more of a deist than a theist.


No, I am not hiding anything of The Apostles' Creed, not even that part about father almighty.


What I am doing is to bring your attention to the quintessence of God as far as we humans can know of Him with our reason and intelligence.


The rest is a matter of faith, on the script of men claiming to be commissioned by God to teach about God.




You see, first I want to see if you can at least see the possibility of the concept of God as maker of heaven and earth and everything.


Then for people here although atheists who can still with their brain harbor the possibility of the concept of God as maker of heaven and earth and everything, I will invite them to join me in the search of anything which can satisfy that description of God.


What's in it for me?


It is fun, and I hope will be fun for you also.


And of course intellectually rewarding.


About God being psychologically comforting for people who take Him for a father, I confess I do that myself; but remember that is a script I take the presumption to make up for God, on the ground that I know Him from reason and intelligence to be maker of heaven and earth and everything.


Do you feel that for yourself it demeans you? That is your privilege founded upon your free thought and free choice.





Yrreg
 
Just pm me if you really want me to react to your thoughts, okay?

Just pm me if you really want me to react to your thoughts, okay?


Otherwise, don't waste the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.


No offense intended, just speaking out my brain's honest and direct thoughts.





Yrreg
 
What I am doing is to bring your attention to the quintessence of God as far as we humans can know of Him with our reason and intelligence.

Ok, so we get that you have a definition of god. You've also been given definitions of the Tooth Fairy and the Flying Spaghetti Monster. Do they exist because we have a definition?

The rest is a matter of faith, on the script of men claiming to be commissioned by God to teach about God.

Finally, you've admitted it. You have a definition of god and faith.

PM me if you want to show me some evidence.
 
Just pm me if you really want me to react to your thoughts, okay?

Otherwise, don't waste the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.

No offense intended, just speaking out my brain's honest and direct thoughts.

Yrreg
Um, no. It's not ok.

The point of the forum is public discourse. You've stated your position and we've stated ours. If you choose to not continue the discussion and merely repeat your position, that is your prerogative. It only serves to undermine your argument as it gives all appearances of an inability to respond.

You do not, however, get any say in who or how often people post in this thread, nor do you get a say in what they post. If you are embarrassed by the comments, that's your problem. Either defend your position or become an intellectual punching bag.



I'll help you along. You can start by answering the following question: Why is your definition of god any better/worse than my definition of god? For a reminder, my current definition of god is a dog seen in a mirror.
 
No, I am not hiding anything of The Apostles' Creed, not even that part about father almighty.

It's not important, really.

What I am doing is to bring your attention to the quintessence of God as far as we humans can know of Him with our reason and intelligence.

Oh, yes, you brought this to our attention, because no one in the R&P forum had yet thought to discuss the idea of people worshiping imaginary beings. Wow, thanks so much.


The rest is a matter of faith, on the script of men claiming to be commissioned by God to teach about God.

The rest of what? You've wasted many, many threads with all this crap, and so far, nothing has come of it, aside from a few really good jokes made at your expense. Oh, do continue.


You see, first I want to see if you can at least see the possibility of the concept of God as maker of heaven and earth and everything.

You've already been told several times that a maker of everything must also be the maker of itself, and so is part of the everything it supposedly creates, and you don't really understand that, do you?


Then for people here although atheists who can still with their brain harbor the possibility of the concept of God as maker of heaven and earth and everything, I will invite them to join me in the search of anything which can satisfy that description of God.

Yes, and tomorrow, we're going to teach you to use the big boy's potty.


What's in it for me?

We care?


It is fun, and I hope will be fun for you also.

Oh, you can't imagine. :p


And of course intellectually rewarding.

One keeps hoping you'll actually learn something. One is beginning to despair.

About God being psychologically comforting for people who take Him for a father, I confess I do that myself; but remember that is a script I take the presumption to make up for God, on the ground that I know Him from reason and intelligence to be maker of heaven and earth and everything.

Late at night, in the dark, you comfort yourself with thoughts of an imaginary daddy who loves you.


Do you feel that for yourself it demeans you? That is your privilege founded upon your free thought and free choice.

Next up: water is still wet.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom