What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Read this post again, giving utmost attention and concentration and thus compliance to the lines in bold.

<snipped by X>

(1) It is good or useful for people to know what actual or at least possible entity outside your brain or even inside your brain the word you use refers to.


(2) Does my definition of God serve that purpose for people to know what entity outside their brain and/or inside their brain the word God refers to?

(3) Does it tell people what atheists and what theists are talking about with the word God?

(4) If they know what is a maker, what is heaven, what is earth, and what is everything, then they should find nothing wrong with the word God defined as the maker of heaven and hearth and everything.

(5) If you find something wrong with that definition of God, then it is because for you: you can't know what people are talking about with the word God, whereas they know what they are talking about, even kids in nursery school have no trouble with the word God and its meaning.

(6) The cause could be some kind of peculiar brain configuration on your part, not found in people who do know what is being talked about with the word God.

(7) Or perhaps you have some kind of dread with the word itself of God, what is that dread all about?



(8) So, judge the definition whether at least it gives the possible object in your brain or brains of people except in yours of the concept of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.


Responses to points in numbered order:

(1)
The trouble is that your "definition" does not let other people know what entity you are referring to. Is it Vāhigurū? Allah? Brahmā? Chaos? The Flying Spaghetti Monster? The Great Green Arkelseizure? You complain every time someone mentions these concepts, accusing the person bringing them up of being idiots. Yet your own definition does not rule them out.
So, as far as trying to inform others of what entity you are referring to, you "definition" is insufficient.


(2)
See previous answer. Your "definition" does not tell me what your use of the term "God" refers to. There are many god concepts, and many of them fit your definition. Your "definition" does not let me know which "God" you are talking about.


(3)
No, it does not. See (1) and (2).


(4)
I am familiar with the concepts of Heaven, Earth and everything. THey are well defined. Heaven is a paradise afterlife, Earth is the planet on which we live, and everything is well, everything (which includes Heaven and Earth, by the way).
However, since your definition of God is merely as the maker of those objects and no more specific than that, you should find nothing wrong with me using the Flying Spaghetti Monster as the concept of god for this discussion. It fits your definition, after all. If you don't like it, come up with a more explicit definition.


(5)
You're right. I can not know what people are talking about when they use the word God. There are many different religions, each with their own god or gods. Further, in my experience, each individual has their own interpretation of god. It's very much a personal concept. I can claim that you are talking about the genocidal, vindictive, maniacal and petty god of the Torah. But I have no way of knowing for sure. There are simply too many god concepts for the word "god" to have any specific and clear meaning.


(6)
You really do need to stop insulting everyone who doesn't ascribe to your belief system. Or else we might start flinging insults at you for not following our beliefs or lack thereof.


(7)
I have no more fear of the word "god" (or even it's general implications) than I do of the word "leprechaun".


(8)
Very well. I judge it to fail. It does not provide a concept of "the possible object [...] of the concept of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything". Why not? Because you ask if it provides a singular concept. It doesn't. It encompasses many many god concepts.




Again, please read my earlier post, quoted below:


Yrreg; Read The Following.

You asked us what we felt was wrong with your definition of god (maker of heaven and earth and everything).

This has been provided, although you dismiss the posts as signs of naivete. Which is insulting, frankly. But then, so is most of what you write.


Here is the issue:

You routinely and reliably get angry whenever somebody brings up the Flying Spaghetti Monster or the Invisible Pink Unicorn or other deity concepts to prove a point.

The trouble is, these deity concepts are perfectly compatible with your definition of god.

Yet you refuse to acknowledge the analogies made, instead insulting the posters by saying people who bring up such concepts are "non-thinkers".

If these concepts are not your god, the fault lies with you.
Your definition, as presented, gives no way of differentiating between many hundreds of deity concepts (many of which are mutually incompatible).

Since you obviously have a specific god-concept in mind (or else you wouldn't reject the others as "non-thinking"), and since your definition fails completely to describe the specific concept you have in mind (or any other specific concept, for that matter), it is not a very good definition. By definition.


That is what is wrong with it. As a definition of a concept, it works, but doesn't really clarify anything. As a definition of a specific deity-concept, as you are using it for, it fails utterly. It is too vague, and it eschews actual description in favour of giving a resume.
 
Last edited:
Which God are you refering to?

So, judge the definition whether at least it gives the possible object in your brain or brains of people except in yours of the concept of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.

In order to find a consensus for the definition of God as maker of everything, perhaps you could specify which God you have in mind so we could narrow it down to one?
 
Last edited:
Man is the measure of everything even God, wherefore man defines God.

Man is the measure of everything even God, wherefore man defines God.

Of course, now that we are so concerned about whether He does exist or not, then we start with the concept itself of God in our brain.

Here is my concept of God in my brain:
The maker of heaven and and earth and everything.
​
And here is my idea of what a definition is good or useful for to man, as understood by man, who is himself the measuring entity of everything that is of concern to man.

[...]

It [ a definition ] is good or useful for people to know what actual or at least possible entity outside your brain or even inside your brain the word you use refers to.

[...]


At this point of the thread I like to invite people to concentrate on the word God as at least referring to a possible entity inside the brain of humans at least some, which word God refers to the concept again in the brain of at least some people connoting:
The maker of heaven and earth and everything.
​

If you have trouble with everything, it means everything that man knows now and can know in the future and also they thought they knew in the past but now know better.

So if you are a man or a woman or anything in between provided still human with a genetically human brain,* everything means everything you know now or in the future.

Some people know more things than others of course, but everyone knows everything he does know.

If you are again and still having trouble with knowing everything, then just pretend that you don't know something of the everything that you know, then that should still be all right in regard to the everything that you now know, whereas you actually know one more than everything you now know with the pretended ignorance of one thing of the everything you know without pretending to not know the one thing you do know without the said pretension*.


Please, for the love of viable communication, don't be more smart and thus all entangled in useless knots because you want to imagine that you are a super intelligence all knowing entity, and not just a human knowing entity, knowing the limited number of things you do know which to you is everything you know, and include in that also all the things you don't know but can know, and even cannot know because your brain no matter how much it exposes itself to and for how long, will still not know everything in objective reality that can be known by what I postulate to be the concept of God:
The maker of heaven and earth and everything.
​


And please don't bring in names of gods and goddesses of earlier folks or more technologically backward peoples, unless and until you update and upgrade them to the level and quality of our current cognitive sophistication.

Rule 12 violation removed.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky




Okay? So, for the present let us all if I may include all of you to consider just the intrinsic possibility of the concept of God as:
The maker of heaven and earth and everything.
​
Then we will work on His existence outside the concept in our brain, but of course corresponding to the concept.




Yrreg
Edited by Tricky: 
Edited per mod-box above

​
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If you have trouble with everything, it means everything that man knows now and can know in the future and also they thought they knew in the past but now know better.


So if man doesn't know it now, won't know it in the future, and didn't know it, or even think they knew it, in the past, god didn't make it.

Got it.

What about if a woman knew it? Something like, say, the location of the car keys?
 
Standing on the bridge over the koi pond, Gozu asked master Boshi: "What is God?"

The master leaned over the handrail and shook the collected moths out of the lamp basin. They floated on the water like cherry blossoms. The koi came to the surface to feed. One slapped its tail on the water as it circled, briefly disturbing the reflection of the two men.

"You're welcome," laughed Boshi.

"What is God?" asked Gozu, unsure if he had been heard.

"You hang the lantern tonight," said Boshi; "here," and walked away.

That night the light illuminated the rice hut's porch, the gathering moths, as the two men slept. Gozu had worried as he lit the lamp that the wind would blow it out.

commentary: the lamp, the flame, the wind, the moths, the koi, the light, the cherry blossom... Who will you thank?
 
Man is the measure of everything even God, wherefore man defines God.

Which God? Are you unable to reveal this God? Can't you define him with a name? If you can't, then your argument goes nowhere.

Of course, now that we are so concerned about whether He does exist or not, then we start with the concept itself of God in our brain.

Here is my concept of God in my brain:

The maker of heaven and and earth and everything.​

I believe you have mentioned this before.:rolleyes:


At this point of the thread I like to invite people to concentrate on the word God as at least referring to a possible entity inside the brain of humans at least some, which word God refers to the concept again in the brain of at least some people connoting:

The maker of heaven and earth and everything.​

You really like wasting time and forum bandwidth, don't you?

If you have trouble with everything, it means everything that man knows now and can know in the future and also they thought they knew in the past but now know better.

So if you are a man or a woman or anything in between provided still human with a genetically human brain,* everything means everything you know now or in the future.

Some people know more things than others of course, but everyone knows everything he does know.

If you are again and still having trouble with knowing everything, then just pretend that you don't know something of the everything that you know, then that should still be all right in regard to the everything that you now know, whereas you actually know one more than everything you now know with the pretended ignorance of one thing of the everything you know without pretending to not know the one thing you do know without the said pretension*.

Seriously, did you have Don Rumsfeld write this?

Please, for the love of viable communication, don't be more smart and thus all entangled in useless knots because you want to imagine that you are a super intelligence all knowing entity, and not just a human knowing entity, knowing the limited number of things you do know which to you is everything you know, and include in that also all the things you don't know but can know, and even cannot know because your brain no matter how much it exposes itself to and for how long, will still not know everything in objective reality that can be known by what I postulate to be the concept of God:

The maker of heaven and earth and everything.​

:words:


And please don't bring in names of gods and goddesses of earlier folks or more technologically backward peoples, unless and until you update and upgrade them to the level and quality of our current cognitive sophistication.

Your God is...Allah? Jehovah? Did Protestants and Catholics fight over the same God? Why are Americans considered infidels in some countries?

I wished you guys would not keep playing naive, or you are really born naive; if you keep playing naive, then suppose you just proclaim yourselves born-again naive -- then I will not invest time and trouble to read your posts here.*
Perhaps you could stop being so evasive and be more specific?


Then we will work on His existence outside the concept in our brain, but of course corresponding to the concept.

Why don't you get started right now?
 
What's exactly, specifically wrong with my definition of God?
as maker of heaven and earth and everything.​





Yrreg

Well

What's exactly, specifically wrong with my definition of the tooth fairy?

A lovely little fairy, pink dress, magic wand, capable of magically transforming old teeth into golden coins

I'll let you think on that one

Ron
 
And please don't bring in names of gods and goddesses of earlier folks or more technologically backward peoples, unless and until you update and upgrade them to the level and quality of our current cognitive sophistication.


Assuming that you are talking about the God mentioned in the Bible, does this mean that we can still talk about post-Bronze Age gods such as the FSM (a God of the internet age)?
 
Now, atheists you tell me in less than ten words what is your concept of God.

This is my concept of God as a theist:

The maker of heaven and earth and everything.​


That's a concept of God expressed in eight words.


Now, atheists, you tell me in less than ten words what is your concept of God.






Yrreg
 
A human construct used to explain misunderstood natural phenomena.
 
This is my concept of God as a theist:

The maker of heaven and earth and everything.


That's a concept of God expressed in eight words.


Now, atheists, you tell me in less than ten words what is your concept of God.

I'm not certain your earlier demand for exactness and specificity meets with your new demand for brevity but here you go anyway...

An apparently imaginary being that some believe made everything.

Whoo! Nine words! What do I win?!?!

EDIT: Damn! zooterkin has succinctness down to a fine art.
 
Last edited:
The metaphysical synergy between the quantum conscious and unconscious shakras.
 
Man is the measure of everything even God, wherefore man defines God.
Therefore god comes from man. However how can a human produce a maker of everything?
In short, mankind can't, therefore its a mere Delusion, with a pint of supreme arrogance.


And please don't bring in names of gods and goddesses of earlier folks or more technologically backward peoples
You mean like your god? Don't you know that the faith in your god is stronger in more backward areas.
 
Okay? So, for the present let us all if I may include all of you to consider just the intrinsic possibility of the concept of God as:
The maker of heaven and earth and everything.
​
Then we will work on His existence outside the concept in our brain, but of course corresponding to the concept.




Yrreg


If the concept of god in your brain is actually nothing but what it says in your definition, then you have no concept of any particular god at all. If that definition is truly all you are working from, then you have not gone beyond the stage of imagining that the universe is created, to consider what might have created it. Yrreg, no matter how much verbiage you pile on, your definition is not the definition of any particular god with any particular attributes. It is only the shell of a definition, or a label for a more complete concept of God defined elsewhere. Whether you like it or not, or take offense at the suggestion or not, the definition you provide is applicable to any creation myth, real or imagined, and contains no specifications that could distinguish the God you (presumably) believe in from pantheistic deities, myths and parodies. If we did not infer it from your peevish responses, and from the context in which you operate here in this forum, your definition would give us no reason at all to presume that you are speaking of a monotheistic deity of the sort christians and muslims worship, rather than some Coyote myth or the Spaghetti Monster.

Since this is so, I wonder that you are taking so much trouble with the question. It is true that the definition you have put forth, despite its flaws, can be reasonably understood for the purposes of discourse about God and his existence, but it would be both simpler and more accurate simply to refer to some better definition in a dictionary,or in the doctrine of whatever religious persuasion you prefer, and say you are speaking of that concept. It would save you much trouble, and spare you the embarrassment of many many pages of incoherent writing and misdirected insults.

Your apparent inability to distinguish between the content of your definition and the content of your brain continues to trip you up. If what we are seeing here is the content of your brain, you would do well to be more circumspect in revealing it. It's not a pretty sight.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom